- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Jyotirmoy Das v. Land Acquisition Collector, Calcutta & Ors.
Structured Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner filed a writ petition seeking (a) an order directing respondents to release excess land measuring 17 Cottahs (at premises No. 59, Bagmari Road, Calcutta) pursuant to a release order dated 20.4.1998 (annexed as Annexure "F"), and (b) a direction restraining respondents from undertaking development, construction, addition or alteration on that exempted 17 Cottahs.
Relevant events recited by the Court include:
- Between late February and early March 1997, Calcutta Improvement Trust (C.I.T.), the requiring body, negotiated with a contractor for construction of a Market-cum-Commercial Complex; work order was issued on 11 March 1997.
- On 5 March 1997 the First Land Acquisition Collector informed the petitioner that an area of 6 Bighas 5 Cottahs had been acquired earlier (L.A. Case No. VII-M/106 of 1954) for the C.I.T. scheme.
- The petitioner, by representation dated 12 March 1997, asked C.I.T.'s Chief Valuer to demarcate the balance land reportedly remaining outside the scheme and offered to pay demarcation fees.
- On 9 June 1997 the Chief Valuer opined that the premises had been fully acquired under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 and that no balance land remained; demarcation of balance land was declared not feasible.
- A Single Bench of this Court in W.P. No. 9456(W) of 1997 (order dated 10 June 1997) directed the "concerned authority" to consider the petitioner's prayer for demarcation expeditiously (preferably within eight weeks).
- Thereafter, no appeal was preferred against that Single Bench order. The acquiring authority (part of the acquiring authority, namely the Second Land Acquisition Collector) inspected and, by report dated 20 April 1998, found land measuring about 17 Cottahs 5 Chittaks at the eastern side of premises Nos. 59 and 60 and issued a release order accordingly (Annexure F).
- The Calcutta Improvement Trust opposed demarcation and resisted other measures; during interim proceedings this Court had contemplated appointing a Special Officer but C.I.T. opposed it, and the Court passed a status-quo order.
- Subsequently a memo dated 12 March 1999 by a newly appointed First Acquisition Collector purportedly cancelled the earlier memo and report dated 20 April 1998, an action which the Court described as creating a cloud and as an afterthought. The Court estopped giving effect to that cancellation.
- On final consideration the Court found the petitioner had a prima facie cause of action based on the earlier Single Bench order and the measurements taken by the acquiring authority, and disposed of the writ petition with directions either to release the excess land by demarcation or to pay compensation at market rate.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the respondents (including the Calcutta Improvement Trust) must release the excess land measuring 17 Cottahs (identified in the acquiring authority's report of 20.4.1998) to the petitioner in accordance with the release order (Annexure F) and the Single Bench direction dated 10.6.1997.
- Whether the respondents should be restrained from undertaking any development, construction, addition or alteration on the said exempted 17 Cottahs until demarcation or compensation is completed.
- Whether the principle of inordinate delay or doctrines relied upon in the cited precedents (relating to reopening acquisitions and entitlement to relief on delay grounds) apply so as to preclude the petitioner from obtaining relief.
- Whether statutory provisions of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (including Sections 8, 9(2), 11, 12, 18 and Section 26(2) as invoked by respondents) render the writ petition non-maintainable or require different remedy procedures.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner sought an order directing release of the excess land of 17 Cottahs pursuant to the release order dated 20.4.1998 (Annexure F) and pursuant to the Court's earlier Single Bench direction dated 10.6.1997 to consider demarcation.
- The petitioner contended he was entitled to demarcation and executory relief because the acquiring authority, in compliance with the Single Bench order, measured and found excess land in favour of the petitioner.
- The petitioner accepted that compensation had been paid in respect of the originally acquired area (6 Bighas 5 Cottahs) and therefore his claim does not concern non-acceptance of award moneys under Section 18 — instead it concerns release/measurement of excess land being held without sanction of law.
- The petitioner volunteered to pay demarcation costs and sought a brick-wall demarcation at his cost if ordered by the Court.
Respondents' (Calcutta Improvement Trust / Requiring Authority) Arguments
- C.I.T. contested the grant of relief and advanced arguments on the scope and ambit of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, emphasizing provisions (as relied upon) including Section 12 read with Section 26(2) — arguing that an award by the Collector is deemed a decree and not challengeable before a writ court, and that remedy lies under Section 18.
