- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Surendra Kumar Saxena v. State Of Madhya Pradesh
Judicial Opinion Summary (Singh, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
This matter first came before the Court on 14 October 1987 on interlocutory applications (I.A. Nos. IV and V) seeking either an ad interim writ or an early hearing on merits. An earlier interim application (I.A. No. III) had been pressed before the learned vacation Judge on 17 June 1987 and was rejected on the ground that the dispute required decision on merits.
The petitioner alleged non-payment of salary since April 1985 and claimed he had been refused salary which was paid "less but not according to rules." The Court fixed the matter for hearing on 20 October 1987, but hearing extended over several dates because respondents/State sought multiple adjournments. Oral hearing concluded on 1 February 1988 and written arguments were placed on record on 11 February 1988; the matter was then closed for judgment.
Substantively, the petitioner entered service on 1 July 1976 on "temporary muster" in the Public Health Engineering Department, Maintenance Division, Gwalior. He was promoted to the post of "filter attendant" by order dated 6 May 1981 (annexure P1) as a "work-charged" employee in the pay-scale Rs. 90 (in the scale Rs. 90-3-120-4-140-5-170) on a temporary basis. An order addressed to the petitioner dated 1 February 1986 (annexure P3) informed him that he had not completed five years' service in that post, that the 1974/1984 rules did not provide pay-scale for filter attendant, and that an overpayment (Rs. 6,760.35) would be recovered.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the impugned order annexure P3 (dated 1 February 1986) is valid.
- Whether the petitioner, appointed as a "work-charged" filter attendant by annexure P1, is entitled to the revised pay-scale applicable to the post of "filter attendant" under the Madhya Pradesh Revision of Pay Rules, 1983 (i.e., Rs. 515-800) from the date of his appointment.
- Whether the petitioner can claim relief on the judicial doctrine of "equal pay for equal work" where statutory rules (1983 Rules and 1984 Rules) and their application to work-charged employees are in issue.
- Whether, in the circumstances, any costs or compensation are appropriate against the respondents for delay and conduct in litigation.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments (as recorded)
- The petitioner claimed entitlement to the pay-scale Rs. 515-800 applicable to the post of "filter attendant" under the 1983 Rules from the date of his appointment (annexure P1), on the ground that he discharged the same duties and functions as other filter attendants.
- Counsel for the petitioner (Sri Velankar) relied on the judicial doctrine of "equal pay for equal work" and invoked case-law (including Bhagwan Dass and other authorities) to support a claim that the petitioner should not be denied the minimum pay applicable to regularly appointed filter attendants.
- The petitioner sought, in addition to arrears, a claim for compensation (Rs. 10,000) and interest for non-payment of salary for about three years, invoking concepts described as restitutive/distributive justice (this claim was advanced but ultimately not accepted by the Court).
Respondents' / State's Arguments (as recorded)
- State Counsel Sri Sinha contended that the petitioner was a "work-charged" employee (not a "regularly appointed" filter attendant) and that regularly appointed filter attendants had different functions and duties; as such the petitioner was not entitled to pay-scales applicable to regularly appointed incumbents.
- The State relied on item 3(A) of annexure II to the 1984 Rules, submitting that the petitioner did not satisfy the minimum qualifications (specifically, passing Class VIII and a one-year ITI training certificate) required under column (4), cl. (ii) for the relevant entry and therefore could not be considered even a "temporary employee" under those rules for the revised scale shown (Rs. 445-635) — as argued by Sri Sinha.
- State took a position (in annexure P3 and related material) that the post of "filter attendant" was not provided for under the 1984 Rules and that, accordingly, the petitioner was not entitled to revised pay under those rules; the State also asserted an overpayment had occurred which it proposed to recover.
