- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
United India Insurance Co., Ltd. v. Smt. Heera Bai
Case Summary: United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Heerabai (Judgment by Faizanuddin, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal was brought by the United India Insurance Co. Ltd. (the Company) under section 30 of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1932, challenging an award dated 31 July 1980 by the Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation, Sagar, in W.C. Case No. 7/79, in favour of respondent No. 1 (Smt. Heerabai).
The relevant events as recorded in the opinion are: Omprakash (the deceased), husband of respondent No. 1, was employed as a bus driver by respondent No. 2. The opinion records that on 3-7-1978 the deceased was required to take bus No. M.P.D 195 to the Railway Station, Sagar, and was assaulted with a knife by one Munnalal and later succumbed to injuries. (The opinion also records, in an account of the appellant's contention, an assertion that the murder occurred on 3-7-1976; this reflects a contradictory date presented in argument.)
Procedurally, the widow filed a compensation application under section 10 of the Act claiming Rs. 28,000 on the basis that the deceased earned Rs. 400 per month and died of injuries arising out of and in the course of employment. The employer (respondent No. 2) and the insurer (appellant Company) contested the claim, disputing that the deceased was on duty at the time and disputing the asserted wage. Before the Commissioner, the claimant (respondent No. 1) gave evidence herself and the employer examined one witness (Dayashankar Pandey, A.W.1). The Commissioner found the deceased's monthly earnings to be Rs. 285 and held the injury arose out of and in the course of employment, awarding Rs. 10,000 under Schedule IV of Section 4, with interest at 6% as a penalty under Section 4(a). The Company appealed against that award.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the fatal knife attack on Omprakash constituted an "accident arising out of and in the course of his employment" within section 3(1) of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1932.
- Whether there was collusion between the claimant and the employer such that the insurer would not be liable to indemnify the insured (as asserted by the appellant, raised late in the appeal).
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant (United India Insurance Co. Ltd.)
- Contended there was complete collusion between the owner of the bus (respondent No. 2) and the claimant; therefore the Company should not indemnify the insured. Noted by the Court: this collusion plea was not pleaded in the written statement, was raised for the first time before the Court, and was not included in the memo of appeal.
- Argued there was no connection between the employment of the deceased and his murder; thus the death did not arise out of and in the course of employment. In support, reliance was placed on a Full Bench decision of the Allahabad High Court in Mst. Abida Khatun v. General Manager Diesel Locomotive Varanasi.
Respondent No. 1 (Claimant, Smt. Heerabai)
- Claimed compensation under section 10, asserting that the deceased earned Rs. 400 per month and that he died of personal injuries arising out of and in the course of his employment as a bus driver.
Respondent No. 2 (Employer)
- Contested the claim, asserting that at the time of death the deceased was not on duty and did not receive injuries by any accident arising out of and in the course of his employment. Pleaded that deceased's salary was Rs. 135 per month (contrary to claimant's claim of Rs. 400).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Mst. Abida Khatun v. General Manager Diesel Locomotive Varanasi | Authority relied on by appellant to contend that the death did not arise out of employment where claimant failed to show the workman was exposed to any special risk inherent in his duties. | The Court distinguished this decision, finding it inapplicable because in Abida Khatun there was no establishment that a risk was ordinarily inherent in the duties; whereas in the present case the deceased was required, as part of his duty, to take the bus to the railway station at a particular time and place where he was stabbed. |
| N.I.A.S Co. v. Monorama | Illustrates that an employee exposed to a dangerous place as part of his employment may be deemed to have suffered injury arising out of and in the course of employment even if the risk was shared with the public. | Cited to support the proposition that exposure to a risk by reason of employment (being required to pass or be at a dangerous place) can establish that the accident arose out of employment. |
| Shanubai v. General Manager | Holds that there must be a causal (proximate) connection between the accident and the employment; the peril must be incidental to the employment and not personal to the employee. | Applied to emphasize that proximate cause, not a remote cause, is necessary and that the peril must be incidental to the employment; used as part of the analytical framework to determine causation. |
| Babuhl Mulchand v. A H Mohammad Rajjab | Affirms that some connection is required between employment and accident and that an unforeseeable agent causing injury during the course of employment can satisfy the test if the employee was performing his duty. | Invoked to show that injuries from unforeseen agents (e.g., dacoits firing at a bus) can be deemed arising out of employment when the employee was performing duties that exposed him to that risk. |
| Mackinnon Mackenize v. I.M. Issak | Provides definitions: "in the course of employment" (in the course of work the workman is employed to do and incidental to it) and "arising out of employment" (injury resulting from a risk incidental to the duties of the service; a causal relationship is required). | Relied upon to articulate the dual requirement that the injury must be both in the course of and arising out of employment and to stress the need for a causal relationship between employment and accident. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court's analysis proceeds in discrete steps, following the Commissioner's factual findings and statutory interpretation:
- Identification of statutory test: The Court reproduced section 3(1) of the Workmen's Compensation Act and explained that two conditions must be satisfied for employer liability: (i) personal injury must be caused by an accident "arising out of" employment; and (ii) the injury must be "in the course of" employment. The Court described "in the course of" as pointing to the point of time during which the injury occurred and "arising out of" as requiring a causal nexus between employment and the risk that caused the injury.
