- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Kumar Electric Works v. Anuj Electronics
Factual and Procedural Background
The plaintiff, a partnership firm engaged in manufacturing and marketing electrical and electronic goods since 1979, started using the trademark "OLYMPUS" in 1983. The trademark was registered in the name of one partner, Sh. Raj Kumar, for electric flat irons (Class 9) and a design for electric fans was also registered. The plaintiff claimed extensive use, reputation, and goodwill in the trademark "OLYMPUS" for various electrical goods and sought a temporary injunction under Order 39 rules 1 and 2 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The injunction aimed to restrain the defendant from using the mark "OLYMPUS" on black and white televisions, alleging passing off and trademark infringement. The defendant contested ownership of the trademark, claimed the plaintiff was not registered for televisions, and asserted that the trademark belonged to a Japanese company, M/s Olympus Optical Co. Ltd., which was also using the mark in India.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the plaintiff had acquired reputation and goodwill in the trademark "OLYMPUS" sufficient to claim proprietary rights.
- Whether the defendant's use of the trademark "OLYMPUS" on televisions constituted passing off and infringement.
- Whether the plaintiff was entitled to a temporary injunction restraining the defendant from using the mark on televisions.
- The relevance of trademark registration and prior use by a third party (Japanese company) in a passing off action.
Arguments of the Parties
Plaintiff's Arguments
- The plaintiff had been using the trademark "OLYMPUS" since 1983 on various electrical and electronic goods and had established distinctiveness and goodwill.
- The trademark was registered in the name of one of the partners for electric flat irons and the design of electric fans was also registered.
- The defendant's use of the same trademark on televisions, which are allied and cognate goods, amounted to passing off and would cause confusion among the public.
- Extensive advertising and sales figures supported the plaintiff's claim of reputation and goodwill.
Defendant's Arguments
- The plaintiff was not the registered owner of the trademark "OLYMPUS"; the registration was in the name of Sh. Raj Kumar individually.
- The plaintiff had not used the trademark on televisions and the registration was limited to Class 9, which did not include televisions.
- The trademark "OLYMPUS" belonged to the Japanese company M/s Olympus Optical Co. Ltd., which was the registered owner in India for televisions and related goods.
- Both the plaintiff and defendant were alleged to be "pirates" using a trademark belonging to the Japanese company, thus the plaintiff was not entitled to injunction relief.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Creative Handicrafts v. Sadana Electric Co., IA No. 3344 of 1988 in Suit No. 1347 of 1988 (Decided July 19, 1988) | Extension of trademark protection to cognate goods in passing off actions | The court relied on this precedent to hold that televisions, being cognate goods to the plaintiff's electrical products, fell within the scope of protection against passing off. |
| Century Traders v. Roshan Lal Duggar & Co., AIR 1978 Delhi 250 DB | Irrelevance of trademark registration in passing off actions | The court held that registration is not determinative in passing off suits and relied on this to reject the defendant's argument based on the Japanese company's registration. |
| Capital Plastic Industries v. Kappy Plastic Industries, FAO (OS) 85 of 1988 (Decided March 2, 1989) | Trademark piracy and entitlement to injunction | The defendant relied on this decision to allege piracy by both parties, but the court found it inapplicable due to lack of evidence against the plaintiff. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court first examined the plaintiff's evidence, including registration certificates, advertisements, newspaper cuttings, and sales figures, which prima facie established reputation and goodwill in the trademark "OLYMPUS" for various electrical goods. Although the plaintiff was not using the mark for televisions, the court found televisions to be cognate goods within the same trade channel, thus extending the plaintiff's right to restrain the defendant's use of the mark on televisions. The court rejected the defendant's contention that the Japanese company’s registration entitled it to use the mark, emphasizing that registration is irrelevant in passing off actions and that there was no evidence of prior use by the Japanese company in India. The court also rejected the piracy allegation against the plaintiff due to lack of evidence. Considering the plaintiff's prima facie case, absence of irreparable injury to the defendant, and the balance of convenience, the court granted the temporary injunction.
Holding and Implications
The court granted a temporary injunction restraining the defendant, its servants, agents, and representatives from selling, offering for sale, or otherwise dealing in televisions under the trademark "OLYMPUS" until the disposal of the suit.
The direct effect of this decision is to protect the plaintiff's trademark rights in cognate electrical goods and prevent the defendant from using the mark on televisions pending final adjudication. The court did not set a new precedent but applied established principles of passing off, including protection for cognate goods and the irrelevance of registration in such suits.
