Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Darpan Potdarin v. Emperor

Patna High Court
Oct 29, 1937
Smart Summary (Beta)

Concise Analytical Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant is Darpan Potdarin, a woman aged between 50 and 55 years, who was convicted and sentenced to death by the Sessions Judge of Bhagalpur (Santal Parganas) for the murder of her daughter, Titwa (about 24 years old). The incident occurred in the early hours of 19 February, when the village chaukidar Raghoo Mirdha (P.W.10) alerted the Sub-Inspector (P.W.11) at Sarath police station that there had been a murder in village Dhoro Dumar. The injured girl, Titwa, was found with multiple incised wounds to the neck and face and was taken to Sarath hospital; she later died and a post mortem was sent to Deoghar. Darpan lodged a first information report at the thana; later statements and examinations took place (including an interview at the hospital purportedly amounting to a dying declaration recorded by the Sub-Inspector by interpreting the injured girl's signs). Another accused, Dhano Poddar, was arrested and tried with Darpan but was acquitted by the Sessions Judge. The appeal challenges the safety of Darpan's conviction and sentence.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the supposed dying declaration recorded by the Sub-Inspector (by interpreting the injured girl's signs and head movements) was properly recorded and admissible in evidence.
  2. Whether, on the whole of the evidence (including motive, blood-stains on the accused's clothing, statements allegedly made by the deceased to neighbours, the child's testimony, and the absence of a recovered weapon), it was safe to maintain the conviction and death sentence against Darpan.
  3. Whether the testimony of the child witness (Jiblal, aged ten) could be relied upon where there was a delay before he communicated his account and no evidence that it was reported immediately, raising the possibility of coaching.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
41 CWN 513.1 That when an injured person makes replies by signs, the recorder should describe the precise nature of the signs and leave interpretation to the tribunal (i.e., proper recording of non-verbal dying declarations). The court relied on this authority to conclude that the Sub-Inspector's record was defective because he did not describe the signs or movements; consequently the supposed dying declaration was held to be very unsatisfactory and inadmissible in law (and, even if admitted, pointed more clearly to the guilt of Dhano than to that of Darpan).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook a careful evaluation of the evidence and applied the following analytical steps based on the material in the record:

  1. Examination of the purported dying declaration recorded by the Sub-Inspector:
    • The Sub-Inspector recorded answers based on the injured girl's "making signs with her hand" and "movement of her head" but did not describe the precise signs or movements.
    • Applying the principle cited (see 41 CWN 513.1), the court held that the absence of any description of the signs meant the declaration was recorded defectively and therefore inadmissible in law.
    • The court further observed that, on its face, the interpreted content of that record pointed more clearly to the guilt of Dhano than to Darpan.
  2. Assessment of contemporaneous statements to neighbours and their inconsistencies:
    • Several neighbours (including Rafiuddin Mirza and others) were said to have heard Titwa accuse her mother. The court noted discrepancies in accounts (for example, why immediate arrest or notification to the Sub-Inspector was not effected by those who heard the accusation), and found that these circumstances undermined the reliability of the neighbours' accounts.
    • The court regarded the refusal of water at the hands of Darpan (if true) as capable of multiple explanations and not determinative of guilt.
  3. Evaluation of the child witness (Jiblal, aged ten):
    • The boy gave a detailed account to the Sessions Judge, but the court stressed that he did not appear to have related his story to anyone until later in the day (to his father).
    • The court emphasized the general rule that the evidence of children, unless immediate and insulated from the possibility of coaching, is unreliable and "notoriously dangerous." It held that reliance on the child's evidence alone would be unsafe.
  4. Physical evidence and investigative omissions:
    • The injured girl had multiple incised wounds consistent with a knife attack. No weapon was ever recovered; the court noted the police appear to have made no effective search for a weapon.
    • Darpan had blood-stains on her sari and at the corners of her eyes; the Sub-Inspector's examination showed dried blood on the garments, but the court accepted Darpan's explanation that these stains could have arisen from going to her daughter's cut and holding the child's baby. The stains were not inconsistent with that explanation.
    • The court noted that, given the alleged nature of the attack, it was improbable that the accused could have concealed a weapon or removed blood from her hands unobserved, and there was no evidence of blood on her hands or arms sufficient to support guilt conclusively.
  5. Consideration of motive and village dynamics:
    • The court acknowledged a possible motive: Darpan had for about a year accused her husband of improper relations with the daughter, and domestic management had been given to the daughter, creating resentment.
    • Nevertheless, motive alone was insufficient; combined with other weaknesses in the prosecution case, the motive did not support a safe conviction.
    • The court also considered but could not exclude the possibility that villagers might have combined to protect the real perpetrator by implicating an unpopular, quarrelsome woman.
  6. Overall assessment and procedural fairness:
    • The court criticized the defence representation as incompetent in cross-examination and observed that several obvious lines of inquiry were not pursued by defence counsel.
    • It commented on the duty of the trial judge and of those selecting counsel for indigent accused persons to ensure competent representation and, where necessary, for the judge to assist by exercising judicial power to test witnesses when defence counsel is manifestly inadequate.
  7. Conclusion of analysis:
    • Taking together: the inadmissibility of the dying declaration (as recorded), the unreliable or inconsistent lay witnesses' accounts, the inherent danger of relying solely on the delayed evidence of a child, the absence of a recovered weapon, and the plausible innocent explanations for blood-stains, the court found the prosecution case insufficiently safe to maintain a conviction and sentence.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court directed that the reference be discharged, the appeal be allowed, and the appellant be set at liberty.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that Darpan's conviction and death sentence were quashed and she was ordered to be released.
  • The court did not purport to lay down a new general precedent beyond applying the established requirement (as cited) for proper recording of non-verbal dying declarations; it also reiterated well-known cautions about reliance on child evidence and the need for basic investigative steps (such as recovery of a weapon).
  • The opinion contains explicit judicial commentary on systemic and procedural concerns: the need for competent appointment of counsel to defend indigent accused persons and the trial judge's duty to protect the interests of justice when defence counsel is manifestly incompetent. These are remedial observations directed to practice rather than the creation of novel legal rules in the judgment itself.
V.B/R.K

Disposition: Appeal allowed.

Show all summary ...

1. This is the appeal by a, woman named Darpan Potdarin (aged between 50 and 55 years) who has been convicted and sentenced to death by the Sessions Judge of Bhagalpar sitting in the Santal Parganas for the murder of her daughter Titwa (aged about 24 years).

2. In the early hours of the morning of 19th February last, the Sub-Inspector (P.W 11) stationed at the police station of Sarath in the district of Dumka was awakened by a chaukidar Raghoo Mirdha (P.W 10) of village Dhoro Dumar, about three miles from the thana. The chaukidar said that there had been a murder in his village. The Sub-Inspector came out and saw a girl lying on a cut with bleeding injuries. He asked her who were her assailants, but she could not peak. There were also present the accused Darpan and some villagers of whom four have been called as witnesses; that is to say, Barjoo Poddar (P.W 6), Muhammad Hakeem Mirza (P.W 7), and the before mentioned chaukidar Raghoo Mirdhan (P.W 24). In addition to these, other Potdars (men) are said to have been present and also two persons Sakroo Mahto and Loku Baut. The accused Darpan Potdarin was questioned by the Sub-Inspector and her statement was taken down and lodged as a first information. The first information however does not embody the complete statement of Darpan, for as will be shown later, she made additional statements to the Sub-Inspector after the first information report. She stated that she was the wife of Bhagirath Poddar (P.W 9), that she had come with certain villagers (whose names I have mentioned) and her daughter who was lying wounded on the cut. She said that on the previous night she and her daughter after taking their meal were Bleeping on separate cuts on the southern verandah of their house, that her youngest son Jiblal (P.W 4) aged ten years was sleeping with her and that the daughter Titwa was sleeping with her own child aged two years; that after the moon had Bet, she (the informant) went into the courtyard for natural purpose and then heard her daughter crying out ‘mother, mother, I am killed, I am killed’. She ran to the verandah and saw two men running away and passing out through the western wall of the compound in front; that she lighted a lamp and found that her daughter was set with blood, with her neck and cheek out, and that she could not speak. That she and her son raised a cry and the villagers including the chaukidar came up and saw what had happened. That her daughter's son Ganesh Poddar (not called as a witness) had gone away on the morning of the day before to celebrate the sun god festival at village Sirsa (which is 7 or 8 miles from this village) where her eldest son lives and works as a goldsmith. That the informant's husband had also gone to Sirsa at noon of the day before. That she suspected that someone from the village had committed the crime but she could not recognize the men whom she saw running away. The Sub-Inspector noted also that the chaukidar had found a goldsmith's iron anvil saying that this was found near the daughter's cut. It bore no blood stains, but the Sub-Inspector took it and kept it.

