- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Amir v. Sheopujan
Concise Analytical Summary of the Opinion (Das, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
These are two second appeals by defendants nos. 1 to 5 (the appellants) arising from two suits for declaration of title and recovery of possession. Tulsi and Panchayan were two brothers. Defendants nos. 1–5 were sons of Tulsi (the appellants). Defendant no. 6, Musammat Batasia, was the widow of Panchayan; defendant no. 7, Musammat Bipti, was Panchayan's minor daughter. The plaintiffs in the two suits alleged that Tulsi and Panchayan lived separate in mess and business, and that after Panchayan's death Musammat Batasia came into possession of the properties of Panchayan and executed two rehan (mortgage) bonds in favour of the plaintiffs: one for Rs. 999 dated 27 February 1939, and another for Rs. 450 dated 28 February 1939.
After execution of the rehan bonds, a dispute arose between defendants 1–5 on one side and defendants 6–7 on the other, with defendants 1–5 resisting the plaintiffs' attempts to cultivate the mortgaged lands. The plaintiffs sued for (a) declaration of title and delivery of possession and mesne profits; and alternatively (b) realization of the mortgage debt (principal and interest) by sale of the rehan property.
The trial court found that Tulsi and Panchayan were joint (i.e., the plaintiffs failed to prove separation), held that Musammat Batasia had no transferable interest, but nevertheless gave the plaintiffs a simple money decree against Musammat Batasia (defendant no. 6). The plaintiffs appealed. The Additional Subordinate Judge (the lower appellate court) found that, although there had been no formal partition by metes and bounds, Tulsi and Panchayan lived separate and there was a cessor of commensality; on that basis the court below granted the plaintiffs a decree for recovery of possession of the lands covered by the rehan deeds, jointly with defendants 1–5. Defendants 1–5 then brought these second appeals against that decree.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the findings of the lower appellate court that Tulsi and Panchayan were separate (i.e., there had been a cessor of commensality) are supported by the evidence and are open to review in a second appeal.
- Whether a plaintiff who has been given one of alternative reliefs at trial (a simple money decree) can prosecute an appeal seeking the other alternative relief claimed in the plaint (possession or mortgage-sale), particularly in light of prior authorities relied upon by the appellants.
- Whether the plaintiffs were entitled to a decree for possession (and whether such possession could be exclusive as to particular plots) where the plaintiffs had sought possession of specific plots but the property was not partitioned by metes and bounds.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments (Defendants nos. 1–5)
- The court of appeal wrongly drew an inference of separation of Tulsi and Panchayan from the evidence—particularly that reliance on Chaukidari Assessment Registers (Exts. 3) for 1926–27 is incorrect because Tulsi was dead before 1926, so these entries are not probative of separate possession.
- The plaintiffs, having obtained one of the alternative reliefs (a simple money decree against Musammat Batasia) at trial, should not be entitled to press an appeal for the other alternative relief (possession) — reliance was placed on Musammat Panchani v. Musammat Rikhia and Reajuddin Patwari v. Syed Abdul Jobbar.
- The plaintiffs were not entitled to a decree for possession (or for joint possession that would effectively grant exclusive possession of particular plots), because they had asked for possession of specific plots and a co-sharer cannot transfer exclusive title to particular portions of undivided property without the consent of all co-owners — reliance was placed on the Allahabad decision (Jamna v. Jhalli).
Plaintiff-Respondents' Position (as stated in the opinion)
- The plaintiffs asserted that Tulsi and Panchayan were separate in mess and business; after Panchayan's death Musammat Batasia came into possession of his properties and, as guardian, executed two rehan bonds in favour of the plaintiffs.
