Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Uttar Pradesh Co-Operative Union And Others v. Prabhu Dayal Srivastava And Others

Allahabad High Court
Apr 18, 1988
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petition concerns whether an employee of the Uttar Pradesh Co-operative Union (the Union), an apex co-operative society registered under the Uttar Pradesh Co-operative Societies Act, 1965, is entitled to gratuity benefits payable under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972. The respondent, Sri Prabhu Dayal Srivastava, was employed by the Union and retired as a supervisor on 30 November 1976 after reaching superannuation age. He filed an application on 28 September 1977 before the Controlling Authority under the Payment of Gratuity Act claiming entitlement to gratuity, which was denied by the petitioners. The petitioners raised a preliminary objection that the Union was not an "establishment" within the meaning of Sections 1(3)(b) and 1(3)(c) of the Act, and thus the Act did not apply to its employees. This preliminary objection was rejected by the Controlling Authority on 22 May 1979, leading to the present petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India challenging that order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Uttar Pradesh Co-operative Union qualifies as an "establishment" under Sections 1(3)(b) or 1(3)(c) of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972.
  2. Whether employees of the Union are entitled to gratuity benefits under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The Uttar Pradesh Co-operative Union is not an "establishment" within the meaning of Sections 1(3)(b) or 1(3)(c) of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972.
  • Therefore, the provisions of the Act do not apply to the Union or its employees.

Respondent's Arguments

  • Although the term "establishment" is not explicitly defined in the Act, it has a comprehensive meaning that includes organized bodies maintained for a purpose.
  • The Union, as an organized body employing persons to perform legal duties, qualifies as an "establishment" under Sections 1(3)(b) or 1(3)(c) of the Act.
  • Hence, the employees of the Union are entitled to gratuity benefits under the Act.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Orissa v. Titaghar Paper Mills Company, Ltd. [1985 Supp SCC 280 : AIR 1985 SC 1296] Use of dictionary meanings to interpret undefined statutory terms, with contextual relevance. The Court relied on this precedent to justify consulting dictionary definitions to interpret the term "establishment" in the absence of a statutory definition.
I.S Aziz Pasha v. Union of India [AIR 1968 SC 662] Interpretation of the term "establishment" in Article 30(1) of the Constitution as "to bring into existence." The Court referred to this case to clarify the meaning of "establishment" as bringing into existence, supporting a broad understanding of the term.
V. Transport (Private) Ltd. v. Regional Provident Fund Commissioner, Madras [AIR 1965 Mad. 466] Definition of "establishment" as an organization employing persons where employer-employee relationship exists. The Court applied this principle to hold that the Union qualifies as an establishment since it employs persons and the employer-employee relationship exists.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by examining the relevant statutory provisions of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, particularly Section 1(3), which specifies the applicability of the Act to various categories including shops and establishments. The Court interpreted the conjunctive word "and" in Section 1(3)(b) disjunctively as "or" based on legislative intent and context, distinguishing between establishments related to shops and other establishments specified under Section 1(3)(c).

Recognizing the Act as progressive social legislation, the Court emphasized that its provisions must be construed to promote its purpose — providing gratuity benefits to employees. The Court noted that the term "establishment" is not defined in the Act or the General Clauses Act, thus resorting to authoritative dictionary meanings, which describe an establishment as an organized body or place of business with employees.

The Court found that the Uttar Pradesh Co-operative Union is an organized body employing persons to perform duties for its objectives, thus fitting the definition of an "establishment" under the Act. The employer-employee relationship was found to exist between the Union and its employees. Consequently, the Court held that the Act applies to the Union's employees and the respondent's application for gratuity was maintainable. The preliminary objection raised by the petitioners was correctly rejected by the Controlling Authority.

Holding and Implications

The Court dismissed the petition, affirming that the Uttar Pradesh Co-operative Union qualifies as an "establishment" under Sections 1(3)(b) or 1(3)(c) of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, and that its employees are entitled to gratuity benefits under the Act. The Court ordered no costs.