1. In an action for passing off and infringment of trade mark the plaintiff has filed this application under Order 39 rules 1 and 2 read with Section 151 of the code of Civil Procidure seeking temporary injuction restraining the defendants its servants, agent and representatives from manufacturing, selling, offering for sale otherwise dealing in Black & White T.V sets under the impugned trade mark ‘OLYMPUS’ and passing off its said product under the said trade mark or any other similar and/or deceptively identical trade mark as that of the plaintiff.
2. According to the averments in the plaint the plaintiff was a partnership firm. S/Sh. Vinod Kumar, Satish Kumar, T.C Kumar end Raj Kumar were its partners. It was engaged in the business of manufacturing and marketing of etectrical and electronics goods since the year 1979. In 1983 it started using trade mark ‘OLYMPUS’ for its electronics and electrical products and was using the same since then. It has enormous sales throughout India and has been spending substantial amount of advertisements. On account of long, established, continuous and extensive user coupled with large scale publicity throughout the whole country since 1983, the plaintiff's trade mark and acquired distinctiveness and had come about to be evclusively identified and recognised with the products of the plaintiffs manufacture and was adopted to distinguish the products of the plaintiff and was connected in the course of trade with the plaintiff exclusively. Further case of the plainfiff is that the plaintiff's trade mark ‘OLYMPUS’ was duly registered at No. 417839 as of February 17, 1984 in the name of Sh. Raj Kumar, one of the partners of the plaintiff firm in respect of electric flat irons included in class 9, and it had also applied for registeration under class 11 and 7 and that the design of electric fan the plaintiff was registered at No. 153018 dated 19th April, 1983. The said trade mark was duly advertised in the Trade Mark Journal No. 910 of May, 1983.
3. It is next alleged that the defendant had recently adopted the trade mark ‘OLYMPUS’ for its product of Black and White TV which was also an electrical/electronic item and was allied and cognate good of the same nature as the products of plaintiff. The adoption and use of the trade mark of the plaintiff ‘OLYMPUS’ amounted to passing off the defendan's goods under the said trade mark as the goods of the plaintiff and this act was bound to cause confusion and/or deception in the minds of public and trade. This act was in violation of the plaintiff's statutory right under the Trade and Merchandise Marks, Act, 1958.
4. The defendant resisted the application. It was pleaded that the plaintiff was not the registered owner of the trade mark ‘OLYMPUS’. The owner of the trade mark No. 417839 dated February 17, 1984 was Sh. Raj Kumar and not the plaintiff. It was next pleaded that the defendant was using the trade mark ‘Olympus’ in respect of television and the plaintiff had yet to start the manufacture or sale of televisions under the trade mark ‘OLYMPUS’ and that the plaintiff's trade mark was registered under class 9 which did not include television. It was also pleaded that the plaintiff itself had misappropriated the trade mark ‘OLYMPUS’ which belongs to a Japanese Company M/s. Olympus Optica] Co. Ltd., 43-2, 2-Chome, Hatagaya, Shivuyaku, Tokyo, Japan. The said Company is the registered owner ot the trade mark ‘OLYMPUS’ in India under trade mark No. 322816 dated 8th February, 1977, in respect of television sets, magnetic tape, tape cassettes, tape recorder cassettes, radio receivers, microphones, loud speakers, video tape recorders, video cassettes, video cameras, pick ups for optical video disc players.
5. No man can have any right to represent his goods as the goods of another. It is an actionable wrong for any person to pass off his goods as and for the goods of another person. To succeed the plaintiff was first required to prove that it had acquired a reputation/good-will in the trade mark ‘OLYMPUS’ and had proprietory right in the said trade mark. Secondly he has to show that the acts of the defendant are calculated to lead the public to confuse the goods of the defendant as the goods, of the plaintiff.
