- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Saradindu Mukherjee v. Kunja Kamini Roy
Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal arises from a suit by the lessors (Plaintiffs) for recovery of arrears of rent. In 1928 the Plaintiffs' predecessors granted a mokarari lease by a registered potta dated 16 July 1928 to four persons (including Defendant No. 1). The rent reserved was Rs. 5,600 per year, payable in four instalments in the months of Poush, Magh, Falgoon and Chait. The lessees also agreed to pay revenues, cesses and rents due by the lessors to superior landlords. Defendant No. 1 later acquired the interests of his three co-sharers and became sole owner. In 1932 the rent was reduced from Rs. 5,600 to Rs. 5,100 per year as a result of litigation with the lessors.
On 27 January 1936 (Magh 13th, 1342 B.S.) Defendant No. 1 sold his interest to Defendant No. 2. The Plaintiffs filed the present suit on 12 April 1938 claiming arrears of rent from the Poush kist of 1342 B.S. to the Falgoon kist of 1344 B.S., totalling approximately Rs. 18,027. The Plaintiffs alleged the transfer to Defendant No. 2 was a collusive, sham (benami) transaction and sought recovery from both Defendants.
At trial the Subordinate Judge found Defendant No. 2 was not a benamdar and held that the Plaintiffs (being strangers to the deed of transfer) could not raise the question of benami. The Subordinate Judge concluded Defendant No. 1 was tenant up to 27 January 1936 and Defendant No. 2 thereafter, but declined to apportion liability between them and entered a joint decree against both. Defendant No. 1 appealed to this Court. The present opinion determines that appeal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Plaintiffs (lessors), as strangers to the deed of transfer, were competent to raise and prove that the transfer to Defendant No. 2 was a benami (sham) transaction.
- Whether, even if the transfer to Defendant No. 2 was not benami, Defendant No. 1 (the original lessee) remained personally liable for rent accruing after he transferred the tenure, having regard to the personal covenant in the potta and the provisions of the Bengal Tenancy Act (in comparison with English law and Transfer of Property Act principles).
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments (Defendant No. 1)
- On the findings of the Subordinate Judge that Defendant No. 1 ceased to be tenant from 27 January 1936 and was not personally liable for rent accruing after that date, the Appellant contended he should not have been made liable for rents that fell due after the date of transfer; liability for the subsequent period should have been cast solely on Defendant No. 2.
Respondent's Arguments (Plaintiffs)
- The Plaintiffs' counsel (Mr. Das) advanced a twofold case: (a) the transfer to Defendant No. 2 was a benami transaction and the Court below erred in holding that the Plaintiffs, not being parties to the deed, could not raise the question of benami; (b) if Defendant No. 2 was not a benamdar, Defendant No. 1, as an original lessee, was nevertheless bound by the personal covenant in the potta to pay rent despite assignment, and hence remained liable.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Lala Achalram v. Raza Kazim Hussain Khan | The principle (as stated by the Judicial Committee) that a stranger to a deed intended to be real and operative cannot dispute payment or adequacy of consideration. | The Court observed that the Subordinate Judge relied on this decision to hold Plaintiffs could not raise benami; the appellate Court held that reliance was incorrect because Achalram's principle does not apply where the deed is challenged as fictitious. |
| Kamini Kumar Deb v. Durga Charan Nag | That the principle enunciated in Achalram has no bearing where the deed is challenged as fictitious and never designed to operate as a real deed or effect transfer of title. | The Court cited this case to support overruling the Subordinate Judge's reliance on Achalram and to state that Plaintiffs were not automatically barred from raising benami. |
| Surapati Roy v. Ram Narain Mukher-jee | The Judicial Committee held that as soon as the transfer of a permanent tenure is complete, the liability of the old tenant for rent ceases. | The Court relied on this authority (and the series of decisions it followed) to conclude that Defendant No. 1's liability for rent ceased once the transfer was complete (i.e., after registration on 27 Jan 1936). |
| Hemendra Nath Mukherjee v. Kumar Nath Roy | The original lessee was held to be absolved from liability to pay rent after a deed of release was executed and registered by him. | The Court noted that the Judicial Committee had expressly approved this reasoning and cited it in support of the view that an original tenant's liability to pay rent ends once a properly executed and registered transfer (or deed of release) is complete. |
| Kanai Lal Ghose v. Basanta Behari Sen | On completion of transfer of a permanent tenure under sec. 12 of the Bengal Tenancy Act the liability of the transferor who was an original tenant ceases; the original tenant may nevertheless remain liable for other personal obligations created by the lease. | The Court relied on this decision (which followed Hemendra Nath) to hold that once the transfer was complete under sec.12 the transferor (Defendant No. 1) was absolved from rent liability but remained liable for other personal obligations under the lease (none of which were made a basis here to continue rent liability). |
| Jitendra Nath Ghose v. Monmohan Ghose | Observations that after the Act of 1885, as soon as the deed of transfer is registered the old tenant ceases to be tenant irrespective of the landlord's actual notice; the registration completes the transfer. | The Court invoked this authority to support the statutory effect that registration completes transfer and removes the old tenant's rent liability even if the landlord has not had actual notice. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded stepwise, addressing the parties' points in turn and relying on statutory provisions and judicial authorities cited in the opinion.