- The respondents argued applicability of Sections 8, 9(2), 11, 12 and 18 of the Land Acquisition Act to support their position (the opinion records that these sections were pressed on the Court).
- C.I.T. resisted appointment of a Special Officer for physical verification/measurement and opposed immediate demarcation attempts; C.I.T.'s counsel also criticized the conduct of the Land Acquisition Collector during hearings.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| (1981) 3 SCC 628 : AIR 1979 SC 1713, Babu Singh v. Union of India (referenced with Paragraph 11) | Principle concerning inordinate delay and entitlement to relief (i.e., limitations on relief where delay is inordinate or where reopening an award is concerned). | The Court held this ratio inapplicable to the facts because the petitioner's cause of action derived from the Single Bench order directing demarcation and not from reopening the 1954 acquisition; no appeal was taken, and the acquiring authority acted on the Court's order. |
| (1996) 6 SCC 1 : AIR 1997 SC 432, Municipal Corporation of Greater Bombay v. The Industrial Development Investment Co. Pvt. Ltd. (Paragraphs 19 and part of 22) | Principles about reopening matters and entitlement to relief where acquisition and awards are involved (used to argue against delayed relief/reopening). | The Court found this precedent inapplicable for similar reasons: the instant demarcation claim flows from a binding order of the Single Bench and does not amount to reopening the 1954 acquisition or challenging the original award in the manner addressed by that precedent. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court's analysis proceeds in several discrete steps, following the sequence of facts and prior orders:
- Established factual core: The 1954 acquisition (6 Bighas 5 Cottahs) and payment of compensation in respect of that acquisition are not disputed; the present dispute concerns an alleged excess land measuring about 17 Cottahs 5 Chittaks lying at the eastern side of premises Nos. 59 and 60.
- Recognized binding procedural antecedent: A Single Bench order dated 10 June 1997 directed the "concerned authority" to consider the petitioner's request for demarcation expeditiously. The Court interpreted "concerned authority" to mean the acquiring authority (not the requiring body), and noted that no appeal was filed against that order.
- Relied on acquiring authority's action: The Second Land Acquisition Collector inspected and reported on 20 April 1998 that an area of 17 Cottahs 5 Chittaks existed and that a release order was issued accordingly (Annexure F). The acquiring authority therefore acted in compliance with the Single Bench direction.
- Rejected respondents' procedural objections: The Court considered respondents' reliance on the Land Acquisition Act provisions (including Sections 8, 9(2), 11, 12, 18 and Section 26(2)) but found those arguments do not defeat the petitioner's claim because the cause of action presently asserted flows from the Single Bench order for demarcation and the acquiring authority's subsequent measurement and release order. In particular, Section 18 (reference to Collector when award is not accepted) was held inapplicable because the petitioner had accepted compensation for the 6 Bighas 5 Cottahs; the petition concerns alleged excess land held without sanction.
- Addressed delay/reopening doctrines: The Court examined precedents relied upon by respondents (relating to reopening acquisitions and inordinate delay) and concluded those ratios were not applicable, given that demarcation does not concern the original acquisition area and that the petitioner's claim arises from a court order complied with by the acquiring authority.
- Considered interim conduct and balance of convenience: The Court noted the requiring body's resistance to a Special Officer appointment and the filing of a cancelling memo by a subsequently appointed Collector (12 March 1999) undoing the 20 April 1998 report — actions which the Court characterized as creating a cloud and possibly being afterthoughts or attempts to frustrate compliance. On balance, the Court found the balance of convenience favored the petitioner and that retention of excess land by State machinery without legal sanction offends Article 300A principles (protection against arbitrary State deprivation).
- Relief fashioned consistent with findings: Given the above, the Court held that the petitioner was entitled to executory relief. It provided two alternative remedies to the requiring body: (a) to release the excess land in accordance with Annexure F by making an actual demarcation (a brick wall) at the petitioner's cost within a fortnight, in the presence of the 1st or 2nd Land Acquisition Collector; or (b) if demarcation is not feasible, to pay market-rate compensation (per State registration values) within a further fortnight. The Court also ordered demolition of any construction encroaching into the released area and restrained further construction until one of the courses was completed.
