Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

The State Of Punjab And Others v. Shamsher Singh And Others

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Oct 11, 1965
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary — Mehar Singh, J. (with P.C. Pandit, J. concurring)

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent Angrez Singh held 130 standard acres and 1/4 unit in village Bhatgaon Dungran (alias Rattan Garh), Sonepat Tehsil, Rohtak District. Between 15 August 1947 and 15 April 1953 he split the holding into three lots, gifting 43 standard acres and 13½ units to his son Ranbir Singh, 43 standard acres and ½ unit to his wife Bholi, and retaining 43 standard acres and 2¼ units with himself. The Punjab Security of Land Tenures Act, 1953 (Punjab Act 10 of 1953) came into force on 15 April 1953; the transfers to his son and wife were made before the Act's commencement and thus were not affected by it, according to the opinion.

Subsequently (1 and 20 June 1956, and 26 June 1958) Angrez Singh, Ranbir Singh and Bholi sold various portions of their lands to third parties. Those sales were subject to and defeated by pre-emption decrees obtained by Shamsher Singh and Jangbir Singh (grand nephews of Angrez Singh), who thereby took possession.

On 18 July 1960 the Assistant Collector First Grade (appellant 3) declared certain areas from Angrez Singh, Ranbir Singh and Bholi as surplus under the Act. Because the sales had been pre-empted after the Act's commencement and thus were not effective for purposes of utilization of surplus area from the vendors, the Assistant Collector declared the same areas with Shamsher Singh and Jangbir Singh as surplus. The two pre-emptors challenged these administrative orders in writ petitions after failing in appeal and revision.

A learned Single Judge (on 14 May 1962), following his earlier decision in Bhalle Ram v. The State of Punjab, allowed the writ petitions of Shamsher Singh and Jangbir Singh and quashed the orders of the Collector and Commissioner. The State, the Commissioner and the Assistant Collector filed three Letters Patent Appeals (L.P.As. Nos. 254, 256 and 257 of 1962) against those Single Judge orders. One appeal (L.P.A. No. 256 of 1962, arising out of C.W. 281 of 1961) was heard by a Division Bench (Dulat and Grover, JJ.) and on 7 May 1963 reversed the Single Judge and remitted the matter for disposal on other questions on merits; the Division Bench reasoned that an amendment (Punjab Security of Land Tenures (Amendment and Validation) Act, 1962 — Punjab Act 14 of 1962) amended section 10A and thereby removed the basis for the Single Judge's decision in Bhalle Ram.

Because the three writ petitions (C.Ws. Nos. 281, 282 and 283 of 1961) were essentially identical and challenged the same legal point with respect to three separate pieces of land (each obtained by Shamsher Singh and Jangbir Singh by pre-emption), the court concluded that the decisions in L.P.As. Nos. 254 and 257 must conform to the result in L.P.A. No. 256.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether transfers of portions of a landowner's holding made before the commencement of the Punjab Security of Land Tenures Act, 1953 are affected by the Act.
  2. Whether, for the purpose of declaring surplus land under the Act, the surplus should be taken out of the permissible area of the original vendor (ignoring subsequent pre-emption) or should be taken from the land that came into the hands of pre-emptors as a result of sales that occurred after the Act came into force.
  3. Whether an amendment to the Act (Punjab Act 14 of 1962, which amended section 10A) removes the legal basis of an earlier Single Judge decision (Bhalle Ram) so as to justify reversal on appeal.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants (State of Punjab, Commissioner of Ambala Division, Assistant Collector)

  • The appellants relied on the effect of the legislative amendment (Punjab Security of Land Tenures (Amendment and Validation) Act, 1962 — Punjab Act 14 of 1962), which amended section 10A of the principal Act and, as contended and accepted by the Division Bench, took away the basis of the Single Judge's earlier decision in Bhalle Ram v. The State of Punjab.
  • On that basis, the Division Bench reversed the Single Judge's quashing orders and remitted the matter for further disposal of other questions on the merits.