- On the Subordinate Judge's internal inconsistency: The Court observed that the Subordinate Judge had concluded Defendant No. 1 ceased to be tenant from 27 January 1936 and was not personally liable for rent thereafter, yet nonetheless a joint decree had been entered against both Defendants without apportionment. The appellate Court found that, accepting the Subordinate Judge's findings of fact and law, a joint decree against both could not be supported and the liabilities could and should have been apportioned from the record.
-
On the benami contention: The Court agreed that the lower Court erred in applying Achalram to hold that Plaintiffs (being strangers to the deed) were incompetent to challenge the transfer as benami. It invoked Kamini Kumar Deb to explain that Achalram's principle does not preclude challenging a deed as fictitious. However, the Court then examined the evidence adduced by the Plaintiffs and found it insufficient to prove benami. The Plaintiffs' sole witness Jogesh Chandra Dey gave statements attributed to Saradindu Babu, including:
"Saradindu Babu said that he had made the benami transaction in her relation's name and that the Defendant No. 2 was his relation and mother-in-law…….. We learnt on enquiry that Nanda Rani has no means to purchase properties for Rs. 4,000 and Saradindu Babu himself maintains her."
and in cross-examination:"Each year I meet Saradindu Balm who also goes to Rai Bahadur Gunendra Krishna Roy's house. In his presence Saradindu Babu said that he had made the benami transaction."
The Court found that these statements were not sufficiently probative: it was implausible that a person intending a sham transfer would openly declare it to his landlord, and there was no direct evidence that Nanda Rani did not pay consideration. Though there were suspicious circumstances (attesting witnesses were employees of Defendant No. 1 and management remained with Defendant No. 1's officer), suspicion alone could not support a finding of benami. Accordingly, the Court overruled the Plaintiffs' first contention for lack of adequate proof. -
On the question whether the original lessee remained liable after transfer: The Court reviewed the relevant principles. It noted the English law rule (and Transfer of Property Act sec. 108(j)) distinguishing liability founded on privity of estate (which ceases on transfer) from liability founded on privity of contract (where the original tenant may remain liable until the lessor accepts the assignee). The crucial question was how these principles operate in the context of a permanent tenure governed by the Bengal Tenancy Act.
- The Court explained that under sec. 11 of the Bengal Tenancy Act a permanent tenure is transferable like other immovable property, and sec. 12 prescribes the mode: registration of the transfer completes it (registration requires payment of the landlord's fees).
- The Court relied on Surapati Roy, Hemendra Nath Mukherjee, and Kanai Lal Ghose to conclude that once the transfer is complete under sec. 12, the liability of the original tenant for rent ceases; the lessor must recognize the transferee as tenant unless the lease contains a contract imposing conditions (e.g., security) making transfer ineffective without fulfillment of those conditions.
- The Court further referred to Jitendra Nath Ghose to note the change effected by the Act of 1885: upon registration the old tenant "walks out of the field" even if the landlord has no actual notice, reinforcing the statutory effect of registration in completing the transfer.
- Remedial disposition: On this basis the Court allowed the appeal, modified the Subordinate Judge's judgment to apportion liability between the Defendants in accordance with the Court's findings, and specified the decree amounts and costs as detailed below.
Holding and Implications
HOLDING: The Court allowed the appeal and modified the Subordinate Judge's judgment. It held that Defendant No. 1's liability for rent ceased following the registered transfer on 27 January 1936; Defendant No. 1 was therefore liable only for rent up to that date, and Defendant No. 2 alone was liable for the subsequent period in suit.
Direct consequences for the parties:
- The Plaintiffs were awarded a decree for Rs. 1,626-15-3 against Defendant No. 1 (representing rent up to the transfer) and a decree for Rs. 16,400-9-6 against Defendant No. 2 (for subsequent rent), each with proportionate costs of the trial Court against the respective Defendant.
- There was no order as to costs in the appellate Court (this Court), and the cross-objection was dismissed with no order as to costs in this Court.
