- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
P.K Balakrishnan v. N.R Ramaseshan And Others
Concise Analytical Summary of the Opinion (Varghese Kalllath, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
These appeals arise from the judgment in Original Petition No. 8684/87. Writ Appeal No. 284/89 was filed by the State of Kerala (the first respondent in the Original Petition) and Writ Appeal No. 226/89 by the additional third respondent. The petitioner in the Original Petition was the manager of Nurani Hindu High School, Palghat.
The petitioner challenged Government notification Ext. P9, issued under Section 14(2) of the Kerala Education Act, 1958 read with sub‑rule (5) of Rule 1 in Chapter 20 of the Kerala Education Rules, 1959. A learned Single Judge quashed Ext. P9 and allowed the Original Petition. The State and the additional third respondent appealed against that judgment.
Key events recorded in the opinion: the manager gave notice (Ext. P3 dated 21‑2‑1985) that he proposed to close the school with effect from 1‑6‑1986; the Director of Public Instruction declined permission by an order (Ext. P4 dated 13‑2‑1986); the manager responded (Ext. P5 dated 5‑3‑1986) asserting that no permission was required; the manager informed the Headmaster (Ext. P6) and subsequently issued Ext. P7 stating that the school had been closed with effect from 1‑6‑1986. A complaint (Ext. P8) alleges that the school was unlawfully re‑opened on 2‑6‑1986. The District Educational Officer's counter statement (Ext. P10) is recorded as supporting that the manager had closed the school on 1‑6‑1986. The Government then issued Ext. P9, the notification impugned in the Original Petition.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether Ext. P9, issued under Section 14(2) of the Kerala Education Act, 1958, was valid.
- Whether the manager validly closed the school under Section 7(6) of the Act read with Rule 24(1) of the Kerala Education Rules.
- Whether sub‑rule (2) of Rule 24 of Chapter V of the Rules (which conditions closure on grant of permission) is consistent with Section 7(6) of the Act and constitutional guarantees (specifically Article 14 and Article 19 rights as discussed in the authorities cited).
- Whether non‑compliance with Rules 25 and 26 (concerning handing over records/accounts and financial guarantees) prevented the closure from being effective for the purposes of the Government's exercise of powers under Section 14.
- Whether the prerequisites of Section 14(1) (i.e., neglect of duties by the manager and the public interest requirement) existed so as to justify the exercise of emergency power under Section 14(2).
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant (additional third respondent — as recorded)
- Counsel for the appellant in W.A. No. 226/89 submitted that at the time Ext. P9 was passed there was no closure of the school (i.e., the school continued to function), and therefore the Government could lawfully issue Ext. P9.
- The same counsel also submitted that because the manager had not complied with Rules 25 and 26 of Chapter V of the Rules, it could not be said that the manager had closed the school and so the Government retained the right to issue Ext. P9.
Petitioner / Manager (as recorded)
- The manager asserted (through Ext. P3, Ext. P6, Ext. P7 and the complaint Ext. P8, and as reflected in Ext. P10) that he had given the statutory notice and closed the school with effect from 1‑6‑1986; therefore Ext. P9 was invalid.
