Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Nafar Chandra Sardar And Ors. Judgment-Debtors, v. Kalipada Das Decree-Holder, Opposite Party

Calcutta High Court
Jan 16, 1940
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of the Judgment — Civil Revision Cases Nos. 963, 1506 & 1650 of 1939

Factual and Procedural Background

The Petitioners applied under section 8 of the Bengal Agricultural Debtors Act to the Debt Settlement Board, Howrah, for settlement of debts. The Board dismissed the first application (filed 10 November 1937) on 19 January 1938 on the ground that the Petitioners were not "agriculturists." An appeal to the Appellate Officer was dismissed on 25 May 1938 and a review under section 44(b) was also rejected.

Petitioners Nos. 1–4 filed a second application under section 8 before the Special Debt Settlement Board, Howrah; that application was dismissed on 27 November 1938 as a fresh application being not maintainable. A review of that order was allowed by the Board on 19 March 1939 (the creditor was absent at the hearing) and hearing on merits was fixed for 16 April 1939.

On 1 May 1939 notices under section 34 of the Bengal Agricultural Debtors Act were issued staying execution proceedings in the Munsif Court at Howrah in two matters (one by Petitioners Nos.1–4 and one by Petitioner No.5). The Munsif stayed execution accordingly. The decree-holder applied to vacate the stay. The Board on 21 May 1939 decided Petitioners Nos.1–4 were "agriculturists." On 29 May 1939 the Munsif found (1) that the earlier finding of the Board in proceedings based on the first application was binding and thus the second petition was not a petition by debtors within the meaning of the Act, and (2) that after dismissal of the first application under section 8 a second application was not maintainable in law; the Munsif vacated the stay.

On 20 June 1939 the judgment-debtors applied to this Court under section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure by way of Rule to show cause why the Munsif's order vacating the stay should not be set aside. The question before the Munsif (and central to the execution proceedings) was whether the judgment-debtors were "debtors" within the meaning of the Bengal Agricultural Debtors Act and therefore entitled to the Act's protections.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an order in execution proceedings that determines the question whether judgment-debtors are debtors within the meaning of a special law (here the Bengal Agricultural Debtors Act) is a "decree" within the meaning of section 2(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure and thus appealable as a decree.
  2. Whether the High Court can entertain a revision under section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure in respect of a subordinate Court's order when an appeal to the High Court is available (by first appealing to the lower Appellate Court), i.e., the proper interpretation of the phrase "in which no appeal lies thereto" in section 115.
  3. Whether the petition for revision under section 115 is competent where the aggrieved party has an appellate remedy that would ultimately reach the High Court (if the party avails itself of the intermediate appeal procedure).

Arguments of the Parties

Judgment-Debtors' (Petitioners') Arguments

  • The word "lies" in section 115 should be read to mean "lies" at the time when the High Court is moved under section 115; therefore, because no appeal to the lower Appellate Court had been preferred and decided, a second appeal to the High Court did not lie at that time and revision under section 115 should be permissible.
  • That the jurisdiction of the High Court to interfere under section 115 in cases like this had never been questioned previously, and thus the Court should exercise revisional jurisdiction in this instance (an argument the Court treated as largely irrelevant to statutory interpretation and more relevant to costs or possible admission of a future appeal under section 5 of the Limitation Act).

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the Opposite Party's (decree-holder's) specific legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jogodishury Debea v. Kailash Chundra Lahiry Supports the proposition that an order in execution proceedings is a decree when it conclusively determines a question relating to the rights and liabilities of the parties with reference to the relief granted by the decree (in light of section 47 and section 2(2) of the Code). The Court relied on this authority (with the combined effect of sec. 47 & sec. 2(2)) to hold that the Munsif's decision that the judgment-debtors were not debtors under the Bengal Agricultural Debtors Act was a decree because it conclusively determined the judgment-debtors' liability with reference to the relief granted by the original decree.
Maharaja Sashi Kanta Acharya Bahadur v. Nasirabad Loan Office Co. The case may support the narrow proposition that where an appeal lies to the lower Appellate Court but no further appeal lies to the High Court, an aggrieved person may invoke the High Court's revisional jurisdiction under section 115 without first appealing to the lower Appellate Court. The Court treated that decision as potentially authority for a limited proposition but expressly held it was not authority for allowing revision where an appeal to the High Court does in fact lie (via the lower Appellate Court). The Court declined to accept that Maharaja Sashi Kanta supports invoking section 115 when an appeal to the High Court is available by following the ordinary appellate route.
Bani Madho Ram v. (Pandit) Mahadeo Pandey Holds that revision under section 115 does not lie where there is an adequate remedy by appeal to the District Judge and thence by second appeal to the High Court; a party who has the right to reach the High Court by way of appeal but fails to use the appellate route cannot ask for revision under section 115. The Court expressly agreed with the observations in that case and applied them in concluding that section 115 should not be invoked where a party has an appellate route that ultimately reaches the High Court but has not pursued that route.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's reasoning proceeds in distinct steps:

  1. Characterisation of the Munsif's order: The Court analyzed whether the Munsif's decision—declaring that the judgment-debtors were not debtors within the meaning of the Bengal Agricultural Debtors Act and thereby refusing the benefit of that Act—was a decree. Citing the combined effect of section 47 and section 2(2) of the Code and the precedent Jogodishury Debea v. Kailash Chundra Lahiry, the Court held that where an order in execution conclusively determines a question relating to the rights and liabilities of the parties (with reference to the relief granted by the decree), that order is a decree. The Munsif's determination was such a conclusive determination and therefore was a decree.
  2. Available appellate route: Because the Munsif's order is a decree, the Court identified the statutory appellate route: an appeal lies against such a decree to the District Judge (under section 96) and a further appeal to the High Court (under section 100). Thus, an appeal to the High Court was available by following the ordinary two-step appellate process.
  3. Interpretation of section 115: The Court interpreted section 115 (which permits the High Court to revise a subordinate Court's record "in which no appeal lies thereto") as intended to be available only where no appeal to the High Court is permissible under the Code or other statute. The word "lies" was read to mean "is allowed" under the Code or other law. Allowing revision under section 115 where an appellate remedy exists that ultimately reaches the High Court (provided the intermediate appeal is taken) would permit parties to bypass the ordinary appellate route and would frustrate legislative intent.
  4. Consideration of the judgment-debtors' textual argument: The petitioners argued that "lies" should be read as meaning "lies at the time the High Court is moved" (i.e., that because no lower appellate decision had been rendered, no second appeal then lay). The Court rejected this interpretation as contrary to legislative intent, reasoning that it would enable a party to withhold an intermediate appeal and thereby stifle a second appeal to the High Court by invoking section 115.
  5. Reliance on precedent: The Court relied on authority (including Bani Madho Ram) for the view that revision under section 115 should not be available where there is an appellate remedy to the High Court—via the prescribed appellate chain—and the party has failed to use that remedy.
  6. Disposition on competence: For these reasons, the Court concluded that the petition for revision under section 115 was incompetent and therefore discharged the Rule. The Court expressly declined to express any opinion on the substantive questions raised in the Rule (i.e., it did not decide the merits of whether the Petitioners were debtors under the Bengal Agricultural Debtors Act).
  7. Separate concurring reasoning (Rau, J.): Rau, J. agreed that the determination whether execution is barred by a special law is a question within section 47 and hence a decree under section 2(2), making an order staying or refusing to stay execution appealable as a decree. On the interpretation of section 115, Rau, J. discussed two possible readings: (a) a broad reading that treats "in which no appeal lies" as including future appeals that might lie to the High Court, and (b) a narrower reading that bars revision only where an appeal immediately lies to the High Court. Rau, J. expressed reluctance to adopt the broader construction but concluded that, in any event, there was no urgent need for intervention in the present stage and agreed that the Rule should be discharged.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The petition for revision under section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure is incompetent and the Rule is discharged.

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • The Rule brought by the judgment-debtors in Civil Revision Case No. 963 of 1939 was discharged; there will be no order for costs.
  • Civil Revision Cases Nos. 1506 and 1650 of 1939, which had facts materially the same as No. 963, were also discharged for the same reasons, without costs.
  • The Court expressly did not decide the substantive questions raised in the Rule (it declined to express any opinion on those merits questions).

Broader implications: The Court's reasoning clarifies that where an order in execution conclusively determines questions of liability with respect to a decree (and thus constitutes a decree under section 2(2) read with section 47), the ordinary appellate route (first to the District Judge and thence to the High Court) should be used rather than invoking the High Court's revisional jurisdiction under section 115. The Court relied on existing precedents to support this limitation on the scope of section 115.

Show all summary ...

The Judgment of the Court was as follows:—

Civil Revision Case No. 963.