- Acceptance of findings of fact by Commissioner: The learned Commissioner found (based on evidence from the claimant and the employer's witness) that the deceased was required to take the bus to the railway station at a particular time and that he was on duty when stabbed. The Court treated these factual findings as established for the purposes of the appeal.
- Application of precedents: The Court surveyed authority from various High Courts and this Court to frame the legal meaning of "arising out of and in the course of employment." The authorities were used to show (i) that an employee's exposure to a risk because of his employment (even if shared by the public) can satisfy the "arising out of" test; (ii) the required connection is one of proximate cause; and (iii) if the peril is incidental to employment, liability follows unless the employee added to the peril by his own acts.
- Applying law to facts: The Court concluded that the deceased's obligation to take the bus to the railway station at a particular time was a circumstance incidental to his employment and that being at that place and time exposed him to the fatal attack. The stabbing was viewed as a proximate cause that resulted from a risk incidental to his duties; had he not been engaged in the duty owed to his employer, he would, in all probability, not have suffered that injury.
- Rejection of late collusion plea: The Court observed that collusion was not pleaded before the Commissioner or in the written statement and was raised for the first time before the Court; there were no circumstances suggesting collusion. On that basis, and on the merits, the contention was rejected.
- Distinguishing opposing precedent: The Court distinguished Abida Khatun on the ground that in that case the claimant failed to establish that the workman faced a risk inherent in the duties at the place of the accident; by contrast, in the present case the duty required presence at the railway station where the danger materialised.
Holding and Implications
Holding:
APPEAL DISMISSED.
The Court dismissed the insurer's appeal and therefore upheld the Commissioner's award. The direct operative consequences stated in the opinion are:
- The award of Rs. 10,000 (made by the Commissioner under Schedule IV of Section 4 of the Act) along with interest at 6% under Section 4(a) stands.
- The appellant is ordered to pay costs; counsel fees to be as per the schedule, if certified.
Implications beyond the parties: The opinion does not state that it establishes any novel legal precedent. The Court applied established principles concerning the dual requirement ("arising out of" and "in the course of" employment) and distinguished prior authority relied upon by the appellant. No broad new principle was announced beyond the application of settled tests to the factual circumstances.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
Faizanuddin, J.:— This appeal by the United India Insurance Co. Ltd., (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Company’) under section 30 of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1932 (hereinafter referred to the ‘Act’), has been directed against the award dated 31st July, 1980, made by the Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation Sagar, in W.C Case No. 7/79, in favour of respondent No. 1.
2. One Omprakash, the husband of the respondent No. 1, was employed as a driver by respondent No. 2. On 3-7-1978, deceased Omprakash Singh was required to take the bus No. M.P.D 195 belonging to the respondent No. 2 to the Railway Station, Sagar. The driver Omprakash Singh was assaulted with a knife by one Munnalal as a result of which he succumbed to injuries. Smt. Heerabai respondent No. 1 the widow of the deceased driver Omprakesh Singh, filed an application for compensation under section 10 of the Act, claiming Rs. 28,000/- by contending that her deceased husband was earning Rs. 400/- per month as wages and that he had died for the personal injuries received by him in accident arising out of and in the course of his employment within the meaning of section 3 of the Act. There was no dispute that the deceased Omprakash Singh was in the employment of respondent No. 2 as a bus driver. There was also no dispute that the said bus was insured with the appellant Company. The employer, respondent No. 2, however, contested the claim petition by, contending that at the time of his death Omprakash Singh was not on duty and that he did not receive the injuries by any accident arising out of and in the course of his employment as a driver. He pleaded that the deceased was paid Rs. 135/- per month as salary and not Rs. 400/- as alleged by respondent No. 1. Similar was the defence pleaded by the appellant-Company.
