- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Patel India P Ltd. v. Deputy Commissioner Of Income Tax
Judicial Opinion Summary
Factual and Procedural Background
This is an appeal directed against the order of the Commissioner (Appeals) dated 13-10-1997 relating to the assessment year 1994-95. The assessee had two principal disputes with the assessing officer (AO) and the Commissioner (Appeals):
- Interest disallowance: The assessee had advanced interest-free loans to three sister concerns (A.J. Patel (P) Ltd., Designer (P) Ltd. and Patel India (P) Ltd.). The AO disallowed a portion of interest claimed (making an addition of Rs. 5,15,682) on the ground that interest-bearing borrowed funds were diverted as interest-free advances to sister concerns. The Commissioner (Appeals) upheld the principle but restricted the addition to Rs. 2,74,430, the amount debited to the Profit & Loss account.
- Long-term capital gains valuation: The assessee sold part of a property known as "White House", Walkeshwar Road, Mumbai, by conveyance dated 23-4-1993 for Rs. 4,09,00,000. The assessee computed long-term capital gains (LTCG) at Rs. 1,87,09,390 using a fair market value (FMV) as on 1-4-1981 based on an approved valuer's report (Roshan H. Nanavati). The AO computed a substantially lower FMV as on 1-4-1981 and assessed additional LTCG of Rs. 1,25,17,061, which the Commissioner (Appeals) confirmed.
The assessee appealed to the court on both issues. The appeal raises factual and legal questions about the propriety of the AO's additions and the necessity or mandatory nature of a reference to the departmental Valuation Officer under section 55A of the Income Tax Act for determining FMV as on 1-4-1981.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the assessing officer's disallowance of interest (addition arising from interest-free advances to sister concerns) should be sustained and, if so, to what extent (specifically whether the Commissioner (Appeals) was correct in restricting the addition to Rs. 2,74,430).
- Whether the assessing officer's determination of the fair market value of the property as on 1-4-1981 (resulting in an addition of Rs. 1,25,17,061 to long-term capital gains) is sustainable, and whether the matter should be referred to the departmental Valuation Officer under section 55A of the Income Tax Act.
- Whether a reference to the Valuation Officer under section 55A is mandatory when the assessee produces a report of an approved valuer and the assessing officer disputes that valuation (i.e., the scope and mandatory nature of section 55A, in light of CBDT Circular No.96 and the authority cited by the assessee).
Arguments of the Parties
Assessee's (Appellant's) Arguments
- On the interest disallowance: The assessee contended there were no unsecured loans as at the year end (31-3-1994), and therefore no disallowance of interest was called for. The aggregate advances to the three sister concerns had decreased from Rs. 36,30,411 (as at 31-3-1993) to Rs. 13,07,057 (as at 31-3-1994), which the assessee relied upon to argue against the AO's disallowance.
- On valuation/LTCG: The assessee relied on a valuation report by an approved valuer (Roshan Nanavati) which established FMV as on 1-4-1981 at Rs. 78,87,758 (at Rs. 1,250 per sq. ft.). The assessee argued valuation is a technical matter and, since it furnished a report by an approved valuer, the proper course was to refer the matter to the departmental Valuation Officer under section 55A of the Income Tax Act. The assessee also furnished an affidavit from its Chartered Accountant stating that an oral plea for reference to the valuation cell had been made before the Commissioner (Appeals) and that the Commissioner (Appeals) did not give reasons for not referring the case back.
- The assessee relied on CBDT Circular No.96 dated 25-11-1972 for the scope of section 55A and on the Punjab & Haryana High Court decision in Raj Paul Oswal v. CWT (1988) 171 ITR 489 (P&H) to argue that referral is mandatory in appropriate circumstances.
- On merits, the assessee contended that the sale instances cited by the AO were not comparable (different localities) and that there was rampant understatement of values in sale deeds; the Departmental Valuation Cell itself had valued some Walkeshwar properties at much higher figures in earlier matters, supporting the assessee's contention that AO's FMV was understated.
Departmental Representative's Arguments
- The Departmental Representative (DR) argued there was no evidence of understatement of sale consideration in the sale instances relied upon by the assessing officer, and therefore the assessee should not be permitted to take that plea without proof.