- State filed an unverified application (I.A. No. VI) asserting certain factual averments (for example, that petitioner worked as pump attendant and was not on the Moti Jheel filter plant), but the Court declined to rely on these unverified and unpressed averments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Karyabharit Evam Dainik Vetan Karmachari Sangh, Bargi Nagar, Jabalpur v. State of Madhya Pradesh [1988-I L.L.N 122] | Decision of the Divisional Bench on 10 April 1987 (consideration of validity of 1984 Rules). | The Court stated the view taken made it unnecessary to examine rival contentions raised with reference to this decision; it observed that that decision dealt with constitutional validity of the 1984 Rules and not scope/applicability to particular cases. |
| Bhagwan Dass v. State of Haryana [1988-I L.L.N 1] | Authority on constitutional issues (referred to by parties in relation to temporal sequencing and relevance to other decisions). | The Court noted Bhagwan Dass did not entitle the petitioner to the full revised scale under the 1983 Rules, though it considered Bhagwan Dass when addressing rival submissions; Bhagwan Dass was distinguished on facts and scope. |
| Daily-rated Casual Labour Employed under Posts and Telegraphs Department v. Union of India [1988-I L.L.N 48] | Illustration and exposition of the doctrine "equal pay for equal work" and the constitutional protection of minimum wages for State employees performing same work. | The Court relied on this decision as articulating the pith and substance of the equal pay doctrine and used it to support awarding the petitioner the minimum of the higher pay-scale where he discharged the same duties as regularly employed filter attendants. |
| Dhirendra Chamoli v. State of Uttar Pradesh [1986-I L.L.N 293] | Supportive authority for equal pay principle and protection against denying minimum pay to similarly placed workers. | Cited as an earlier case giving similar meaning to the doctrine; used to reinforce the Court's application of equal pay to the petitioner. |
| Surinder Singh v. Engineer-in-Chief, Central Public Works Department [1986-I L.L.N 522] | Support for the proposition that minimum pay cannot be denied to a State employee doing the same work because of different mode of recruitment. | Relied upon as part of the body of authority reinforcing the equal pay principle applied to the petitioner's claim. |
| Randhir Singh v. Union of India [1982-I L.L.N 327] | Source case concerning pay differential generally; part of the jurisprudential origin of the equal pay doctrine. | Referred to as one of the source authorities underlying the judicial doctrine relied upon by the Court. |
| Ramachandra Iyer (P.K) v. Union of India [1984-I L.L.N 433] | Held unequal pay-scales based on no or irrational classification violative of Arts. 14, 16 and 39(d). | Used to support the constitutional dimension of the equal pay doctrine and the proposition that statutory rules cannot be applied to produce irrational discrimination. |
| Delhi Veterinary Association v. Union of India [1984-II L.L.N 46] | Guidance to pay commission and interpretation surrounding pay-scale determination. | Cited for context on how pay commissions/rules are to be guided; Court observed decisions do not require total ignoring of statutory rules but can fill gaps constitutionally. |
| Raja Bai Gorkar (Kumari) v. State of Madhya Pradesh [1987-II L.L.N 577] | Authority for awarding compensatory costs against the State for vexatious defence and unnecessary delays. | The Court relied on this decision to justify awarding costs against the respondents for unjustified adjournments and meritless defence conduct; it awarded Rs. 2,000 by reference to Raja Bai Gorkar. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
Summary of the Court's step-by-step legal analysis based exclusively on the opinion text.
- The Court began by isolating the determinative point: whether the petitioner, claiming salary as a filter attendant, was discharging the functions and duties of the post of "filter attendant" and thereby entitled to the pay applicable to that post.
- The Court examined the statutory framework: the Madhya Pradesh Revision of Pay Rules, 1983 (given retrospective effect from 1 April 1981) and the Madhya Pradesh Work-charged and Contingency Paid Employees Revision of Pay Rules, 1984 (retrospective effect from 1 April 1982). It noted that the 1983 Rules (annexure II) specifically list the post of "filter attendant" with an existing scale shown as Rs. 135-230 and revised scale Rs. 515-800.
- The Court considered the 1984 Rules which govern work-charged and contingency paid employees and observed their scope: these rules apply to members (work-charged employees) drawing pay in the existing scale on 1 April 1982, with provisos about temporary employees needing minimum qualifications per annexure II. The Court quoted rules 3, 4 and 5 of the 1984 Rules to set out their application mechanics.
- The respondents' specific contention that item 3(A) of annexure II to the 1984 Rules governed the petitioner's entitlement was analysed and rejected on the factual ground that the post of "filter attendant" is not contained in item 3(A) — the Executive Engineer himself (in annexure P3) admitted the post of "filter attendant" was not provided for under the 1984 Rules. Hence, the Court concluded the 1984 Rules could not be the basis to deny the petitioner's claim in the present case.