- Final disposition and ancillary orders: The writ petition was disposed of with these directions, interlocutory applications were disposed, urgent certified copies to be supplied within seven days upon requisition, no costs awarded, and a subsequent prayer for stay of operations was considered and refused.
Holding and Implications
Holding: Writ petition disposed of with directions that the requiring body (and its agents/servants/assignees/representatives in possession) must either (a) release the excess land identified in Annexure 'F' by physical demarcation (brick wall) at petitioner's cost within a fortnight in the presence of the Land Acquisition Collector, or (b) pay market-rate compensation for the excess land within a further fortnight; demolition of any encroaching construction and a prohibition on further construction until compliance were also ordered.
Implications
- Immediate practical effect: The respondents are obliged to implement one of the two specified remedies within the strict timeframes set by the Court (fortnight for demarcation, further fortnight for compensation if demarcation not feasible).
- Enforcement and consequential effects: Any construction encroaching into the area ordered to be released must be demolished; no further construction is permitted until either demarcation or compensation is completed.
- Precedential effect: The Court explicitly stated that the cited authorities on inordinate delay and reopening are inapplicable on the facts; thus the decision is narrowly based on the existence of the Single Bench order, the acquiring authority's measurement and release order, and the particular procedural posture (no appeal having been preferred). The Court did not purport to establish a new broad principle beyond applying those facts to grant executory relief.
- Costs and procedural notes: No order as to costs was made; interlocutory applications disposed; urgent certified copies to be supplied within seven days on requisition; a subsequent application for stay of the order was refused.
Note: This summary is limited strictly to the matters recorded in the provided opinion. Where the opinion itself used ellipses or incomplete transcriptions (for example within the acquiring authority's report), those specific missing details are reflected as gaps in the source and have not been supplemented.
1. Basically the petitioner made this writ petition for the purpose of commanding the respondents to release the excess land measuring 17 Cottahs at 59, Bagmari Road, Calcutta to the petitioner in view of the release order made by the respondent No. 2 herein dated 20.4.98 being Annexure ‘F’ to the writ petition.
2. He also made the prayer to direct the respondents to forbear from making any such development and/or construction work under the development scheme and/or making any such addition, alteration or construction of the said exempted land measuring 17 Cottahs of the said exempted land being 59, Bagmari Road, Calcutta etc. Between late February and early March 1997, Calcutta Improvement Trust being requiring body of the concerned land started negotinting with one Rashtriya Pariyojona Nirman Nigam Limited for the purpose of construction of Market-cum-Commercial Complex therein. On 5th March, 1997 the first Land Acquisition Collector, Calcutta informed the petitioner with reference to the letter dated 11th October, 1996 that they acquired an area of 6 Bighas 5 Cottahs of land under L.A Case No. VII-M/106 of 1954 for C.I.T Scheme No. VII-M (Maniktala Main Road to Ultadanga Main Road). Thereafter no L.A proceedings has been initiated as yet in respect of the said property by any department of State Government. On 11th March, 1997 Calcutta Improvement Trust issued work order upon the aforesaid contracting party. On 12th March, 1997 the petitioner informed the Chief Valuer of the Calcutta Improvement Trust that Land Acquisition Collector issued a certificate regarding the acquired land of the above subject property with a request to demarcate the balance lend which is now remaining outside the scheme and project of C.I.T The petitioner agreed to pay all requisite fees for the demarcation affairs.
3. On 9th June, 1997 Chief Valuer of the Calcutta Improvement Trust came to the finding that premises No. 59, Bagmari Road, Calcutta had been fully acquired under Land Acquisition Act, 1894 by the L.A Collector, Calcutta and possession of the said premises measuring about 6 Bighas 5 Cottahs had been handed over to C.I.T as per provisions of L.A Act, 1894, and no balance land remains in the said premises. Upon demarcation of the balance land of premises No. 59, Bagmari Road, is neither feasible nor plausible.
4. Real crux of the case stands on measurement of the laid in excess measuring 17 Cottahs and/or exemption of the same from the acquired land. There is no doubt that a land measuring 6 Bighas 5 Cottahs was acquired in the year 1954 and compensation was paid in respect of such acquisition to the appropriate party. There is no existing dispute to that extent.