- The DR further submitted that the sale instances used by the assessing officer were nearer in time and location to the property in question and thus the assessing officer was justified in determining the FMV as on 1-4-1981 based on those instances.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Raj Paul Oswal v. CWT, (1988) 171 ITR 489 (Punjab & Haryana High Court) | Relied on by the assessee to argue that a reference to the Valuation Officer is mandatory in circumstances where valuation disputes arise (assessee's position of mandatory reference). | The Court distinguished this authority: it held Raj Paul Oswal arose under section 16A of the Wealth Tax Act where the statutory language specifically prescribed circumstances requiring reference, and therefore the decision does not make section 55A of the Income Tax Act mandatory. The court held Raj Paul was not applicable to section 55A. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court addressed the two principal issues sequentially and applied statutory language, factual findings and administrative guidance to reach its conclusions.
Interest Disallowance (Addition of Rs. 2,74,430)
- The court agreed with the Commissioner (Appeals) that the addition should be sustained to the extent of Rs. 2,74,430. The court noted that the interest-free advances to sister concerns were made in earlier years at a time when the assessee's share capital was only Rs. 15,00,000, and that the shareholders' funds of Rs. 2,15,93,870 as at 31-3-1994 mainly represented accretion by way of capital gains on the sale of a flat in the year relevant to assessment year 1994-95.
- Because the advances were made in earlier years and, in those years, they were made out of borrowed funds, the court concluded the addition of Rs. 2,74,430 was properly sustained. The court therefore rejected the assessee's ground on this issue.
Valuation for Long-Term Capital Gains (Addition of Rs. 1,25,17,061)
- Statutory interpretation of section 55A: The court examined the language of section 55A of the Income Tax Act and CBDT Circular No.96 (25-11-1972) to determine whether a reference to the Valuation Officer was mandatory. The court concluded that section 55A is attracted when the assessing officer is of the opinion that the fair market value of an asset exceeds the value claimed by the assessee. In the present case the factual posture was the reverse (the assessee claimed a higher FMV than the AO's figure), so the statutory provisions referred to by the assessee (ss.55A(a) and 55A(b)(i)) do not mandatorily apply.
- Distinguishing precedent: The court considered the Raj Paul Oswal decision relied upon by the assessee but rejected its application because that decision concerned section 16A of the Wealth Tax Act where the statutory language prescribes specified circumstances mandating reference to the Valuation Officer. The court emphasized that section 55A's language is different and does not create the same mandatory duty.
- Discretion under section 55A(b)(ii): The court recognized that section 55A(b)(ii) permits a reference to the Valuation Officer "when, having regard to the nature of the asset and other relevant circumstances, the Income Tax Officer considers it necessary to do so." The court found that, although a mandatory reference was not required, the particular circumstances of this case brought it within the scope of section 55A(b)(ii).
- Evaluation of evidence and comparative valuations: The court observed that valuation of a flat is highly technical and can vary significantly even within a building. While sale instances cited by the assessing officer supported the department's stance, the court also noted valuations by the Departmental Valuation Officer of other comparable properties as at 1-4-1981 at much higher rates (examples cited in the record: flat No. 201, Jamuna Niketan valued at Rs. 800 per sq. ft. — adjusted to Rs. 1,000 after adding 25% for a commercial character; flat No. 21 B-6 Dongersay Road valued at Rs. 905 — adjusted to Rs. 1,130 after similar adjustment). When compared with these departmental valuations, the AO's value appeared very low.
- Conclusion on referral: Balancing the technical nature of valuation, the presence of other departmental valuations at materially higher figures, and the availability of statutory discretion under section 55A(b)(ii), the court held that the matter deserved to be referred to the departmental Valuation Officer for determination of the fair market value as on 1-4-1981. The court directed that the assessing officer was free to bring all sale instances relied upon to the notice of the Valuation Officer.
- Result on the LTCG addition: Subject to the referral to the Valuation Officer, the court set aside the order of the revenue authorities on the issue of the addition of Rs. 1,25,17,061 under the head long-term capital gains.
Holding and Implications
APPEAL PARTLY ALLOWED
Holding:
- The court sustained the addition of Rs. 2,74,430 (interest disallowance relating to interest-free advances to sister concerns) and therefore rejected the assessee's ground on that point.
- The court set aside the revenue authorities' order insofar as the addition of Rs. 1,25,17,061 under the head long-term capital gains is concerned and directed a reference to the departmental Valuation Officer under section 55A(b)(ii) of the Income Tax Act to determine the fair market value of the property as on 1-4-1981. The assessing officer is permitted to place before the Valuation Officer all sale instances relied upon in the assessment.
Immediate implications and consequences:
- The addition of Rs. 2,74,430 stands confirmed against the assessee.
- The addition of Rs. 1,25,17,061 for long-term capital gains is set aside pending fresh valuation by the departmental Valuation Officer; the final tax consequence on LTCG will depend on the valuation outcome.
