- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Rajendra Prasad v. The Chancellor, Magadh University And Others
Structured Summary of the Court's Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner and respondent No. 4 were rival candidates for appointment as Principal of Sardar Patel Memorial College, Biharsharif. Respondent No. 4 was appointed by the order contained in Annexure 13, which the petitioner challenged as illegal and sought quashing of that appointment and of a general direction given by the Chancellor in Annexure 19.
Relevant events recorded in the opinion:
- Petitioner had been working as Principal since 1974 and had been initially appointed by the Governing Body; the College Service Commission accorded concurrence in 1977 for a period of three months (Annexure 4).
- The College Service Commission (respondent No. 3) issued an advertisement for permanent appointment; both petitioner and respondent No. 4 applied. The Commission recommended respondent No. 4 as first nominee; the Governing Body, by resolution dated 16.3.1980 (Annexure 8), held that the recommended candidates did not fulfil advertisement conditions and sought reconsideration.
- The Commission responded that the post would be readvertised. The Governing Body meanwhile resolved to appoint the petitioner permanently and requested the Commission to act; the Commission's consideration was pending (Annexure 12).
- The college became a constituent college of Magadh University while the matter was under consideration. On 19 February 1981 the Chancellor issued Annexure 19 directing authorities to act upon recommendations recorded up to 30 November 1980.
- Respondent No. 4 had filed a representation to the Chancellor that was pending; the Chancellor called for a report in March 1981. On 20 April 1981 the impugned appointment of respondent No. 4 was made by Annexure 13.
- The petitioner filed a representation before the Chancellor unsuccessfully and then filed the present writ petition challenging Annexure 13 (and seeking quashing of Annexure 19 as relevant).
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a recommendation of the College Service Commission that was received before a college became a constituent college remained legally valid after the college became constituent (issue arising from sub-section (3)(a) of section 57A of the Bihar State Universities Act, 1976, and the language of the Hindi amending statute).
- Whether the Commission's recommendation, having been made in February 1980, remained valid for the purpose of making an appointment in April 1981, in view of the statutory provision that recommendations remain valid for one year (section 57A(2)(c) and section 2(9) of the Bihar University Service Commission Act, 1976).
- Whether the petitioner had locus standi to challenge the appointment of respondent No. 4 despite the Commission not having recommended the petitioner.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant (Petitioner's) Arguments — Mr. Mukhopadhya
- Under sub-section (3)(a) of section 57A of the Bihar State Universities Act, 1976, the recommendation of the Commission was valid only up to the date on which the college was made a constituent college; hence, after that date the recommendation ceased to exist in the eye of law and the University could not act on it.
- Under section 57A(2)(c) (and reliance on section 2(9) of the Bihar State University Service Commission Act, 1976) a recommendation of the Commission is valid only for one year from the date it was made; because the appointment was made after one year, it was illegal.
Respondent No. 4's Arguments — Mr. Basudeo Prasad
- Sub-section (3)(a) of section 57A should be treated as an exception to the general rule that a recommendation is valid only for one year; where a college becomes a constituent college, the special rule should prevail so that the recommendation did not lapse at the end of one year.
- The decision in Annexure 19 by the Chancellor (dated 19.2.1981) was taken within one year of the recommendation and therefore the appointment should be upheld.
- Since the Commission did not recommend the petitioner, the petitioner lacked locus standi and therefore could not maintain the writ to quash respondent No. 4's appointment.
University's Argument — Mr. Additional Advocate General
- The English translation of the amending statute (section 57A(3)(a)) was inaccurate; the original amending Act was in Hindi and the proper translation supports that recommendations received before a college becomes a constituent college remain valid.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded in a stepwise statutory and textual analysis limited to the materials and submissions on record:
- Textual interpretation of section 57A(3)(a): The court noted that section 57A was inserted by a 1980 amendment whose original text was in Hindi. The English translation of subsection (3)(a), relied on by the petitioner, was found to be inaccurate. The court held that the Hindi original must control and that a proper translation shows that recommendations received before a college becomes a constituent college remain valid. The official English translation could not override the Hindi original. This construction was reinforced by reading subsection (3)(d) (English translation of which was not challenged) which contemplates action where an affiliated college becomes constituent and a recommendation is received.
