Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Dr. Subhash Chandrakar v. State Of Madhya Pradesh And Others

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Jul 3, 1997
Smart Summary (Beta)

Court Opinion Summary — Durga Mahavidyalaya Selection Proceedings (W.P. Nos. 1164/96, 1174/96, 1750/96)

Factual and Procedural Background

These writ petitions arise from common selection proceedings for appointment to the posts of Assistant Professor in Political Science and Philosophy at Durga Mahavidyalaya, an institution governed by the Madhya Pradesh Ashashkiya Shikshan Sanstha (Adhyapakon Tatha Anya Karmachariyon Ke Vetano Ka Sandaya Adhiniyam, 1978) and rules framed thereunder. An advertisement was issued under the Recruitment Rules. The selection committee prepared panels: Dr. Subhash Chandrakar was placed at the top of the Philosophy panel; Dr. (Ku.) Gayatri Sharma was placed at number one and Dr. (Smt.) Ranjana Sharma at number two in the Political Science panel.

The Governing Body issued appointment orders dated 2-3-1996 in favour of Dr. Subhash Chandrakar (Philosophy) and Dr. (Smt.) Ranjana Sharma (Political Science). A few days later, by a communication dated 7-3-1996, the Chairman of the Governing Body cancelled those appointments, stating that the appointment orders had been issued by mistake because the Governing Body had found legal infirmities in the selection panels and had not decided to appoint anyone from them. The communication offered the candidates an option to apply when posts were re-advertised.

The affected persons filed writ petitions: Dr. Subhash Chandrakar and Dr. (Smt.) Ranjana Sharma challenged cancellation of their appointments (W.P. Nos. 1174/96 and 1164/96 respectively), and Dr. (Ku.) Gayatri Sharma filed W.P. No. 1750/96 challenging her non-selection to the Political Science post.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Governing Body validly cancelled the appointment orders issued on 2-3-1996, particularly when those appointments had been acted upon by the appointees.
  2. Whether Rule 15(3) of the Recruitment Rules, requiring the selection list to contain names five times the number of posts, is mandatory or directory (i.e., whether a selection panel with fewer than five names is valid where fewer suitable candidates exist).
  3. Whether the selection committee's failure to record reasons (minutes disclosing due application of mind) for relaxing the minimum prescribed percentage of marks (50% at B.A. level) vitiates the selection panel and appointments.
  4. Whether the cancellation of appointment orders issued by mistake required observance of principles of natural justice (i.e., hearing the affected appointees and/or selection committee members) before annulment.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments (Applicants / Selected Candidates)

  • Counsel for Dr. Subhash Chandrakar and Dr. (Smt.) Ranjana Sharma contended the cancellation breached principles of natural justice because neither the appointees nor selection committee members were heard before annulling the appointments. Reliance was placed on Shrawan Kumar Jha v. State of Bihar (as cited in the opinion).
  • It was argued that Rule 15(3) (the requirement of the panel to contain five times the number of posts) is directory and not mandatory; if fewer suitable candidates exist, the selection committee may recommend fewer than five names. Reliance was placed on earlier decisions including Zahir Ahmed v. Kuladhipati Bhopal and Ram Singh v. University of Sagar.
  • Concerning the required 50% marks at B.A. level, counsel for the petitioners contended that the Rules themselves contain a proviso permitting the selection committee to relax the qualification where research work is of a very high standard; where a candidate appears in the panel, an inference of relaxation can be drawn (relying on the judge's prior decision in Dr. Subhash Chand Jain v. State of M.P.).
  • Counsel for Dr. (Ku.) Gayatri Sharma argued that once the selection committee placed his client at number one, the Governing Body had no discretion to appoint another candidate (i.e., Ranjana Sharma) to the post of Assistant Professor in Political Science.