3. Before the Commissioner the applicant-respondent No. 1 Smt. Heerabai examined herself only. The employer respondent No. 2 also examined only one Dayashankar Pandey (A.W 1). On the basis of evidence of these two witnesses, learned Commissioner came to the conclusion that the deceased Omprakash was drawing Rs. 285/- per month as driver of the respondent No. 2 and that the husband of the claimant-respondent No. 1 had received personal injuries by accident arising out of and in the course of his employment as a driver. Learned Commissioner, therefore, awarded a sum of Rs. 10,000/- as compensation according to Schedule IV under Section 4 of the Act, together with interest at 6 per cent by way of penalty under Section 4(a) of the Act, against which this appeal has been preferred by the Company.
4. Learned counsel for the appellant first contended that there was a complete collusion between the owner of the bus respondent No. 2 and the claimant in as much as the deceased Omprakash Singh was murdered by one Munnalal on 3.7.1976 at about 12.30 in the night near Railway Station and not in any accident arising out of and in the course of his employment, and therefore, the Company was not liable for the compensation to indemnify the insured. It may be pointed out that the appellant-Company has not pleaded any collusion in the written statement and has advanced this ground for the First time before this Court. No ground of collusion has been taken in the memo of appeal also. There are also no circumstances to infer any collusion. In these circumstances, it is not open to the appellant to advance this ground at this stage and even otherwise there is no merit in the said contention.
5. Learned counsel for the appellant next submitted that there was no connection between the employment of the deceased and the incident of his murder and therefore his death cannot be said to be an incident arising out of and in the course of his employment. In support of this contention he placed his reliance on a Full Bench decision of Allahabad High Court in the case of Mst. Abida Khatun v. General Manager Diesel Locomotive Varanasi (1). Thus, the crucial point advanced by the learned counsel for the appellant is whether Omprakash Singh, the deceased husband of respondent No. 1 sustained personal injuries by knife inflicted by one Munnalal by accident arising out of and in the course of his employment, as a bus driver of respondent No. 2 or not.
6. Here, it may be relevant to refer to the provisions of Section 2(1) of the Act which run as under:—
S. 3(1): If personal injury is caused to a workman by accident arising out of and in the course of his employment, his employer shall be liable to pay compensation in accordance with the provisions of this Chapter:
Provided that the employer shall not be so liable—
(a) in respect of any injury which does not result in the total or partial disablement ot the workman for a period exceeding three days;
(b) in respect of any injury, not resulting in death, caused by an accident which is directly attributable to—
(i) the workman having been at the time thereof under the influance of drink or drugs, or
(ii) the wilful disobedience of the workman to an order expressly given or to a rule expressly framed, for the purpose of securing the safety of workmen, or
(iii) the wilful removal or disregard by the workman of any guard or other device which he knew to have been provided for the purpose of securing the safety of workmen.
7. A careful perusal of the provisions of Section 3 reproduced above will go to show that in order to attack the provisions two conditions are required to be satisfied namely:—(i) personal injury must be caused to a workman by an accident arising out of his employment and that (ii) the personal injuries must have been caused to him in the course of his employment. In the present case, there is no dispute that the deceased Omprakash Singh was employed as a bus driver by the respondent No. 2 and, therefore, the second requirement that he received personal injury as a result of an accident which took place in the course of his employment is fulfilled. The only question remains to be seen is whether in the facts and circumstances of the present case, it can be said that personal injury was caused to the deceased Omprakash Singh by accident arising out of his employment. The expression “in the course of his employment” suggests the point of time. In other words, the injury must be caused by accident which took place in the course of and during currency of his employment. The expression “arising out of his employment” are wide enough so as to cover a case there may not necessarily be a direct connection between the injury caused as a result of accident and the employment of the workmen. There may be circumstance attending the employment which would go to show that the workmen received personel injury as a result of accident arising out of his employment.