3. The Sub-Inspector in cross-examination stated that he had questioned Darpan and asked her if she had any quarrel with anybody. She replied that she had a quarrel with Moti Poddar (P.W 8) who had called her a witch on the Wednesday preceding the day of occurrence, and she told him further that Moti's wife had become insane and it was in that connexion that Moti had called Darpan a witch. She also stated to the Sub-Inspector that her husband Bhagirath had illicit connexion with the wife of Dhano Poddar and that Titwa's character was bad. The Sub-Inspector prepared an injury report of the daughter Titwa and sent her to the Sarath hospital. She had about a dozen injuries consisting of incised wounds on the neck and face which would seem from their nature to have been indicted with a knife. There was also a simple fracture of the left clavicle. The Sub-Inspector also examined the person of Darpan, the first informant. In his evidence he says that he conducted this examination at the thana at about 9 A.M, that is to say, after the taking of what has been called a dying declaration of the injured girl at the hospital, but we are not sure that the Sub-Inspector is correct in stating that he made the examination of Darpan after the taking of such dying declaration; he may have done it after taking the first information report. He was not cross-examined on this point as he should have been, but at whatever time she made the declaration he found the following state of affairs. There were marks of dried blood at the corner of each eye and there were also blood-stains on the sari, but the sari was being worn inside out and the stains were on the side which she was then wearing next to her body. They consist of drops of blood in 13 or 14 places and looked as though they had been spurted on to the garment. There were also stains on the upper wrapper which had a smeared appearance. Darpan on being questioned by the Sub-Inspector explained that these stains had been caused when she went to her daughter's cut and also when she held the girl's child in her arms. The stains are not inconsistent with this statement.

4. It is now necessary to refer to the inter, view between the Sub-Inspector and the girl Titwa at the Sarath hospital where he was summoned by the doctor with the information that the girl was in a serious condition. He found her unable to speak and recorded his own questions in the vernacular, but he has stated that the replies were by signs only. He does not describe the signs more particularly than; by stating that they were by waving of the hands and movement of the head, and there is the gravest doubt whether in the circumstances the localled dying declaration can be admitted into evidence. It was not his function to record merely his interpretation of the signs, but he should have recorded the precise nature of the signs, leaving the interpretation to the tribunal: see 41 CWN 513.1 Even if the interpretation placed by the Sub-Inspector on the signs is correct, it would deem that the meaning of the dying girl was that she had in fact been assaulted by the person Dhano Poddar whom we have mentioned as one of the party who came to the thana with Darpan and her daughter, as well as by Darpan. This interpretation also seems to have been placed upon the signs by the witness Muhammad Hakeem Mirza (P.W 11). Dhano was arrested and put on trial with Darpan. He was however acquitted, the Judge being of opinion that the dying girl did not properly understand the nature of the questions put to her in respect of this man. The supposed dying declaration may now be examined in detail. It is printed at page 42 of the paper-book in the form of questions and answers. The first question put by the Sub-Inspector was “who have assaulted you the Mians or the Mirzas or the Poddars?” The question in this form is highly objectionable and it is difficult to understand why the Sub. Inspector was confining the assailants to these three categories. The answer recorded is “by making signs with her hand she expressed that the Poddars had assaulted her”. The Sub-Inspector has not given a description of the signs from which he could infer that the woman intended to refer to the Poddars. The second question which was put is as follows: “Which Poddar did assault you” and then the name of 13 Poddars are mentioned including Dhano Poddar. The answer recorded is as follows: “By making signs with her hand and by a movement of her head she expressed that Dhano Poddar had assaulted her”. Here again the Sub-Inspector has not given a description of the signs which the injured person is stated to have made with her hand nor is it clear how the movement of her head was interpreted by the Sub-Inspector to refer to Dhano Poddar. The next question put was:

Why had he assaulted you to obtain money or oath of enmity or with the object of outraging your modest?

