- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Chundy Churn Dhur v. Boistab Churn Dhur And Others
Background:
The matter at hand concerns the administration of the estate of Kissendoyal Dhur, who is deceased. The case raises significant issues pertaining to the estate's assets, specifically regarding the inclusion of certain financial instruments in the estate. On January 31, 1901, a reference was made to the Registrar to take accounts and conduct inquiries related to the estate.
Issues:
1. Whether a sum of Rs. 5,000 deposited with Messrs Anderson Wright & Co. constitutes part of the deceased's estate.
2. Whether a Government paper for Rs. 5,000 deposited with Messrs Graham & Co. is part of the estate.
Facts:
- It was alleged that Kissendoyal Dhur had deposited a Government Promissory Note No. 110550 of the 4 percent loan of 1842–1843, valued at Rs. 5,000, with Messrs Anderson Wright & Co. as security for the faithful discharge of duties by his son, Kanal Lall Dhur, who is the father of the Defendants.
- On March 2, 1903, an order was served to the Bank regarding these deposits, which has yet to be complied with.
- On May 4, 1903, the Bank suggested that the court should resolve the questions raised.
Legal Considerations:
- The Plaintiff's right to inspect the Loan Register under Section 76 of the applicable Act must be evaluated. The Plaintiff has presented prima facie evidence of an interest that warrants inspection rights.
- The common law principle permitting inspection of public documents is constrained by specific interests, as articulated in *Rex v. Justices of Staffordshire*.
- The Plaintiff's personal interest in the public document in question supports the argument for a common law right to inspect the Loan Register.
- There is a potential risk of serious consequences if individuals without vested interests are allowed access to inspect the Loan Register.
- Mr. Garth noted that certain promissory notes have been consolidated and may no longer exist independently.
Conclusion:
The court finds that the Plaintiff is entitled to inspect all entries in the Loan Register relevant to the transfers involving Messrs Graham & Co. and Makhun Lall Dhur, including any conversions up to the date of transfer. The Plaintiff is also entitled to obtain certified copies of these entries.
Order:
The court's order extends beyond the Plaintiff's entitled rights, and it is determined that the Bank shall bear the costs associated with this matter, as submitted by Mr. Woodroffe.
Significance:
This case highlights the complexities involved in estate administration, particularly regarding the rights of interested parties to access financial records that may impact the distribution of the deceased's estate. The ruling reinforces the necessity of protecting the integrity of public documents while balancing the rights of individuals with legitimate interests.
Henderson, J.:— This application raises a question of considerable importance not only to the Plaintiff in this case but also to the public. The suit was one for the administration of the estate of Kissendoyal Dhur, deceased, and on the 31st January, 1901 a reference was made to the Registrar to take certain accounts and make a number of enquiries. Permission was given to raise at the reference the following issues which had been raised at the hearing of the suit, namely, (1) whether the sum of Rs. 5,000 deposited with Messrs Anderson Wright & Co., formed part of the estate of the deceased, and (2) whether the Government paper for Rs. 5,000 deposited with Messrs Graham & Co., formed part of the same estate. These issues arose in this way: It was said that Kissendoyal had deposited with Messrs Anderson Wright & Co., a Government Promissory Note No. 110550 of the 4 per cent loan of 1842–1843 for Rs. 5,000 by way of security for the faithful discharge of the duties of one of his sons, Kanal Lall Dhur, the father of the Defendants Boistab Churn and Natabar Dhur. Kauai Lall Dhur died on the 14th December, 1891, leaving him surviving the two sons just mentioned and these sons are still employed. In the firm of Messrs Anderson Wright & Co. in the place of their father Kanai Lall Dhur. The Government Promissory Note is said to have been renewed and to be still in the possession of Messrs Anderson Wright & Co., as security for the Defendants Boistab Churn Dhur and Natabar Dhur. It is said further that Kissendoyal deposited three other Government securities, namely, 047809 of the 4½ per cent loan of 1872 for Rs. 1,500, No. 009496 of the same loan for Rs. 2,000 and No. 072083 of the 4 per cent loan of 1835–1836 for Rs. 1,500 with Messrs Graham & Co. for the due discharge of the duties of another son named Subul Chunder Dhur who was then employed there. These notes were produced by Messrs Graham & Co. and were renewed by conversion into the following, namely, 000947 of the 3 per cent loan of 1879 for Rs. 2,000, 007182 of the same loan for Rs. 1,500 and 028569 of the 3½ per cent loan of 1865 for Rs. 1,500 and the renewed papers remained with Messrs Graham and Company until recently. The note 000947 of 1879 appears from a receipt, which I shall presently mention, to have been converted into No. A044703 of 1889.