- The manager's position (as accepted by the learned Single Judge and described in the opinion) was that issuing the notice under Section 7(6) is a statutory right and cannot be treated as neglect under Section 14(1) so as to justify takeover under Section 14(2).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| 1972 K.L.T. 496 (Krishnan v. State of Kerala) | Held that sub‑rule (2) of Rule 24 of the Kerala Education Rules is inconsistent with Section 7(6) of the Kerala Education Act and beyond rule‑making power; found invalid. | The court reaffirmed the correctness of that decision and treated sub‑rule (2) of Rule 24 as not a sustainable provision; relied upon it in concluding that Ext. P9 could not be sustained. |
| 1986 K.L.T. 359 (Subramanian v. State of Kerala) | Followed the 1972 decision; restated that the obligation under Section 7(6) and Rule 24(1) is to give notice and does not create a requirement of permission to close. | Cited as a subsequent decision that followed 1972 KLT 496; the opinion treats that follow‑up as support for the proposition that the manager has the right to close after complying with Section 7(6) and Rule 24(1). |
| Unreported judgment in O.P. No. 8552/83 (affirmed in W.A. No. 515/88) | Applied the same principle that the manager's statutory right to close after notice cannot be overridden by a Rule requiring permission. | Referred to as consistent authority supporting the manager's right to close the institution after required notice. |
| W.A. No. 512/88 (Division Bench, speaking through Chief Justice Mallmath) | Observed that Section 7(6) enables the management to close down the school after complying with its obligations; criticized authorities compelling an aided institution to continue when notice has been given. | Referred to as additional authority aligning with the view that the management may close the school after meeting statutory obligations; used to reinforce the conclusion that the management's right exists. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded through several linked analytical steps, applying statutory construction, precedent, and the facts shown by the record:
- Statutory framework: Section 7(6) of the Kerala Education Act requires a manager to give one year's notice expiring with 31st May of any year before closing a school. Rule 24(1) corresponds to this requirement. Rule 24(2) sought to enable the Director to grant or refuse permission for closure.
- Validity of Rule 24(2): The opinion summarized and accepted prior decisions (notably 1972 K.L.T. 496 and 1986 K.L.T. 359) which hold that sub‑rule (2) of Rule 24 is inconsistent with Section 7(6) and exceeds rule‑making power. The court agreed that rules cannot add conditions that abridge the statutory right conferred on the manager.
- Factual determination of closure: The court examined the documentary record (Ext. P3, P5, P6, P7, P8, P10) and concluded there was clear intimation to the Director and that the manager had, in fact, closed the school on 1‑6‑1986. The court noted a complaint (Ext. P8) alleging forcible re‑opening on 2‑6‑1986, but the overall record indicated that the manager had given the requisite statutory notice and effected closure.
- Compliance with Rules 25 and 26: The court considered the submission that failure to comply with Rules 25 and 26 (relating to handing over records/accounts and release of financial guarantee) meant the school had not been effectively closed. The court held that those rules envisage a state of affairs after closure and that non‑compliance with them did not, in itself, negate the reality of the manager's closure for the purpose of evaluating Ext. P9.
- Proper scope of Section 14: Section 14 requires, under subsection (1), that the manager must have neglected duties imposed by the Act or Rules and that takeover must be in the public interest. Emergency power under subsection (2) can be exercised only when subsection (1) conditions exist. The court found no justification for treating the manager's statutory act of giving notice and closing the school as "neglect" and therefore concluded the preconditions of Section 14(1) were absent.
- Conclusion from statutory and factual matrix: Because the manager had complied with the statutory notice requirement and because Rule 24(2) cannot validly impose a further condition, and because Section 14(1) conditions did not exist, Ext. P9 (issued under Section 14(2)) was invalid. The court saw no reason to re‑open or overrule the earlier precedent and instead reaffirmed their correctness.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The court affirmed the judgment of the learned Single Judge and concluded that Ext. P9 could not be sustained. Both Writ Appeals are dismissed.
Implications (direct effects described in the opinion):
- The impugned governmental notification Ext. P9 issued under Section 14(2) of the Act was held invalid on the grounds recorded.
- The manager's statutory right to close the aided school after complying with Section 7(6) (and Rule 24(1)) was recognized and enforced; Rule 24(2) (conditioning closure on permission) was treated as unsustainable in light of earlier decisions.
- The court reaffirmed existing case law (including 1972 K.L.T. 496 and 1986 K.L.T. 359) rather than displacing it; the opinion states there is no reason to doubt those authorities.
- No finding in the opinion suggests that the court set out a new, broader precedent beyond affirming the statutory construction and prior decisions described above; the ruling operates to uphold the Single Judge's decision in the particular factual matrix before the court.