5. The answer recorded is “by making signs with her hand she expressed that he assaulted her with the object of outraging her modesty”. Again there is a complete absence of any description of the sign which was interpreted by the Sub-Inspector to mean an intended outrage of modesty. The fourth question put was “How could you recognize Dhano Poddar? Was a dibia burning or was it dark”? The answer recorded is “by making signs with her hand and by moving her head she expressed that dibia was burning”. It is difficult for us to understand how by making signs with her hand and by moving her head the woman could have expressed that the dibia was burning. It was necessary for the Sub-Inspector to have given a description of the signs and of the movements of the head which led him to believe that the woman intended to say that the dibia was burning. The fifth question is recorded in this manner “showed Dhano Poddar to her and asked, who had assaulted you? Also showed her the other Poddars of the village”. The answer is recorded as follows:

Seeing Dhano Poddar, she expressed by moving her hand and head that the very same Dhano Poddar had assaulted her and seeing the others she expressed by a movement of her hand and head that they had not assaulted her.

6. It is to be seen that here again the Sub-Inspector has not recorded a description of the movements which led him to infer that the woman was definite in identifying Dhano as the person who had assaulted her. It will also be noticed that in none of these five questions and answers the woman is at all speaking of or indicating the mother as her assailant. The last question put by the Sub. Inspector is very important and is this: “Who else did as fault you”? The answer is recorded as follows; “Seeing her mother she expressed by making signs with her hand that she also had assaulted her”. It is difficult for us to understand from this very brief record in which there is complete absence of any description of the Signs stated to have been made by the deceased that the Sub-Inspector was able to infer that the mother had also assaulted the daughter. In our opinion the dying declaration so re corded is very unsatisfactory and is indeed inadmissible in law. But if it were ad missile, it points far more clearly to the guilt of Dhano than to the complicity of Darpan. Dhano however has been co-quitted by the Sessions Judge. The Sub. Inspector states that until he had recorded the supposed dying declaration, he had not examined anyone else of the party save Darpan. He then examined Barjoo. Poddar and the other men who had accompanied the party and later Bhagirath Poddar (P.W 9), husband of the accused and father of the deceased girl Titwa, who states that on the Thursday (the 18th) he had set out from the village leaving Darpan, Titwa and her child and his own son Jiblal in the house and had gone to Sarsa 7 or 8 miles away and that he returned home on the Friday (the 19th) in the morning. Then on his way back he had met Rafiuddin Mirza (P.W 5) and had a talk with him and that on reaching home he had found Jiblal (his son) with Titwa's baby and that Jiblal began crying and told him “didi ka mar dehis mayia” and that Titwa had been taken to the thana. He stated further in evidence that seven days before the occurrence he had lost a knife which he had never found again and he further stated that he mentioned this to the police on the first occasion. The Sub-Inspector however says that this is not true and that Bhagirath and nothing about the knife either on that occasion or on the occasion of a sub-sequent questioning on the 21st. This point is of importance because no trace of a weapon has been found and indeed no search seems to have been made for one. At 8 A.M the Sub-Inspector received in formation from the dispensary that Titwa was dead. He went to the hospital and prepared an inquest report and sent off the corpse to Deoghar for post mortem examination. He then arrested Dhano and Dar pan and submitted a charge sheet against them and left for the village where he arrived at midday. He first examined the house of Bhagirath Poddar and found blood-stains on walls and the verandah and prepared a sketch, and the first per son whom he examined was the boy Jiblal.

