- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
J.C. Galstaun v. Kumar Pramathanath Roy
Factual and Procedural Background
The Appellant, J.C. Galstaun, was the defendant in Suit No. 3 of 1918 before the Court of the Judge at Alipore. The suit concerned certain land situated to the south of premises belonging to the Appellant and was settled by a petition of compromise filed on 28 November 1918.
The petition of compromise, as it stood both on the date of the decree and at the time of the later proceedings, used the word “whole” in a crucial passage. The practical effect of the petition, read literally, was that while the Respondents would give certain land to the Appellant, the Appellant would give in exchange an equal quantity of land from land abutting certain roads; and, if that land were insufficient in area, the Appellant would pay for the whole of the land he was to receive at a specified price. The Respondents contended that the word “whole” had been substituted for the word “balance” and that, in truth, the Appellant should give what he had and pay only for the shortfall.
The land the Appellant was to receive was about 8 3/4 cottas; the Appellant's land at the specified place was short by about 2 cottas.
The Respondents (as Plaintiffs) applied in execution to enforce the consent decree, arguing (1) that “whole” should read “balance” and (2) alternatively, that even as written the decree's true intent was that the Appellant give all he had and pay only for the shortage. On appeal in the execution proceedings, this Court construed the decree as requiring the Appellant to pay money compensation for the entire 8 3/4 cottas. The Respondents alleged that the compromise petition had been fraudulently tampered with (substituting “balance” by “whole”), and the Court noted that fraud allegations could not properly be raised in execution but instead must be the subject of an application or suit in the original court.
Thereafter the Respondents applied to the Subordinate Judge to amend the decree alleging the fraudulent alteration. That application was not brought as a review under Order 47 of the Civil Procedure Code (it bore an eight-anna stamp rather than the ad valorem stamp required for review). The Respondents relied (or attempted to rely) on sections 151 and 152 of the Civil Procedure Code, but the opinion states clearly that the case made was outside sec. 152 and that sec. 151 was inappropriately invoked.
The Appellant appealed to the District Judge against the Subordinate Judge's order amending the decree. The District Judge rejected the appeal as incompetent, holding that under sec. 96 and the relevant rules no appeal lay from such an order amending a consent decree (and drawing attention to the limits of appeals under Order 23, r. 3 and Order 43 of the Code).
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a consent decree alleged to have been obtained by fraud can be amended or set aside by means of an execution application or by invoking Order 151 or 152 of the Civil Procedure Code, or whether a separate suit is the proper remedy.
- Whether an order of a Subordinate Judge amending a consent decree on contest is an order from which an appeal lies to the District Judge (and, if so, whether further appeals are available).
- Whether Order 47 (review) of the Civil Procedure Code permits review of a consent decree on the ground that it was obtained by fraud.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The Appellant argued (at least in his appeal to the District Judge) that an order amending a consent decree, when made on contest, was analogous to an order under Order 23, r. 3 directing that an adjustment of suit be recorded; in such cases an appeal is available to the District Judge, and by analogy an appeal should be allowed here.
- The Appellant also proceeded by appeal to the District Judge against the Subordinate Judge's order; implicitly he resisted the Respondents' attempt to amend the decree in the execution/application proceedings below.
Respondents' Arguments
- The Respondents contended that the compromise petition had been fraudulently altered — that the word “whole” in the petition should in truth be “balance” — and they sought amendment of the decree accordingly.
- They argued either that the word should be read as “balance” (a substantive alteration) or, alternatively, that even reading the decree as written the Appellant's obligation was to give all his land at the specified place and pay only for any shortfall.