Respondents' Arguments (Governing Body / Institution)

  • Counsel for the Governing Body and the Principal stated that when the selection panel recommendations were placed before the Governing Body it found two legal infirmities: (a) the panel did not include the minimum five candidates per post as required by Rule 15(3), and (b) the recommended candidates did not possess the requisite percentage of marks at the B.A. level in one or more instances. Because of these infirmities the Governing Body decided not to operate the panel and to re-advertise the posts.
  • It was explained that appointment orders were issued due to confusion/mistake between the Chairman and the Principal; cancellation corrected that mistake. The respondents asserted that cancellation did not necessitate hearing anyone because it rectified a mistake and followed the Governing Body's recorded decision.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shrawan Kumar Jha v. State of Bihar, 1991 Supp (1) SCC 330; AIR 1991 SC 309; [1992 (6) SLR 718 (SC)] Relied upon by petitioners to support contention that cancellation without hearing violated principles of natural justice. The case was cited by petitioners on the natural justice point; the court recorded that reliance but the opinion does not state the court applied this precedent as determinative. The court examined the broader legal questions and remedies instead of solely relying on this authority.
Zahir Ahmed v. Kuladhipati Bhopal, 1983 MPLJ 723 Interpreted provisions similar to Rule 15(3) (preparation of panels) as directory rather than mandatory where fewer suitable candidates exist. The court relied on this decision (and Ram Singh) to hold that Rule 15(3) is directory and not mandatory; accordingly, the Governing Body was in error to reject the panel solely because it contained fewer than five names.
Ram Singh v. University of Sagar, 1973 MPLJ 561; [1973 (2) SLR 153 (MP)] Also treated provisions requiring a prescribed number of names in a panel as directory rather than mandatory in similar statutory contexts. The court cited this decision alongside Zahir Ahmed to support reading Rule 15(3) as directory; this influenced the court to uphold the petitioners' contention on that issue.
Dr. Subhash Chand Jain v. State of M.P. (W.P. No. 1255 of 1991) decided 9-11-1995; reported 1996 (1) MPWN 174 Earlier single-judge view that inclusion of a candidate in a panel permits an inference that the selection committee relaxed minimum prescribed percentage of marks. The Court observed that this earlier single-judge view was not fully approved in the subsequent L.P.A.; therefore, the inference of relaxation in favour of Dr. Gayatri Sharma could not be accepted without further examination. The opinion refers to this decision in discussing the issue of inferred relaxation.
R.S. Sharma v. M.P. Uchcha Siksha Anudan Ayog, 1993 JLJ 73 (Division Bench) Held that while the selection committee need not state full reasons, its proceedings must disclose due application of mind, particularly where relaxation of prescribed qualifications is involved. The court relied on this Division Bench decision to emphasize that minutes of the selection committee should disclose due application of mind when relaxing minimum prescribed percentage. The court used this principle to assess whether non-recording of reasons vitiated the panel.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by examining the Recruitment Rules and the Schedule containing minimum qualifications. The Schedule required a doctorate or research of equivalent standard and a second class Master's degree with minimum 50% marks, together with minimum 50% marks at all educational levels from Higher Secondary to Bachelor's degree. The Schedule contained a proviso permitting the selection committee to relax the minimum 50% requirement if the committee, in its opinion, found the candidate's research work (thesis or published work) to be of a very high standard.

Rule 15 was reproduced and analyzed. Of particular relevance was Rule 15(3), which on its face required that the list prepared under sub-rule (1) "shall contain the names of candidates five times the number of posts proposed to be filled up." The Governing Body's minutes (dated 18-7-1991) recorded two grounds for rejecting the selection panels: (a) panels did not contain five names for one post as required by Rule 15(3), and (b) the selection committee's proceedings did not disclose why it had relaxed the minimum 50% at B.A. level (i.e., no recorded reasons for relaxation).

On the first ground, the court accepted petitioners' submissions and held that Rule 15(3) is directory, not mandatory. The court relied on analogous authorities (Zahir Ahmed and Ram Singh) construing similar provisions and observed that in context and with the object of filling posts on merit, the expression "shall" in that rule must be read as directory. Therefore, the Governing Body erred in refusing to act on the panel solely because it contained fewer than five names.

On the second ground, the court reviewed authorities and earlier pronouncements. A single-judge earlier view (Dr. Subhash Chand Jain) suggested that inclusion of a candidate in the panel could give rise to an inference that the selection committee had relaxed the prescribed percentage. That view had not received full approval on appeal. The Division Bench decision in R.S. Sharma established that while the selection committee need not record elaborate reasons for every selection decision, its proceedings must disclose due application of mind—particularly when relaxation of minimum prescribed qualifications is involved.