- Because the 1984 Rules did not apply to the "filter attendant" post in question, reliance on the second proviso to rule 3 (which could have disallowed entitlement under 1984 Rules) would not assist the respondents. Thus the Court declined to decide the case purely under the 1984 Rules' machinery.
- The Court then engaged with the constitutional doctrine of "equal pay for equal work." It reviewed authorities (including the Daily-rated Casual Labour decision and others) that emphasize that the State cannot deny minimum pay to employees performing the same duties on the basis of differential recruitment or status. The Court held that where a pay-scale for a post exists under the 1983 Rules and the petitioner is performing the same duties as those for whom that scale is provided, he cannot be denied the minimum pay under that scale.
- The Court distinguished Bhagwan Dass and Karyabharit: Bhagwan Dass concerned different factual questions (temporary appointments under a scheme, breaks in service and arbitrary treatment) and Karyabharit concerned constitutional validity of the 1984 Rules; neither decision required the Court to change its outcome on the instant facts. The Court also noted that it need not ignore statutory rules even while applying the constitutional doctrine; rather, the constitutional doctrine can fill gaps.
- The Court considered (and declined) the petitioner's separate claim for restitutionary compensation (Rs. 10,000) and interest: it noted the petitioner had himself initially refused to accept any salary unless it were in accordance with revised pay-scales (annexure R3) and that there existed some justification for the respondents' caution as manifested by audit directions (annexure R1). Thus the Court was not persuaded to award the claimed compensation.
- The Court found the State's conduct in repeatedly seeking adjournments and failing to file the promised affidavit to be meritless and unjustified, causing staggered proceedings. On that basis, the Court exercised its discretion to award compensatory costs against the respondents (Rs. 2,000), relying on precedent (Raja Bai Gorkar) that supports costs for vexatious defence and undue delay.
- Finally, the Court set out remedial directions: it quashed annexure P3; ordered that the petitioner is entitled to the minimum salary in the Rs. 515-800 pay-scale (without increments at this stage) from the date of his appointment as filter attendant (i.e., being entitled via the 1983 Rules as of 1 April 1981); directed recomputation of salary, modification of any recovery order; directed that the petitioner be paid monthly at the rate of Rs. 515 until the State takes appropriate action under rule 11 of the 1984 Rules or otherwise; ordered payment of arrears and costs within one month.
Holding and Implications
CORE HOLDING: The impugned order annexure P3 is quashed. The petitioner is entitled to be paid the minimum salary in the pay-scale Rs. 515-800 for the post of "filter attendant" with effect from the date of his appointment (in view of that pay-scale being available for the post from 1 April 1981 under the 1983 Rules).
Direct consequences and operational directions made by the Court (as recorded in the opinion):
- The direction in annexure P3 that the petitioner would be entitled only to the old/existing pay-scale (Rs. 90-170) is quashed.
- The salary payable to the petitioner shall be recomputed in accordance with the Court's directions; the order of recovery previously made from his salary shall be modified accordingly.
- The petitioner shall be paid monthly salary at the rate of Rs. 515 (the minimum of the 515-800 scale) without increments until the State Government takes action in accordance with rule 11 of the 1984 Rules (or otherwise) to deal with the petitioner's case under applicable rules.
- Arrear salary and the costs awarded (Rs. 2,000) shall be paid within one month from the date of the judgment.
- The petition was allowed with costs to the extent indicated (award of Rs. 2,000 against the respondents for delay/unnecessary adjournments and meritless defence conduct).
Broader implications: The Court applied the constitutional doctrine of "equal pay for equal work" to fill a gap where a post (filter attendant) had a pay-scale under the 1983 Rules but was not encompassed by the 1984 Rules for work-charged employees. The Court did not state that it was creating a new precedent beyond applying established authorities; it distinguished other authorities where necessary and relied on settled principles to prevent discrimination in minimum pay for employees doing the same work.