- The Respondents relied on procedural grounds other than a suit: they brought an application before the Subordinate Judge (not as an Order 47 review), and it appears they sought to rely on sections 151 and 152 of the Civil Procedure Code (the opinion finds these attempts inappropriate or outside the scope of the sections relied upon).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Mussammat Gulab Koer v. Badshah Bahadur (Minor) | Consideration of numerous decisions on whether a consent decree may be reviewed under Order 47; whether review on ground of fraud is permissible. | The Court treated this as a leading local case and relied on its discussion that authorities are not uniform; it recorded the proposition from that case that, although many authorities disallow review of consent decrees, there is little foundation for saying there is a preponderance in favour of review for fraud. The judgment in that case supported the proposition that a party unsuccessful in review may pursue a remedy by suit. |
| Ram Gopal v. Prasunna Kumar | Previously decided authority on the question of review or remedies relating to consent decrees (contrasting positions in the Court's jurisprudence). | The Court noted that Mussammat Gulab Koer's decision was contrary to this earlier decision and recorded that the point was one on which the Court's opinions had differed; Rankin, C.J. reserved his opinion on that earlier decision while expressing his own view against review for fraud. |
| Ram Lagan Sahu v. Ram Birich Koeri (Opposite Party) | Authority approving the view that review under Order 47 is not competent to impeach a consent decree on the ground of fraud. | Rankin, C.J. approved the view taken in this case and cited it as supporting his opinion that Order 47 should not be used to make out a contentious case of fraud to set aside a consent decree. |
| Barahamdeo Prasad v. Banarsi Prasad | Referenced as an authority to be compared or contrasted in the context of review and consent decrees. | The Court observed that authorities contrary to the position it preferred are not numerous or impressive and have been challenged, citing this case as an example of contrary authority considered in prior discussion. |
| Chajju Ram's case (Judicial Committee) | Interpretation of the phrase “or for any other sufficient reason” in Rule 1 of Order 47 — that those words are not unlimited and should be analogous to the grounds already mentioned in the rule. | The Court relied on this authority to support the conclusion that Order 47's final words must be read restrictively and do not permit a party to set up a contentious fraud case by review. |
| Daniel's Chancery Practice (8th Edition, p.709) [text authority] | English chancery practice that a fresh action is necessary to set aside a consent decree on the ground of fraud and that such relief is not properly sought by review. | The Court invoked this text to align Indian practice with English chancery practice and to justify the proposition that a separate suit is the proper remedy to impeach a consent decree for fraud rather than review or other summary procedure. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the procedural and substantive propriety of the Respondents' method for attempting to alter the consent decree. Its analysis proceeded in the following steps, articulated in the text:
- Construction of the Compromise Petition: The Court first described the literal wording of the compromise petition (the word “whole”) and the competing interpretation urged by the Respondents (that “whole” was substituted for “balance”). The Court noted the practical effect on the land exchange and quantified the shortfall (about two cottas).
- Scope of Execution Proceedings: The Court observed in the earlier execution appeal that questions of fraud in the procurement of a decree cannot properly be raised in execution proceedings; any amendment on the ground of fraud must be made in the suit in which the decree was passed or by appropriate separate proceedings.
- Improper Invocation of Review and Sections 151/152: The Court examined the procedural form of the Respondents' application to the Subordinate Judge. It noted that the application was not brought as a review under Order 47 (and bore an incorrect court-fee stamp), and that sec. 152 (limited to clerical or arithmetical mistakes and accidental slips) did not apply. The Court concluded that sec. 151 was not intended to be used to circumvent the general principle requiring a separate suit to impeach a consent decree obtained by fraud.
- Appealability and the District Judge's Ruling: The District Judge had rejected the Appellant's appeal against the Subordinate Judge's amendment order as incompetent, holding that no appeal lay under the statutory framework. The Court acknowledged the seriousness of this consequence, since the Subordinate Judge's order affected property rights and alleged fraud.
- Principle that Separate Suit Is Proper Remedy: The Court articulated a clear principle: where a party seeks to have a consent decree amended or vacated on the ground that it was fraudulently procured, the proper and, in the Court's view, only course is to bring a separate suit. The Court relied on English practice and its own assessment of the scope of Order 47, arguing that Order 47 is not intended to be used for contentious fraud claims — the words “or for any other sufficient reason” must be read restrictively and analogously to the specific grounds listed in the rule.