Applying these principles, the court found that the selection committee's failure to record reasons for relaxation of the 50% requirement was an infirmity. However, the court considered that this non-recording was not so fundamental as to vitiate the entire selection proceedings. Instead of rejecting the whole panel, the Governing Body had the option to refer the matter back to the selection committee for recording appropriate reasons and a fresh panel confined to candidates falling within the zone of consideration on the relevant date. The Governing Body had acted under a misconception of law in rejecting the complete panel for that reason.

Because appointment orders had been issued by mistake despite the Governing Body's decision not to operate the panel, the court accepted that cancellation corrected a mistake. Nonetheless, given the legal errors in the Governing Body's approach (particularly with regard to Rule 15(3) and the appropriate remedy for non-recording of reasons), the court considered partial relief appropriate: quashing the cancellations in respect of the two appointees and directing that the selection committee be reconvened to record reasons / reconsider and submit a fresh panel; the Governing Body was directed to act upon the fresh panel under Rule 15.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The petitions were partly allowed. The Court quashed the cancellation orders dated 7-3-1996 insofar as they affected the petitioners Dr. Subhash Chandrakar and Dr. (Smt.) Ranjana Sharma, permitted them to continue in service and draw salary in terms of the appointment orders dated 2-3-1996, and directed reconvening of the selection committee to reconsider and submit a fresh panel in accordance with Rule 15. The Court also directed the selection committee to be reconvened for the Political Science post (affecting Dr. (Ku.) Gayatri Sharma) and ordered the Governing Body to act on the fresh panel. Parties were directed to bear their own costs insofar as the petition of Gayatri Sharma was only partly successful.

Implications and consequences:

  • The direct effect on the parties: Dr. Subhash Chandrakar and Dr. (Smt.) Ranjana Sharma are reinstated to continue in their posts and draw salary subject to the selection committee submitting a fresh panel and the Governing Body's decision thereon in accordance with the Court's directions. The Governing Body and the Principal are ordered to reconvene the selection committee to record reasons (where appropriate) and submit a fresh panel as on 18-7-1995.
  • On legal principles, the Court held that Rule 15(3) is directory and not mandatory in the circumstances described, and that minutes of a selection committee should disclose due application of mind when relaxation of prescribed minimum qualifications is claimed; but failure to record reasons is not invariably fatal and may be cured by referring the matter back to the selection committee.
  • The Court did not pronounce that a new broad precedent was being laid down beyond applying and following earlier authorities; it applied existing precedents and directed corrective, not punitive, measures. The remedies ordered were targeted at curing the procedural infirmities identified rather than striking down the selection process entirely.

Disposition: Petition allowed in part; detailed directions to reconvene the selection committee and for the Governing Body to act on a fresh panel; affected appointees to continue in service subject to compliance with the directions.

Show all summary ...

D.M Dharmadhikari, J.:— A common order is being passed in this petition and W.P No. 1164/96 (Dr. Smt. Ranjana Sharma v. State of M.P) and W.P No. 1750/96 (Dr. Ku. Gayatri Sharma v. State of M.P). All the petitions arise out of common selection proceedings recommending appointments to the teaching posts of Assistant Professor in the subjects of Political Science and Philosophy in Durga Mahavidyalaya which is an educational institution governed by the provisions of Madhya Pradesh Ashaskiya Shikshan Santha (Adhyapakon Tatha Anya Karmachariyon Ke Vetano Ka Sandaya Adhiniyam, 1978 (for short Act No. 20 of 1978).

2. Recruitments to teaching posts in an institution aided by the State are regulated by Madhya Pradesh Ashashkiya Shikshan Sanstha (Adhyapakon Tatha Anya Karmachriyon Ki Bharti) Niyam, 1979 (for short ‘the Rules’) framed under the Act. In accordance with the above rules, an advertisement for recruitment to the teaching posts was issued. Consequent thereupon, Dr. Subhash Chandrakar applied for the post of Assistant Professor in Philosophy and other petitioners Dr. (Smt.) Ranjana Sharma and Dr. (Ku.) Gayatri Sharma applied for the post of Assistant Professor in Political Science. The Departmental Promotion Committee made its recommendation to the Governing Body for appointment by preparing a selection penal for the post of Assistant Professor in Philosophy. The petitioner Dr. Subhash Chandrakar was placed at the top. In the selection panel for the post of Asstt. Professor in Political Science, Dr. Gayatri Sharma was placed at Serial No. 1 and Dr. Ranjan Sharma was placed at No. 2. On the recommendations made by the Selection Committee, the governing body issued orders of appointment on 2-3-1996 in favour of Dr. Subhash Chandrakar in the subject of philosophy and Dr. (Smt.) Ranjana Sharma in the subject of Political Science. After the appointees had assumed charge of office and started functioning, the Governing Body through its Chairman issued the impugned order dated 7-3-1996 (Annexure-P/18) only few days after their appointments which is challenged in this petition. By the impugned communication, petitioners Dr. Subhash Chandrakar and Dr. Ranjana Sharma were informed that appointment orders came to be issued in their favour by mistake as the Governing Body had found some legal lacuna in the selection panel and had not taken any decision to appoint anyone from the panel. They were given an option to apply as and when the posts are re-advertised.