Singh, J.:— For the first time, this matter came before us on 14 October 1987. On that day, two alternative prayers were pressed before us vide I.A Nos. IV and V — for issuance of ad interim writ, in the alternative, early hearing of the matter on merits for final disposal. We were then informed that since April 1985, the petitioner had not been paid salary and indeed, it was admitted, “he had refused salary which was paid to him less but not according to rules.” We immediately fixed 20 October 1987, for hearing of the matter on merits. However, at this stage, it may be noted that on an earlier occasion, on 17 June 1987, prayer for interim writ as per I.A No. III was also pressed before the learned vacation Judge, but the prayer was rejected even at that time taking the view that the dispute between the parties was to be decided on merits.
2. Unfortunately, despite our best efforts, hearing could not be completed on 20 October 1987, and thereafter on various dates, prayers were made for adjournment on behalf of the respondents/State and further hearing was reluctantly postponed from time to time. However, we heard counsel again on 2 December, 1987 and on 16 December 1987, when the matter was further heard, we took the view that the only point to be decided in the case was, whether the petitioner was discharging functions and duties of filter attendant “regularly appointed” to the post because he claimed salary on that basis. It was submitted on that date by State Counsel Sri Sinha that “regularly appointed” filter attendant had different functions and duties unlike the petitioner who was a “work-charged filter attendant.” Counsel took time to place material before us in that regard by filing affidavit, etc., within three days. Although the matter had to come before us for further hearing on 8 January 1988, we had to note on 11 January 1988, the statement of Sri Sinha that the “affidavit was almost ready and would be filed tomorrow.” We adjourned further hearing to 13 January 1988, by our order passed on 11 January 1988. Unfortunately, neither on 13 January 1988, nor on any date thereafter, the proposed “affidavit” came and on behalf of the State, prayer was made on 25 January 1988, to adjourn the hearing further. On 1 February 1988, we concluded the oral hearing which had staggered too long, but allowed counsel to file written arguments before 4 February 1988. On the next date, on the prayer of State Counsel, further time was allowed to him to file written arguments on or before 10 February 1988. The case was closed for judgment and indeed only on 11 February 1988, we got on record “arguments” in writing signed by State Counsel Sri Sinha.
3. Now, few material facts which are short and simple, but relevant and rather necessary, therefore, to be stated to dispose of the controversy. It is petitioner's case, which is not disputed that on 1 July 1976, his services began on “temporary muster,” in Public Health Engineering Department, Maintenance Division, Gwalior. Although it is denied in the return that the petitioner was taken on “regular muster” as “pump driver” on and from 2 July 1977, it is still admitted that he continued to serve the department “on daily wages prior to his appointment vide order, dated 6 May, 1981 (annexure P1).” On a plain reading of annexure P1, it appears clear that on the recommendation of departmental promotion committee, the petitioner was appointed as “work-charged” employee in the post of “filter attendant” at the salary of Rs. 90 in the pay-scale of Rs. 90-3-120-4-140-5-170 on temporary basis until further orders and on other terms and conditions applicable to work-charged employees.
4. Before us in this matter, validity of the order annexure P3 passed on 1 February 1986, is assailed. In this letter which is addressed by respondent 2 Executive Engineer, P.H.E, Maintenance Division No. 1, Gwalior, to the petitioner, there is reference to petitioner's note, copy of which is filed with the return as a part of annexure R3. The note discloses petitioner's refusal to accept salary on the basis of old pay-scale. By annexure P3, the petitioner was informed that he had been appointed as filter attendant in the pay-scale of Rs. 90, etc. 170 and that he had not completed five years' service on that post. He was also informed that the relevant rules applicable to work-charged and contingency employees of 1974 and 1984 did not provide any pay-scale for the post of filter attendant. For availing benefit of revised pay-scales, a work-charged employee was required to complete ten years' service and in that connection, reference in the letter was made to annexure II of the relevant rules (to which, we will soon advert) to intimate him further that the petitioner did not fulfil the other eligibility conditions thereunder and in that view of the matter, benefit of five years' service that he had put in would not avail him. In the same letter, it was further mentioned that an over-payment of Rs. 6,760.35 was made to him as a result of his being given the benefit of the revised pay-scale through mistake and that the amount would be recovered from him for which appropriate proceedings were being taken.