- Effect of subsection (3)(a) on the petitioner's first argument: On the basis of the correct translation, the court rejected the petitioner's first contention that the recommendation ceased to exist on the date the college became constituent. The court concluded that subsection (3)(a) was not intended to render earlier recommendations void.
- One-year limitation on recommendations: The court then considered section 57A(2)(c) which expressly provides that "The recommendations of the Commission shall remain valid for a period of one year from the date on which they are made." The court also cited section 2(9) of the Bihar University Service Commission Act, 1976, which likewise prescribes that a Commission recommendation is valid for one year. The court read these provisions as mandatory: the language is imperative and causes the recommendation to lose legal efficacy on expiry of one year.
- Interaction between subsection (3)(a) and the one-year rule: The court analysed whether subsection (3)(a) constituted an exception to the general one-year validity rule. It concluded that subsection (3)(a) merely protects recommendations from lapsing because of the change in the college's status (affiliated to constituent) but does not alter the statutory period of validity. There was no inconsistency between subsection (3)(a) and the one-year limitation in subsection (2)(c) and section 2(9); hence subsection (3)(a) could not be read to extend the time limit.
- Application to facts and timing of appointment: The Commission's recommendation was made in February 1980; respondent No. 4's appointment was made on 20 April 1981 (by Annexure 13), more than one year later. The Chancellor's general direction in Annexure 19 dated 19 February 1981 was itself a policy direction and did not decide respondent No. 4's representation or make the appointment; moreover, the respondent's representation remained pending at least until 25 March 1981. The impugned appointment was therefore made after the one-year validity of the Commission's recommendation had expired.
- On locus standi: The court rejected the respondent's contention that the petitioner lacked locus because he had not been recommended. The petitioner had been serving as Principal since 1974 and his case was actively under consideration by the Commission when the college became constituent; therefore he was aggrieved by the appointment and entitled to maintain the writ. The court also observed that after expiry of one year the Commission must reassess relative merits and that the petitioner would thereby get another opportunity.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The court quashed the order of appointment of respondent No. 4 as Principal contained in Annexure 13 and allowed the writ application (the order is quashed and the writ is allowed without costs).
Implications and immediate consequences:
- The impugned appointment is void because it was made after the statutory one-year validity of the College Service Commission's recommendation had expired.
- The Chancellor's general direction (Annexure 19) did not itself dispose of the pending representation nor did it constitute a decision sufficient to validate the subsequent appointment made after the one-year period.
- The authority concerned is directed to take fresh steps for appointment in accordance with law (i.e., in light of the statutory requirements identified by the court).
- No broader change of judicial precedent is identified or discussed in the opinion; the decision's practical effect is to set aside the particular appointment and require a lawful fresh process.
This summary is confined strictly to the material and reasoning contained in the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts or law beyond that text.
Lalit Mohan Sharma and Anand Pd. Sinha, JJ.:— The petitioner and the respondent No. 4 were rival candidates for being appointed as the Principal of Sardar Patel Memorial College, Biharsharif (hereinafter referred to as “the College”), and the respondent No. 4 was appointed by the order contained in Annexure 13, which is challenged in the present writ application as illegal. It is said that the appointment was made in pursuance of a general direction given by the Chancellor in his letter Annexure 19. There is also a prayer for quashing the said direction.