3. By W.P No. 1174/96 and H64/96, Dr. Subhash Chandrakar and Dr. (Smt.) Ranjana Sharma have assailed the orders cancelling their appointments. Dr. (Ku.) Gayatri Sharma who was in the selection panel at th top for the subject of Political Science has filed writ petition No., 1750/96 as she felt aggrieved by her non-selection to the post of Assistant Professor in Political Science.

4. Shri Rajandra Tiwari, learned counsel who appears for Dr. Subhash Chandrakar and Dr. (Smt.) Ranjana Sharma assails the order of cancellation of their appointments firstly on the ground that the action is in flagrant breach of the principles of natural justice. It is contended that before annulment of their appointments, neither they were heard nor the members of the selection committee. Such action, it is said, deserves to be quashed on the short ground of denial opportunity of hearing. Reliance is placed on Shrawan Kumar Jha v. State of Bihar, 1991 Supp (1) SCC 330 : AIR 1991 SC 309 : [1992 (6) SLR 718 (SC)].

5. In response to the notice served to these petitions, Shri Alok Aradhe who appears for the Governing Body of the Institution and the Principal (respondents Nos. 3 and 4) has filed a return annexing with it the copy of the proceedings of the selection committee. It is pointed out that when the recommendation contained in the selection panel was placed before the Governing Body, it found that minimum five candidates for each post which should have been included in the panel in accordance with the rules were not there. It was also found that the two petitioners who were selected and appointed did not have requisite percentage of marks at B.A Level. Because of these legal infirmities in the recommendation of the selection committee, the Governing Body expressly recorded its decision not to operate the panel and to re-advertise the post for fresh selection. It is stated that because of some confusion between the Chairman and the Principal, by mistake, appointment orders came to be issued on the basis of such unapproved selection panel. By cancellation of the appointment orders, the said mistake has been corrected and the question of grant of opportunity of hearing to anyone was not at all necessitated.

6. Shri Rajendra Tiwari, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners, after the selection proceedings were filed in the case, assailed them to support the relief claimed in the petition. It is contended that the Governing Body totally misconstrued the rule to hold that the selection panel must have contained minimum five names for one available post. It is submitted that the rule in that behalf has only to be read as directory and not mandatory because if there are insufficient number of suitable candidates, it was open to the selection committee to recommend less than five candidates Reliance is placed on Single Bench decision of this Court in, Zahir Ahmed v. Kuladhipati Bhopal, 1983 MPLJ 723 and Ram Singh v. University of Sagar, 1973 MPLJ 561 : [1973 (2) SLR 153 (MP.)]. Relying on the above decisions, it is contended that similar provisions contained in the M.P Vishwavidyalay Adhiniyam and University of Sagar Act, in the matter of inclusion of names of eligible candidates in selection panel have been construed to be only directory and not mandatory.

7. So far as the other ground mentioned in the proceedings of the Governing Body that the candidates recommended did not have requisite percentage of marks at B.A level is concerned, Shri Rajendra Tiwari and Shri Ajit Singh appearing for Dr. Gayatri Sharma contend that there is a power of relaxation contained in the rules themselves and where such candidates were included in the panel relaxation of minimum required percentage of marks at B.A level may be inferred. Reliance is placed on my decision rendered at Gwalior in, Dr. Subhash Chand Jain v. State of M.P (M.P No. 1255 of 1991) decided on 9-11-1995 (1996) 1 MPWN 174.