Nasim Ali, J.:— The facts which are not in dispute in this Rule are as follows: On the 10th November, 1937, the Petitioners filed an application for settlement of their debts before the Debt Settlement Board, Howrah, under sec. 8 of the Bengal Agricultural Debtors Act. The application was dismissed by the Board on the 19th January, 1938, on the ground that the Petitioners were not “agriculturists.” They appealed against this decision to the Appellate officer. This appeal was dismissed on the 25th May, 1938. They applied for review under sec. 44(b) this application was also rejected. The Petitioners Nos. 1-4 thereafter filed another application before the Special Debt Settlement Board, Howrah, under sec. 8 of the Act for settlement of their debts. This application was dismissed on the 27th November, 1938, on the ground that a fresh application was not maintainable. They applied for a review of this order. The Opposite Party creditor was not present on the date of the hearing of this application. On the 19th March, 1939, the Board allowed the application for review and fixed 16th April, 1939, for hearing on the merits. On the 1st May, 1939, the Board issued a notice under sec. 34 of the Bengal Agricultural Debtors Act for staying execution proceedings against the Petitioners in the first Court of Munsif at Howrah which was started by the Opposite Party for realisation of about Rs. 2,000 on the basis of a decree. A similar notice under sec. 34 of the Act was also issued on the same date on the application of Petitioner No. 5 before the Debt Settlement Board. The Munsif thereupon stayed the proceedings on that date. On the 10th May, 1939, the Opposite Party decree-holder applied to the Munsif for vacating the order of stay. On the 21st May, 1939, the Board decided that the Petitioners Nos. 1-4 were “agriculturists.” On May 29th, 1939, the Munsif arrived at the following findings:—

(1) That the finding of the Board in the proceeding started on the basis of the first application by the judgment-debtor under sec. 8 of the Act is binding on the Board and consequently the second petition filed by them is not a petition by debtors within the meaning of the Act; and

(2) That after the dismissal of the first application under sec. 8, a second application under that section was not maintainable in law.

He accordingly vacated the order staying the execution proceedings. On June 20th, 1939, the present Rule was issued on the decree-holder on the application of the judgment-debtor to show cause why the said order should not be set aside.

The issue between the parties before the Munsif in substance was whether the judgment-debtors were debtors within the meaning of the Bengal Agricultural Debtors Act and were therefore entitled to have their debts settled under that Act. This question is a question relating to execution as no order for attachment and sale of the properties of the judgment-debtors in execution can be made without the determination of this question. This question was therefore determined by the Munsif under sec. 47 of the Code. By sec. 2(2) of the Code, decree includes the determination of any question under sec. 47. The combined effect of sec. 47 and sec. 2(2) of the Code is that an order in execution proceedings is a decree, if, so far as regards the Court passing it, it conclusively determines a question relating to the rights and liabilities of the parties with reference to the relief granted by the decree. Jogodishury Debea v. Kailash Chundra Lahiry (1). Under the decree the judgment-debtors are liable to pay at once the entire decretal amount. The decision of the Munsif is that the judgment-debtors are not debtors within the meaning of the Bengal Agricultural Debtors Act and are not therefore entitled to the benefit of that Act. This decision will preclude them from pleading it in a subsequent stage of the execution proceedings that their liability under the decree has been reduced by an award under sec. 19 of the Bengal Agricultural Debtors Act or that they have been declared insolvent under sec. 22 of the Act and that the execution proceedings have abated by reason of an award under sec. 19 or by an order under sec. 22 (see sec. 34). It therefore conclusively determines the question relating to the judgment-debtors' liability with reference to the relief granted by the decree and is a decree.

An appeal against such a decree of a trial Court lies to the District Judge or to the High Court under sec. 96 of the Code and an appeal from the decree of the lower Appellate Court lies to this Court under sec. 100. In this case an appeal against the decision of the Munsif lay to the District Judge and a further appeal to this Court. The judgment-debtors did not appeal to the District Judge but moved this Court under sec. 115 of the Code. The question is whether this order can be revised under sec. 115 of the Code.

That section authorises this Court to revise an order of a subordinate Court in any case “in which no appeal lies thereto.” The appeal referred to in this section may be an appeal to this Court under secs. 96, 100, 104 or under Or. 43 of the Code of Civil Procedure or under any other statute. In the case of Maharaja Sashi Kanta Acharya Bahadur v. Nasirabad Loan Office Co. (2) a second appeal to this Court was apparently barred under sec. 102 of the Code. The decision in that case may be an authority for the proposition that in cases where an appeal is allowed to the lower Appellate Court but no appeal is allowed against an Appellate decree to the High Court the person aggrieved may invoke the jurisdiction of the High Court under sec. 115, though he has not preferred any appeal to the lower Appellate Court. But that case is no authority for the proposition that where an appeal is allowed to the High Court, the High Court can interfere under sec. 115 of the Code.