Respondents (Shamsher Singh and Jangbir Singh)

  • Their counsel relied upon the observations in Mota Singh v. Financial Commissioner, Punjab, contending that where lands were sold by the original vendors (Angrez Singh, Ranbir Singh and Bholi), the surplus area should be accounted out of the permissible area remaining with each vendor and not from the land that came into the pre-emptors' hands by virtue of the subsequent sales.
  • The respondents argued that the Division Bench's pronouncements in Gobind Singh and related Financial Commissioner decisions support treating alienations as not invalidated by the Act for purposes of determining permissible and surplus area, subject to exceptions for misrepresentation or unfairness on the facts.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bhalle Ram v. The State of Punjab (1962 64 PLR 331) Single Judge decision earlier followed by the learned Single Judge in the present matters; had led to quashing orders in the writ petitions. The Division Bench found that a subsequent statutory amendment (Punjab Act 14 of 1962) altered section 10A and thereby removed the basis of the Single Judge's decision in Bhalle Ram; as a result, the Single Judge's orders were reversed in appeals that related to identical issues.
Mota Singh v. Financial Commissioner, Punjab Raised the point that surplus should be computed from the vendor's permissible area, not from land that later came to pre-emptors; contains observations relied on by respondents' counsel. The court analyzed the reported observations and explained why reliance on a part of Mota Singh was misplaced; ultimately held that nothing decisive turned on that argument in the present appeals.
Gobind Singh v. Punjab State (1963 65 P.L.R 105) Division Bench decision which followed the ratio in Hira Singh and Sapooran Singh to the effect that the Act does not invalidate alienations and that total holding ignoring alienations is to be considered for permissible area. The court treated Gobind Singh as endorsing Hira Singh and Sapooran Singh and clarified that Gobind Singh did not accept Pirtha Singh as a correct general rule; the present court relied on this line of authorities to explain the precedential landscape and why certain factual distinctions matter.
Pirtha Singh v. The Punjab State (Financial Commissioner decision; 1961 40 L.L.T 68) A Financial Commissioner's decision differing from Hira Singh and Sapooran Singh; took the view that alienations might be treated differently where there was non-disclosure or unfairness to the alienee. The court distinguished Pirtha Singh on its facts, observing that Pirtha Singh appeared to rest on a finding of unfair dealing or non-disclosure and thus could be reconciled with Hira Singh and Sapooran Singh rather than treated as a general rule.
Hira Singh v. The State Financial Commissioner decision holding that the Act does not invalidate alienations and that total holding ignoring alienations is to be considered for determining permissible and surplus area. The court (via Gobind Singh and the present analysis) accepted Hira Singh as a correct decision forming part of the precedent supporting the proposition that alienations per se are not invalidated by the Act.
Sapooran Singh v. The Punjab State Decision aligned with Hira Singh that alienations are not invalidated by the Act and total holding is to be taken into account for permissible area. The court treated Sapooran Singh together with Hira Singh as correctly decided precedents that informed the Division Bench's approach in Gobind Singh and the court's assessment of competing authorities in the present matter.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded by identifying the temporal facts (transfers by Angrez Singh pre-Act; sales later pre-empted after the Act) and tracing the procedural history of the writ petitions and appeals. The key legal pivot was the effect of subsequent statutory amendment on prior judicial decisions:

  1. The Single Judge had followed his earlier decision in Bhalle Ram and quashed the administrative orders declaring surplus; the State appealed those decisions.
  2. A Division Bench (hearing L.P.A. No. 256 of 1962) reversed the Single Judge in that specific appeal on the ground that the Punjab Security of Land Tenures (Amendment and Validation) Act, 1962 (Punjab Act 14 of 1962) amended section 10A in a manner that removed the legal basis for the Single Judge's reliance on Bhalle Ram. The Division Bench therefore remitted the petition for disposal of other questions on merits.
  3. Because the three writ petitions (C.Ws. Nos. 281, 282 and 283 of 1961) were identical in their pleadings and issues (each challenging orders with respect to distinct parcels obtained by pre-emption), the court held that the outcomes of L.P.As. Nos. 254 and 257 must conform to the Division Bench's determination in L.P.A. No. 256.
  4. The court addressed respondent counsel's reliance on Mota Singh and the associated line of Financial Commissioner decisions (Hira Singh, Sapooran Singh, Pirtha Singh, Gobind Singh). The opinion explains that Gobind Singh had accepted the ratio of Hira Singh and Sapooran Singh (that the Act does not invalidate alienations and that total holding ignoring alienations is the basis for permissible area), and that Pirtha Singh was distinguishable on its facts (possibly involving nondisclosure or unfair dealing). The court clarified that the Mota Singh report might give an impression to the contrary, but on careful reading Gobind Singh did not adopt Pirtha Singh as the general rule.
  5. Having resolved that the amendment to section 10A removed the legal foundation of the Single Judge's prior decision, and given the identity of the three writ petitions, the court concluded that the two Letters Patent Appeals under consideration (Nos. 254 and 257 of 1962) must be decided consistently with the result in L.P.A. No. 256, leading to reversal of the Single Judge's orders in those matters.