2. According to the case in the writ application, the petitioner was appointed as the Principal of the College in 1974 by the Governing Body and the College Service Commission accorded concurrence in 1977 as per Annexure 4 to the petitioner's appointment for a period of three months. Steps were taken for permanent appointment to the post and an advertisement was issued by the College Service Commission. Both the petitioner and respondent No. 4 were applicants and their cases were considered by the College Service Commission (respondent No. 3). The Commission did not recommend the name of the petitioner. The respondent No. 4 was recommended as the first nominee and another candidate as the second choice, but the Governing Body by a resolution dated 16.3.1980 (Annexure-8) held that they did not fulfil all the conditions of the advertisement and so could not be appointed. The Commission was requested to reconsider the matter. The Commission wrote back that the post would be readvertised. In the meantime the Governing Body resolved that the petitioner who was working as the principal since 1974 should be appointed on permanent basis and a request was accordingly made to the Commission. While the suggestion was under the active consideration of the Commission (as stated by it in Annexure-12), the college became a constituent college of the Magadh University. On the 19th of February, 1981, the Chancellor issued a general order as contained in Annexure-19 directing the authorities concerned to act upon the recommendation of the Commission recorded up to the 30th November, 1980, and to make appointments. The respondent No. 4 also had in the meantime moved the Chancellor by filing a representation which was pending. In March, 1981, the Chancellor called for a report in the matter of the respondent's representation. On the 20th of April, 1981, the impugned appointment of respondent No. 4 was made by Annexure-13. The petitioner then filed a representation before the Chancellor unsuccessfully. In support of the petitioner's case, Mr. Mukhopadhya contended that in view of sub-section 3(a) of Section 57A of the Bihar State Universities Act, 1976, the recommendation of the Commission was valid only till the date on which the college was made a constituent college. The recommendation, therefore, was not in existence in the eye of law for the University to act on it. His second point is that in view of the provisions of section 57A(2)(c) of the Bihar State Universities Act, 1970, the recommendation of the Commission was valid only for a period of one year from the date on which it was made and since the University has appointed the respondent No. 4 after this period, the appointment is illegal. Reliance has also been placed on section 2(9) of the Bihar State University Service Commission Act, 1976.
3. It is the admitted position that no appointment of a college teacher can be made unless a recommendation by the Commission is available for consideration. The question which arises, therefore, is whether the Commission's recommendation was valid in the eye of law, on the basis of which the impugned appointment could have been made.
4. Section 57A was inserted in the Bihar State Universities Act, 1976, by an amendment in 1980. The original amending statute was in Hindi language. The English version of section 57A(3)(a) is in the following terms:
“College Service Commission shall give its consent/recommendation for the appointment, dismissal or termination etc. of teachers of affiliated colleges till the date of their being made constituent colleges. Its consent/recommendation shall be deemed valid only till that date.”
5. The language of the sub-section, quoted above, is apparently in favour of the petitioner. Mr. Additional Advocate General appearing for the University placed before us the original Hindi text quoted below and submitted that the English translation is not accurate.
6. He appears to be right. Properly translated, the provision states that the recommendation received till before the College becomes a constituent college shall be deemed to be valid. The intention of the legislature must be gathered from the language which has been used by it. Since the Amending Act was admittedly in Hindi, the English translation, though official, cannot override the Hindi text. The English version is the interpretation of the person entrusted with the task of translation. It cannot be equated with the original text. In that view we hold that the English translation, quoted above, and relied on by the petitioner cannot be accepted as giving the correct meaning of the sub-section. In accordance with the original Hindi text, it must be held that the recommendation which was received by the college before it became a constituent college remained valid. This interpretation appears to be consistent with the provisions of sub-section (3)(d) which (according to the English translation which is not challenged by any party) is in the following terms:
“If an affiliated college becomes a constituent college of a University by the time the recommendation of the College Service Commission is received, the Syndicate, shall take action in accordance with sub-section (4) of section 57 of the said Act, as if the recommendation has been made by the Selection Committee.”