- On that basis the plaintiffs sought recovery of possession (or alternatively realization of the mortgage debt by sale of the rehan property) and appealed the trial court's finding which had denied possession and only given a money decree against defendant no. 6.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Musammat Panchani v. Musammat Rikhia (unreported; Agarwala, J., 14 Jan 1941) | Applied for the proposition that where a plaintiff has expressed satisfaction with an alternative relief and has been granted that relief, he cannot later claim the other alternative relief on appeal. | The court noted reliance on the decision by the appellants but distinguished it: in the present cases the plaintiffs had not expressed themselves as being satisfied with a simple money decree (the relief actually given by the trial court) and therefore the rule in that case did not apply here. |
| Reajuddin Patwari v. Syed Abdul Jobbar | Similar proposition as above regarding a plaintiff who obtained an alternative relief being precluded from seeking the other relief on appeal (cited in Musammat Panchani). | The court treated the case as fact-specific and dependent on section 157 Bengal Tenancy Act in that instance; it declined to apply the principle by analogy to the present facts because the plaintiffs here had not succeeded in obtaining one of the two alternative reliefs claimed in the plaint. |
| Jamna…Plaintiff v. Jhalli…Defendant (Allahabad) | Establishes that co-sharers cannot, without the consent of all co-owners, transfer exclusive title to particular portions of undivided joint property; vendors cannot earmark specific plots as exclusive portions where they only hold an undivided share. | The court observed that the Allahabad case involved earmarking of exclusive plots by vendors; it distinguished that case from the present facts, noted that the rehan bonds were not printed in the record, and relied on the Subordinate Judge's explicit direction that the plaintiffs would get only joint possession and not exclusive possession of particular parts. Thus the principle did not defeat the decree for joint possession as framed by the court below. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined the evidence relied upon by the lower appellate court and the trial court. On the central factual issue of separation between Tulsi and Panchayan the court noted:
- The Chaukidari Assessment Registers for 1926–27 (Exts. 3), showing separate assessments, were held to be genuine by both courts below (they bore the seal of the Subdivisional Magistrate and the signatures of the punches). Although appellants argued the registers could be inaccurate because Tulsi died before 1926, the mere appearance of Tulsi's name in the registers after his death did not, in the court's view, prove the registers false.
- The court of appeal did not rely solely on the assessment registers; it considered other documentary evidence (rent receipts showing payment by Musammat Batasia, canal parchas showing payment of water rate by her) and a contemporaneous mortgage (Ext. 2: a mortgage bond executed by Musammat Batasia on 5 October 1936 in favour of Chandrika Mahton), which indicated that, before any dispute, Musammat Batasia had been dealing with the property as if she had inherited it after her husband's death.
- Oral testimony and surrounding circumstances (including the fact the lands had not been subdivided on the spot) were also considered. On the whole record the court below concluded there had been a cessor of commensality and separate possession (tenants in common).
- The present court treated that conclusion as essentially a finding of fact and held it could not be reopened in a second appeal absent error of law. The court found no such error: it was unable to accept the appellants' contention that the finding of the lower appellate court was vitiated by law.
On the second contention (whether plaintiffs could appeal after receiving an alternative relief at trial), the court:
- Considered the authorities relied on by appellants (Musammat Panchani and Reajuddin Patwari) and explained the factual distinction: in those cases the plaintiffs had expressed themselves as content with the alternative relief which had been granted, whereas in the present matter the plaintiffs had not stated in the plaint that they would be satisfied with a simple money decree against Musammat Batasia.
- Concluded that because the trial court had only given a simple money decree (which was not one of the two alternative reliefs the plaintiffs had sought against the co-sharers in the manner claimed), the plaintiffs had not in fact succeeded in getting one of the two alternative reliefs they had claimed, and therefore their appeal was not barred by the rule applied in the cited authorities. The court also remarked that it doubted whether a universal rule can be laid down that an alternative relief granted at trial necessarily bars an appeal for the other relief, especially where statutory contexts (e.g., section 157 of the Bengal Tenancy Act) shaped the earlier decisions.
On the third contention (exclusive possession of particular plots), the court:
- Noted the principle from the Allahabad case that a co-sharer cannot transfer exclusive title to specific undivided portions without consent of other co-sharers. But the court observed that the rehan bonds were not on record in printed form in the reported file and that the Subordinate Judge had expressly stated that in the absence of a partition by metes and bounds the plaintiffs were not entitled to eject defendants 1–5 and obtain exclusive possession of particular plot(s).
- Therefore the decree as framed (declaring the plaintiffs' rights as rehandar and awarding joint possession with the defendants 1–5, with the possibility of a partition suit later if exclusive possession were sought) was appropriate in form and substance.
Holding and Implications
APPEALS DISMISSED.
Direct holding and immediate consequences:
- The second appeals by defendants nos. 1–5 are dismissed with costs in favour of the plaintiff-respondents.
- The court affirmed the lower appellate court's factual finding that Tulsi and Panchayan were separate (a cessor of commensality occurred) and upheld the decree that declared the plaintiff-respondents' right as rehandar and awarded them joint possession with defendants 1–5.