The court expressly states that nothing decisive turns on the respondents' argument drawn from Mota Singh once the precedential distinctions and the statutory amendment are taken into account.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The judgments of the learned Single Judge under appeal in Letters Patent Appeals Nos. 254 and 257 of 1962 are reversed. Each of the two writ petitions (Nos. 282 and 283 of 1961) is remitted to the learned Single Judge for disposal of the other questions involved on the merits. There is no order as to costs.

IMPLICATIONS:

  • The immediate effect is reversal of the Single Judge's quashing orders in the two appeals and remittal for further consideration of the remaining issues in the corresponding writ petitions.
  • The decision relies on a subsequent legislative amendment (Punjab Act 14 of 1962) altering section 10A, and the court treated that amendment as removing the basis of the earlier Single Judge decision (Bhalle Ram). The opinion does not purport to lay down a new general precedent beyond the application of existing authorities and the effect of the statutory amendment; it thus primarily affects the parties in the litigation by sending the matters back for further adjudication on merits.
  • No costs were ordered; the opinion does not record any broader legal rule newly established by this judgment beyond the interpretive conclusions drawn from the authorities and the statute as applied to the facts.

Order accordingly. (P.C. Pandit, J. concurred.)

Show all summary ...

Mehar Singh, J.:— The holding of Angrez Singh respondent was 130 standard acres and ¼ unit in his village Bhatgaon Dungran, alias Rattan Garh, in Sonepat Tehsil of Rohtak District. This total area was split up by him into three lots between August 15, 1947 and April 15, 1953, whereby he made a gift of 43 standard acres and 13½ units to his son Ranbir Singh, respondent, and 43 standard acres and ½ unit to his wife Bholi, respondent, leaving with himself 43 standard acres and 2¼ units of land. The Punjab Security of Land Tenures Act, 1953 (Punjab Act 10 of 1953), came into force on April 15, 1953; and the transfers were made by Angrez Singh respondent in the name of his son and his wife before the coming into force of the Act, which therefore, does not effect those transfers.

2. Subsequently on June 1, and 20, 1956, and June 26, 1958, those three respondents, namely, Angrez Singh, his son Ranbir Singh, and his wife Bholi, sold various areas of land with them to third persons, which sales were pre-empted by Shamsher Singh and Jangbir Singh, respondents, grand nephews of Angrez Singh respondent, and in consequence of the pre-emption decrees those two pre-emptors took possession of the lands sold by the other three respondents as named above.

3. On July 18, 1960 appellant 3, Assistant Collector First Grade of Sonepat, under the provisions of the Act declared 13 standard acres and 2½ units, 13 standard acres and 13½ units, and 13 standard acres and ¼ units, of agricultural land as surplus respectively from Angrez Singh, Ranbir Singh and Bholi, respondents, but as the sales which had been pre-empted by Shamsher Singh and Jangbir Singh respondents, were after the coming into force of the Act and thus were not effected for the purposes of utilization of the surplus area of the vendors-respondents, appellant 3 declared those areas with Shamsher Singh and Jangbir Singh, respondents, as surplus. Those two respondents failed in appeal and revision and came in writ petitions to this Court challenging the orders of the authorities under the Act.