7. If the recommendation of the Commission received later than the college becoming constituent has to be acted upon by the University for the purpose of appointment under sub-section (4), it is not likely that the legislature intended that the recommendation received earlier would be completely ignored. We, therefore, hold that the first point urged on behalf of the petitioner has no substance.
8. For appreciating the other question urged by Mr. Mukhopadhya, it has to be remembered that the recommendation of the Commission was made in February, 1980, and appointment of the respondent No. 4 was in April, 1981, that is, after a period of one year. Clause (c) of section 57A(2) reads as follows:
“The recommendations of the Commission shall remain valid for a period of one year from the date on which they are made.”
9. Section 2(9) of the Bihar University Service Commission Act, 1976, under which the respondent Commission was established, is also to that effect. It reds as follows:
“The Commission shall recommend for appointment to every post of teacher, names of two persons arranged in order of preference and considered by the Commission to be the best qualified therefor. The recommendation shall be valid for one year from the date of the recommendation by the Commission.”
10. The language used in the above mentioned provision is imperative in nature and the recommendation must, therefore, be held to lose its legal efficacy on the expiry of the period of one year. In that view, the impugned appointment having been made without a valid recommendation must be held to be illegal.
11. Mr. Basudeo Prasad, appearing for the respondent No. 4, contended that in view of the sub-section (3)(a) of section 57A mentioned above, it must be held that the recommendation did not lapse on the expiry of one year. The learned counsel argued that the sub-section (3)(a) is by way of an exception to the general rule in regard to the recommendation remaining valid for a period of one year only. Where a college is made a constituent college, the special provision is to be applied. The question which arises is, whether sub-section (3)(a) provides a special rule in this regard so as to pravail over the general rule. An examination of its language shows that its sole purpose is to protect the recommendation from getting expired on account of the college being a constituent college. The recommendation continues to be subject to the other conditions as before. The sub-section does not deal with the period of its validity and there is no inconsistency between this provision and section 57A(2)(c) and section 2(9) of the Bihar University Service Commission Act. It will further be observed that the provisions limiting the life of the recommendation to one year is of universal application. It is of little consequence as to whether a college is affiliated college, the management being in the hands of the Governing Body, or it is a constituent college. We are, therefore, of the view that sub-section ???(a) can not be treated as an exception to sub-section (2)(c). It follows that after a period of one year from February 1980, the life of the Commission's recommendation expired and in the eye of law, it was not in existence for the purpose of the impugned appointment.
12. It was argued by Mr. Basudeo Prasad that since the decision by the Chancellor as contained in Annexure 19 was taken on 19.2.1981, that is, just within one year, the appointment of the respondent No. 4 should be upheld as valid. We are afraid, it is not possible to save the appointment on this basis. From Annexures 5 and 6 and the other materials available on the record, it is established beyond doubt that the representation of respondent No. 4 was pending till at least the 25th of March, 1981. The letter Annexure 19 did not dispose of the representation of respondent No. 5 and did not take am decision in regard to his appointment. It was laying down a general policy. The decision to appoint respondent No. 4 was taken after the expiry of one year by the impugned order in Annexure 13 dated the 20th of April, 1981. In the circumstances, the appointment of respondent No. 4 has to be struck down as illegal. Mr. Prasad lastly urged that since the Commission did not recommend the petitioner for appointment, he has no locus standi to maintain this application and the appointment of respondent No. 4 should not be quashed at his instance. There is no force in this argument. The petitioner was working as the principal since 1974 and his case was under active consideration of the Commission when the College became a constituent college. He is, therefore, aggrieved by the impugned appointment (Annexure 13) so as to maintain the writ petitioner further, after the expiry of One year from the date of recommendation, the Commission has to reassess the relative merits of all the candidates and the petitioner thus gets another chance.
13. In the result, the order of appointment of the respondent No. 4 as the Principal of the college under Annexure 13 is quashed. The authority concerned may now take fresh steps for appointment in accordance with law. The writ application is accordingly allowed but without costs.
Alert