- The court made clear that the plaintiffs will not receive exclusive possession of specific parts of the property under the present adjudication; any party seeking exclusive possession of particular parts must bring a properly constituted partition suit later.
- The trial court's simple money decree against Musammat Batasia did not preclude the plaintiffs from maintaining an appeal for the possession relief they sought in these suits, because the factual and pleading circumstances differed from the earlier authorities relied upon by the appellants.
- The court ordered the appellants to pay costs to the plaintiff-respondents and fixed one hearing fee for both appeals.
The opinion does not purport to lay down any broad new principle of law; the court treated the precedent relied upon by appellants as fact-specific and distinguished it on the facts of this case.
Judge(s): Das, J.; Manohar Lall, J. (concurring). Result: Appeals dismissed. (All content in this summary is taken directly from the provided opinion and no outside facts have been introduced.)
Das, J.:— These two second appeals by some of the defendants arise out of two suits for declaration of title and recovery of possession in the following circumstances. Tulsi and Panchyan were two brothers. Defendants nos. 1 to 5 were the sons of Tulsi, and are appellants in the two appeals. Defendant no. 6, Musammat Batasia, was the widow of Panchayan, and Musammat Bipti (defendant no. 7) was the minor daughter of Panchayan. The plaintiff-respondents—there are different plaintiffs in the two suits—claimed that Tulsi and Panchayan were separate in mess and business, and after the death of Panchayan, his widow, Musammat Batasia, came in possession of the properties left by him. She, for self and as guardian of Musammat Bipti, executed two rehan bonds in favour of the plaintiffs of the two suits—one of the documents being for a sum of Rs. 999, executed on the 27th of February, 1939, and the other for a sum of Rs. 450, executed on the 28th of February, 1939. Subsequent to the execution of the aforesaid mortgage bonds, there was a dispute between defendants 1 to 5 on one side and defendants nos. 6 and 7 on the other with the result that the plaintiffs, who wanted to cultivate the lands mortgaged to them, were resisted by defendants nos. 1 to 5. The plaintiffs, therefore, brought the two suits with regard to the lands mortgaged to them and claimed the following reliefs:—
“1. On an adjudication of the plaintiffs' title and want of title in defendants nos. 1 to 5, possession over the rehan property may be caused to be delivered to the plaintiffs and Rs. 100 may be awarded against defendants nos. 1 to 5 by way of mesne profits, and orders for the recovery of future mesne profits may be passed.
“2. If, for any reason, possession cannot be delivered to the plaintiffs, then Rs. 999 principal and Rs. 81 on account of interest, total Rs. 1,080, may be caused to be realised by the sale of the rahan property.”
I have quoted the reliefs in extenso from the plaint in one of the two suits, because one of the points, raised in appeal, depends on the question as to whether the plaintiff-respondents could prefer an appeal to the lower appellate court after having been given one of the reliefs claimed by them.
The defence of the appellants in the two suits brought against them raised several points with which we are not at present concerned. The main defence was that Panchayan was all along joint with Tulsi, and defendants nos. 1 to 5 after Tulsi's death. Panchayan continued to be the karta of the family, and after his death, defendants nos. 1 to 5 got the entire properties by the rule of survivorship. The appellants also alleged that Musammat Batasia was not the lawfully wedded wife of Panchayan.
The trial court found in favour of the appellants on the question as to whether Panchayan and Tulsi were joint or separate. He found that the plaintiffs had failed to prove that the two brothers were separate. On this finding, he held that Musammat Batasia, widow of Panchayan; had no interest of her own in the property of Panchayan, which she could transfer to the plaintiff-respondents. The trial court, however, gave a simple money decree in favour of the plaintiffs against Musammat Batasia (defendant no. 6). The plaintiffs appealed, and the court of appeal below found in favour of the plaintiffs on the question of separation of the two brothers Tulsi and Panchayan. The learned Additional Subordinate Judge, who heard the two appeals, came, to the finding that even though there was no partition by metes and bounds, Tulsi and Panchayan lived separate, and there was a complete cessor of commensality between them. On this finding, he gave the plaintiffs a decree for recovery of possession of the lands covered by the rehan deeds, jointly with defendants nos. 1 to 5. It is against this decree in the two suits that the two appeals have been preferred by the defendants nos. 1 to 5.