5. Although endless arguments on both sides had been advanced as also in written arguments and a huge mass of case-law is cited to support various contentions, as earlier alluded, we propose to dispose of this matter by considering merely the grievance of the petitioner based on the judicial doctrine “equal pay for equal work” and in that regard only we propose to refer also the relevant statutory provisions and case-law cited. Madhya Pradesh Revision of Pay Rules, 1983, for short, 1983 Rules or rules had been given, retrospective effect under rule 1(2) of the said rules from 1 April 1981. However, rule 4 of the said rules, by Cl. (d) of the proviso excluded from operation ot those rules, “persons paid from contingencies and work-charged employees.” Revised scales of pay applicable to various posts are shown in annexures I and II of the rules. Annexure II contains particulars of “post” in different departments showing “existing scales” and “revised scales” applicable to Government servants in the pay and establishments of the State of Madhya Pradesh. The post of “filter attendant” is one of the posts in the Public Health Engineering Department mention of which is made in annexure II. The existing pay-scale of the post is shown as Rs. 135-230 and the revised scale as Rs. 515-800. In this matter, the petitioner claimed that he is entitled to be paid salary in the pay-scale of Rs. 515-800 from the date of his appointment as “filter attendant” under annexure P1 because all filter attendants, whether they are employed on “work-charged” basis or are borne on “permanent establishment” they do the same job.
6. We also looked at the Madhya Pradesh Work-charged and Contingency Paid Employees Revision of Pay Rules, 1984, for short, 1984 Rules or the rules to which reference is made in annexure P3. These rules have also been given retrospective effect on and from 1 April 1982, by rule 1(b). The terms “permanent employee” and “temporary employee” are defined in rule 2 under Cls. (g) and (h) respectively; Cl. (i) defines the term “member” to mean “member of the work-charged and contingency paid employees service drawing pay in the existing scale.” We extract in extenso rules 3 and 4:
“3. Scope and application.— These rules shall apply to all members of the work-charged and contingency paid employees' service drawing pay in the existing scale on 1 April 1982:
Provided that a temporary employee shall be governed by these rules only, if he fulfils the requisite qualifications shown in column (4) of annexure II in respect of the posts mentioned in column (2) thereof:
Provided further that a temporary employee who does not possess the requisite qualifications will continue to get the emoluments in the existing scale till ho becomes permanent member as per Cl. (g) of rule 2.
4. Revised scale of pay.— The revised scale of pay applicable to a post carrying existing scale shown in column (2) of annexure I shall be the corresponding scale shown in column (4) thereof in respect of that post.”
[emphasis added.]
In virtue of rule 5, a “permanent employee” as also a “temporary employee” are enabled to “draw pay in the revised scale applicable to the post which be holds.” In annexure I of the rules are given “existing,” and “revised” scales of pay. In annexure II are given columnwise such particulars as—
“(2) designation;
(3) pay-scale;
(4) minimum qualification, experience and other conditions; and
(5) percentage for direct recruitment and promotion.”
Reliance is placed by Sri Sinha, Government Advocate, on item 3(A) of annexure II to support the impugned order annexure P1. It is counsel's submission that the minimum qualifications envisaged thereunder are not fulfilled by the petitioner and as such, he cannot even be considered as a “temporary employee” though he had completed five years' service on the date on which the order was passed. Indeed, his precise contention is that petitioner could have availed the revised pay-scale Rs. 445-635 under item 3(A) of annexure II if he fulfilled the requirement contemplated under Cl. (ii) of column (4) of annexure II which contemplate that the holder of the post mentioned in column (2) must have “passed VIII class and one year training certificate from ITI.” Because the petitioner's case is not that he possessed one year training certificate from ITI, he was not en titled to the revised pay-scale contemplated against item 3(A) of annexure II.
7. In this connection, it may be noted that in annexure II, the revised scale, Rs. 445-635, is shown as the new pay-scale which replaces two “existing” pay-scales— (a) 90-170, and (b) 105-200. However, it is also to be noted that of the several different posts described by their respective “designations” in column (2) of item 3(A), there is no post of “filter attendant.” True it is, column (2) also speaks illustratively of “and others of equivalent work requirements,” but, the fact of the matter is that the Executive Engineer has himself, in his letter annexure P1, admitted that the post of “filter attendant” is not provided for under 1984 Rules and, therefore, we will not be justified in accepting the contention of Sri Sinha that the case of the petitioner has to be decided in the context of item 3(A) of annexure II of 1984 Rules. Indeed, as earlier alluded, although Sri Sinha persuaded us to adjourn hearing of the matter repeatedly to enable him to file affidavit to establish the nature of duties and functions of the petitioner, but that move proved abortive.
