Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Hem Chandra Dutta v. Girindra Chandra Chaudhuri Opposite Party.

Calcutta High Court
Jul 29, 1920
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.

1. This is a Rule calling upon the District Magistrate and the opposite party to show cause why the proceeding against the petitioner should act be gnashed, or why a further inquiry should act be made into the paction of compromise.

2. It appears that the opposite party who is a pleader of the Thakurgaon Munsif's Court in the Dinajpore District brought a case for defamation against the petitioner who is a muktear's clerk.

3. The parties, however, came to an amicable settlement and a petition of compromise was filed in the case in the Court of the Sub-divisional Magistrate before whom the case was pending, The petitioner denied that he had defamed the opposite party and said that if any such defamatory words had reached the ears of the opposite party the same were absolutely false, that the petitioner was sorry for ??? and tendered his sincere apology to the opposite party. The opposite party ??? in the same petition that the accused having admittas that the defamatory words that he heard were false, and having expressed his regret ab the circulation of the false rumour and having apclcgised in the above manner, he (the opposite party) did not wish to proceed farther in the matter and be prayed that the case might be finally disposed of under the provisions of Section 345 of the Cr PC. The petition was signed not only by the petitioner but also by the opposite party himself. It was engrossed by his (the opposite party's) clerk Gopal Chander Das.

4. After the petition had been filed with the Peshkar the latter put it up before the Sub-divisional Magistrate. Thereupon the Sub-divisional Magistrate sent for the opposite party and there was some talk between them as the result of which the pleader put in another petition by which he wanted to withdraw from the compromise. That has been given effect to, and the case is being proceeded with against the petitioner. We are of opinion that there was a lawful compromise under Section 345 of the Cr PC which amounted to an acquittal of the petitioner and that no farther proceedings ought to have been taken against him.

5. Under sub-section 2 of S. 345, certain offences can be compounded with permission of the Court before which any prosecution for such offence is pending and clause (5) also provides for composition where the accused has been committed for trial or where he has been convicted and an appeal is pending with the leave of the Court. In the other cases mentioned in S. 345 no leave of the Court is required for compounding the offence. The offence for which the petitioner was being prosecuted was defamation under S. 500 and it was compoundable by the person defamed. The latter agreed and himself signed the petition filed in Court having accepted the apology offered by the petitioner. The offence, therefore, was lawfully compounded and the Magistrate ought to have directed an acquittal. Instead of doing that he sent for the pleader (the opposite party) and it appears tram his report to the District Magistrate that it was he who asked the pleader to withdraw the petition of compromiss on the ground that the petition was filed under a misapprehension, the misapprehension being that the Sub-divisional Magistrate had not approved of this compromise when he was informed of it by some pleaders and mnktears on the morning of that day whereas the opposite party was given to understand that the Sub-divisional Magistrate that approved of it.

6. We do not see what the Sub-divisional Magistrate had be do with the compasitlan of the offence under section 600 it being a private matter between the pleader and the muktear's mohurir. It is clear that it was after the talk with the Sab-divisional Magistrate that the pleader changed his mind. It is said that there was to understanding with the opposite party that the petitioner would offer an apology in open Court. But the petition does not state that. She petition itself contained expression of apology by the petitioner, ant acceptancy thereof by the opposite party. That the petition was signed with know ledge of its contents is not, and cannot be denied by the opposite party. The subsequent petition of withdrawal show that the petition of compromise filed in Court was made by both parties and it we prayed by the subsequent petition by the opposite party that the petition of room promise might be rejected.

7. There being no doubt of the opposite party having signed the petition compromise with knowledge of its contend and of which the Sub-divisional Magistral was satisfied when he sent for the opposite party, as appears from his order he ought to have acquitted the accused under the provisions of section 315, Criminal Procedure Code. See the case of Kmutn Bewa v. Beahu Bewa (1).

8. We were referred to on behalf of the petitioner to two cases in the Madras High Court. In the case of Mahomed Kanni Bowthtr v. Pattani Inayathalla Sahib (2) Abdur Rahim, J., observed as follows; “A composition arrived at between the parties of a compoundable offence is complete as soon as it is made and it has the effect of an acquittal of the accused under Section 345 of the Cr PC, in respect of that offence though one of the parties later on resiles from the compromise and no statement or petition recording the compromise is filed in Court by the parties.” See also the case of Kumarmwami Chetty v. Kuppuswami Chetty (3).

9. It is unnecessary for us to consider the question whether the compromise of a case outside the Court is a valid compromise and must be given effect to when no petition was filed in Court and this was the question in those two Madras cases. Here the petition was filed in Court and signed by both parties, and we think it ought to have been given effect to the result is that further proceedings in the case against the petitioner are quashed and the Magistrate directed to record an order of acquittal against the petitioner.

10. Rule made absolute.