Learned Counsel for the appellants has raised three main contentions. Firstly, he has contended that the court of appeal below has drawn a wrong inference of separation of the two brothers from the evidence in the record. The court of appeal below has relied on the entries in the Chaukidari Assessment Registers of the years 1926 and 1927 (Exts. 3 series). These entries show that Tulsi and Panchayan were separately assessed to chaukidari tax. Learned Counsel for the appellants has contended before us that these entries cannot be correct, inasmuch as Tulsi was dead before 1926. The mere fact that the name of Tulsi appears in the Chaukidari Assessment Registers, even after his death, does not necessarily prove that the Assessment Registers were not genuine. As a matter of fact, both the courts below have come to the finding that these Assessment Registers were genuine, and bore the seal of the subdivisional Magistrate and the signatures of the punches. It is also contended that the entries in these Assessment Registers do not by themselves give rise to the inference that Tulsi and Panchayan were separate. The court of appeal below has not, however, based its finding merely on the entries on these Assessment Registers. It has taken into consideration other evidence, such as, some of the rent receipts, Which show payment of rent by Musammat Batasia, canal parchas showing payment of water rate by Musammat Batasia and also the very significant fact that on the 5th of October, 1936, Musammat Batasia had executed a mortgage bond in favour of one Chandrika Mahton (Ext. 2). This last document shows that before any dispute broke out between the parties, Musammat Batasia had been dealing with the property separately, as though she had inherited the property after her husband's death. The court of appeal below has also considered the oral evidence in the case, and has taken into consideration the circumstance in favour of the appellants to the effect that the lands, which originally belonged to the family, had not been subdivided on the spot. On a consideration of the entire evidence in the record, the court of appeal below has come to the finding that though there was no partition by metes and bounds the evidence and circumstances of the case satisfactorily establish the fact that Tulsi and Panchayan were separate, and there was a complete cessor of commensality between them they were in separate possession as tenants in common. This finding arrived at by the court of appeal below is essentially a finding of fact, and cannot be re-opened in second appeal. I am unable to accede to the contention raised on behalf of the appellants that this finding is vitiated by any error of law.
Secondly, it has been contended on behalf of the appellants that the plaintiff-respondents were given a decree by the trial court which allowed them one of the reliefs claimed by them: having got one of the alternative reliefs which they had claimed, it was not open to them to come up in appeal. Reliance has, been placed on an unreported decision of this Court in Musammat Panchani v. Musammat Rikhia, decided by Agarwala, J., on the 14th January, 1941. That was a case in which the appellant sued for recovery of possession of a house which was mortgaged to him by defendant no. 3. In the alternative, the plaintiff of the suit asked for recovery of the mortgage debt of Rs. 200 against the mortgagor, defendant no. 3. There were two other defendants, defendants nos. 1 and 2, who were in possession of the house and against whom a suit, brought by defendant no. 3, had been dismissed prior to the institution of the suit, which gave rise to the appeal. The plaintiff was given a decree against defendant no. 3, and applying the principle laid down in the case of Reajuddin Patwari v. Syed Abdul Jobbar, it was held that the plaintiff could not succeed, inasmuch as he had in his plaint expressed himself to be satisfied either with the decree for recovery of possession against defendants nos. 1 and 2, or a decree for the sum advanced against defendant no. 3. The case of Reajuddin Patwari v. Syed Abdul Jobbar Was also of a similar nature; In that case, a suit was brought, by the plaintiff-respondent for ejectment of defendants nos. 1 and 2 from certain lands. The plaintiff, in the alternative, made a prayer for assessment of a fair and equitable rent under section 157 of the Bengal Tenancy Act. The court of first instance declared the plaintiff's ijara right to the eight annas share of the village and declared that the plaintiff would get rent of the lands in respect of his share, holding that the defendants were tenants with regard to these lands. There were appeals by both parties against the decision of the trial court. The plaintiff appealed against the order fixing a fair and equitable rent under section 157 of the Bengal Tenancy Act, and the defendants appealed against the decree declaring the right of the plaintiff to the property in suit. The learned Judge in the court below dismissed both the appeals. There was a second appeal by the defendants and a cross-appeal by the plaintiff. In the cross appeal the plaintiff claimed that he was entitled to khas possession on the ground that the defendants were trespassers. In these circumstances, it was observed as follows:—
“But he (the plaintiff) made an alternative claim under section 157 of the Bengal Tenancy Act for assessment of a fair and equitable rent and the learned Judge in the Court below: has given him relief under that section. It seems to me that he is not entitled to say that he does not want that alternative relief which has been granted to him, and that he desires to have the other relief which he claimed by way of ejectment. In effect, the plaintiff expressed that he would be satisfied with either of the two reliefs which he made in his plaint and he succeeded in getting one and, therefore, he has no real cause for complaint.”