8. Still, to be fair to Sri Sinha, we may mention that he did file, though he did not press it, I.A No. VI on 13 January 1988, in which he took upon himself the responsibility of making few unverified factual averments. The application is signed only by the counsel and not even by the officer in-charge and indeed, it is not even supported by any affidavit. In the said application, it is stated that the petitioner was working as pump attendant in Maintenance Division 1, Public Health Engineering Department, Gwalior, and that he was “not on the filter plant installed at Moti Jheel.” We do not think if we would be justified to take cognizance of the averments made in the said application which was not pressed even for our acceptance in the course of hearing and also because of the new stand taken in the said application contrary to admission of the Executive Engineer himself in annexure P3. It has been clearly established in this cage on the basis of annexures P1 and P3 that the petitioner was appointed to the post of “filter attendant” on 6 May 1981, and that he was discharging the duties and functions of that post even on 1 February, 1986 and this position came to obtain as a result of his promotion to the post on the basis of the recommendations of the departmental promotion committee though he was initially inducted into service as a “pump driver.” In annexure P4, it is clearly projected that in 1979, the petitioner was serving as a pump driver and as such, he had continued on that post till he was promoted to the post, of “filter attendant” in 1981.
9. We are of the view on the facts and law discussed above, relevant to the controversy in issue, that the case of the petitioner cannot be disposed of in terms of 1984 Rules. Because, though he was appointed as a filter attendant in 1981 under annexure P1 as a “work-charged” employee in the scale of Rs. 90-170 and the corresponding revised pay-scale under 1984 Rules is Rs. 445-635, that scale of pay mentioned in 1984 Rules is not meant for the “post of filter attendant.” This position, as we have seen, has indeed been accepted and admitted by the Executive Engineer in his letter annexure P 3. Rules 4 and 5 of 1984 Rules make it clear that the “existing” as also “revised” scales of pay envisaged under 1984 Rules are relatable to (in respect of) particular “posts” mentioned in annexure II of the said rules. There being no mention of the post of “filter attendant” in 1984 Rules reliance on the provisions thereof to dismiss the claim of the petitioner (in terms of second proviso to rule 3) would not avail the respondents.
10. The view we have taken in this matter renders it unnecessary for us to examine rival contentions raised with reference to a recent decision of this Court in Karyabharit Evam Dainik Vetan Karmachari Sangh, Bargi Nagar, Jabalpur v. State of Madhya Pradesh [1988-I L.L.N 122]. On behalf of the petitioner, Sri Velankar has contended vehemently that the decision has to be ignored as it has ceased to be a good law, running counter to the view expressed by their Lordships in Bhagwan Dass v. State of Haryana [1988-I L.L.N 1], of which no notice could indeed have been taken by the Divisional Bench which decided the case on 10 April 1987, before decision was rendered by their Lordships of the Supreme Court in Bhagwan Dass (vide supra), on 31 July 1987. Indeed, this Court, in the above referred case, was required merely to consider the constitutional validity of 1984 Rules and nothing more. The rules were held valid and no other question was considered on the scope, ambit, interpretation and applicability of the rules to any particular case. That being the position, we do not consider it necessary to deal with case law cited on both sides on rival contentions on the validity of the decision or of 1984 Rules.
11. However, we are also not satisfied that reliance on Bhagwan Dass [1988-I L.L.N 1] (vide supra), would avail the petitioner to press his claim to the extent that he was entitled to the benefit of the revised pay-scale contemplated under 1983 Rules in respect of the post of “filter attendant,” namely, Rs. 515-800. On the other hand, the petitioner, in our view, would only be entitled, in the facts and circumstances of the case, to claim the minimum salary in the pay-scale of Rs. 515-800 (without increments, at this stage) on the basis of the judicial doctrine “equal pay for equal work.” Because he has been appointed as “filter attendant” and there is a pay-scale for the post of “filter attendant” under 1983 Rules and none under 1984 Rules, for the work done in the post of “filter attendant,” he cannot be denied the minimum salary which was being paid to any “filter attendant” (under 1983 Rules) in the same Public Health Engineering Department. More on this later, as we have to say few words first on Bhagwan Dass (vide supra), to repel the contention of Sri Velankar advancing petitioner's claim to the pay-scale of “filter attendant” under 1983 Rules.