Note: This summary is strictly confined to the facts, arguments, precedent citations, reasoning and conclusions that appear in the provided opinion. No additional facts or inferences beyond the opinion have been introduced.
Varghese Kalllath, J.:— These appeals are against the judgment in O.P No. 8684/87. W.A No. 284/89 is by the first respondent-State of Kerala in the Original Petition and W.A No. 226/89 is by the additional 3rd respondent. Petitioner in the Original Petition challenged Ext. P9 notification issued by the Government under Section 14(2) of the Kerala Education Act, 1958 (Act 6 of 1959) (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’) read with sub-rule (5) of Rule 1 in Chapter 20 of Kerala Education Rules 1959 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Rules’).
2. A learned single Judge of this Court after considering the points raised by the petitioner against Ext. P9, quashed Ext. P9 and allowed the Original Petition. The State/first respondent has filed W.A No. 284/89 and the additional 3rd respondent has filed W.A No. 226/89. In these circumstances, we think that it is only appropriate to dispose of these two Writ Appeals by a common judgment. Petitioner in the Original Petition was the manager of Nurani Hindu High School, Palghat. By Ext. P3 dated 21-2-1985, petitioner in the Original Petition. Informed the Director of Public Instruction that he proposes to close down the institution with effect from 1st Jane, 1986. He only said that the circumstances do not permit him to run the school. The Director of Public Instruction declined permission by his order dated 13-2-1986. Petitioner replied to Ext. P4 by Ext P5 communication dated 5-3-1986 staling that no permission is required to close that school and so Ext. P4 is ineffective and invalid. By Ext. P6, petitioner informed the Headmaster also that he is closing down the school from 1-6-1986. In Ext. P7 he has said thus; “please be informed that in pursuance of my notice cited given to you, the school has been closed down with effect from this day”. The notice referred is Ext. P3 dated 21-2-1983. In the light of these proceedings, Government passed Ext. P9 order which is challenged in the Original Petition.
3. The question that was considered in the Original Petition by the learned single Judge was as to the validity of Ext. P9 notification. Admittedly Ext. P9 was passed under Section 14(2) of the Act. If is contended by the petitioner that by Ext. P3 notice read with Ext. 17, the school closed from 1-6-1986 and there was no existing school to enable the Government to assume management long after 1-6-1986 by Ext. P9 proceedings dated 8-9-1987. Section 7(6) of the Act provides that no manager shall close down the school unless one year's notice, expiring with the 31st May of any year, of his intention so to do, has been gives to the officer authorised by the Government in this behalf. The Rule corresponding to Section 7(6) of the Act is Rule 24 of Chapter V of the Rules. Rule 24(1) provides that no private school shall be closed down without giving the Director one year's notice expiring with the 31st May of any year of the intention to do so. Rules 24(2) of the Rules enables the Director to consider the question of closure of the school and to grant or refuse permission for the closure of the school. This provision was found to be invalid in the decision reported in 1972 KLT 496 (Krishnan v. State of Kerala). This Court held that sub-rule (2) of Rule 24 of the Rules is inconsistent with Section 7(6) of the Act and beyond rule making power. We may advert to this decision a little elaborately when we deal with the question of the correctness of this decision.