7. The boy when examined by the Sessions Judge gave a very detailed statement beginning with the fact that his father had left the house at about noon of the same day for Sarsa and that his elder brothers had also left the house. He stated that his mother and Titwa usually slept in the kitchen and that on that same night his mother had suggested to Titwa that they should Bleep on the verandah. Therefore he slept with his mother on a cut on the verandah and Titwa slept with her child on the same verandah on another cot. There was no light on the verandah then. The cut upon which Titwa slept was on the verandah and the cut on which Jiblal and his mother slept was a few feet away at right angles to the first cot. That he woke up at about 1 or 2 A.M hearing the cry of Titwa “Asire Baboo hamre jan, marlak”. His mother was not on the cut with him. He covered himself up with his cloth and then he heard a sound of “Hun Hun” which he recognized as the mother's voice. He says she was hitting someone with force, and then he heard his sister's cry “Hai re bap Hai re bap” and that this went on “for a long time”. He uncovered his face and called his mother several times and saw her go from the verandah to the Court yard. On being questioned as to how he recognized his mother, he said, by the moonlight. He related that his mother said that the thief had wounded his sister and she advised him to come away. He asked his mother to bring a light which she brought from the kitchen and he carried it near his sister his mother remaining in the kitchen. By the aid of the light, he saw Titwa and found her covered with blood, and returned to the court-yard. He wished to raise an alarm, but his mother stopped him saying that if he raised an alarm the thieves would beat him, but he continued to shout. Nobody came however and he went to the door of the house adjoining the road and shouted from there, whereupon Barjoo Poddar, Moti Poddar, Bhola Poddar and others arrived. Barjoo and Moti left the place to call the village chaukidar whereupon the chaukidar, Rafiuddin Mirza and Hakeem Mirza came up. Rafiuddin asked Titwa who had injured her and she replied in a faltering tone that she had been injured by her mother. Rafiuddin asked the mother to give her water, but Titwa turned her face away and waved her hand thereby declining the offer. Then Barjoo Poddar offered her water which Titwa drank. The accused Dhano came last of all when called by Hakeem Mirza. Rafiaddin sent Titwa away on the same khatia to the hospital. The witness however did not go. The next morning his father returned home and the witness told him that his mother had assaulted his sister. He further stated that there were quarrels between the mother and Titwa and the last quarrel took place four or five days before the occurrence and that Titwa only uttered the words “Hai Baboo jan mar lek”.

8. Now the witness does not state that he related what he had seen to any of the persons present, and there is no indication that he mentioned what he had seen to anybody until he made a statement to his father much later in the day which followed the night in question. It is truly astonishing that the advocate for the defence whose crass-examination of all the witnesses was of a most incompetent character did not ask any questions with a view to finding out when the boy first told his story. That some kind of story by Jiblal reached the police indirectly through Bhagirath Poddar (his father) who came to the station is true; but there was no attempt whatever to obtain either from Bhagirath Poddar or from the police what story Jiblal had related, save the statement which we have quoted earlier “Didi ke mardihis maiya” (my mother struck my sister). It is remarkable that the Bub-Inspector appears to have made no search whatever for the weapon with which the crime was committed. According to the evidence of Jiblal and of all the other witnesses the mother did not leave the premises from the moment of the commission of the crime until long after the neighbours had arrived and that she was throughout within sight of everybody and it is difficult to see how she could have disposed of a knife or any other weapon. Moreover if the injuries were inflicted with a knife as is indicated by their nature, it is extremely probable that her hands would have become covered with blood but there is not the slightest suggestion of any such state of affairs nor had she any opportunity of cleansing her hands unobserved. Why this point was not made by the defence is difficult to understand. It is an extremely obvious one and must again be attributed to the incompetence of the defence. Now the evidence of what happened on the arrival of the neighbours was offered by the following witnesses. Rafiuddin Mirza is the Pradhan of the village. He states that he was roused as by the chaukidar Raghoo Mirdha and other persons with the statement that there had been a murder in the house of Bhagirath Poddar about three or four rasis from his own house. He went there and found ten or eleven persons at Bhagirath's house, some on the verandah and some in the angan, and he saw Jiblal on the verandah. He made no enquiries either from Jiblal or Dar pan. He found Titwa's body covered with blood and marks of blood on the ground and on the walls. He did not go very close to the cut of Titwa. He asked Titwa who assaulted her. She replied in a low tone “Kaka hamre maiya marlek” (Uncle, my mother assaulted me). She then made signs that she wanted to drink water and she also asked in a very low tone for water. Her mother brought some but Titwa slightly turned her face away. The witness then asked Barjoo to offer her water, whereupon Titwa drank it. He then asked her again “Well Nonia, who has assaulted you”, whereupon she gave the same reply as before. He then sent Titwa to the Sarath thana with her relations. At that time it was still dark and Titwa was conscious. If the evidence of Rafiuddin be accepted, it is astonishing that he did not take Darpan into custody and send her as a prisoner to the thana, and it was even more astonishing that the persons Barjoo Poddar and Moti Poddar, who claim also to have heard the daughter accuse her mother, did not themselves inform the Sub-Inspector immediately on their arrival at the thana but allowed Dar pan to lodge the first information. The learned Judge passes somewhat lightly over this curious circumstance with the observation that this is the sort of thing which goes on in the district and is not very surprising. Barjoo denies that there was any consultation as to who should lodge the information either at the place of occurrence or on the road to the thana. There is some discrepancy between the account given by Barjoo and that given by Rafiuddin as to what happened at the place of occurrence. Barjoo heard Rafiaddin ask her as to who had assaulted Titwa and heard her voice in reply but could not follow her voice; after drinking the water he heard her say “maiya marlek”. There is no doubt from the evidence that Darpan had been for at least a year past accusing her husband of carrying on an intrigue with his own daughter Titwa. This accusation may or may not be true, but Bhagirath himself stated that Darpan had so accused him at the first interview with the Sub-Inspector at the thana and there can be no doubt that Darpan was much troubled by this belief, whether true or not. It is also clear that the management of Bhagirath's household had been taken by him out of the bands of Darpan and entrusted to his daughter. There are also indications that this had worked upon the mind of Darpan and he was in a constant state of resentment against her daughter.