- The court clarified that it was not laying down a general rule that references under section 55A are mandatory whenever an assessee produces a registered valuer's report; rather, it exercised the discretion under section 55A(b)(ii) in the particular facts of this case to direct a reference in the interest of justice. Thus, no binding new precedent expanding the mandatory ambit of section 55A was created by this decision.
Disposition recorded in the opinion: The appeal is partly allowed.
M.V.R. Prasad, A.M.
This appeal is directed against the order of the Commissioner (Appeals) dated 13-10-1997 for the assessment year 1994-95. The first ground taken reads as follows :
"On the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the learned Commissioner (Appeals) erred in confirming the addition of the amount of interest not charged from sister concern Designers (P) Ltd. & Patel India (Del) (P) Ltd. against interest-free advances made to them amounting to Rs. 2,74,430".
2. The assessee has advanced certain loans to its sister concerns, (1) AJ. Patel (P) Ltd., (2) Designer (P) Ltd. and (3) Patel India (P) Ltd. The assessing officer made an addition of Rs. 5,15,682 on the ground that the interest on borrowed funds claimed to have been paid by the assessee has to be disallowed to the extent of diversion of funds interest-free to sister concerns. The Commissioner (Appeals), in principle, agreed with the findings of the assessing officer but restricted the addition to only Rs. 2,74,430 on the ground that the amount debited to the Profit and Loss account is only this amount.
3. Before us, the learned counsel for the assessee pleaded that the assessee has no unsecured loans towards the year end, i.e., 31-3-1994, and so, no disallowance out of the interest paid is called for. It is also argued that the aggregate advances to the above three sister concerns have come down from Rs. 36,30,411 as on 31-3-1993, to Rs. 13,07,057 on 31-3-1994.
4. We agree with the findings of the Commissioner (Appeals). We find that the above mentioned interest-free advances were made in the earlier years when the share capital of the assessee was only Rs. 15,00,000. The shareholders' funds of Rs. 2,15,93,870 as on 31-3-1994, represent mainly the accretion by way of capital gains on the sale of a flat during the year of account relevant for the assessment year 1994-95.
As the advances were made in the earlier years and as in those two years they were made only out of borrowed funds, we have to sustain the addition of Rs. 2,74,430. The ground is rejected.
5. The next two grounds relate to the addition of Rs. 1,25,17,061 made by the assessing officer under the head "long term capital gains" and they read as follows :
"2. The learned Commissioner (Appeals) erred in confirming the addition of the amount of Rs. 1,25,17,061 under the head long term capital gains"as under :
L. T. C. G. as calculated by assessing officer 3,12,26,451 L. T. C. G. as per computation of income (-) 1,87,09,390 1,25,17,061
3. Without prejudice to the above, the learned Commissioner (Appeals) erred in not referring the matter for valuation to the valuation cell, since the assessing officer is not a competent person to determine the value of the asset as at 1-4-1981. In view of this, the Commissioner (Appeals) should have set aside the assessment for reference to the Valuation Officer".
6. The assessee- company owned a property named "White House" in Walkeshwar Road, Mumbai, and it sold a part of this property vide a conveyance deed dated 23-4-1993 for a consideration of Rs. 4,09,00,000. It offered the long-term capital gains at Rs. 1,87,09,390 as per the following computation :
Sale proceeds as per conveyance deed dated 23-4- 1993 4,09,00,000 Less: Cost of improvement paid as per conveyance deed dated 23-4- 1993.
Less: Cost of improvement paid as per conveyance deed dated 23-4- 1993.
