- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ramgobind Prasad v. Gulab Chand Sahu
Structured Summary of the Opinion (Chatterji, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
The plaintiffs sued for recovery of Rs. 1,066-12-3 based on entries in bahi khatas (account books). They alleged that the defendants formed a joint family (with defendant No. 2 as karta) operating two confectionery shops in Samastipur, and that those shops purchased flour, sugar and other items from the plaintiffs' firm on credit. Previous transactions were paid up to 14th Asarh, 1340, and the suit concerns transactions between 14th Asarh, 1340 and 13th Jeth, 1342. The claimed amount included interest at 1% per mensem, said to have been agreed to by the defendants.
The defendants denied the transactions in toto and pleaded that defendant No. 2 and his son (defendant No. 9) were separate from defendant No. 1 and his sons (defendants 3–8).
At trial the learned Munsif decreed the suit against all defendants, finding the defendants to be joint and accepting the plaintiffs' account books as genuine and kept in the ordinary course of business. On appeal by defendants 2 and 9, the Subordinate Judge affirmed the finding of jointness and the genuineness of the books but held that mere entries in the books, unsupported by independent evidence of the transactions, were insufficient to charge the defendants; he therefore dismissed the suit. The plaintiffs took a second appeal to the Court containing this opinion.
Legal Issues Presented
- How is section 34 of the Evidence Act to be applied to entries in books of account regularly kept in the course of business — specifically, whether such entries, without further independent proof of each item, can suffice to charge defendants with liability.
- Whether the testimony of the person who wrote the account books (the munshi) and who states that the transactions were noted in his presence can corroborate the entries sufficiently to constitute evidence of the transactions referred to in those entries.
- Whether, on the evidence before the appellate Court, the plaintiffs had proven the debts recorded in the bahi khatas so as to sustain a decree against the defendants (including any question as to interest).
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments (Plaintiffs)
- Counsel for the appellants (Mr. Sushil Madhab Mullick) argued that the Subordinate Judge proceeded on an erroneous view of section 34 of the Evidence Act and erred in requiring "independent evidence" of each separate transaction described in the account books.
- The plaintiffs relied on their account books (admitted as genuine and regularly kept) and on oral testimony, including that of P.W.1 (plaintiff No. 1) and P.W.8 (their munshi, Niras Jha), who wrote many of the entries and testified that transactions were noted in the course of business.
Respondents' Arguments (Defendants)
- The defendants denied the transactions alleged in the plaint and pleaded separation between some family members (i.e., that certain defendants were not joint).
- The Subordinate Judge, supporting the defendants, treated the entries in the plaintiffs' account books as insufficient in themselves to charge the defendants and relied on earlier authorities holding that books must be corroborated by independent proof of the transactions or by admissions of the opposite party.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Bibi Imambandi v. Haji Motasuddi | It is essential to establish that books were regularly kept; mere proof of correctness of books is not enough — the entries themselves have to be proved unless the opposite party admits them. | The Court observed that in Bibi Imambandi only evidence of correctness of the books was produced (not proof of the entries themselves), and such evidence was insufficient. The Court distinguished the present case because here the writer of many entries had been examined and his testimony corroborated those entries. |
| Rampat Sahu v. Bhajju Sahu | Where a witness proves only that certain entries are in a particular person's handwriting but does not prove the transactions recorded, there may be no evidence sufficient to charge the defendants. | The Court treated Rampat Sahu as distinguishable: in that case the writer of the entries was not called and no evidence of the transactions was given; in the present case the munshi who wrote many entries (P.W.8) did give evidence as to the transactions and thereby corroborated those entries. |
| Ganeshi Lal v. The Firm Mangat Ram-Atma Ram (Lahore High Court) | Held that a plaintiff must prove the various items of his account by independent evidence (supporting a stricter approach requiring item-by-item proof). | The Court noted the decision but regarded it as a single-Judge decision that "went too far"; without knowing the precise facts of that case it could not be regarded as laying down a general principle applicable here. |
| Baboo Gunga Persad v. Baboo Inderjit Singh (Privy Council) | Where the fact of payments by a banking firm is distinctly put in issue, books are at most corroborative; a general statement that books were correctly kept is not sufficient when better evidence can be produced. | The Court cited this authority for the proposition that the sufficiency of corroboration depends on the nature of the dispute and available evidence; it used the principle to explain that what constitutes adequate corroboration is fact-dependent. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court analyzed the interplay between section 34 of the Evidence Act (entries in books of account regularly kept in the course of business are relevant but shall not alone be sufficient to charge any person with liability) and section 159 (allowing a witness to refresh memory from books). The Court emphasized that:
- Section 34 does not rigidly require "independent evidence" of each and every particular transaction (such as proof that "such and such articles valued at such and such amount were supplied on such and such dates").