4. On May 14, 1962, a learned Single Judge following his earlier decision in Bhalle Ram v. The State of Punjab . 1962 64 PLR 331., allowed the writ petitions of respondents Shamsher Singh and Jangbir Singh, quashing the orders of the Collector and the Commissioner. Against the judgment of the learned Judge, the State of Punjab, the Commissioner of Ambala Division and the Assistant Collector 1st Grade of Sonepat, appellants 1 to 3, filed three appeals under clause 10 of the Letters Patent.

5. Those are L.P.As Nos. 254, 256 and 257 of 1962. The reason why three appeals have been filed by the appellants is that there were three separate orders by the learned Single Judge, deciding the same point with regard to the three sales made by respondents Angrez Singh, Ranbir Singh and Bholi the lands of which, on successful pre-emption suits, came into the possession of Shamsher Singh and Jangbir Singh respondents, who, therefore, filed three separate writ petitions challenging the orders of the appellants declaring surplus area with each one of the three vendors-respondents. One of those appeals, which is L.P.A No. 256 of 1962, arising out of C.W 281 of 1961, was heard by a Division Bench consisting of Dulat and Grover, JJ., and on May 7, 1963, the learned Judges reversed the decision of the learned Single Judge and remitted C.W 281 of 1961 to the learned Single Judge for disposal of the other questions arising in the petition on merits. The reason why the learned Judges reversed the judgment of the learned Single Judge was that after the decision in Bhalle Ram v. The State of Punjab, there was an amendment of the Act by the Punjab Security of Land Tenures (Amendment and Validation) Act, 1982 (Punjab Act 14 of 1962), in which section 4 has amended section 10A of the Act, and in that manner has taken away the basis of the judgment in Bhalle Ram's case. This argument prevailed with the learned Judges and they reversed that decision. The learned Single Judge had quashed the orders of the Collector and the Commissioner in C.Ws Nos. 281 and 283 of 1961, out of which L.P.As Nos. 254 and 257 of 1962 have arisen, following his earlier decision in Bhalle Ram's case, and as the learned Judges reversed that Judgment, so in L.P.A No. 256 of 1932 they reversed the judgment of the learned Single Judge in C.W No. 281 of 1961.

6. When C.Ws Nos. 281, 282 and 283 of 1961 are compared, each one is a copy of the other two to the last word, and it had to be so because Shamsher Singh and Jangbir Singh, respondents, have challenged the validity of the orders of the appellants under the pro visions of the Act with regard to each one of the three pieces of land which they obtained under three pre-emption decrees following upon the three sales by Angrez Singh, Ranbir Singh and Bholi, respondents. It is obvious that the decision in these two appeals, Nos. 254 and 257 of 1962 has to be according to the decision in appeal No. 256 of 1962.