8. Shri Ajit Singh, on behalf of his client Dr. (Ku.) Gayatri Sharma, also contended that once the selection committee had placed his client at number 1 in the list, the rules left no discretion with the Governing body to select and appoint Dr. Ranjana Sharma (i.e writ petitioner in W.P No. 1164/96) to the post of Assistant Professor in Political Science.

9. For deciding the rival contentions advanced by the learned counsel appearing for the three candidates before me in the three petitions, it would be necessary to examine the relevant provisions of the Recruitment Rules. The minimum qualifications for recruitment for the teaching posts in the institution are contained in Schedule appended below the rules. For Lecturers in colleges, the basic qualifications are a doctors' degree or published research work of equivalent high standard and II Class Masters' degree with minimum 50% marks. The candidate is also required to possess minimum 50% marks at all levels in his educational career from Higher Secondary to Bachelor's degree. The Schedule which has laid down qualifications, however, contains a proviso permitting the selection committee to relax the laid down qualification of minimum 50% marks at all levels in educational career from Higher Secondary to Masters' Degree, ‘if in the opinion of the selection committee the research work of a candidate from his thesis or published work is of a very high standard.’ The exact language of the provision is as under:

“Provided that if the Selection Committee is of the view that the research work of a candidate as evident either from his thesis or from his published work is of very high standard it may relax any of the qualifications prescribed in (b) above.”

10. It is on the above laid down qualifications, with the power of relaxation, in the circumstances mentioned above, the selection committee has to prepare a selection panel in order of merit. The appointing authority is then duty bound to make appointments in order of merit from the select list prepared. Rule 15 on the subject of selection and appointment is worth reproduction:—

“15(1) The Committee shall, having regard to the nature of duty of the post, select candidates by any one of the methods prescribed under the said rule and shall prepare a list of such candidates.

(2) The candidates shall be selected on the basis of merit and the panel as well as the order of the names in the panel recommended by the selection committee should have the full concurrence of at least one expert.

(3) The list prepared under sub-rule (1) shall contain the names of candidates five times the number of posts proposed to be filled up.

(4) The list prepared under sub-rule (1) shall be submitted to the institution.

(5) Appointment to any post of a teacher or other employee shall be made in order of merit from the list prepared under sub-rule (1).”

11. The proceedings of the Governing Body as recorded and disclosed to this Court, no doubt, show that the Governing Body had found two serious infirmities in the recommendations of the selection committee and, therefore, had taken a decision not to appoint any candidate but to readvertise all the vacancies. It would be fitting to reproduce the relevant contents of the proceedings of the Governing Body dated 18th July, 1991 containing the reasons for rejecting the recommendations of the selection committee.

“AGENDA NO. 2. Sealed envelope of the selection committee for the post of Asstt. Professor in Philosophy is opened. Seal is found intact. Envelope is opened. Envelope is signed by all the members of the Governing Body.

Thereafter, the names recommended for appointment by the selection committee was discussed at length and the testimonials were also examined and discussed. According to Rule 15(3) framed under M.P Ashaskiya Shikshan Sanstha Adhiniyam, 1978 the Governing Body is under obligation under rules to make selection from the list in order of merit. Here name of Ku. Dr. Gayatri Sharma is first in order of merit, therefore, in normal course she deserves appointment according to selection committee. With due respect to the selection committee, the minimum qualification as prescribed in the Schedule for appointment as Asstt. Professor in ‘Philosophy,’ there is a short fall of marks than 50% in Bachlor Degree and as such the minimum qualification is not fulfilled. However, the members of the Governing Body did not lose sight of the proviso clause prescribed in the rules, all the same the selection committee has not given out any reasons for relaxing the minimum qualification, therefore, it appears to be incongruous with the rules touching qualification. Further-more, the rules prescribe that the list should contain five times names of the post vacant. Here there being only one post, there should have been list of five candidates.

Therefore, the majority members fell that the list being not complete, appointment should not be made.

However, Dr. S.R Das Gupta and Dr. Ashok Parakh feel that the first name should be accepted and infirmities be pointed out and sent the recommendation to Commissioner, Higher Education Bhopal for approval. It is also pointed out that the list is complete.

Since the majority feels that the panel be not accepted and the post be advertised, papers be sent to Commissioner, Higher Education for information.

(b) Envelope of the selection committee for the post of Asstt. Professor in Political Science is found. In this list the candidate recommended in second position has not scored the minimum marks in B.A List of five persons is also not recommended. Hence the members feel that the panel recommended by selection be not approved and the post be re-advertised.