- What amounts to adequate corroboration of book entries depends on the facts of each case and especially on the issues in dispute between the parties. When transactions are numerous and spread over time, expecting independent proof of each transaction is impracticable; the genuineness and regular keeping of the books become determinative.
- Nevertheless, entries must be corroborated in some way; mere proof of the correctness of the books will not suffice. The best form of corroboration is the testimony of the person who wrote the books and who can state that the transactions referred to were made in his presence or to his knowledge. Such a witness can, under section 159, refresh his memory from the books.
- Where the dispute is confined to specific items, the Court acknowledged that specific independent evidence in relation to those items should be insisted upon.
Applying these principles to the facts, the Court examined the evidence:
- P.W.1 (plaintiff No. 1) testified that the defendants purchased from the plaintiffs' firm and that the books were kept in due course of business; he proved entries but did not say he was present at the transactions or present when the entries were made for 1340 (those entries were written by a former munshi not called in the case).
- P.W.8 (Niras Jha), the plaintiffs' present munshi, testified that he had written the plaintiffs' bahis since 1341, that in 1341–42 Gulab Chand (defendant No. 2) made purchases and payments, and that the transactions and payments were noted in the bahi khata in due course. He proved the entries he had written (Exts. 2z(7)–2z(12) in the khatas and Exts. 3z(179)–3z(283) in the rokars).
- Although P.W.8 conceded in cross-examination that purchases were often noted later at the gaddi and that he did not orally remember particulars of all transactions, the Court held that his evidence did more than prove handwriting: he testified that the transactions recorded by him actually took place and thus sufficiently corroborated those entries he had written.
- The Court rejected the Subordinate Judge's narrower view that independent evidence proving each item was necessary, and distinguished previous authorities (Bibi Imambandi and Rampat Sahu) on the ground that in those cases the entries themselves were not proved by witnesses who could attest to the transactions; by contrast, here the writer of many entries had been examined and had testified as to the transactions.
- The Court also noted the Subordinate Judge's own observation that if plaintiff No. 1 or one of his servants had offered specific evidence referring to entries, combined with other general evidence, such evidence might have been sufficient — an observation underscoring that the issue turned on the evaluation of the munshi's testimony.
Because it was unclear from the Subordinate Judge's judgment whether he accepted the evidence of P.W.8 and because the appellate Court had not determined the amount covered by the entries proven by P.W.8 (nor had it decided on the question of interest), the Court concluded that the proper course was to set aside the appellate Court's decision and remand the case for disposal in light of these observations.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: The appeal was allowed; the decision of the lower appellate Court (the Subordinate Judge) was set aside and the case was remanded to that Court for disposal according to law in the light of the observations recited in the opinion.
Direct consequences:
- The appellate Court's dismissal of the suit was set aside and the matter is remitted to that Court for reconsideration particularly to determine (a) whether the evidence of P.W.8 sufficiently corroborates the entries written by him and (b) the amount due on the basis of those entries and the question of interest.
- Costs were ordered to abide the result (i.e., costs to be decided on final outcome).
Broader implications and clarifications by the Court:
- The Court clarified the proper application of section 34: entries in properly kept books are relevant and may be sufficient when supported by appropriate corroboration, and requirement of "independent evidence" of each item must be taken in context — where many transactions occur over time, the regular keeping and genuineness of the books combined with corroboration (especially by the writer) can suffice.
- The Court disapproved of an unduly rigid rule requiring item-by-item proof in every case, and it treated certain prior authority (the Lahore single-Judge decision) as not laying down a general rule applicable to all cases.
- The opinion did not purport to lay down a novel, binding precedent beyond these reasoned clarifications; instead it applied existing statutory provisions and precedent to the facts and remanded for factual determination by the lower appellate Court.
Disposition as recorded in the opinion: "Appeal allowed. Case remanded." (Costs to abide the result.)