18,00,000 3,91,00,000 Less: Security deposit (interest-free) incurred in total sale proceeds Less: Security deposit (interest-free) incurred in total sale proceeds 1,00,000 3,90,00,000 Less : Expenditure incurred wholly and exclusively in connection with the transfer of property Less : Expenditure incurred wholly and exclusively in connection with the transfer of property
(a) Legal & professional expenses Paid to Little & Co. Solic Income Tax Officers as per Bill No. 366 of 1994 vide cheque No. 862522 dated 26-3-1994 drawn on Hong Kong and Shanghai Banking Corporation, M.G. Road, Bombay 2,26,500
(b) Brokerage Paid to Laljee Thakkar & Co. by account payee cheques as under :
on 27-1-1994 2,00,000 on 08-2-1994 2,09,000 on 22-3-1994 4,09,000 8,18,000 10,44,500 3,79,55,500 Less: Improved cost of acquisition as per cost-inflation index Less: Improved cost of acquisition as per cost-inflation index Fair market value as at 1-4-1981 Multiplied By cost inflation index of 1993-94 Divided By cost inflation index of 1981-82 (Since property purchased before 1-4-1981) Fair market value as per valuation report dt. 26-2-1994 of Roshan H. Nanavati Rs. 78,87,750 Cost inflation index of 1993-94 Rs. 78,87,750 X 244 1,92,46,110 Long term capital gains on sale of immovable property 1,87,09,390 It may be observed that the assessee opted for the fair market value of the property as on 1-4-1981, as permitted under section 55 of the Income Tax Act. The fair market value as on 1-4-1981, returned by the assessee was supported by a valuation report from an approved valuer, Roshan Nanavati, who valued the property at the rate of Rs. 1,250 per sq. ft. at Rs. 78,87,758 (inclusive of garages, etc.) The assessing officer held that the sale instances cited by the said approved valuer were not really comparable as they related to different localities and he worked out the fair market value as on 1-4-1981, at Rs. 433 per sq. ft. at Rs. 27,57,807 (inclusive of garages, etc.) Thus, there is a big difference between the fair market value as on 1-4- 1981, of the property in question estimated by the approved valuer and that worked out by the assessing officer. The Commissioner (Appeals) agreed with the findings of the assessing officer and confirmed the addition made by the assessing officer.
7. Before us, the learned counsel for the assessee pleaded that valuation is a technical matter and as the assessee has returned the fair market value as on 1-4-1981, of the property in question on the basis of the report of the approved valuer, the minimum that should have been done was to refer the property to the valuation cell of the department under section 55A of the Income Tax Act. It is also mentioned that an argument to this effect was raised orally before the Commissioner (Appeals) but the Commissioner (Appeals) did not agree. In this context, the learned counsel for the assessee has also filed an affidavit dated 28-5-1998, from the Chartered Accountant of the assessee, Atul Arun Kumar Mehta, which reads as follows:
"1. Atul Arunkumar Mehta, Chartered Accountant of Patel India (P) Ltd., do hereby solemnly affirm and declare as under :
1. That I had attended before the Commissioner (Appeals), XL, Mumbai Shri Beharilal in the appeal of Patel India (P) Ltd. for the assessment year 1994-95.
2. That in the course of hearing, an oral plea for sending the appeal back to the assessing officer for reference to the valuation cell was made.
3. That from the reading of the Commissioner (Appeals), XL, Mumbai, Order, the honourable Commissioner (Appeals) did not consider this plea and has not given any reasons for not referring the case back to the assessing officer.
Solemnly affirmed and declared This 28-5-1998. "
It is pleaded that under the provisions of section 55 it is mandatory for the assessing officer to have made the reference to the valuation officer and as he has not made the reference, the fair market value worked out by him is vitiated and it is not valid in law. In this context, reliance is placed upon the Circular No 96 dated 25-11-1972 of the CBDT, which explains the scope of section 55A and may be seen at p. 2126 of Chaturvedi & Pithisaria Vol. 2, Fourth Edition, which reads as follows :
'26. A new section 55A has been inserted in the Income Tax Act enabling the Income Tax Officer to refer the valuation of any capital asset to the valuation officer with a view to ascertaining the market value of such asset. References under this section will lie only after 31-12-1972, as the provisions of section 2 of the Amending Act will come into force with effect from 1-1-1973.
Under the new provision, an Income Tax Officer may refer the valuation of any capital asset to a valuation officer in a case where the assessee has got the assets valued by a registered valuer and the Income Tax Officer is of opinion that the value as estimated by the registered valuer (i.e., a person registered as a valuer under section 34AB of the Wealth Tax Act) is less than the fair market value of the asset. Other cases in which a reference may be made to the valuation officer would be where the Income Tax Officer is of opinion that the fair market value of the asset exceeds the value of the asset as claimed by more than 15 per cent of the value claimed or by more than Rs. 25,000, whichever is less or where, having. regard to the nature of the asset and other relevant circumstances, the Income Tax Officer considers it necessary to do so. It will be seen that in case where the assessee has opted for substitution of the cost of acquisition of an asset by its fair market value as on 1-1-1954, the fair market value as claimed by him may be higher than its actual fair market value. The provisions of section 55a(a) and (b)(i) will, therefore, not apply in such a case. It will however, be open to the Income Tax Officer to make a reference to the valuation officer under section 55a(b)(ii)."