- Evaluation of Local Authorities: The Court reviewed local authorities (including Mussammat Gulab Koer and Ram Gopal) and concluded that although the authorities are not uniform, the sound view is that Order 47 does not permit review for fraud in relation to consent decrees. The Court approved the reasoning in Ram Lagan Sahu as consistent with this view.
- Relief and Disposition in the Present Case: Given that the Respondents did not properly apply by review and had adopted an inappropriate method before the Subordinate Judge, and given that they remain able to pursue a remedy by a fresh suit, the Court declined to allow amendment of the decree through the route the Respondents had chosen. The Court also rejected the contention that earlier comments by a Division Bench in the execution matter legally bound the Appellant; such remarks were described as gratuitous advice without legal consequence.
- Procedural Treatment of the Appeal: The Court decided to treat the present appeal as an application under section 115 of the Civil Procedure Code against the Subordinate Judge's order and set aside the entire proceedings on the amendment application.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: The Court set aside the whole of the proceedings upon the application for amendment of the decree and held that the correct course for a party seeking to impeach a consent decree on the ground that it was fraudulently procured is to bring a separate suit (and not to succeed by execution proceedings, by an Order 47 review, or by inappropriate invocation of secs. 151/152).
Direct consequences ordered by the Court (as stated in the opinion):
- The proceedings before the Subordinate Judge on the Respondents' application to amend the decree are set aside.
- The Respondents are ordered to pay the Appellant's costs of the proceedings before the Subordinate Judge and in this Court.
- The Appellant is entitled to a refund of the court-fee paid on the memorandum of the appeal to this Court, less Rs. 10 which would have been paid on a revision application.
- The Court recorded that it may be open to the Respondents, if they bring a fresh suit, to seek an allowance under the Limitation Act for the time expended before the Subordinate Judge (the Court did not decide that question, only left it as a possibility arising from its order).
The opinion contains also an express judicial view (by Rankin, C.J.) that Order 47 of the Civil Procedure Code is not competent to obtain a review of a consent decree on the ground of fraud; the Court approved the view in Ram Lagan Sahu and indicated that authorities to the contrary were not persuasive. The Court, however, did not mechanically convert every procedural objection into a final bar on future remedies — it expressly left open the Respondents' ability to proceed by separate suit.
The Judgment of the Court was as follows:—
Rankin, C.J:— In this case the Appellant, J.C Galstaun, was Defendant ??? Suit No. 3 of 1918 in the Court ??? Judge at Alipore. The case had reference to certain land situate to the south of premises belonging to the Appellant and was settled in terms of a petition of compromise filed on the 28th November 1918.
Reading the petition of compromise as it now stands, and as it stood on the date of the decree, the first word of the third line on the third page is the word “whole” and the effect of the petition so read has been held to be that while the Respondents were to give certain land to the Appellant, the Appellant was to give in exchange an equal quantity of land from the land abutting certain roads, but if this land of the Appellant was not sufficient to equalise in area the land which the Appellant was to receive, then the Appellant would pay for the whole of the land which he was to receive at a certain price. The Respondents contention is that the word “whole” in the place where it occurs as above mentioned has been substituted for the word “balance,” the real bargain between the parties being that the Appellant was to give to the Respondents from his land enough to equalise in area the land which he was to receive, but that if he had not enough land at the place specified, he should give what he had and pay the Respondents for the balance. It appears that the land which the Appellant was to get by this exchange was an area of about 83/4 cottas and that the land which the Appellant had at the place above mentioned was short of that area by about two cottas.