Chatterji, J.:— This appeal arises out of a suit for recovery of Rs. 1,066-12-3 on basis of bahi khatas. The plaintiffs' case is that the defendants are members of a joint family, the defendant no. 2 being the karta. They have two confectionery shops in Samastipur, and for the purpose of those shops they used to purchase from the plaintiffs' firm flour, sugar, etc., on credit and made payments from time to time. The transactions were going on for some years, but the plaintiffs' dues up to the 14th Asarh, 1340, were paid up. The transactions continued after that date till the 13th Jeth, 1342. The claim in the suit relates to the transactions between the period from the 14th Asarh, 1940, to the 13th Jeth, 1342. The amount claimed includes interest at 1 per cent, per mensem which the defendants are said to have agreed to pay.
The defence was a total denial of the transactions. It was also pleaded that the defendant no. 2 and his son defendant no. 9 were separate from defendant no. 1 and his sons defendants 3 to 8.
The learned munsif decreed the suit against all the defendants, holding that they were all joint, and that the transactions alleged by the plaintiffs were true. He found that the account books of the plaintiffs were genuine and were kept in regular course of business. On appeal by defendants 2 and 9, the learned Subordinate Judge affirmed the Munsiff's finding regarding the defendants' jointness, and though he did not doubt the genuineness of the plaintiffs' account books, he considered that there being no independent evidence in proof of the transactions, the entries in the account books alone were not sufficient to charge the defendants with liability. In this view he dismissed the whole suit. Hence this second appeal by the plaintiffs.
Mr. Sushil Madhab Mullick on behalf of the appellants contends that the decision of the learned Subordinate Judge proceeds on an altogether erroneous view of section 34 of the Evidence Act. That section runs as follows:—
“Entries in books of account regularly kept in the course of business, are relevant whenever they refer to a matter into which the court has to enquire, but such statements shall not alone be sufficient evidence to charge any person with liability.”
The learned Subordinate Judge says “There is no independent evidence to prove that such and such articles valued at such and such amounts were supplied on such and such dates. The evidence produced by the plaintiffs is rather general evidence showing transactions between the defendants and the plaintiffs' firm”. Such evidence, he thinks, is not sufficient to charge the defendants with liability. He relies on the case of Bibi Imambandi v. Haji Motasuddi in which it has been laid down that “it is essential in every case when reliance is placed upon books of account to establish that they have been regularly kept in the course of business, but it is not sufficient merely to prove the correctness of the books; the entries themselves have to be proved, unless the necessity for such proof is removed by the admission of the opposite party. He also refers to the decision of this Court in Rampat Sahu v. Bhajju Sahu in which “the plaintiffs who sued on bahi khatas called a witness to prove that certain entries in the bahi khatas were in the handwriting of a particular person, but he offered no evidence of the transactions themselves and did not prove the debts which were purported to have been recorded in the bahi khatas”. The learned Judges held that there was no evidence sufficient to charge the defendants with liability and, consequently, dismissed the suit. The learned Subordinate Judge further relies on the decision of the Lahore High Court in Ganeshi Lal v. The Firm Mangat Ram-Atma Ram where it was held that a plaintiff to succeed must prove the various items of his account by independent evidence.
In the present suit the plaintiffs have examined several witnesses including the plaintiff no. 1 and their Munshi Niras Jha, P.W 8. All these witnesses depose that the defendants had transactions with the plaintiffs. This evidence, however, is of a general character. The plaintiff no. 1 (P.W 1) says:
“Defendants used to make purchases from my firm for carrying on shops of puri, mithai………Rs. 1,066-12-3 as principal plus interest is due from defendants……Defendants continued business with my firm till 13th Jeth, 1342 Fs. The books of accounts of my firm were written in due course of business.”
He also proves the entries in the account books. But he does not say that the entries were made in his presence or that he was present when the transactions referred to in the entries took place. According to his evidence the entries in the account books for 1340 were written by his Munshi Anant Lal who is no longer in his service, nor has he been examined in this case. But the evidence of P.W 8 Niras Jha, who is the present Munshi of the plaintiffs, is important. He says that he writes the plaintiffs' bahis since 1341. He further says in his examination in chief
“In 1341 and 1342 Rs. Gulab Chand (defendant no. 2) made purchases from plaintiffs' firm and made payments also from time to time. Tile transactions and the payments were noted in the bahi khata accounts in due course of business.”