8. The expression ‘arising out of and in the course of his employment’ occuring in Section 3(1) of the Act has been the subject for interpretation before various High Courts and apex Court of India. In the case of N.I.A.S Co. v. Monorama (2) a boy who was employed in a tea shop had gone in a close by factory to serve tea and at that point of time a mob of factory workmen attacked the police and the police fired in self-defence. The bullet struck the boy who died. The mother of the deceased boy filed an application for compensation. The question arose whether the boy bad received the personal bullet injuries by accident arising out of and in the course of his employment or not. The Division Bench of Calcutta High Court held that the accident arose in the course of his employment on the, reasoning that it was not necessary for the mother of the deceased boy to establish that the death resulting from some special risk to which the boy was exposed. It has been observed that the boy was exposed to the risk as his employment required him to pass a dangerous spot or place and in passing such a place he received injury, and that being so it can be said that the accident arose out of his employment. In the case of Shanubai v. General Manager (3) a Division Bench of Bombay High Court while interpreting the expression “arising out of employment” took the view; that there must be a casual connection between the accident and the employment in order that the Court can say that the accident arose out of the employment of the deceased. The cause contemplated is the proximate cause and not any remote cause. If the employee in the course of his employment has to be in a particular place and by reason of his being in that particular place he has to face a pcril and the accident is caused by reason of that peril which he has to face, then a casual connection is established between the accident and the employment. The fact that the employee shares that peril with other members of the public is an irrelevant consideration. The peril which he faces must not be something personal to him; the peril must be incidental to his employment. He must not by his own act add to the peril or extend the peril. Once the peril is established, it is for the employer then to establish that either the peril was brought about by the employee himself that he added or extended the peril, or that the peril was not a general but a peril personal to the employee. In the case of Babuhl Mulchand v. AH Mohammad Rajjab (4) this Court relying on the aforesaid decisions of the Calcutta and Bombay High Courts (supra) also took the view that there must be some sort of connection between the employment and the accident. It is sufficient if it is shown that the accident took place due to some unforeseen agent but during the course of employment and when the employee is actually performing his duty as an employee. In this case a cleaner of a bus accompanying the bus was injured as a result of shots fired by dacoits on the bus. The question arose whether the cleaner had received the injury arising out of and in the course of his employment. It was on these facts that this Court took the view that the accident arose in the course of his employment since it was his duty as a cleaner which required him to accompany the bus through dacoits infected area. The expression “arising out of and in the course of employment” also came up for consideration of their Lordships of Supreme Court in the case of Mackinnon Mackenize v. I.M Issak (5) wherein it was held as under:—
“To come within the Act the injury by accident must arise both out of and in the course of employment. The words “in the course of the employment” mean “in the course of the work which the workman is employed to do and which is incidental to it”. The words “arising out of employment” are understood to mean that “during the course of the employment, injury has resulted from some risk incidental to the duties of the service, which, unless engaged in the duty owing to the master, it is reasonable to believe the workmen would not otherwise have suffered”. There must be a counsel relationship between the accident and the employment. If the accident had occurred on account of a risk which is an incident of the employment, the claim for compensation must succeed, unless of course the workman has exposed himself to an added peril by his own imprudent act.”
9. In the present case, on evolution of evidence on record the learned Commissioner has reached a definite conclusion that the deceased Omprakash Singh while employed as a driver of the respondent No. 2 had to take the bus to the Railway Station, Sagar, and when he was stabbed by one Munnalal he was on duty. From the evidence and the finding recorded by the learned Commissioner it is clear that the deceased Omprakash was required to take the bus to the railway station at a particular time. This was a circumstance attending his employment because at that time and place Omprakash had to take the bus at Railway Station where he was stabbed by one Munnalal in consequence of which he died. The deceased had to take the bus to the Railway Station as part of his duty where he was given a fatal blow. The incident of inflicting knife injury at the time and place when the deceased was on duty was an proximate cause. The injury had resulted to the deceased from the risk incidental to the duties of his service and unless he was engaged in the duty owing to his master, in all probability the workman that is the deceased Omprakash Singh would not have otherwise suffered the injury. In those circumstances, it can well be said that a casual connection was established between the accident and the employment and the accident had occurred on account of the risk which was an incident of the employment. There is neither any pleading nor any suggestion that the deceased by his own act added to the said incident or the same was brought about by himself. The decision in the case of Abida Khatun (supra) relied on by the learned counsel for the appellant does not advance his contention because in that case it was not established that there was any risk which was ordinarily inherent in discharge of the duties of the deceased workman with his employment. It was also found that the claimant had failed to establish that the workman was exposed to some special risk at the place where the accident took place. It was in these circumstances, the Full Bench of the Allahabad High Court in the case of Ali Mohd. Rajoo (supra) took the view that it was not established that the accident arose “out of employment”.
10. For the reasons stated above the appeal fails and is hereby dismissed with cost. Counsel fees as per schedule, if certified.
Alert