12. Their Lordships were not required to consider in Bhagwan Dass [1988-I L.L.N 1] (vide supra), the scope of entitlement under two different sets of service rules. The questions which fell for their Lordships' consideration were that the petitioners had been treated as temporary Government servants and were not being regularised and they were not being given the benefit of the pay-scale applicable in case of regular employees though they did the same work as supervisors in the education department who had been absorbed as regular Government servants. Indeed, in that case the question was, whether the petitioners could be denied the pay-scale on the ground that their appointments, were made under a temporary scheme on six monthly basis and there was a break in their service. There, service conditions of the petitioners were not regulated by any statutory rules, which exposed them to arbitrary treatment. The holding in that case was that the petitioners could not be denied the pay-scale as they were entitled to be paid on the basis of length of service computed from their date of appointment by disregarding the breaks.
13. In the instant case, the position is entirely different. The petitioner is a “work-charged” employee as his right is traceable to his appointment made under annexure P1. True, 1984 Rules have been framed to deal with cases of persons of his class though his case unfortunately is not covered by those rules. Still, on that account, it cannot be said that the rules are so deficient or incomplete that the petitioner may stand the risk of being treated arbitrarily and, therefore, we ignore his statutory status as a “work-charged” worker and treat him on the same basis as a case of “temporary” employee conceived under Bhagwan Dass [1988-I L.L.N 1] (vide supra), to protect his interest in the same manner. This view, we have taken because of the provisions contained in rule 11 of 1984 Rules by which the State Government is empowered to “relax or suspend the operation of any of the provisions of these rules in the case of an employee or category of employees in such manner and to such extent as may appear to it to be just and equitable or necessary or expedient in the public interest.” Indeed, the provision is meant to ensure that the rules do not operate to the “disadvantage of the employee or category of employees, as the case may be” as is made clear by the proviso to the rule. That apart, it is well within the competence of the State Government to amend the rules if so advised, from time to time, should it appear to it that the case of any work-charged employee or class or category of such employees who discharge duties of a particular post as such an employee has been ignored or overlooked under those rules. In Bhagwan Dass case (vide supra), such position did not obtain and arbitrary action of the Government in dealing with persons discharging same duties and functions to the disadvantage of some such persons was struck down. That was a case of a pay-scale which could be otherwise availed, but being denied arbitrarily by making appointments of some persons on six monthly basis and the break of service disentitling them to claim the pay-scale.
14. Other decisions cited by Sri Velankar on the doctrine “equal pay for equal work” do indeed support the view we have taken in this case. In the latest decision in Daily-rated Carnal Labour Employed under Posts and Telegraphs Department v. Union of India [1988-I L. L N. 48], we read what may be considered as the pith and substance of the doctrine. If a “filter attendant” who is borne on the permanent establishment is entitled to the pay-scale of Rs. 515-800, it would be a gross violation of Arts. 14, 16, 23, 37, 38, 39(d) and indeed also of 43 of the Constitution if the petitioner discharging the same functions and duties is allowed to continue in the pay-scale of Rs. 90-170. What was regarded statutorily as the minimum wage (“living wage” under Art. 43) for a class of “filter attendants” should be applicable to all filter attendants in the same Public Health Engineering Department doing the same work so as to preempt denial of equal opportunity in matters of employment, such as, entitlement of minimum wage and protection against forced labour. It was held by their Lordships in the Dai'y-rated Casual Labour case (vide supra), that State could not deny to them the minimum pay in the pay-scale of regularly employed workmen because such denial amounted to exploitation of labour. The Government cannot take advantage of its dominant position and compel any worker to work even as a casual labourer on starving wages though the Government may not be compelled to extend all the benefits enjoyed by regularly recruited employees. The same view was earlier taken in a similar case Dhirendra Chamoli v. State of Uttar Pradesh [1986-I L.L.N 293], which was cited before their Lordships, but there are other cases also which give the same meaning to the doctrine, such as Surinder Singh v. Engineer-in-Chief, Central Public Works Department [1986- I L.L.N 522]. The principle underlying the decisions indeed is that no employee under the State would be denied the minimum wage (to which a regularly appointed employee is entitled) on the footing that same employee is not similarly appointed and is recruited differently and he does not possess the same or similar qualifications for the job. In the source of the judicial doctrine, Randhir Singh v. Union of India [1982-I L.L.N 327], the question considered was of pay differential generally, though later, in Ramachandra Iyer (P.K) v. Union of India [1984-I L.L.N 433], their Lordships categorically held that unequal scales of pay based on no classification or irrational classification was violative of Arts. 14, 16 and 39(d). In Delhi Veterinary Association v. Union of India [1984-II L.L.N 46], the pay commission was given necessary guidance in the matter. Decisions cited, we reiterate, do not lay down that when statutory rules occupy the field, they have to be totally ignored. According to us, the constitutional doctrine can be, and has to be, used to fill in gaps in such rules.