Subul Chunder died on the 17th April, 1898, leaving the Defendant Makhun Lall Dhur and his brothers, who are also Defendants, and on his death the sons were brought upon the record as his representatives.
On the 1st July Makhun Lal Dhur, without notice to the Plaintiff, applied for and obtained Letters of Administration to the estate of his father Subul Chunder, and in doing so, he included in the schedule of assets belonging to the estate of his father the Promissory Notes Nos. A044703 of 1889 for Rs. 2,000, 007182 for Rs. 1,500, 028569 of the loan of 1865 for Rs. 1,500, and these were stated to be in the possession of Messrs Graham and Company.
On the strength of the Letters of Administration granted to him Makhun Lall Dhur took over from Messrs Graham & Co. the following Government Securities for Rs. 5,060, namely, one for Rs. 2,000, No. of 1889 (the lower figures showing that there had been a conversion), 007182 for Rs. 1,500 and 028569 of 1865 for Rs. 1,500, and these Notes were included in the receipt which he gave on the 19th July, 1901, as having been lodged with Messrs Graham and Company by his late father Subul Chunder Dhur.
The present application is made under the following circumstances: On the 31st July, 1901, the day on which the order was made for the reference, the Plaintiffs Attorneys wrote to the Secretary and Treasurer of the Bank of Bengal, Public Debt Office Branch, giving notice on behalf of the Plaintiff that Makhun Lall Dhur, one of the Defendants, was attempting to deal with the Government Securities which have been last mentioned and they pointed out that these notes belonged to the estate of Kissendoyal Dhur having been deposited by him with Messrs Graham & Co. as already stated. On the 5th February 1903, after the notes had been taken over by Messrs Graham & Co., the Plaintiff's Attorneys applied for a subpoena against the Bank for the production of the Public Debt Office Loan Register, but before issuing a subpoena the Registrar directed them to enquire whether the Bank had any objection to produce the Register. The Bank at first offered to furnish certified copies of the Register and on the 13th February, 1903 an order was made by this Court directing the Bank to prepare and produce certified copies of the entries in the Loan Register showing the different numbers to which the Government Promissory Notes produced by Messrs Graham and Company were renewed by conversion and showing the names of the persons by whom they had been converted and the names of the present holders thereof and also to prepare and produce certified copies of the entries in the Register showing the different numbers into which the Government Promissory Notes which was produced by Messrs Anderson Wright and Company was converted from time to time and the present number of the said Government Promissory Note and the names of the persons by whom it had been presented for conversion and the present owners thereof. This order is the subject of the present application. It was served on the 2nd day of March 1903 and so far the Bank has not complied with the order. In the course of the reference the Registrar required the Plaintiff's Attorneys to produce proof regarding the conversion of the notes alleged to have been deposited with Messrs Anderson Wright and Company and Messrs Graham and Company, respectively, in order that it might be seen whether the note or notes now in the possession of Messrs Anderson Wright & Co., and representing the original deposit is or are renewals of the note No. 110550 of 1842–1843 and whether similarly the notes made over to Messrs Graham & Co. by Makhun Lall Dhur are renewals of the notes said to have been made over to Messrs Graham and Company by Kissendoyal Dhur.
In reply to the letter written by the Plaintiff's Attorneys on the 6th February last to the Secretary and Treasurer, Bank of Bengal, the Deputy Secretary and Treasurer of the Bank of Bengal on the same day stated that the Loan Registers could not be produced at all as they were public documents under sec. 74 of the Evidence Act, but he stated that a certified extract was obtainable on payment of Rs. 1 and was admissible in evidence under sec. 77 of the same Act. Subsequently on the 3rd March, 1903 the Secretary and Treasurer of the Bank informed the Registrar that the Bank had been advised that the Bankers' Books Evidence Act under which the order of the 13th February, 1903 had been made was not applicable to the Loan Register and that the Bank's proper course was to give notice to show cause against the order under sec. 6, sub-sec. 3 of the Act mentioned. He also stated that it had been pointed out to the Bank that it was questionable whether the records of the Public Debt Office were open to public inspection and whether accordingly the Bank was at liberty to grant extracts or copies in the manner suggested in his previous letter. Under these circumstances he requested that the Bank might be afforded an opportunity of showing cause against the order. On the 23rd April, 1903 the Plaintiff's Attorneys wrote to the Registrar suggesting that if the Bank had any objection to or any cause to show against the order of the 13th February, 1903, it should come before him on a day to be fixed and take his decision in the matter. On the 4th May, 1903, however, it was suggested on behalf of the Bank that the question raised should be decided by the Court itself.