9. Now summing up the evidence against Darpan, it would seem to consist of the following facts: firstly, motive to which I have just referred; secondly, the blood stains on her clothing and face, but this can be accounted for by her cont not with the injured girl and the child; thirdly, the supposed dying declaration taken by the Sub-Inspector at the hospital, but we are of opinion that this is in the circumstances inadmissible; fourthly, the evidence as to the statements made by Titwa to the neighbours, but this contacts with the supposed dying declaration in the matter of the accusation against Dhano. Moreover, the refusal of the water at the hands of Darpan, even if true, might be explained on many other grounds. Further more, it is astonishing that the Pradhan and the neighbours should not have arrested Darpan and sent her in custody to the thana and that the chaukidar should not himself have lodged the first information but have allowed Darpan to do this. Lastly, there is the evidence of the boy Jiblal; and if the other points which I have mentioned are rejected, it would be quite unsafe to convict on the evidence of a child ten years old, more especially as he does not seem to have told anyone of his experience until the day time when he said something to his father. The evidence of children unless immediately available and unless received before, any possibility of coaching is eliminated; is notoriously dangerous. In favour of the accused is the fact that no weapon has been found and it is difficult to see how she could have any opportunity of concealing the weapon in any place where it would not have been immediately found even on the most perfunctory search; secondly, the fact that her hands and arms showed no blood stains and there was no possibility of her having removed such blood stains. We must further remember that a quarrelsome old woman with a very pronounced and scandalous grievance is a highly unpopular member of a village community and the more so if the grievance is unfounded. We cannot exclude from consideration the possibility that the villagers may have combined to screen the real murderer at the expense of this woman. For these reasons we are of opinion that it would be unsafe to maintain the conviction, and we direct that the reference be discharged, the appeal allowed and the appellant be set at liberty.

10. We desire to make some remarks about the defence of prisoners who are too poor to instruct lawyers on their own account. Those whose duty it is to select lawyers to defend at the expenses of the Crown should not treat the selection as a matter of patronage for the benefit of the lawyer so appointed. The selection should be; made from among young men of marked ability. We have frequently observed that the persons actually appointed do their work very badly and conspicuous opportunities for cross-examination and obvious arguments are entirely ignored. In such circumstances also the trial Judge should remember that he has the duty not only to prosecution but to the defence. He has the police diary in front of him and should use his greater experience to cross-examine the witnesses when he sees that the defence lawyer is incompetent. He should not do this unnecessarily but only when it is desirable in the interest of justice.

V.B/R.K

11. Appeal allowed.