The learned counsel for the assessee has also relied on the decision of the Hon'ble Punjab & Haryana High Court in the case of Raj Paul Oswal v. CWT (1988) 171 ITR 489 (P&H), in the light of which, according to the learned counsel, such a reference is mandatory.
On merits, it is explained that Shri Roshan Nanavati has given a rejoinder dated 28-9-1997, which was produced before the Commissioner (Appeals) and has mentioned in this rejoinder that the Departmental Valuation Cell itself valued the properties even in Walkeshwar as on 1-4-1981, at much higher figures. So, it is pleaded that the sale instances cited by the assessing officer cannot be taken as reflecting the correct values because of the rampant understatement of values in the sale deeds.
8. It is also pleaded that the value worked out by the assessing officer is so low that if the cost of construction and the contractors profits normally accepted are reduced therefrom, the land value would work out to a ridiculously low figure. So, it is requested that in the interests of justice, the property in question should be got valued by the valuation cell.
9. The learned Departmental Representative on the other hand, pleaded that there is no evidence of understatement of sale consideration in the sale instances cited by the assessing officer and so, the assessee should not be allowed to take such a plea. It is also pleaded that the sale instances quoted by the assessing officer are much nearer in time and location to the property in question sold by the assessee and as such, the assessing officer was justified in working out the fair market value as on 1-4-1981, on the basis of the sale instances gathered by him.
10. We are of the view that the matter deserves to be sent to the valuation cell for working out the fair market value as on 1-4-1981. However, we make it clear that we do not agree with the argument of the learned counsel for the assessee that such a reference under section 55A of the Act is mandatory. The decision of the Hon'b1e Punjab & Haryana High Court in the case of Raj Paul Oswal v. CIT cited (supra) by the learned counsel for the assessee was given in the Context of section 16A of the Wealth Tax Act and the language of this section is totally different from that of section 55A of the Income Tax Act. Under section 16A of the Wealth Tax Act, specified circumstances are laid down under which a reference has to be made to the Valuation Officer and it is because of the specification of the circumstances, the Hon'ble High Court held that a reference is mandatory when those circumstances are specified. Such is not the case under section 55A of the Income Tax Act. The provisions of section 55A are attracted only when the assessing officer is of the opinion that the fair market value of the assets exceeds the value of the assets as claimed by the assessee and not in a reverse case such as the present one where the assessee claims that the value as on 1-4-1981, exceeds the fair market value determined by the assessing officer. So, on the plain language of the section, the provisions of sections 55a(a) and (b)(i) are not attracted and that is also made clear by the Board's Circular No. 96 dated 25-11-1972, extracted hereinabove. As mentioned in the above circular, a reference can be made under section 55a(b)(ii) when having regard to the nature of the asset and other relevant circumstances, it is necessary so to do. In the circumstances, we hold that it is not correct to say that it was mandatory in the present case to have made a reference under section 55a(a) or 55a(b)(i).
11. However, we are of the view that valuation of a flat is highly technical matter and varies not only from road to road but between building and building and even between one flat and another in the same building while the sale instances taken by the assessing officer definitely support the stand of the department. We also find that there are other properties which have been valued by the Departmental Valuation Officer as on 1-4-1981 at much higher figures. For example, at p. 75 of the assessee's paper-book, there is a report in respect of flat No. 201, Jamuna Niketan Manav Mandir Road, Mumbai-6, which has been valued as on 1-4-1981, at Rs. 800 per sq. ft. This is only a residential property and the assessing officer himself has given 25 per cent addition for a commercial property like the flat of the assessee. So, the valuation of Rs. 800 has to be increased by another 200 rupees and that gives a value of Rs. 1,000 as on 1-4-1981. Similarly, there is another property, flat No. 21 B-6 Dongersay Road, which has been valued by the valuation cell under section 55A as on 1-4-1981, at Rs. 905 per sq. ft. This is also a residential property and this valuation has also to be increased by 25 per cent and it gives a valuation of Rs. 1, 130 per sq. ft. Compared to this valuation, the value worked out by the assessing officer is very low. In the circumstances, in the interest of justice, we are of the view that the matter deserves to be referred to the valuation cell for working out the fair market value as on 1-4-1981. Reference may be made under section 55A(b)(ii) of the Income Tax Act. We direct accordingly. The assessing officer is free to bring all the sale instances on which he has relied in the assessment order to the notice of the valuation officer.
12. Subject to the above remarks, we set aside the order of the revenue authorities on the issue of addition of Rs. 1,25,17,061 under the head long-term capital gains.
13. The appeal is partly allowed.
Alert