If would appear that in consequence of the non-compliance with the order of the 13th February, 1903 it had been impossible to go on with the reference and it has had to be adjourned from time to time. The position which has been taken up by the Bank has been taken up on principle and from no desire to obstruct the Plaintiff in the proof of his case before the Registrar. So far as I know the question now raised has never before been raised, at all events in this form, and I feel bound to say, the Bank has always hitherto shown their readiness to produce in Court certified copies of the Loan Register when required and from the correspondence to which reference has already been made it would appear that at one time the Bank was prepared in this case to produce certified copies. The ground upon which the objection of the Bank is based appears to be that the Register relates not only to the transactions of the Government of India but also to matters which relate to the titles of holders of Government Securities and that being so the Bank subject to certain exceptions is not at liberty to give inspection of, or make public, the contents. Moreover, it is contended that the Bank in so far as it is concerned with the management of the Public Debt Office on behalf of Government is not a Banker within the meaning of the Bankers' Books Evidence Act and that the Loan Register is not a Banker's book within the meaning of the same Act.
On the 8th August last the Plaintiff gave notice of the present application which is for an order that the Secretary and Treasurer of the Bank of Bengal, Public Debt Office, do comply with the order made by this Court on the 13th February, 1903 or for such order as the circumstances of the case may require.
Having so far cleared the ground I shall now proceed to deal with the question raised. In the first place it seems to me that the Loan Register is a public document within the meaning of sec. 74 of the Indian Evidence Act and that is the view which was at first put forward by the Bank itself in regard to this matter. As to the right of the Plaintiff to a certified copy it is necessary to consider whether under sec. 76 of the same Act he is a person having a right to inspect the Loan Register. It is not denied that the claim he has put forward in this suit, namely, that the Promissory Notes in question formed part of the estate of Kissendoyal Dhur was made bonâ fide. He has, in my opinion, made out a primâ facie case and more specially with regard to the Promissory Notes which were made over to Makhun Lall by Messrs Graham and Company. The facts alleged in the petition, on which the application is based have not been denied.
Sec. 76 of the Evidence Act provides that every public office having the custody of a public document which any person has a right to inspect, shall give that person on demand a copy of it on payment of the legal fees therefor together with a certificate written at the foot of such copy that it is a true copy of such document or part thereof as the case may be and such certificate shall be dated and subscribed by such officer with his name and his official title and shall be sealed, whenever such officer is authorized by law to make use of a seal, and such copies so certified shall be called certified copies.
I agree with the opinion expressed by Mr. Justice Shephard in Queen-Empress v. Arumugam that it “might be inferred that the Legislature intended to recognise the right generally, that is the right to inspect public documents, for all persons who can show that they have an interest for the protection of which it is necessary that liberty to inspect such documents should be given.” Here, there can be no doubt that the Plaintiff has shown primâ facie evidence that he has an interest for the protection of which it is necessary that liberty to inspect should be given.
In Mutter v. The Eastern and Midlands Railway Company referred to by the Full Bench in the Madras case, Lord Justice Lindley made the following remarks: “When the right to inspect and take a copy is expressly conferred by Statute, the limit of the right depends on the true construction of the Statute. When the right to inspect and take a copy is not expressly conferred, the extent of such right depends on the interest which the applicant has in what he wants to copy and on what is reasonably necessary for the protection of such interest. The common law right to inspect and take copies of public documents is limited by this principle as is shown by the judgment in Rex v. Justices of Staffordshire.” In the case which is mentioned by Lord Justice Lindley, Lord Denman, Chief Justice, observed that for the persons interested “every officer appointed by law to keep records ought to deem himself for that purpose” (for the protection of documents), “a Trustee.”
Here, so far as I am aware, no statutory right is given. Sec. 76 of the Evidence Act deals with the case where there is a right to inspect in the person demanding a certified copy. As I have said, there can be no doubt that the Plaintiff is personally interested in the public document in question and it would seem therefore that in the absence of a right conferred by Statute, he has common law right to inspect it. If he has a right to inspect it becomes necessary to see what is the extent of his right to inspection, It is clear that if persons not having an interest were allowed to inspect the Loan Register this would give rise to consequences of a very serious character. With regard to the Bank Mr. Garth has pointed out what the practice has been hitherto. It is said that the practice has always been to give inspection to any person, who can show that he is either in himself or as representing an estate entitled to a particular Promissory Note but only so far as he himself or the estate is concerned. Where there is an endorsement showing that a particular note has been transferred to a third person, it is only on giving an indemnity that he is allowed to see the endorsement, the object being to protect subsequent holders of securities. Mr. Garth has also pointed out that the notes Nos. 000947 of 1879, 007182 of 1879 and 028569 of 1865, or at all events some of them, do not now exist but have been consolidated on the other notes and not renewed separately. If this be so the consolidation must have been effected after Messrs Graham & Co. had handed over the notes in deposit with them to Makhun Lall Dhur, for we have a list of these notes given in Makhun Lall Dhur's receipt.
