- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Imperial Bank Of India
Factual and Procedural Background
This is an application by the liquidator for directions on matters set out in the Judge's Summons concerning the priority and payment of claims listed in Schedules A–F to the liquidator's affidavit, and the remuneration and costs of the liquidator. The liquidation of Morrison & Co., Ltd. has been ongoing for about two years. The schedules set out preferential charges (Sch. A), tax and customs sums (Sch. B), bank and creditor claims (Sch. C), and other claims including Sch. F. The liquidator sought directions as to which claims have priority and the quantum and payment of his remuneration and costs.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the amounts listed in Sch. A and Sch. B are to be paid first as preferential charges.
- Whether the Imperial Bank of Madras holds a valid floating charge on the company's assets and whether the requirements of Sect. 109 Cl. (e), and Sects. 230 and 233 of the Companies Act are satisfied so as to give it priority.
- Whether Sect. 52 of the Insolvency Act applies to floating charges created by a company in favour of a bank.
- Whether the Oversea Export and Import Co. proved a priority claim in respect of goods (i.e., whether the goods were sold to Morrison & Co., Ltd. or Morrison & Co. were agents only).
- Whether the Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation has priority over certain sums based on the parties' letters and arrangements.
- What remuneration is fair for the liquidator for the period of liquidation, and the order for payment of taxed costs (including taxed costs as between attorney and client).
Arguments of the Parties
Liquidator
- Sought directions on payment priorities among schedules and approval of his remuneration and costs.
Imperial Bank of Madras
- Asserted a floating charge created by deed dated 12 December 1921, registered 21 December 1921 (Ex. A), satisfying the provisions of Sect. 109 Cl. (e) of the Companies Act, entitling it to priority under Sects. 230 and 233.
Oversea Export and Import Co.
- Claimed priority in respect of certain goods; dispute whether goods were sold to Morrison & Co., Ltd. or Morrison acted as agent for Oversea Export & Import Co.
Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation
- Relied on letters from Morrison & Co. Ltd. indicating Morrison acted as agent for sale, sale proceeds to be paid over, unsold goods to be returned, and property to be at the disposal of the Bank, asserting priority for specified sums.
Mr. M.O. Alasingarachariar (Sch. F claimant)
- Claimed Rs. 739 for professional services rendered to Morrison & Co. (before conversion to a limited company) and filed an affidavit proving the amount due.
- Contended those services incurred a debt, but the company did not undertake to pay pre-incorporation debts; directors' proceedings indicate debts were not payable by the company.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded schedule by schedule and claim by claim, applying statutory provisions and documentary evidence presented in the liquidation affidavit and exhibits:
- Sch. A: The items are preferential charges under the Act; there was no dispute and they are to be paid first. Rs. 21 costs allowed to Abdur Rahiman (rent) are to be added to the Sch. A sums.
- Sch. B: No dispute; items (income-tax and Postmaster-General for Customs duty) to be paid accordingly.
- Imperial Bank (Sch. C items 1 and 2): The deed dated 12 Dec 1921 (Ex. A) was filed and registered on 21 Dec 1921 satisfying Sect. 109 Cl. (e). Under Sects. 230 and 233 of the Companies Act the Bank can have a charge on company assets. The court held Sect. 52 of the Insolvency Act did not apply to floating charges created by a company in favour of a bank and observed that a floating charge by its nature leaves possession with the company. Conclusion: Imperial Bank is entitled to payment of the amounts in items 1 and 2 of Sch. C first (after Schs. A & B and liquidator's charges/costs).
- Oversea Export & Import Co. (Sch. C item 3): The agreement indicated dealings as principal and agent and drafts were drawn against the goods. The company did not appear and prove priority. The court concluded priority was not established for Oversea Export & Import Co.
- Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation (Sch. C items 4 and 5): Letters showed Morrison & Co. acted as agents for sale, sale proceeds to be paid over, unsold goods to be returned, and property to be at the Bank's disposal. The court held the Bank has priority in respect of Rs. 3,500 and Rs. 2,309-8-0 (items 4 and 5).
- Mr. M.O. Alasingarachariar (Sch. F): His services were rendered before Morrison & Co. became a limited company; there is nothing to show the limited company undertook to pay pre-incorporation debts, and directors' proceedings indicate such debts were not payable by the company. The court noted the practical consequence—apart from the Imperial Bank and the Hongkong & Shanghai Banking Corporation there would be no assets to pay other creditors—and observed limited hardship to him as a result.
- Liquidator's remuneration: Given liquidation proceedings of about two years, the court considered Rs. 200 per month fair and allowed Rs. 200 per month from the date the liquidator assumed charge up to the date of the order.
- Payment directions: The court directed that Schs. A and B, the liquidator's remuneration, and the costs of the application be paid first; out of the balance the Imperial Bank and the Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation will be paid rateably.
- Costs: The taxed costs of the liquidator (as between attorney and client) and of the Imperial Bank to be paid out of funds in the liquidator's hands. The court certified for counsel and ordered accordingly.