The Respondents, as Plaintiffs, made an application in execution to enforce the consent decree, and it appears that they contended, first, that the word “whole” should be “balance” and, secondly, that even if the consent decree were read as it stands, the true meaning and intent thereof was to the effect that the Appellant should give all the land he had at the place mentioned and should pay for the shortage only. This execution matter came before this Court on appeal and it was determined between the parties that as the decree stood, its true construction was that the present Appellant was to pay money compensation for the entire 8 3/4 cottas. The Court, however, took notice of the fact that the present Respondents were contending that the compromise petition had been fraudulently tampered with and that the consent decree had been in this way fraudulently obtained by alteration of the word “balance” into the word “whole.” This Court pointed out that such a question could not be raised in execution and went on to say that “any amendment on the ground that there was fraud in the matter must be made by the Court in the suit in which the decree was passed. It will be open to the Roys to make such application as may be necessary to the Court to make an enquiry in the matter.” The present Respondents thereupon made an application before the learned Subordinate Judge for amendment of the decree alleging that the word “balance” had been fraudulently altered in the compromise petition. This application was not brought as an application in review under Or, 47 of the Civil Procedure Code; indeed it was brought upon an eight anna court-fee stamp whereas an application in review requires an ad valorem stamp of the same amount as the plaint. It would appear to have been contended by the present Respondents that the application was brought under sec. 152 of the Civil Procedure Code, but it is clear that the case made is entirely outside that section. Sec. 151 has also been put forward as a section which governs and authorises the application for amendment of this consent decree upon the ground that the decree as it stands had been fraudulently obtained.
Accordingly, when the present Appellant appealed to the District Judge against the order amending the decree, he was made to face a preliminary objection on the part of the Respondents to the effect that no appeal lay from the order complained of. He did his best to persuade the District Judge that as an order amending a consent decree was, when made on contest, much the same in effect as an order directing, after contest, that an adjustment of suit be recorded under. Or. 23, r. 3 of the Civil Procedure Code, one appeal at least should be given to him as it is given to a party against whom it has been held that a suit has been adjusted. This argument from analog was not accepted by the District Judge who further held that under sec. 96 of the Code, it was not possible to appeal from a consent decree. As Or. 43 of the Code does not specify orders made under sec. 151 of the Code as being orders from which an appeal shall lie, the appeal to the District Judge was rejected as incompetent.
It appears to me that in these circumstances, it is very necessary to examine the propriety of the procedure adopted by the Respondents in this case. The order of the Subordinate Judge not only affects the proprietorship of some 6 cottas of land in Calcutta but also convicts the Appellant of fraud, and indeed of a very grave fraud, not lacking in incidents which would, bring it within the ??? Criminal Law. If the ??? be told that there is no appeal whatever from this decision, it a serious matter for him. Even if the case could be regarded as within Or. 23, r. 3, the Appellant's right would be restricted to an appeal to the District Judge as no second appeal lies from an order made under this rule [of sec. 104, sub-sec. (2) Civil Procedure Code].
Now, it appears to me that if a party desires to have a consent decree amended or vacated upon the ground that it was fraudulently procured, his propel course, and indeed his only course, is to proceed by separate suit for the purpose. The matter is certainly grave enough to deserve a separate suit. The questions which have to be decided are entirely different from those at issue in the original suit. The relief sought is a very well recognised form of relief appropriate to a suit. In English practice it is old law that a fresh action is necessary to set aside a consent decree upon the ground of fraud and that such relief is not properly sought in an action of review. It appears to me that sec. 152 of the Code which is confined to clerical or arithmetical mistakes and to an accidental slip or omission, is based upon this general principle, and that sec. 151 is in no way intended as a violation of that principle. If the relief can be properly obtained in a separate suit, it does not appear that there is any justification for invoking sec. 151 at all.