5. However dispute as cropped up resulted to an order passed by a Single Bench of this Hon'ble Court in disposing a writ petition being W.P No. 9456(W) of 1997 on 10th June, 1997 which speaks as follows:—
“In presence of Mr. Gupta, learned Senior Advocate on behalf of the state-respondents, this writ petition is disposed of with a direction upon the concerned authority to consider the prayer of the writ petitioner for the purpose of demarcation of the lands in question in pursuance of his representation dated 12th March, 1967 in accordance with the provisions of law as expeditiously as possible preferably within a period of 8 weeks from the date of communication of this order.”
6. The word ‘concerned authority’ has some significance in the matter and law says ‘concerned authority’ signifies acquiring authority but not the requiring authority.
7. No appeal was preferred from the order by any of the parties. Acquiring authority has acted upon on the basis of such order.
8. It appears from the report of the Second Land Acquisition Collector, Calcutta i.e being part of acquiring authority dated 20th April, 1998 which that he was made an inspection and ………… that there is land in ……… amounting to an area of 17 Cottahs and 5 Chittaks in a ……… at the eastern side of premises Nos. 59 and 60, Bagmari Road, Calcutta as shown in the plan as the said land awarded in favour of Government and at present Calcutta Improvement Trust is in possession. Therefore, release order was issued accordingly.
9. Since no appeal was preferred from the aforesaid order passed by a Single Bench of this Hon'ble Court on 10th June, 1997 and since appropriate part of competent authority of the State, in compliance of such order taken measurement and found that the land in question being 17 Cottahs 5 Chittaks at the eastern side of premises Nos. 59 and 60, Bagmari Road, Calcutta and passed release order to that extent there is no scope for the Calcutta Improvement Trust, in this respect, being the requiring authority to oppose such contention either on their behalf or on behalf of the acquiring authority i.e Land Acquisition Collector but to release the same.
10. To strengthen my observation I have carefully considered all other annexures to the writ petition as well as affidavits wherefrom I found that everywhere the measurement of the acquired land even prior to the date of the order passed by a Single Bench of this Court on 10th June, 1997 found to be the area of 6 Bighas 5 Cottahs as acquired under L.A Case No. VII-M/106 of 1954 for C.I.T Scheme No. VII-M (Maniktala Main Road to Uitadanga Main Road) from the subject property and award was given in respect thereof.
11. Therefore, from the ultimate analysis of the aforesaid aspects, it is crystal clear that the petitioner has a prima facie cause of action is this respect which is neither belated as regards to the demarcation nor for any involvement of third party. In effect, the cause of action of this application flowing from an order of the Court and consideration in respect thereof.
12. At the initial stage of hearing, this Court was inclined to pass an order for appointing a Special Officer for the purpose of physical verification and measurement of the land. Although, the petitioner was willing but the Calcutta Improvement Trust was not willing for the same which obviously created cloud in the mind of the Court as to whether the requiring body is trying to hide the actual picture before the Court of law or not.
13. However, this Court was pleased to pass an order of status quo in respect of the land in question and postponed hearing in a future date but surprisingly within such period of order of status quo, a purportedly newly Appointed First Acquisition Collector, Calcutta by a memo No. 63-LA(II) dated 12th March, 1999 cancelled the order passed by an appropriate authority in this respect being memo No. 216/1(3)-LA dated 20th April, 1998 along with the report with supporting plan forwarded to the petitioner. This action also formed cloud in the mind of the Court. It is obviously afterthought and brain child of delayed legal advice. However, giving effect of this order was estopped by this Court.
14. Thirdly, on the date of final hearing when this Court enquired about the conduct of the Land Acquisition Collector is this respect and wasted a plausible answer from them, learned Counsel of the Calcutta Improvement Trust intervened and argued at length in one hand with regard to scope and ambit of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 and to protect their interest, on the other hand, took part in criticising the conduct of the Land Acquisition Collector. This stand also formed cloud in the mind of the Court.
15. ??? exiertora indicant interiora secreta i.e, external acts indicate the secret mind. Under this background balance of convenience obviously striks in favour of the petitioner in getting equitable relief.