Holding and Implications
Directions issued concerning priority of payments and allowance of liquidator's remuneration.
Holding (direct orders):
- Schs. A and B are to be paid first; Rs. 21 costs for Abdur Rahiman added to Sch. A.
- Imperial Bank is entitled to payment of items 1 and 2 of Sch. C (having a registered floating charge under the Companies Act).
- Oversea Export & Import Co. did not establish priority.
- Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation has priority for the sums specified (Rs. 3,500 and Rs. 2,309-8-0 for items 4 and 5).
- Liquidator awarded Rs. 200 per month from assumption of charge to date; Schs. A and B, liquidator's remuneration, and costs of the application to be paid first; remaining balance to be paid rateably to Imperial Bank and Hongkong & Shanghai Banking Corporation.
- Taxed costs of the liquidator (as between attorney and client) and of the Imperial Bank to be paid from funds in the liquidator's hands; counsel certified.
Implications: The decision fixes the payment priority among the listed claimants and awards liquidator remuneration and specific cost payments; the opinion does not purport to create or announce a broader legal precedent.
This is an application by the liquidator for direction, as to various matters set out in the Judge's Summons. The first question is as regards the charges set out in Sch. A to the Liquidator's affidavit. Sch. A is a list of preferential charges which, under the Act, have to be paid first and there is no dispute about Sch. A. The amounts in Sch. A will be paid first by the Liquidator and to the sums mentioned therein will be added Rs. 21, costs allowed to Abdur Rahiman, on his application as regards rent. As regards Sch. B, there is also no dispute, as items referred to therein are sums payable in connection with income-tax and to the Postmaster-General for Customs duty. Sch. C refers to certain claims made by the Imperial Bank of Madras and to certain sums due to the Overseas Export and Import Co., and the Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation. Items 1 and 2. of Sch. C refer to the Imperial Bank of Madras. The Imperial Bank obtained a floating charge on the properties of the Morrison & Co., Ltd., by deed dated the 12th December, 1921. This deed has been marked A, in the liquidation proceedings. It appears from Ex. A that it was filed with the Registrar of Joint Stock Companies and registered on the 21st December, 1921, so that the provisions of Sect. 109 Cl. (e) of the Companies Act have been satisfied. It is clear from Sects. 230 and 233 of the Companies Act that the Imperial Bank can have a charge over the assets of the company. I do not think that Sect. 52 of the Insolvency Act has any application to cases of floating charges, created by a company, in favour of the Bank. Sect. 229 refers to the Insolvency Act, only as regards the rights of secured and unsecured creditors. It is obvious that a floating charge, if created, must leave the possession with the company, as otherwise it cannot carry on business at all. The Imperial Bank will be paid the amounts of items 1 and 2 of Sch. C to the affidavit of the Liquidator first. Item 3 of Sch. C refers to the Oversea Export and Import Co., and the question is whether the goods were sold to Morrison & Co., Ltd. or whether Morrison & Co., were only the agents for the Oversea Export & Import Co. The Company does not appear and prove its claim to priority. It appears from the agreement that they were to deal inter se as principal and agent and that drafts were drawn against the goods; and I therefore do not think it is proved that the Oversea Export & Import Co., have any priority. As regards item 4, which relates to Honkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation, it appears from the letters written by Morrison & Co. Ltd., to the Imperial Bank, which represented the Honkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation, that Morrison & Co. Ltd., were only agents for sale, that goods were to be sold and that the sale proceeds were to be paid over in due course, that the unsold goods were to be returned and that the property was to be at the disposal of Honkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation. In these circumstances, I think that Honkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation has got a priority, in respect of Rs. 3,500 and 2309-8-0, items 4 and 5. As regards the other schedules, I accept the statements refer, red to in the affidavit of the liquidator. Mr. M.O Alasingarachariar, who is one of the persons mentioned in Sch. F and who claims Rs. 739, states that this sum is due for professional services rendered by him and that he has filed an affidavit proving the amount due. The difficulty, however, in his case is that they were services rendered to Morrison & Co. Ltd., before it was turned into a limited liability company and there is nothing to show that Morrison & Co., Ltd., undertook to pay the debts of Morrison & Co. On the contrary, the proceedings of the Directors, which are referred to, by Mr. Mockett show that the debts were not payable by the company. As however it is clear that excepting the Imperial Bank and the Honkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation, who have got priority, there would not be assets to pay other creditors, it seems to me that he has not much hardship in the matter. The next question is as regards the remuneration of the liquidator. The liquidation proceedings have been going on, for the last two years and I think that Rs. 200, a month, would be fair remuneration for the trouble taken by the liquidator, during the period of liquidation. I allow him Rs. 200, a month, from the date he assumed charge up to this date. I direct that Schs. A and B and the liquidator's remuneration and the costs of this application will be paid first and out of the balance, the Imperial Bank and the Honkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation will be paid rateably.
The taxed costs of the liquidator, as between attorney and client, and of the Imperial Bank, will be paid out of the funds in the liquidator's hands. I certify for counsel.
W. S. S.Ordered accordingly.
Alert