The facts, as stated above, of the aforesaid two decisions are different from the facts of the cases before us. I have already quoted in extenso, at the beginning of this judgment, the reliefs which the plaintiff-respondents claimed. The plaintiff-respondents claimed for recovery of possession or in the alternative, a mortgage decree by sale of the rehan property. They did not state in the plaint that they would be satisfied with a simple money decree against Musammat Batasia (defendant no. 6). The trial court gave a simple money decree against Musammat Batasia in favour of the plaintiff-respondents. It cannot, therefore, be said that the plaintiff-respondents had succeeded in getting one of the two reliefs which they had claimed. In view of this distinction, it is unnecessary to consider the correctness or otherwise of the two decisions referred to above. I doubt, however, if a general rule can be laid down that in all cases where an alternative relief has been granted, the plaintiff has no right of appeal for getting a decree for the other relief which he had claimed in the plaint. section 157 of the Bengal Tenancy Act refers to alternative reliefs in a suit for the ejectment of a trespasser: it is open to the landlord to recognise a trespasser and accept him as a tenant. If he expresses himself to be satisfied with accepting rent from a trespasser, it is obvious that he cannot seek to eject him. The decision in Reajuddin Patwari v. Syed Abdul Jobbar has reference to the facts of that case and the particular terms of section 157 of the Bengal Tenancy Act. I am unable to apply the principle of that case by analogy to the facts of the present case, which, as I have shown above, are different.
Thirdly, it has been contended that the plaintiff-respondents were not entitled to a decree for joint possession, inasmuch as they had asked for possession of specific plots and no co-sharer is entitled to say that he has an exclusive right to any particular portion of the joint property and to confer an exclusive right on a third party by alienation without the consent of all the co-owners. Reliance has been placed on the case of Jamna…Plaintiff v. Jhalli…Defendant .. The Allahabad case, however, was one in which the plaintiff claimed exclusive possession of certain plots, though he had purchased by means of a sale deed the three-fourths share in the khata in question. It was pointed out in that case that his vendors were co-sharers to the extent of three-fourths in the khata which was admittedly joint zamindari property; it was then held that without the consent of the remaining co-owner they could not transfer an exclusive title to particular portions of the property as yet undivided. It was further pointed out that the vendors did not effect to transfer their undivided share or a portion of it, and what they did was to earmark certain plots and transfer them as if they were the exclusive owners of them. The rehan bonds, on the basis of which the plaintiff-respondents sued in the two suits in question, have not been printed. The learned Subordinate Judge has, however, made it perfectly clear that no exclusive possession can be given to the plaintiff-respondents of any particular portion of the property belonging to the co-sharers. The learned Subordinate Judge has expressed himself as follows:—
“As I have already pointed out, in the absence of proof of partition by metes and bounds, the plaintiffs are not entitled to recovery of possession by ejecting the defendants 1 to 5 from the suit lands. So far as these suits are concerned, the plaintiffs would be entitled to decrees for joint possession with the defendants 1 to 5. It may be open to the plaintiffs or to defendant no. 6 to seek partition by a properly constituted suit hereafter.”
I do not see any particular objection to the form of the decree passed by the court of appeal below. Obviously, the plaintiff-respondents will not get exclusive possession of any particular part of the property in dispute. Their right as rehandar has been declared, and they have been given joint possession with the other co-sharers. If any of the parties want exclusive possession of a particular part, a properly constituted partition suit would be necessary, as has been observed by the learned Subordinate Judge.
The result, therefore, is that the contentions raised on behalf of the appellants fail, and the appeals are dismissed with costs in favour of the plaintiff-respondents. There will be one hearing fee for both appeals.
Manohar Lall, J.:— I agree. On the facts found it is unnecessary to consider the correctness of the view expressed in some cases that the plaintiff cannot in appeal be granted the second alternative relief claimed by him.
Appeals dismissed.
K.D
Alert