Papers of this post be also forwarded to Commissioner Higher Education, Bhopal for information.”

12. From the above minutes of the meeting of the Governing Body, it is clear that the selection panel was rejected on two grounds-firstly that as required by Rule 15(3) of the Recruitment Rules the panel did not contain names of minimum five candidates for one post, and secondly, the proceedings of the selection committee do not disclose why it recommended the name of Dr. Gayatri Sharma by including her in the panel at the top and why the requirement of minimum 50% marks at B.A level in her case had been relaxed.

13. Shri Alok Aradhe, learned counsel, is right in his submission that appointment orders came to be issued from the panel regardless of the decision taken by the Governing Body not to operate the panel for the infirmities mentioned above.

14. The second question, however, urged on behalf of the candidates who are petitioners before this Court in these cases challenging the decision of the Governing Body, cannot outrightly be rejected. It is open to this Court to examine whether the reasons assigned by the Governing Body in rejecting the panel recommended by the selection committee are sound in law.

15. Taking up the first reason assigned by the Governing Body for refusing to implement the panel that it did not contain minimum five names for one vacancy as required by Rule 15(3) of the Recruitment Rules, this Court finds no difficulty in upholding the contention advanced on behalf of the candidates that the said provision is only directory and not mandatory. Similar provisions contained in Madhya Pradesh Vishwavidyalaya Adhiniyam and University of Sagar Act in the matter of preparation of panel were considered by this Court in Zahir Ahmed's case (supra) and Dr. Ram singh's case (supra). It has been held that where the available suitable candidates are less than five, the selection committee can recommend candidates less in number than five and even one candidate can be recommended. Although in the relevant rule the expression used is “shall”, in the context and looking to the object of the rules aimed at filling of the post on the basis of merit and selection, the provision has to be read as merely directory and not mandatory. The Governing body was, therefore, in error in not acting upon the selection panel on the ground that less than 5 candidates were recommended for each available post by the selection committee.

16. The second reason assigned by the Governing body for rejecting the panel recommended by the Selection Committee is that Dr. Gayatri Sharma had less than 50% marks at B.A level and she could not be put at the top in the panel for the post of Assistant Professor in Political Science. It is true that sitting singly in Gwalior Bench, in the case of Dr. Subhash Jain (W.P No. 1255/91 decided on 9-11-1995) reported in 1996 (1) M.P.W.N 174, I had taken a view that inclusion of name of a candidate in the panel by the selection committee raises an inference that the want of minimum prescribed percentage of marks at post-graduate level or higher secondary level had been relaxed by the selection committee: The aforesaid judgment was subject of L.P.A No. 175 of 1995 before the Division Bench decided on 4-9-1996. My decision has not received full approval in the L.P.A The contention of Shri Ajit Singh, therefore, that inference of relaxation in the matter of minimum prescribed percentage of marks at B.A level in the case of Dr. Gayatri Sharma cannot be accepted. In the case of R.S Sharma v. M.P Uchcha Siksha Anudan Ayog, 1993 JLJ 73. I sitting in D.B with Tamaskar, J., had taken a view that although it may not be necessary for the selection committee to record reasons for including a candidate or candidates in the selection panel, but its proceedings should disclose due application of mind particularly in the matter of relaxation of minimum prescribed percentage of marks as required by the proviso below Clause-A of the Rules quoted above. In the case of R.S Sharma (supra), on the facts and controversy involved therein, the Division Bench observed as under:

“……………In our opinion, the committee constituted for making selection of teachers or lecturers is not required to state reasons for selection or non-selection of candidates, but it is necessary that its proceedings should disclose due application of mind. The minute of the selection committee do not disclose due application of mind. The minutes of the selection committee do not disclose that its members were alive to the requirement of the rule in the Schedule that if Ph. D. candidates are available, they can be rejected only if found unsuitable and non-Ph.D could be considered only in such eventuality. The proceedings of the selection committee should have also disclosed from its minutes that the committee was conscious of the requirement of the rule that although a candidate does not possess degree or research work of equivalent standard, he must at least possess two years' research experience. The proceedings of the selection committee in placing the petitioner at the top of the select list did not at all mention in the opinion of the selection committee, the petitioner's work after registration for Ph.D was of a nature which could be considered as fulfilling the minimum prescribed qualifications of his possessing two years research experience.”