13. However, Sri Velankar has also made submissions to persuade us to develop the concept of restitutive justice by enlarging the concept of distributive justice in pressing the claim of the petitioner for award of a compensation of Rs. 10,000 and also interest against the respondents for non-payment of salary to him for the last three years. Unfortunately, in the facts and circumstances of the case, we are not satisfied if that exercise we should undertake in this case because of the stand which the petitioner had himself taken initially in annexure R3 refusing to accept any salary until his salary was drawn and paid to him in accordance with the revised pay-scales. In this case, there is some justification for the action by the respondents which is manifested in two letters marked annexure R1. These are two letters addressed by the Engineer-in-Chief, Public Health Engineering Department of the State on 17 February, 1987 to all Executive Engineers of Public Health Engineering Divisions of the State in the context of audit objections in regard to “over payments” on the basis of “incorrect fixation” of pay by allowing benefit of revised pay-scales. True it is, the general audit objection may not be the final word as this Court shall have the final say on the petitioner's grievance, as to what salary he had to be paid. It cannot still be said that action of the respondents was wholly without jurisdiction or tainted with mala fide.
14. We are still prepared to take care of the injustice which the petitioner has suffered in the course of hearing of his grievances in this Court on account of adjournments which State Counsel obtained unnecessarily and without valid justification. Sri Velankar has drawn our attention to this Court's decision in Raja Bai Gorkar (Kumari) v. State of Madhya Pradesh [1987-II L.L.N 577], when this Court made an order for compensatory cost against the State in the sum of Rs. 5,000 for “vexatious defence” and for unnecessarily and unceremoniously delaying proceedings in this Court. We are satisfied that the petitioner has a reasonable grievance against the meritless defence which was advanced in this case by the State in support of which “affidavit” was to be filed and has not been filed, but also for staggering disposal of the matter otherwise on account of several adjournments which State Counsel obtained in the course of hearing of the matter. We consider it appropriate to make an order for costs against the respondents in the sum of Rs. 2,000.
15. For the reasons aforesaid, we hold that the impugned order annexure P3 must go. We bold that the petitioner is entitled to be paid the minimum salary in the pay-scale of Rs. 515-800 for the post of “filter attendant” with effect from the date of his appointment as he would be entitled thereto in virtue of that pay-scale being available for that post on and from 1 April, 1981 under the 1983 Rules. This view, we have taken on being satisfied about the position that he is discharging the same duties and functions of the post of “filter attendant” to which other persons serving in that post doing the same job are entitled from 1 April 1981. Accordingly, the direction in the impugned order annexure P3 that the petitioner will be entitled to salary in the old or existing pay-scale of Rs. 90-170 is quashed. We also direct that the salary payable to him shall be recomputed in accordance with the directions herein made and the order of recovery from his salary shall be modified to that extent. We further direct that he shall be continued to be paid monthly salary at the rate of Rs. 515 without increments till such time as appropriate action is not taken by the State Government in accordance with rule 11 of 84 Rules by amendment of the rules or in such other manner as it may deem fit and proper to ensure that the petitioner, while serving in the post of “filter attendant” does not suffer a hostile treatment and his case is dealt with under the rules applicable to him in accordance with constitutional imperatives as laid down in the decisions of their Lordships of the Supreme Court. The arrear-salary of the petitioner as also the costs awarded to him shall be paid within one month from today.
16. As a result, the petition succeeds and is allowed with costs to the extent already indicated above.
Alert