16. Moreover, if the same would have been the position in respect of the State would they have released a private citizen? If that would not have been the position the same cannot be done by any State machinery as against a private citizen specially when law is well settled in respect of the protection of the private citizen as against the State machinery in respect of unfair play, discriminatory or arbitrary actions. This Court is astonished to know that a State machinery want to retain excess land without any legal proceeding. Such activities, in effect, hit by Article 300A of the Constitution of India.
17. Therefore, principle of inordinate delay and entitlement of relief on that score in favour of the contesting respondents is not available in the fact situation. Accordingly, ratio of (1) (1981) 3 SCC 628 : AIR 1979 SC 1713, Babu Singh v. Union of India, Paragraph 11 and (2) (1996) 6 SCC 1 : AIR 1997 SC 432, Municipal Corporation of Greater Bombay v. The Industrial Development Investment Co. Pvt. Ltd., Paragraph 19 and last part of 22 are inapplicable herein. Similarly matter of reopening of case does not arise herein because the demarcation does not relate in respect of acquisition of 6 Blighas 5 Cottahs of land and compensation paid thereon. Moreover, right of measurement flows from on order of this Court from which no appeal was preferred…… due compliance was given thereto.
18. A further argument was put forward in respect of applicability of different sections being Sections 8, 9(2), 11, 12 and 18 of the Land Acquisition Act but the same cannot form part and parcel of the strength of argument of the contesting respondents because of the reason that the case proceeded on a given cause of action under an order of Single Bench of this Hon'ble Court, having binding effect in respect of the demarcation and it appears for some reason or other the requiring body is trying to avoid the demarcation. Therefore, the cause of action derives from the order of a Single Bench of this Hon'ble Court dated 10th June, 1997 cannot be put to be a cause of action relate back to 1954.
19. The requiring body also emphasized more in respect of maintainability of the application on the basis of the relevant provisions of the act being Land Acquisition Act, 1894. More emphasize was given on Section 12 read with Section 26(2) of the Act by saying that award passed by the Collector shall be deemed to be a decree and, therefore, it cannot be challenged before a Writ Court but there is no answer that award about which land. It is also stated that if a person is aggrieved he may ask for reference to the concerned Collector under Section 18 of the Act.
20. There is a falacy in respect of the argument as above……there is no explanation by the respondents-Counsel on that score upon enquiry made by this Court. Section 18 provides for making an application before the Collector who has not accepted the awarded amount. This is not the case that the petitioner that he has not accepted the awarded amount. In the instant case petitioner did accept the awarded amount but in respect of the land measuring 6 Bighas 5 Cottahs and the allegation is that the requiring authority holding excess land without any sanction of law for which he is entitled for a measurement. On top of it there is an order of this Court to that extent and the authority concerned proceeded accordingly and held that there is excess land. Therefore, in this writ petition, then petitioner is entitled for executory relief.
21. Therefore, two courses are open for the requiring authority either to release the excess land to the petitioner as prescribed under Annexure ‘F’ to the petition within a prescribed time period upon making actual demarcation line alternatively pay the compensation to the petitioner as per market rate of the land of the locality made by the state for the purpose of registration of the properties, for retaining such land by them without sanction of law.
22. Therefore, the requiring body of the State and/or it's agents, servants, assignees or representatives whosoever in the possession of the land is directed to release the land in excess as per Annexure ‘F’ to the petition to the petitioner in presence of the 1st or 2nd Land Acquisition Collector, whosoever is present in the office by making demarcation line in the form of a brick wall at the cost of the petitioner within a period of fortnight from the date of the order. In case any construction encroached into such laid the same should be demolished being a consequential effect.
23. If the same is not feasible as stated by the requiring body either it or it's agents, servants, assignees or representatives will pay compensation of such excess land to the petitioner within a period of further fortnight thereafter at the market rate of the land of the locality as per value of the registration of properties made by the State due to retaining the same without sanction of law. No further construction will be made till either of the courses are resolved.
24. Thus the writ petition is disposed of. No order is passed as to costs. By the said order interiocutory application or applications are also disposed of. Urgent xerox certified copy will be supplied within seven days from the date of putting requisition.
25. Later on—Prayer for stay of operation of the order is made considered and refused.
26. S.K.G
Alert