6. The plaintiff has produced photo copy of the registration certificate and advertisements in Journal. These show that Raj Kumar was the registered owner of the trade mark ‘OLYMPUS’ under registration No. 417839 dated February 17, 1984 in class 9 in respect of ‘Electric flat irons included in class 9. The advertisement further show that the said Raj Kumar claimed user since 1st January, 1983. The plaintiff has also filed on record certificate of registration ol design. It shows that the design of Electric fan was registered at no. 153018 dated 19th April, 1983 in the name of Raj Kumar under the Designs Act, 1911. The design of electric fan shows that it had the mark ‘OLYMPUS’. Newspaper cuttings have been filed which show the ‘Olympus Heat Convector’ was advertised in the issues of the Hindustan Times dated 23rd December, 1983 and 27th December, 1983. It was also advertised in the issue of Sandhya, Times of 16th December, 1983. 20th December, 1983, 23rd December, 1983 and 27th December, 1933. The plaintiff has filed pamphlets showing that it was using, the trademark ‘OLYMPUS & in respect of various other electric products such as Geysers, air cooler, Juicer-blender-grinder, washing machine, cooler pump, cooler fan, sandwich toaster etc. The statement of sales shows that in 1982-83 its sales were to the extent of approximately 20 lacs and in 1987-88 the sales were to the extent of approximately 25 lacs. The defendant, according to its case, started using the trade mark ‘OLYMPUS’ in respect of television sets since August, 1988.
7. The evidence produced by the plaintiff, prime fecie shows that the plaintiff, by use of the trade mark ‘OLYMPUS’ in relation to its electric goods mentioned above, had acquired a reputation/good will in the use of trade mark ‘OLYMPUS’ in the respect of the said goods.
8. Admittedly the plaintiff was not using the trade mark ‘OLYMPUS’ in respect of televisions—the goods which the defendant was marketing under this name. However, the fact remains that, prima facie, the plaintiff's electronic and electrical goods namely electric fans, heat convector, air coolers, juicer-blender-grinder, washing machine, cooler pump, cooler fan and sandwhich toaster were being marketed through the trade mark ‘OLYMPUS’. Plaintiff's right to restrain the defendant from using the trade mark, prima facie extends to cognate classess of goods. Televisions, which are being sold by the defendant under exactly the same trade mark prima facie, were in the same trading channel and were cognate goods. This view finds support from the decision of this Court in Creative Handicrafts v. Sadana Electric Co., IA No. 3344 of 1988 in suit No. 1347 of 1988 Decided on July 19, 88. In the circumstances, prima facie, Second requirement has also been made out.
9. Learned counsel for the defendant vehemently contended that M/s. Olympus Optical Company Ltd. (a joint stock company of Japan) was the registered owner of the trade mark ‘OLYMPUS’ in respect of televisions and other goods. The plaintiff and the defendant were both pirators and consequently plaintiff was not entitled to the temporary injunction prayed for. Reliance was placed on a Division Bench decision of this court in Capital Plastic Industries wersus Kappy Plastic Industries FAO (OS) 85 of 1988 Decided on March 2, 89.
10. Defendant has filed on record a photo copy of page No. 305 of Trade Mark Journal dated July 16, 1987. It shows that the said Japenese Company had applied for registration of trade mark ‘OLYMPUS’ in respect of various good including ‘television sets’ and the application was advertised under the provisions of Section 20(1) of the Trade Marks Act before acceptance. Its number is 389345 dated April 29, 1982. Defendant also filed a photo copy of page No. 814 of Trade mark Journal No. 944 dated 1.10.88 showing number of various applications for registration which were neither rejected nor veried. This list includes number 389345 which was the number of M/s. Olympus Optical Company Ltd. (the Japanese company).
11. On a careful consideration I find no merit in this contention. In an action for passing off registration of trade mark is irrelevant (See Century Traders… v. Roshan Lal Duggar & Co…, AIR 1978 Delhi 250 DB). There is not an iota of evidence to show that the Japanese Company has ever used this trade mark.
12. Moreover, at this stage it cannot be said that the plaintiff was not the original originator of this trade mark. The plaintiff has filed on record copies of newspapers dated December 23, 1983 in which plaintiff advertised its goods. The Japanese Company applied for registration of the said trade mark on April 19, 1982. There is no evidence when it was registered. As noticed above there is no evidence of any prior user of this trade mark by the Japanese company. At this stage it cannot be said that the plaintiff was a pirator. Division Bench judgment Capital Plastic Industries' case is not applicable.
13. For these reasons, in my view, the plaintiff has made out a prima facie case.
14. The defendant, it appears, came in business only in 1988. No irreparable injury is likely to be caused if temporary injunction, as prayed by the plaintiff is granted. Balance of convenience is also in favour of the plaintiff.
15. Consequently, I grant a temporary injunction restraining the defendant, its servants, agent and representatives from selling, offering for sale or otherwise dealing in televisions under the trade mark ‘OLYMPUS’ till the disposal of the suit I.A stands disposed of.
Alert