17. The last question remains is whether on the second infirmity pointed out above, that the proceedings of selection committee do not reflect due application of mind with regard to relaxation of minimum prescribed 50% of marks, the entire selections and appointments deserve to be set aside or not.

18. The infirmity of non-recording of reasons by selection committee in the matter of relaxation of required minimum percentage of marks at graduate level, was not so vital as to vitiate the whole proceedings of selection. The Governing body, instead of rejecting the whole panel and directing re-advertisement of posts, had definitely an option, to refer back the matter to the selection committee for recording reasons in its minutes on the question of relaxation of minimum prescribed percentage of marks and then submit a fresh panel concerning the candidates under consideration on the relevant date. The Governing body acted under a misconception of law that for non-recording of reasons by the selection committee in the matter of relaxation of minimum prescribed percentage or marks, it had no option but to reject the whole panel. This Court, therefore, considers it expedient in law to partly allow this petition by directing the Governing Body to refer back the matter to the selection Committee for reconsideration of the candidates within the zone of consideration on the relevant date and submit a fresh panel.

19. In view of the discussion aforesaid, this Court grants the following reliefs to the petitioners in the three petitions:

(i) W.P No. 1174/96 (Dr. Subhash Chandrakar v. State of M.P)

The petition partly succeeds. The impugned order dated 7-3-1996 (Annexure-P/18) whereby the petitioner's appointment to the post of Assistant Professor in Philosophy was cancelled is hereby quashed. Consequently, the petitioner shall be allowed to continue in service and discharge her duties and draw salary on the post in terms of the appointment order issued on 2-3-1996 (Annexure-P/13). The respondents Nos. 3 and 4 i.e the Chairman of the Governing Body of the institution and the Principal of the College are directed to reconvene a meeting of the selection committee for recommending a fresh panel in accordance with Rule 15 of the Recruitment Rules in the light of the observations made above by this Court. On submission of such a fresh panel of the candidates as on 18-7-1995, the Chairman of the Governing Body shall convene a meeting of the Governing Body for making appointments under Rule 15 on the basis of the Fresh selection panel to be submitted by the selection committee. It is directed that the petitioner shall continue in service under order of appointment issued in her favour subject to the submission of fresh panel by the selection committee and the decision of the Governing Body thereon in accordance with the directions made above.

(ii) W.P No. 1164/96- (Dr. (Smt.) Ranjana Sharma v. State of M.P).

The petition is partly allowed. The impugned order of the Chairman of the Governing Body dated 7-3-1996 (Annexure-P/20) whereby the petitioner's appointment as Assistant Professor in the subject of Political Science made on 2-3-1996 (Annexure P/15) was set aside, is hereby quashed. Consequently, the petitioner shall be allowed to continue in service on the post of Assistant Professor in Political Science under the order of appointment in her favour dated 2-3-1996. The respondents Nos. 3 and 4 i.e the Chairman of the Governing Body and the Principal of the College are directed to reconvene a meeting of the selection committee for recommending a fresh panel in accordance of the observations made above by this Court. On submission of such a fresh panel of the candidates as on 18-7-1995, the Chairman of the Governing body shall convene a meeting of the Governing Body for making appointments under Rule 15 of the Rules on the basis of the fresh selection panel to be submitted by the selection committee. It is directed that the petitioner shall continue in service under order of appointment issued in his favour subject to the submission of fresh panel by the selection committee and the decision of the Governing Body thereon in accordance with the directions made above.

(iii) W.P No. 1750/96: (Dr. (Ku.) Gayatri Sharma v. State of MP.)

The petition partly succeeds. The respondents Nos. 3 and 4 i.e the Chairman of the Governing Body of the institution and the Principal of the College are directed to reconvene a meeting of the selection Committee for recommending a fresh panel for the post of Assistant Professor in Political Science in accordance with Rule 15 of the Recruitment Rules in the light of the observations made above by this Court. On submission of such a fresh panel of the candidates as on 18-7-1995, the Chairman of the Governing Body shall convene a meeting of the Governing Body for making appointments under rule 15 on the basis of the fresh selection panel to be submitted by the selection committee. In view of the partial success of the petition, the parties are directed to bear their own costs of these petitions.

20. Petition allowed.