The contention of the judgment-debtors is that the word “lies” in sec. 115 means “lies” at the time when the High Court is moved under sec. 115 and that in this case a second appeal to this Court did not lie at the time when this Court was moved under sec. 115 as no appeal to the lower Appellate Court had been then preferred and decided. In other words, the contention is that the expression “appeal lies” means the right of appeal has already accrued. If this contention be sound, the position would be that a person aggrieved by a decree of the trial Court by refusing to file an appeal to the lower Appellate Court can stifle a second appeal to this Court and can confer jurisdiction on the High Court to revise the decree of the trial Court. I am of the opinion that this was not the intention of the legislature in enacting sec. 115. It can never have been intended by the legislature that where a person aggrieved by a decree of the trial Court has his remedy by way of appeal to this Court (if he will only first avail himself of that remedy by taking an appeal to the lower Appellate Court), he can seek his remedy in this Court under sec. 115. The object of sec. 115 was to give relief to a person who cannot get relief in this Court under secs. 96, 100, 104 or Or. 43 or any other statute. The words “appeal lies thereto” indicate that where a relief can be given by this Court in the exercise of its Appellate Jurisdiction, its Revisional Jurisdiction under sec. 115 cannot be invoked. These words, in my opinion, mean “appeal is allowed under the Code or any other law.” In the case of Bani Madho Ram v. (Pandit) Mahadeo Pandey (3), Sulaiman and Niamatulla, JJ., observed:—

“It seems to us that no revision lies under section 115, Civil Procedure Code. It was clearly a case of a decree which could have been appealed against to the District Judge from whose decree a Second Appeal could have been filed to this High Court. It is, therefore, not a case in which no appeal lies to the High Court at all although no appeal could have been filed from the original Decree of the first court direct. In our opinion there is no ground for restricting the scope of the words in which no appeal lies thereto to cases where no appeal lies from the order sought to be revised. So long as the party has a right to come up to the High Court by way of an appeal and has failed to avail himself of that;opportunity by first going up to the District Judge and then coming up to the High Court, he cannot ask the High Court to interfere in revision.”

I respectfully agree with these observations.

The next contention of the judgment-debtors is that the jurisdiction of this Court to interfere under sec. 115 of the Code in cases like this had never been questioned before and, therefore, we should interfere in this case. This argument, however, is irrelevant on the question of the interpretation of sec. 115 though it may be a good ground for not allowing costs in this case, and though perhaps it may have some bearing on the question of an admission of an appeal under sec. 5 of the Limitation Act if such appeal be presented in future by the Petitioners.

I, therefore, hold that this petition for revision is incompetent. In this view of the matter I express no opinion on the questions raised in this Rule.

The Rule is accordingly discharged. But there will be no order for costs.

Civil Revision Cases Nos. 1506 and 1650 of 1939.

The facts of these two cases are in all material particulars the same as in Revision Case No. 963 of 1939. For the reasons given in that case I discharge both these Rules also, without costs.

Rau, J.:— I agree that the question whether the execution of a decree is or is not barred, whether temporarily or permanently, by reason of some special law—in the case before us, by the Bengal Agricultural Debtors Act—is a question within sec. 47 of the Code of Civil Procedure, and its determination is accordingly a decree within the meaning of the definition in sec. 2(2) of that Code. It follows that an order staying or refusing to stay execution upon the ground that execution is or is not barred by the special law in question is subject to appeal as a decree. The order which forms the subject-matter of this Rule is accordingly appealable as a decree.

The next question is whether we have jurisdiction to interfere with the order in revision under sec. 115 of the Civil Procedure Code. The section, it will be remembered, runs:—

“The High Court may call for the record of any case which has been decided by any Court subordinate to such High Court and in which no appeal lies thereto, and if such subordinate Court appears—

(a) to have exercised a jurisdiction not vested in it by law; etc.……………the High Court may make such order in the case as it thinks fit.”

The words “in which no appeal lies thereto” present some difficulty. “Thereto” means of course to the High Court. The words “no appeal lies” are not so easy to interpret. Where, at the moment the record is called for, the case has reached a stage at which the next appeal, whether first or second, is to the High Court, it is easy enough to say whether an appeal actually lies to the High Court or not; and if it lies, revision is clearly barred. But where a case has not reached that stage and has, say, only reached the stage at which the next appeal is to some Court subordinate to the High Court, with a possibility of a second appeal to the High Court at some future date, is revision barred? In other words, are we to interpret the expression “in which no appeal lies” as if it were equivalent to the expression “in which no appeal lies or may in future lie”? I hesitate to place so wide a construction upon these words. According to the alternative interpretation, revision is barred only where an appeal, whether first or second, lies immediately to the High Court; where no such immediate appeal lies, the High Court has jurisdiction to intervene in revision, although whether it will exercise this jurisdiction or not, will depend upon the urgency of the need for intervention.

In the case before us there is no urgent need for our intervention at the present stage, even if we have jurisdiction to intervene. Whatever, therefore, may be the precise interpretation of sec. 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure, I agree that the present Rule should be discharged.

P.C