For the purposes of the Plaintiff I gather that it is not necessary to enquire into the present title of these notes. All that the Plaintiff is concerned with is to see whether the notes which were made over by Messrs Graham & Co., and which are mentioned in the receipt given by Makhun Lall are renewals of notes which were deposited with Messrs Graham & Co. In my opinion Plaintiff has the right to inspect all the entries in the Loan Register up to the transfer by Messrs Graham & Co. to Makhun Lall Dhur.
As to the note No. 110550 said to have been deposited with Messrs Anderson Wright & Co. by Kissen Lall Dhur, it is said it is still in the hands of that firm either in its original or in a renewed form. The Plaintiff it is said has been unable to obtain full information with regard to the present numbers of the note or notes into which it has been converted. The note being a note of the year 1842–1843, it is safe to assume that it has been converted. The Plaintiff further has not been able to ascertain whether the original note or the notes into which it may have been converted is or are still in the possession of Messrs Anderson Wright & Co. Assuming, however, as alleged that the note has been renewed and renewed note or notes is or are still in the name of Messrs Anderson Wright & Co. and in their possession; I am of opinion that the Plaintiff is entitled to inspect the entries in the Register with regard to it and its conversion. If they have been endorsed to any one else by Messrs Anderson Wright & Co., then I do not think that the Plaintiff has any right to see the entries subsequent to the endorsement. Here again it would seem to be sufficient for the Plaintiff's purpose if he is allowed to see the entries in the Loan Register of any conversions up to the transfer, if any, from Messrs Anderson Wright & Co., and in my opinion he is entitled to have certified copies of the entries.
In the order of the 13th February last the Bank was asked to give certified copies of entries beyond those to which I have held the Plaintiff entitled. The order directed the Bank to prepare and produce certified copies of the entries in the Register showing the different numbers into which the Promissory Note No. 047809, Nos. 009496 and 012083 were from time to time renewed by conversion and showing the names of the persons by whom the said Promissory Notes were converted and the names of the present holders thereof and it gave similar directions with regard to the note No. 110550.
The order goes beyond what I think the Plaintiff is entitled to. I am inclined to think that the order was in fact too wide but with regard to this I express no definite opinion. It is sufficient to say that the Plaintiff is content with the order in the form in which I propose to make it.
I direct that the Bank of Bengal do give inspection if required of all entries in the Loan Register relating to Promissory Note Nos. 110550 of the 4 per cent loan of 1842–1843 for Rs. 5,000 down to the present time if the note or notes into which it may have been converted be still in the name and in the possession of Messrs Anderson Wright & Co., and if it has been transferred by them to a third person, then down to the date of the transfer. And similarly with regard to notes Nos. 04-7809 of the 4½ per cent loan of 1872 for Rs. 1,500; 009496 of the same loan for Rs. 2,000; 072083 of the 4 per cent loan of 1835–1836 for Rs. 1,500. The Bank must allow inspection if required of the entries in the Loan Register and give certified copies of all entries in respect of all renewals up to the transfer from Messrs Graham & Co. to Makhun Lal Dhur.
The other question which have been raised as to whether the Loan Register is a Banker's book within the meaning of the Bankers' Book Evidence Act, it is unnecessary to decide, as I have already held, that the Register is a public document and that the Plaintiff in this particular case is entitled to inspection, at least to the extent specified, and to certified copies of the entries which have been specified. I may mention that in Suits Nos. 127 of 1900 and 582 of 1896 a somewhat similar order to that of the 13th February last was made under the Bankers' Book Evidence Act and was complied with by the Bank.
The only question remaining is the question of costs. As far as the Bank of Bengal is concerned I am not at all certain that they were not quite right in asking to have this question determined.
Mr. Woodroffe submits that the Bank should pay the costs. They have not shown cause.
Mr. Garth, contra.—As regards the Bankers' Book Evidence Act the Court has not decided that point.
The Court.—This is an application which arises out of a reference in an administration suit. I direct that each party pay his own costs.
Mr. Woodroffe.—We are to have certified copies with regard to each of these notes and we ask for costs of reference.
The Court.—Yes. I think you ought to get your costs in the same way. I should be inclined to make them costs of the issue before the Registrar.
Messrs Kally Nath Mitter and Sarbadhicary, Attorneys for the Plaintiff.
Messrs Morgan & Co., Attorneys for the Bank of Bengal.
A.N.C
Alert