4. It has to be noted that the above decision has been followed in 1986 K.L.T 359 (Subramanian v. State of Kerala). Another learned single Judge of this Court observed that the provision of Section 7 and of Rule 24(1) of Chapter V do not speak of any “permission” from anyone. The only obligation of the manager is to give one year's notice of his intention to close down, so that if the authorities are so minded, they can make other arrangements for the staff and the pupils. Further it was held that “For the simple reason that it is Inconvenient for the State, the D.P.I or the others to absorb the students and staff elsewhere, they cannot decree, without authority of law, that someone else like the manager should carry the burden for ever”. The court also observed that: “If the establishment and administration of an aided school have anything to do with Art. 19(1)(g) of the Constitution, the manager of such a school should also have the freedom to close it down, subject of course to such reasonable restrictions as are permissible under Art. 19(6)”. The same view was taken in an unreported judgment in O.P No. 8552/83 which was affirmed in W.A No. 515/88. In W.A No. 512/88, a Division Bench of this Court, speaking through Chief Justice Mallmath, observed that the provisions of Section 7(6) of the Act would enable the management to close down the school after complying with the obligations contained in Section 7(6) of the Act. The judgment begin with a surprise in these words: “We are surprised at the action of the authorities to compel an aided educational institution to function even though according to the rules it has given one year's notice of ceasing to function as an aided school”. W.A No. 512/88 was also against the judgment in O.P No. 8352 of 1985 rendered by Justice Paripoornan.
5. So long as sub-rule (2) of Rule 24 of Chapter V of the Rules is no longer a provision which could be sustained, the action taken by the Government in issuing Ext. P9 cannot be sustained for the simple reason that the management has got the right to close down the school after complying with the provisions contained in Section 7(6) of the Act read with Rule 24(1) of Chapter V of the Rules and in this case, it cannot be disputed that it has been done. Counsel for the appellant in W.A No. 226/89 submitted that there was no closure of the school when Ext. P9 order was passed. But such a case was not taken up by the appellant before the learned single Judge. We have already adverted to Ext. P7 which categorically asserts that the management has closed down the school. The manager has produced copy of the complaint, Ext. P8, which was filed before the Superintendent of Police stating that even though the school was closed down, by force the school was re-opened on 2-6-1986 and so necessary action has to be taken for such an unlawful action on the para of the Headmaster and staff of the school. Ext. P10 is the counter statement filed by the District Educational Officer in I.A No. 1167/86 in C.S No. 154/86. A reading of the counter statement also will show that in fact, the manager has closed down the shool on 1-6-1986 pursuant to the notice he has given to the Director of Public Instruction.
6. Counsel for the appellant in W.A No. 226 of 1989 submitted that so long as the manager has not complied with Rules 25 and 26 of Chapter V of the Rules, it cannot be said that the manager has closed down the school and being a school which continued to function, Government has the right to issue Ext. P9 notification. We may advert to Rules 25 and 26 of Chapter V of the Rule 25 provides that when a school is closed down or discontinued or its recognition is withdrawn, the manager shall hand over to the Assistant Educational Officer for the area in the case of the primary schools and to the District Educational Officer for the area in the case of all other schools, all records and accounts of the school and the Department shall takes the necessary steps for taking charge of the records and accounts. Obviously this Rule envisages a state after the closure of the school. Similar is the provision wish regard to Rule 26 of Chapter V of the Rules. Rule 26 of the Rules provides that if any school is closed ??? the financial guarantee furnished by the Educational Agency in respect of that school shall not be released until all liabilities of the school are discharged and all records and accounts relating to the school are handed over to the Department. We do not think that relying on the alleged non-compliance or Rules 25 and 26 of Chapter V of the Rules, appellant in W.A No. 226 of 1989 can contend that there was no real closure of the school at a time when Ext. P9 notification was issued.
7. From Ext. P10 it is clear that the manager has issued a memo intimating the Headmaster that he has closed down the school and to hand over the records to the authorities concerned. We have to consider the case in the light of all circumstances of the case. Further, it has to be noted that the appellant in W.A No. 226/89 has not raised this point before the learned single Judge and the learned single Judge has no occasion to consider this point at all. Of course, counsel submitted that this point has been taken in the appeal memorandum. We feel that the matter has to be considered in the light of what has really happened in this case. There was clear intimation given to the Director of Public Instruction stating that the manager proposed to close down the school, and that notice was given as early as on 21-2-1985. All the circumstances would show, that there was really a cloture of the school on the part of the management.
