- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Kailash Verma Alias Kailash Ram Verma v. Sudhanshu Kumar Chatterjee
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioners are tenants against whom the opposite parties, landlords, filed three separate suits for eviction from three tenanted buildings. The landlords alleged tenancy relationship as the basis for eviction. The tenants, in their written statements, raised the question of title by claiming ownership of the properties. The trial court initially did not frame any issue on title. Subsequently, the tenants filed revision applications leading the court to order framing of an issue on title if pressed by the tenants. The issue on title was framed in all suits. The tenants contended that once the issue on title was framed, the landlords must pay advalorem court fee on the value of the properties. The trial court rejected this contention, which was challenged before this court.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether in a suit filed by a landlord for eviction of a tenant, if the tenant raises and presses the question of title, the landlord is required to pay advalorem court fee on the value of the property despite not having raised the question of title or prayed for eviction based on title.
- What is the legal position regarding payment of court fee when the question of title is raised and investigated at the instance of the defendant (tenant), but the plaintiff (landlord) does not seek eviction on the basis of title?
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- Whenever an issue on title is framed in an eviction suit, the plaintiff landlord must pay advalorem court fee irrespective of who raised the issue.
- Reliance was placed on precedents including Smt. Kasturi Devi v. Shripal Singh, Ramchandra Sah v. Chotan Sah, Sheo Sankar Prasad v. Barhan Mistry, Sardendu Ghosh v. Binayendra Nath Ghosh, and Raghubar Dayal Prasad v. Ramekbal Sah to support this proposition.
Opposite Parties' Arguments
- If the question of title is to be gone into at the instance of the plaintiff, further advalorem court fee is payable.
- Since in these cases the question of title was raised by the defendants (tenants) and the plaintiffs (landlords) have not prayed for eviction on the basis of title, no additional court fee is payable.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Smt. Kasturi Devi v. Shripal Singh (A.I.R 1954 Patna 128) | Investigation of title issue raised by defendant in eviction suit and no additional court fee payable by plaintiff if no decree sought on title basis. | Affirmed that when title is raised by defendant, plaintiff need not pay advalorem court fee if no decree on title is prayed. |
| Ramchandra Sah v. Chotan Sah (1971 B.L.J.R 186) | Support for the principle that advalorem court fee is payable only if plaintiff prays for decree on title. | Reiterated the legal position consistent with Smt. Kasturi Devi. |
| Sheo Sankar Prasad v. Barhan Mistry (1985 P.L.J.R 358) | Before court proceeds fully on title, plaintiff should pay advalorem court fee if decree on title is prayed. | Clarified that this applies when plaintiff seeks decree on title; does not support fee payment if title issue is raised only by defendant. |
| Sardendu Ghosh v. Binayendra Nath Ghosh (S.A No. 48 of 1976) | Similar principle supporting fee payment only when plaintiff prays for decree on title. | Supported the view that fee is not payable if plaintiff does not seek relief on title basis. |
| Raghubar Dayal Prasad v. Ramekbal Sah (A.I.R 1986 Patna 78) | Division Bench decision upholding that additional court fee payable only if plaintiff prays for decree on title. | Confirmed the settled legal position consistent with other precedents. |
| Abdulla Bin v. Galahha ((1985) 2 SCC 54 : A.I.R 1985 S.C 577) | General principle on valuation and court fee in civil suits. | Supported rejection of petitioners' contention for mandatory advalorem fee payment by plaintiff when title issue is raised by defendant. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court analyzed the nature of the suit and the implications of raising the issue of title by the defendant tenant. It emphasized that the written statement of the defendant does not alter the nature of the suit or the forum. The landlord's suit is fundamentally for eviction based on the landlord-tenant relationship. If the landlord fails to prove this relationship, the suit fails unless the landlord prays for eviction on the basis of title and the court grants relief under Order VII Rule 7 CPC.
The court reviewed precedents and observed that when the defendant raises the issue of title, and the plaintiff does not seek eviction on that basis, the plaintiff is not liable to pay additional advalorem court fee. The court distinguished cases where the plaintiff prays for decree based on title, which then necessitates valuation and payment of advalorem court fee. The court found that the petitioners' contention that advalorem fee must be paid whenever an issue on title is framed, regardless of who raised it, was not supported by binding precedent.
The court also clarified that the observations in Sheo Sankar Prasad must be understood in the context of a plaintiff seeking decree on title and do not support the petitioners' broader contention. The court further noted that the trial court's jurisdiction would not be prejudiced if the suit valuation is adjusted when the plaintiff prays for relief on title.
Holding and Implications
The revision applications are dismissed.
The court held that in eviction suits filed by landlords, if the tenant raises the question of title and the landlord does not pray for eviction on the basis of title, the landlord is not required to pay advalorem court fee on the value of the property. The decision directly affects the parties by affirming the trial court's rejection of the petitioners' claim for additional court fee. No new precedent was created; the court adhered to established legal principles as laid down in prior decisions.
Satyeshwar Roy, J.:— Heard the learned counsel for the parties. As the points-involved in all these cases are identical, the matter is being disposed of by this common order.
2. It was submitted on behalf of the petitioners that as an issue on the question of title has been framed by the court below, the opposite parties, plaintiffs in the court below, must pay advalorem court fee. There appears to be confusion on the question whether in a suit filed by landlord for eviction of tenant from a building, if the question of title is required to be gone into on being raised and pressed by the tenant, the landlord shall have to pay advalorem court fee even if he neither raised the question of title nor prayed for a decree on the basis of title. The opposite parties filed three separate suits for eviction of three tenants-petitioners from three tenanted buildings on the allegation that the petitioners were tenants of the opposite party. The former in the written statements, inter-alia, stated that they have purchased the property and were in possession of the same as owners. The question of title was raised in the written statement.