He then goes on to prove the entries in the account books written by him. These are Exts. 2z(7) to 2z(12) in the khatas and Exts. 3z(179) to 3z(283) in the rokars. In cross-examination he says
“A man is debated along with the customer and after the purchase, they come back and get the purchases noted in the bahis at the gaddi……I remember only a few transactions made by Gulabchand. I do not orally remember the particulars of all the transactions entered into by him.”
This witness thus proves not merely the entries written by him, but also that the transactions referred to in those entries actually took place. His evidence, therefore, sufficiently corroborates those entries in the account books that were written by him.
Section 34 of the Evidence Act does not mean that there should be, as the learned Judge thinks, “independent evidence to prove that such and such articles valued at such and such amount were supplied on such and such dates”. What would amount to independent evidence sufficient to corroborate the entries in the account books depends upon the facts of each case, and particularly on the issues between the parties. What is necessary to be seen in each case is whether, besides the entries in the account books, there is any evidence to prove that the transactions referred to in those entries actually took place. Where the transactions sued upon are numerous and extend over some length of time, it is hardly reasonable to expect independent evidence to be given to prove each and every particular transaction. In such case the genuineness of the account books, if they are regularly kept in the course of business, will be the determining factor. But mere proof of the correctness of the entries in the account books will not be enough. There must be some evidence to corroborate those entries. Such corroboration will be best afforded by the evidence of the person who wrote the account books and in whose presence the transactions took place. He cannot possibly have independent recollection of the various transactions, and he may, as provided in section 159 of the Evidence Act, refresh his memory by referring to the account books. But it is not necessary for him to prove that “such and such articles valued at such and such amount were supplied on such and such dates”. If he proves the entries written by him and states that the transactions referred to in those entries actually took place in his presence or to his knowledge, the effect will substantially be the same. Where, however, the dispute between the parties is confined to some particular items only, specific evidence may be available and should be insisted upon to prove those particular transactions. In this connection reference may be made to the decision of the Privy Council in Baboo Gunga Persad v. Baboo Inderjit Singh. There it was held that “where the fact of payments by a banking firm is distinctly put in issue, the books of the firm being at most corroborative evidence, the mere general statement of the banker to the effect that his books were correctly kept is not sufficient to discharge the burden of proof that lies upon him, particularly if he has the means of producing much better evidence.”
In Bibi Imambandi v. Haji Motasuddi there was evidence merely to prove the correctness of the books; the entries themselves were not proved. Certainly such evidence could not be sufficient, and this is what was held in that case. In Rampat Sahu v. Bhajju Sahu a witness was called simply to prove that certain entries in the bahi khatas were in the handwriting of a particular person. The writer of those entries was not called, nor any evidence was given of the transactions themselves. This is not the state of evidence in the present case. The Lahore case, Ganeshi Lal v. The Firm, Mangat Ram-Atma Ram, no doubt supports the defendants' contention. But it is a decision of a single Judge, and with all respect I must say that the decision went too far. Besides, without knowing the actual facts and the exact evidence in that case, the decision cannot be regarded as laying down any general principle of law.
The learned Subordinate Judge himself observes
“If the plaintiff no. 1, or one of his servants, had offered evidence of the various transactions on reference to the entries in the rokar bahis, such evidence coupled with the general evidence of the other witnesses might have been sufficient to charge the defendants with liability.”
This shows that he did not doubt the genuineness of the plaintiffs' account books. If, therefore, he had considered that the evidence of P.W 8 was reliable and sufficient in law to corroborate the entries in the account books so far as those written by him were concerned, he would have given the plaintiffs a decree on the basis of those entries. P.W 8 proves the entries Exts. 2z(7) to 2z(12) in the khatas and the entries Exts. 3z (179) to 3z(283) in the rokars to be in his handwriting. If his evidence about the actual transactions is believed, the plaintiffs will be entitled to a decree for the amount covered by the said entries. But as it is not clear from the judgment of the learned Subordinate Judge whether he believes the evidence of P.W 8 or not and as the amount has not been determined, it is necessary that the case should go back to him. He has not also decided the question of interest.
I would, therefore, allow the appeal and set aside the decision of the lower appellate Court and remand the case to that Court for disposal according to law in the light of the observations made above. Costs will abide the result.
Manohar Lall, J.:— I agree.
S.A.K
Appeal allowed.
Case remanded.
Alert