7. The learned counsel for Shamsher Singh and Jangbir Singh, respondents, however, refers to Mota Singh v. Financial Commissioner, Punjab,2 and contends that the lands having been sold by Angrez Singh, Ranbir Singh, and Bholi, respondents, the surplus area should come out of the permissible area with each one of those respondents and not from the land that has come to them on pre-emption in consequence of sales effected by those three respondents. In that case Grover, J. has followed a Division Bench decision, to which I was a party, in Gobind Singh v. Punjab State . 1963 65 P.L.R 105.. In the last mentioned case, three cases decided by the Financial Commissioners Pirtha Singh v. The Punjab State . 1961 40 L.L.T 68., Hira Singh v. The State,5 and Sapooran Singh v. The Punjab State,6 were considered and it was held that the decision in the last mentioned two cases, that is to say, Hira Singh's case and Sapooran Singh's case, was the correct decision to the effect that the Act does not invalidate alienations of an area from the holding of a land-owner in which there is subsequently found to be surplus area, and all that it does is to provide in section 10A that the total holding of the land-owner, ignoring the alienation or alienations, will be taken into consideration for determination of permissible area and surpuls area. There is nothing in the Act which deprived the land-owner of his right to dispose of any part of his holding simply because subsequently it may be found that part of his holding comes to be surplus area. In Pirtha Singh's case the learned Financial Commissioner had taken a contrary view and against his own judgment in Hira Singh's case. We approved the Financial Commissioners' decisions in Hira Singh's and Sapooran Singh's cases, but distinguished Pirtha Singh's case on the ground that in that case the learned Financial Commissioner proceeded on the basis that the land owner had sold the land ‘without obviously disclosing that some of his land would be declared surplus area including that sold’, and we consider that in this approach the learned Financial Commissioner probably was of the opinion that some kind of misrepresentation or fraud had been practiced on the alienee. We noted that the judgment of the learned Financial Commissioner did not say that such a misrepresentation was pointed out by the alienee or that there was any evidence in support of it. We, therefore, attempted a reconciliation of the cases of inconsistent decisions in Hira Singh's case and Pirtha Singh's case on the ground that the learned Financial Commissioner found in the latter case that the dealing was unfair and inequitable inasmuch as the land-owner in that case did not disclose the facts which the learned Financial Commissioner thought ought to have been disclosed to the alienee. It was, therefore, that on facts we distinguished Pirtha Singh's case from the case of Hira Singh and Sapooran Singh. All the three cases were cited before the learned Judge in Mota Singh's case and it was contended that the Division Bench in Gobind Singh's case having accepted the ratio in Hira Singh's and Sapooran Singh's cases had not accepted the correctness of the decision in Pirtha Singh's case. The opposite side argued that the Division Bench did not overrule the decision in Pirtha Singh's case. The learned Judge proceeded to observe that “it seems to me that so far as Mota Singh's petition is concerned that cannot succeed and must be dismissed because in the Bench decision itself the Financial Commissioner's view was not set aside, although the whole question came up for consideration. It may be that the other observations of the Bench that there should be a clear allegation of misrepresentation, fraud or deceit have to be borne in mind but at the same time it is not possible to lose sight of the fact that the Bench did not consider that Pirtha Singh v. The Punjab State was decided erroneously on its facts.” It is this part of the observation of the learned Judge that the learned counsel for Shamsher Singh and Jangbir Singh, respondents, relies upon. With all respect to the learned Judge, when at the time of decision of Gobind Singh's case we considered Pirtha Singh's case we considered that case as a precedent and we neither decided nor had the right to decide any question of fact in that case. We could not say that the finding of fact in Pirtha Singh's case was right or wrong because that case was not before us for hearing on merits. It was a case cited before us as a precedent and we found that the same learned Financial Commissioner had given an inconsistent decision in Hira Singh's case, which was followed by another learned Financial Commissioner in Sapooran Singh's case. On review of the argument we came to the conclusion that the decisions of the Financial Commissioners in Hira Singh's case and Sapooran Singh's case were the correct decisions, and it follows that the decision in Pirtha Singh's case could not be correct, except on the facts upon which the learned Financial Commissioner proceeded in that case, but we did not, and, as I have said, we could not give a decision on facts in Pircha Singh's case, while deciding Gobind Singh's case. It has been necessary to make this clear because the report in Mota Singh's case is likely to lead to a wrong empression that the Division Bench in Gobind Singh's case did not dissent from the decision in Pirtha Singh's case. It in fact did, but it did not consider it necessary to say that Pirtha Singh's case was wrongly decided because certain questions of fact were involved in it, and it could not give decision in Gobind Singh's case affecting the decision in Pirtha Singh's case. In so far as the question of law decided by the cases of Pirtha Singh, Hira Singh and Sapooran Singh is concerned, we left no manner of doubt in Gobind Singh's case that we were of the opinion that the decisions in Hira Singh's case and Sapooran Singh's case are correct decisions and not so in Pirtha Singh's case. I have stated this again for the sake of clarity. Nothing turns on this argument of the learned counsel for Shamsher Singh and Jangbir Singh, respondents.

8. In the end the learned counsel on both sides are agreed that in these two Letters Patent Appeals Nos. 254 and 257 of 1962 the order must be consistent with the decision of the learned Judges of the Division Bench in Letters Patent Appeal No. 256 of 1962, decided on May 7, 1963. On this approach the two judgments under appeal of the learned Single Judge are reversed, and each one of the two writ petitions Nos. 282 and 283 of 1981 are sent back to the learned Single Judge for disposal of the other questions involved in the same. There is no order in regard to costs.

9. P.C Pandit, J.:— I agree.

10. Order accordingly.