3. The trial court did not frame any issue on title. The petitioners filed C.R Nos. 280 to 282 of 1988 (R). It was ordered that as the petitioners had raised the question of title in the written statements, if they press that issue, the court below shall frame an issue on that point and decide the same. An issue on title in all the suits was framed as pressed by the petitioners.
4. The petitioners in the court below contended that as an issue on title has been framed and it shall be gone into, the opposite parties in all the three suits must pay advalorem court fee on the value of the property. The court below has negatived the contention. That is impugned.
5. The petitioners reiterated in this court the contention made on their behalf in the court below. It was submitted by Mr. Eqbal, learned counsel for the petitioners, that when ever an issue on title is framed, be it at the instance of the defendant—tenant or at the instance of plaintiff—landlord, plaintiff—landlord must pay advalorem court fee. On behalf of the Opposite Parties, Mr. Chatterjee, learned counsel, urged that if the question of title is to be gone into at the instance of the plaintiff, further court fee is payable. He submitted that as in these cases the question of title has been raised by the defendants and the plaintiffs till now have not prayed for a decree on the basis of title, no further court fee is payable. Mr. Eqbal relied in Smt. Kasturi Devi v. Shripal Singh: A.I.R 1954 Patna 128, Ramchandra Sah v. Chotan Sah: 1971 B.L.J.R 186, Sheo Sankar Prasad v. Barhan Mistry, 1985 P.L.J.R 358 and Sardendu Ghosh v. Binayendra Nath Ghosh: S.A No. 48 of 1976 (R) decided on 13th October, 1980) and Raghubar Dayal Prasad… v. Ramekbal Sah….: A.I.R 1986 Patna 78.
6. The written statement of defendant will neither change the nature of suit, nor the forum. If a landlord filed a suit for eviction of tenant on the basis of relationship of landlord and tenant, court shall go only into the question whether there is relationship of landlord and tenant. If the plaintiff fails in proving the relationship, the suit must fail. In these suits, the plaintiffs have prayed for a decree for eviction on the basis of relationship of landlord and tenant.
7. It is now settled that if the plaintiff fails to prove relationship of landlord and tenant and prays for decree for eviction on the basis of title, court may give him that relief in that suit, in view of Order VII Rule 7 of the Civil Procedure Code, if the parties have led evidence on the question of title and the plaintiff has not forfeited his right to seek relief on equitable ground. In that case, the plaintiff shall be required to pay advalorem court fee on the value of the property in suit. What is the legal position regarding payment of court fee when in a suit where question of title is raised by the defendant and the court goes into that question at the instance of the defendant but the plaintiff does not pray for decree for eviction on the basis of title? Shall the plaintiff be still required to pay advalorem court fee on the value of the property?
8. In Smt. Kasturi Devi plaintiff filed a suit for eviction of defendant on the basis that the latter was his tenant. Defendant raised question of title. It was held that the defendant was not in occupation as tenant. Title of plaintiff was accepted and decree in his favour was passed. It was held that the question of title was investigated at the instance of the defendant. Even if the value of the property was beyond the pecuniary jurisdiction of the trial court, no prejudice was caused to the defendant. Decree of the trial court was affirmed by a Division Bench. In Ram Chandra Sah and Sardendu Ghosh, the learned single Judge reiterated it. In Raghubar Dayal Praead, a Division Bench upheld that legal position. In none of these cases, it was held that even if the plaintiff does not pray for a decree for eviction on the basis of title, he shall have to pay advalorem court fee as contended by Mr. Eqbal.
9. In Sheo Shankar Prasad (supra) it was observed that “………before the court goes into the question of title not incidentally, but in a fullfledged manner, the plaintiff should be asked to pay advalorem court fee”. It appears from the judgment of that case that suit was filed by landlord for eviction of tenant. The tenant raised the question of title in defence. The trial court went into it in detail, but no additional court fee was paid by the landlord—plaintiff. He was appellant before this court in Second Appeal. On his behalf, prayer was made to remand the case to the trial court to enable plaintiff to value the suit according to the value of the property and to pay advalorem court fee. The observation of the learned single Judge noted above must be read in this context i.e prayer for decree on the basis of title. This case also does not help Mr. Eqbal. His contention cannot be accepted also in view of Abdulla Bin v. Galahha: (1985) 2 SCC 54 : A.I.R 1985 S.C 577. It was submitted by Mr. Eqbal and accepted by Mr. Chatterjee that if the opposite parties pray for decree for eviction on the basis of title, the trial court shall have to value the suit for computing additional court fee payable by the opposite parties. With reference to Sheo Shankar Prasad ((supra) Mr. Eqbal submitted that in that event if value of suits are found to be beyond the pecuniary jurisdiction of the Munsif, in whose court the suits are pending, it shall have to return the plaints for presentation before the court having pecuniary jurisdiction. It is true that in Sheo Shankar Prasad (supra), the learned Single judge while remitting back the matter to fix the valuation directed the trial court to return the plaint if the valuation fixed by it was found to be beyond its pecuniary jurisdiction. This observation of the learned single Judge in Sheo Shankar Prasad (supra) is contrary to the law laid down in Smt. Kasturi Devi and Raghubar Dayal Prasad (supra), the two Division Bench decisions particularly when in Sheo Shankar it was not recorded how the defendant was going to be prejudiced if the matter was heard again by the Additional Munsif.
10. In the result, I find no merit in these revision applications and the same are dismissed.
Alert