8. Now, we shall independently consider the question whether the order impugned, Ext. P9 is a valid order complying with the provisions contained in Section 14 of the Act. Nothing is stated as reason for invoking the power under Section 14 of the Act except a statement that in the interests of the pupils of the school, the power under Sub-section (2) of Section 14 of the Act has to be exercised. If has to be noted that Section 14 provides that the power under Section 14 of the Act can be exercised only when is appears to the Government that the manager of a school has neglected to perform any of the duties imposed by or under this Act or the Rules made thereunder and also if in the public interest it is necessary to fake over the management of the school. Section 14 of the Act postulates two conditions; (i) that the manager is guilty of neglect to perform any of the duties imposed by or under this Act of the Rules and (ii) that faking over the management of the school must be in the public interest. To say that the manager neglected to perform any of the duties imposed by the Act or under the Rules by issuing a notice or a memo under Section 7(6) of the Act is patently unjustifiable. The statute envisage and gives the right to the management to close down the school under Section 7(6) of the Act and the action taken by the manager under the provision can never be treated as an act of neglect within the meaning of Section 14(1) of the Act. Of course, the action under Ext. P9 has been taken invoking the emergency power given under sub-section (2) of Section 14 of the Act. When that emergency power has to be exercise, it is plain any clear that the parent power to exercise the emergency power is sub-section (1) of Section 14 of the Act and the requirements under sub-section (1) of Section 14 of she Act should exist before invoking sub-section (2) of Section 14 of the Act. In this case, it is plain that the conditions postulated under sub-section (1) of Section 14 of the Act were not in existence to issue Ext. P9 notification. For this reason also, Ext. P9 is invalid.
9. We have said that we will be adverting to the decision reported in 1972 K.L.T 496. We said so, since counsel for the appellant in W.A No. 226 of 1989 submitted that this decision requires reconsideration. If has to be noted that the Government proceeded on the basis that after the decision in 1972 K.L.T 496, Rule 24(2) of Chapter V of the Rules is a dead letter in the Rules and the power under Rule 24(2) of the Rules cannot be exercised. Perhaps that may not be a reason for us to say that the decision does not require re-consideration. But we are of opinion that sufficient reasons have been stated by the learned single Judge to say that sub-rule (2) of Rule 24 of Chapter V of the Rules is violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India and that Rule is inconsistent with Section 7(6) of the Act. A reading of the judgment would show that in fact, the learned single Judge has held that it is not the lack of power that made sub-rule (2) of Rule 24 of the Rules Inconsistent with Section 7(6) of the Act. When the legislature has enabled the manager to close down the school after complying with Section 7(6) of the Act the Rule cannot enlarge the conditions required under Section 7(6) of the Act, and if it does, it amounts to enacting an inconsistent Rule to override a statutory provision which enfranchised a statutory right to the management. Of course, the learned single Judge also adverted to the question whether under the terms of Section 7(6) of the Act the manager's right to close down his school is preserved subject to his complying with the condition laid down in the said Section insisting on one year's prior notice, is subject to what is provided under Rule 24(2) of Chapter V of the Rules. The learned tingle Judge said that the provision contained in sub-rule (2) of Rule 24 of the Rules would abridge the freedom of the manager beyond what the parent enactment has authorised to be done by subjecting the right of the manager to close down the institution to a further condition that it will be dependent upon the grant of permission by the Director of Public Instruction. The above decision (1972 K.L.T 496) has been followed in 1986 K.L.T 359. The learned single Judge also considered the fundamental right of the manager to close down the school subject of course to such reasonable restrictions as are permissible under Article 19(6) of the Constitution of India when considering the question of an action taken by the Director of Public Instruction to prevent the manager from closing down the school. We feel that there is no reason for us to doubt the correctness of the decision reported in 1972 K.L.T 496.
10. In the result, we see no error in the judgment impugned in W.A No. 226/1989 and W.A No. 284 of 1989. Both Writ Appeals are dismissed.
Alert