The direct effect of this decision is that the employees of the Union are entitled to gratuity payments as per the Act. The opinion does not establish any new precedent beyond the application of established interpretative principles to the facts of this case.

Show all summary ...

Yadav, J.:— Whether an employee of the Uttar Pradesh Co-operative Union (for short the Union) (an apex co-operative society registered under the Uttar Pradesh Co-operative Societies Act, 1965), is entitled to benefits of gratuity payable under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 (for short the Act), is the point for our consideration in this petition filed under Art. 226 of the Constitution of India.

2. The facts are admitted. Opposite party 1 Sri Prabhu Dayal Srivastava was an employee of the Union and he retired on. 30 November, 1976 as supervisor after completing the age of superannuation. He filed an application, dated 28 September, 1977 (vide annexure A II) before the Controlling Authority under the Act claiming that he was entitled to gratuity payable under the Act, but the same was not being paid to him by the petitioners. When notices were served on petitioners a preliminary objection was raised on behalf of them that Ss. 1(3)(b) and 1(3)(c) of the Act are not applicable to the employees of Uttar Pradesh Co-operative Union or the Federal Authority as the petitioners were not “establishment” within the meaning of Ss. 1(3)(6) and 1(3)(c) of the Act. The preliminary objection was rejected by the impugned order, dated 22 May, 1979 (annexure A III). Against that order the present petition has been filed.

3. Sri Triloki Nath, learned counsel for the petitioners urged that the Co-operative Union or the Federal Authority, petitioner 1 was not “an establishment” within the meaning of S. 1(3)(b) or S. 1(3)(c) of the Act, hence the Act would not apply. Learned counsel for the respondent on the other hand urged that even though the “establishment” was not a defined term, but nevertheless it has got such a comprehensive connotation that the employees of petitioner 1 coupled with the legal duties they perform, is certainly an organized body of men maintained for that purpose and certainly it is covered by the expression “establishment” used under S. 1(3)(b) or S. 1(3)(c) of the Act. Hence the benefit of gratuity is certainly available to the employees of petitioner 1.

4. In order to appreciate the controversy involved, it is better to set out relevant statutory provision of the Act as under:

“1. Short title, extent, application and commencement: This Act may be called the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972.

(3) It shall apply to—

(a) every factory, mine, oilfield, plantation, port and railway company;

(b) every shop or establishment within the meaning of any law for the time being in force in relation to shops and establishments in a State, in which ten or more persons are employed, or were employed, on any day of the preceding twelve months;

(c) such other establishments or class of establishments, in which ten or more employees are employed, or were employed, on any day of the preceding twelve months, as the Central Government may, by notification, specify in this behalf.”

5. We are conscious that the Act is a progressive, social and beneficial legislation and it has to be interpreted as to promote the purpose or object of the Act. In such matters the construction that promotes the purpose of legislation should be preferred rather than just a literal construction. Under S. 1(3)(c) the relevant clause is “such other establishment” in a State in which ten or more persons are employed or were employed on any day of the preceding twelve months. The preceding Cl. 1(3)(b) was “every shop or establishment within the meaning of any law for the time being in force in relation to shops and establishment in a State.” The word “and” even though appears to be conjunction, but keeping in view the legislative intent and applying elementary principles of textual and contextual interpretation it appears to have the meaning of “or” and has been accordingly, used in a disjunctive sense. This preceding clause under S. 1(3)(b) to the effect “every shop or establishment within the meaning of any law for the time being in force in relation to shops” has got a complete meaning with the establishment pertaining to shops. There was no sense in using the word “and,” a conjunction, and to add subsequent clause “establishment in a State” in which ten or more persons are employed. This obviously indicates that subsequent expression “establishment in a State” has been used in an independent and different sense than the preceding clause and has nothing to do with the establishment in relation to shops. In our opinion the word “and” has been used disjuntively to mean “or.” We are conscious that the word “or” is antithesis of word “and” and the meaning of word “and” has to be sparingly interpreted as “or.” The context of expression has been used under Sub-cl. (b) or Sub-cl. (c) of S. 1(3) of the Act. Keeping in view of the intention and purpose of legislation to provide gratuity to employees drawing wages up to Rs. 270 per month or otherwise. The object of the Act can also be in brief looked into, which is to the following effect:

“The Bill provides for payment of gratuity to employees drawing wages up to Rs. 750 per month in factories, plantations, shops, establishments and mines, in the event of superannuation, retirement, resignation and death or total disablement due to accident or disease. The quantum of gratuity payable will be 15 days' wages based on the rate of wages last drawn by the employees concerned for every completed year of service or part thereof in excess of six months subject to a maximum of 15 months' wages. The term wages means basic wages plus dearness allowance.”

6. In the aforesaid object of the Act it has been clearly specified that the employees of factories, plantations, shops, establishments and mines have been separately provided. It means that the object of legislation was to provide benefit of gratuity to establishments independently of shops.

7. Much emphasis was laid by the learned counsel for petitioner on the word “establishment” used in second clause after the word “and.” the word “establishment” is, however, not a defined term either under the Act or under the General Clauses Act. It is now well-settled principle that dictionary meaning of a word cannot be looked into in case the word has been defined statutorily or has been judicially defined. But where there is no such definition or interpretation, the Court can take the aid of dictionaries to ascertain the meaning in common parlance. In doing so the Court must bear in mind that the words are used in different sense according to its context and the dictionary gives all the meaning of a word and the Court would, therefore, have to select from the meaning which would be relevant to the contest in which it has to interpret the words. See State of Orissa v. Titaghar Paper Mills Company, Ltd. [1985 Supp SCC 280 : A.I.R 1985 S.C 1296].

8. It is better to have some dictionary meanings of the word “establishment.” According to Black's Law Dictionary the word “establishment” connotes an institute, a place where conducted, to settle or fix firmly, place of a permanent footing. According to Words and Phrases (Permanent Edn.), Vol. 15, the word “establishment” means a place where one is permanently fixed for residence or business, such as an office or place of business with its fixtures. Further it means an establishment in which employee is or was employed. “Establishment” means merely something established. In Webster's International Dictionary the word “establishment” means an institute or place of business with its fixtures and organized staff. Oxford Dictionary defines the term “establishment” as organized body of men maintained for a purpose. According to Bouvier, Law Dictionary the word “establishment” connotes that which is instituted or established for public or private use.

9. The word “establish” has also been used in Art. 30(1) of the Constitution where the provision is that the minority whether based on religion or language shall have right to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice. The word “establishment” under Art. 30(1) of the Constitution means to bring into existence. See I.S Aziz Pasha v. Union of India [A.I.R 1968 S.C 662].

10. In V. Transport [Private), Ltd. v. Regional Provident Fund Commissioner, Madras [A.I.R 1965 Mad. 466], it means been held that the word “establishment” has been interpreted to mean an organization which employs persons, where relationship of employee and employer comes into existence.

11. We are accordingly of the opinion that the word “establishment” as used under S. 1(3)(b) or S. 1(3)(c) of the Act connotes an organized body of men and women employed where the relationship of employer and employee comes into existence. There could be no manner of doubt that petitioner 1 has employed a number of employees for a purpose, namely, to carry out the duties assigned to them for the object for which Uttar Pradesh Co-operative Union has been established. There is no doubt that the provisions of Gratuity Act would apply to the employees of petitioner 1. The application of respondent 1 was certainly maintainable and the preliminary objection raised on behalf of the petitioners has correctly been rejected by the impugned order.

12. We accordingly do not find any merit in the petition and the same is dismissed. But there shall be no order as to costs.