- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sheikh Amedali v. Kennor Khan Opposite Party.
After hearing the learned Counsel on both sides we are of opinion that the rule must be made absolute and the orders passed by the Deputy Magistrate on the 4th May and 6th June 1908, directing delivery of the bungalow and its contents to the Opposite Party must be set aside, and in lieu thereof an, order passed that the bungalow and its contents be made over to the Petitioner.
It is clear from the facts stated in the petition that the Petitioner's case in which he charged the Opposite Party with having forcibly dispossessed him of the bungalow and its contents, was found to be true and the Opposite Party was convicted under sec. 323, I.P.C, for having forcibly dispossessed him of both. In those circumstances it was the duty of the Magistrate to pass orders under secs. 522 and 517, Cr. P.C, directing restoration to the Petitioner of the bungalow and its contents from which, it was found, he had been forcibly dispossessed.
It has, however, been contended on behalf of the Opposite Party that this Court has no power to interfere in revision with an order passed by a Magistrate under sec. 522, Cr. P.C It is admitted that such a power expressly is given with reference to an order under sec. 517; but it is argued that as such a power is not expressly given with reference to an order passed under sec. 522, Cr. P.C, this Court cannot interfere with an order under the latter section. We find however that this question was before the Allahabad High Court in the case of Musammat Manki v. Musammat Bhagwanti and the learned Judges distinctly held that under the provisions of clause (d) of sec. 423, Cr. P.C, this Court as a Court of revision has full power to interfere with an order under sec. 522, Cr. P.C The learned Judges in that case referred to the case in this Court of Ram Chandra v. Nabin Mirdha as apparently laying down a different view. The question was not however before this Court in that case, and the remarks made by the learned Judges of this Court in their judgment in which they deal with the argument advanced on the basis of the principle laid down by the Privy Council in Rodget v. Camplar(3) that it is the duty of all Courts to take care that the act of the Court does no injury to any of the suitors, seem to indicate that if a fit case for their interference had been made out they would not have hesitatated to enforce the principle. We agree with the view taken by the Judges of the Allahabad High Court and hold that the objection taken cannot be sustained and that this Court has power to interfere in revision with an order passed by the Magistrate under sec. 522, Cr. P.C
We therefore make the rule absolute, set aside the order of the Deputy Magistrate, dated the 4th May and 6th june, and in lieu thereof direct that the bungalow and its contents be made over to the petitioner.
B.C
Rule made absolute.
Alert