Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ram Prasad v. Emperor

Allahabad High Court
Sep 23, 1918
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The revision on the criminal side arose from an execution case pending in the Court of the Cantonment Magistrate of Meerut acting as a Small Cause Court. The decree-holder was ordered on 9th July 1918 to deposit the diet money of his judgment-debtor within three days. Due to holidays on 10th, 11th, and 12th July, the decree-holder effectively had only 9th and 13th July to comply. On 15th July, the decree-holder complained that although he tendered the money to the Civil Ahlmad Mul Chand, the latter refused to accept it, thus preventing compliance with the order. The Cantonment Magistrate reported this to the Collector. The Collector's departmental enquiry led to the conclusion that the complaint against Mul Chand was false and recommended prosecution of the decree-holder under Section 182 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) for making a reckless complaint. The Cantonment Magistrate concurred and sanctioned prosecution under Section 195 of the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC). The applicant, Ram Prasad, sought revision of this order in this Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the criminal court has jurisdiction to revise the Cantonment Magistrate's order sanctioning prosecution under Section 195 CrPC based on a complaint of false information under Section 182 IPC.
  2. Whether the order sanctioning prosecution can be interfered with under Section 115 of the Civil Procedure Code (CPC) when originating from a civil court's complaint.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the facts and found that the Civil Ahlmad Mul Chand admitted on 15th July that the decree-holder had tendered the money and that he refused to accept it. However, the Collector’s departmental enquiry resulted in a contrary conclusion, finding the complaint false. The court recognized that the Cantonment Magistrate’s order amounted to a criminal complaint by a civil court against a person for giving false information. The court held that it lacked jurisdiction on the criminal side to revise such an order. It further observed that even on the civil side, interference under Section 115 CPC would be impossible. Therefore, despite the court’s personal opinion that it would have set aside the order if jurisdiction existed, it concluded that it was unable to do so and thus rejected the application.

Holding and Implications

Application dismissed.

The court’s decision directly results in the continuation of the prosecution sanctioned by the Cantonment Magistrate against the decree-holder under Sections 182 IPC and 195 CrPC. No broader precedent was established, and the ruling primarily clarifies the limits of the court’s jurisdiction to revise such orders on the criminal side.

Show all summary ...

1. The facts out of which this revision on the criminal side has arisen are as follows: Pending in the Court of the Cantonment Magistrate of Meerut in his capacity as a Small Cause Court was an execution case. The decree-holder was directed to deposit the diet money of his judgment-debtor who was about to be arrested. He was ordered to do so within three days and the order was passed on 9th July 1918. The 10th, 11th and 12th July were holidays, so that the only two days on which lie could possibly deposit the money were the 9th and the 13th of the month. On the 15th of the month he made a complaint to the Cantonment Magistrate that although he had tendered the money to the Civil Ahlmad Mul Chand, the latter had refused to take it and had made it impossible for him, the decree-holder, to comply with the order. On 15th July the Cantonment Magistrate made the following report to the Collector for orders:

“The Civil Ahlmad Mul Chand admits that the decree-holder tendered the fees but that he, Mul Chand, did not accept them at the instigation of the Chaprasi Sharfu who, it appears, is related to the defendant.”

2. Assuming that this report is correct, and there is absolutely no reason to doubt it, on 15th July the Civil Ahlmad Mul Chand did admit to the Cantonment Magistrate that the money had been offered to him and that he had refused to take it.

3. I gather that it was the Cantonment Magistrate's object in making this report to get the Ahlmad punished. On 30th July the Collector wrote an order which goes to show that Mul Chand at his departmental enquiry had not admitted that the money had been tendered to him. Though this is not really stated in the order, it is a natural inference from the language of that order, for the Collector came to the conclusion that the charge made against Mul Chand was untrue and he sent the papers back to the Cantonment Magistrate with the following remarks:

“If you agree with me, I think that you should recommend the prosecution of the decree-holder under S. 182, I.P.C, as reckless complaints of this kind are far too common, and I think that it is our duty to protect our Sub-ordinate officials from them.”

4. On receipt of this the Cantonment Magistrate passed his order of 31st July 1918, which the applicant Ram Prasad now seeks to have revised in this Court. In that order the Cantonment Magistrate remarked as follows:

“In consequence I reported Mul Chand to the Collector, who has enquired into the case and finds that the complaint is a false one. I concur in the Collector's finding and I therefore sanction the prosecution of Ram Prasad under S. 182, I.P.C, under the provisions of Section 195 of the Cr PC.”

5. These are the facts as they stand before me. I have not the slightest hesitation in saying that if sitting as a criminal Court I had power to revise this order, I should at once set it aside in view of the Cantonment Magistrate's order of 15th July 1918, mentioned above, but it seems to me, that I have no authority or jurisdiction whatsoever sitting on the criminal side to interfere with this order. It amounts to a complaint made by a civil Court against a certain person for having given to that Court false information in regard to a certain matter. The order cannot be brought to this Court on the criminal side. At the utmost it could be brought up before this Court on the civil side an even in that aspect also it would be impossible to interfere under Section 115 of the CPC. The order I am afraid will stand, not because I would not set it aside, but because I am unable to do so. The application is rejected.

V.B/R.K

6. Application dismissed.