Now a leading case in this Court upon this subject is the case of Mussammat Gulab Koer…Plaintiff, v. Badshah Bahadur (Minor)…Defendant, . in which numerous decisions are considered. The authorities in is Court are not uniform, but putting ??? at the highest in favour of the Respondents, it may be said that there is some difference of opinion upon the question whether, and in what circumstances, a consent decree may be reviewed under Or. 47 of the Code. It was said in that case that “while it must be conceded that a large preponderance of authority is against the contention that a consent decree cannot on any ground be challenged upon an application for review of judgment, there is no foundation for the suggestion that there is a preponderance of authority in favour of the contention that a consent decree may be reviewed on the ground of fraud.” The main proposition decided in that case was that a party who had applied unsuccessfully under Or. 47 for review of a consent decree on the ground that it had been obtained by fraud was entitled, notwithstanding his failure, to prosecute a remedy by suit. This decision was contrary to a previous decision in the case of Ram Gopal v. Prasunna Kumar (2) and I desire to reserve my opinion upon the point. In Musamat Gidab Koer's case it was pointed out that there are weighty reasons why a regular suit should be regarded as a more appropriate remedy in such eases. Now, I desire to say that in my opinion it is not competent under Or. 47 to obtain a review of a consent decree on the ground that the consent decree was obtained by fraud. It appears to me that before such a doctrine can be taken as authorised by the Code, it is very necessary to lay one's finger upon some enactment which is clearly intended to make so large and inconvenient an exception to the general principles which govern this matter. R. 1 of Or. 47, after speaking of a case where a party has discovered new and important matter which was not within his knowledge or could not be produced by him at the time when the decree was passed, and of mistake or error apparent on the face of the record, introduces the words “or for any other sufficient reason.” In Chajju Ram's case (3) the Judicial Committee had occasion to point out that these words were not unlimited and must be taken to point to a reason which is sufficient on grounds at least analogous to those mentioned in the rule. It appears to me that if mistake or error is primâ facie intended to be beyond the scope of the rule unless the mistake or error be apparent on the face of the record, it is curious, to say the least of it, that a party should employ this procedure for the purpose of making out a contentious case of fraud. In my opinion the correct doctrine under the Code of Civil Procedure is in no ways different upon this point from that which is laid down for England in Daniel's Chancery Practice, 8th Edition, p. 709. The authorities in this Court to the contrary are neither numerous nor impressive and have not infrequently been challenged [of. Barahamdeo Prasad v. Banarsi Prasad ]. On principle, and as a matter of construction of Or. 47 of the Code, I approve of the view taken in Ram Lagan Sahu… v. Ram Birich Koeri…Opposite Party. and were it necessary I should desire to refer the matter to a Full Bench.
In the present case, however, the applicants themselves did not even take the precaution of applying by way of review and they succeeded before the District Judge in having the Defendant's appeal dismissed as incompetent. Assuming it to be possible that we should now treat this matter as arising under Or. 47 of the Code by giving leave to the Respondents to pay the necessary court-fees, I am clearly of opinion that we ought not to do so. The method which they have adopted is highly inappropriate to the circumstances of the case, and moreover so long as there is any room for argument to the effect that the applicants, should they fail in review, can proceed all over again by suit, I should be most unwilling to allow the amendment upon any terms.
It has been contended before us that because the Division Bench of this Court which heard the appeal brought from the order made in execution expressed itself as though the best course for the Respondents was to make an application in the suit for amendment of the decree, the present Appellant should be held bound by this expression of opinion and must sit down under the decision of the Subordinate Judge, however disastrous its consequences may be to his business or to his reputation. I am opinion that the remarks made by the Division Bench in the execution matter carry with them no legal consequence whatever and were in the nature of gratuitous advice.
In my judgment the correct course for us is to treat this appeal as an application under sec. 115 of the Civil Procedure Code against the order of the Subordinate Judge and to set aside the whole of the proceedings upon the application for amendment of the decree. It may or may not be that the Respondents, if they bring a suit, will get an allowance under the Limitation Act for the time which has been expended before the Subordinate Judge. It will be a part of our order that the Respondents do pay to the Appellant his costs of the proceedings before the Subordinate Judge and in this Court.
C.C Ghose, J.:— I agree.
Rankin, C.J and C.C Ghose, J.:— The Appellant is entitled to a refund of the court-fee paid on the memorandum of the appeal to this Court less Rs. 10 stamp which would have been paid on the revision application.
P.C
Alert