Broader implications: The opinion applies established statutory and judicial principles concerning transfers of permanent tenures under the Bengal Tenancy Act and does not purport to lay down any new legal principle beyond those authorities it applies.
End of summary — this document is a faithful summary based solely on the provided opinion.
1. This appeal is on behalf of Defendant No. 1 and it arises out of a suit for recovery of arrears of rent. The Defendant No. 1 and three other persons took a mokarari lease of a large quantity of land in the Sundarbans from the predecessors of the Plaintiffs, under a registered potta, dated July 16th, 1928. The rent reserved was Rs. 5,600 a year, payable in four instalments, in the months of Poush, Magh, Falgoon and Chait, every year. Besides this yearly rent, the lessees undertook to pay revenues and cesses payable in respect of the property and also rents due by the lessors to their superior landlords. The Defendant No. 1 subsequently acquired the interest of his other three co-sharers in the tenure and became the sole owner thereof. In 1932 there were certain litigations between the lessors and Defendant No. 1 and as a result of these the rent was reduced from Rs. 5,600 to Rs. 5,100 a year, all the other terms of the potta being kept intact. On January 27th, 1936, corresponding to Magh 13th, 1342 B.S the Defendant No. 1 sold his interest in the tenure to Defendant No. 2. The present suit was brought by the Plaintiffs lessors on April 12th, 1938, and they claimed arrears of rent for the period commencing from the Poush kist of 1342 B.S and ending with the Falgoon kist of 1344 B.S The claim was laid at Rs. 18,027 and odd. The Plaintiffs' case was that Defendant No. 2 was a relation and benamdar of Defendant No. 1 and the transfer in her favour was a collusive and sham transaction. They therefore claimed rents from both the Defendants.
2. The trial Judge came to the finding that Defendant No. 2 was not a benamdar of Defendant No. 1 and in his opinion, the question of benami could not be raised by the Plaintiffs, who were no parties to the conveyance. The conclusions of the Subordinate Judge therefore were that Defendant No. 1 was the tenant up to January 27th, 1936, and for the subsequent period in suit, Defendant No. 2 was the tenant. The learned Judge however refused to apportion the liability of these two Defendants, being of opinion that this was neither easy nor proper. The Defendant No. 1 has come up to this Court on appeal and the only contention put forward on behalf of him by Mr. Gupta is that on the findings arrived at by the Subordinate Judge himself, the Appellant should not have been made liable for rents that fell due after the date of the transfer of the tenure to Defendant No. 2 and that for the subsequent period the Defendant No. 2 alone should have been made liable. It seems to us that if the conclusions of law and fact arrived at by the Subordinate Judge be accepted as correct, his decision cannot possibly be supported. According to the Subordinate Judge, the Defendant No. 1 ceased to be a tenant on and from January 27th, 1936, and he was further of opinion that he was not personally liable under the terms of the potta for any rent that accrued due subsequent to the transfer. In these circumstances it is difficult to see why there was a joint decree made against both the Defendants, when their liability could have been easily apportioned on the materials appearing on the face of the record.
3. Mr. Das who appears on behalf of the Plaintiffs Respondents, has appreciated the difficulty in his way and he has attempted to support the decision of the Subordinate Judge on grounds other than those upon which the latter relied. The contentions put forward by him are of a two-fold character. In the first place, he says that the Court below should have held on evidence that Defendant No. 2 was a mere benamdar of Defendant No. 1 and it erred in law in holding that the Plaintiffs were incapable of raising the question of benami in the present litigation. The second ground taken is that even if Defendant No. 2 was not a benamdar of Defendant No. 1, the Defendant No. 1 as one of the original lessees, was bound by the personal covenant in the potta to pay the rent in spite of the fact that he had assigned his interest to another person. These are the two points that require consideration in this case.
4. So far as the first point is concerned, we agree with Mr. Das that the Court below was wrong in holding on the authority of the decision in Lala Achalram v. Raza Kazim Hussain Khan(1) that the Plaintiffs not being parties to the deed of transfer were not competent to raise the question of benami in the present litigation. As was held in the case of Kamini Kumar Deb v. Durga Charan Nag(2) the principle enunciated by the Judicial Committee in Achalram's case that a stranger to a deed which is intended to be real and operative between the parties thereto cannot dispute the payment or non-payment of the consideration or its adequacy or inadequacy has no bearing in a case where the deed is challenged as fictitious and never designed to operate as a real deed or to effect transfer of title. We think however that the evidence which has been adduced on behalf of the Plaintiffs in the present case falls short of what is necessary to establish a case of benami. The only witness who has been examined on behalf of the Plaintiffs is his officer Jogesh Chandra Dey. This witness in his deposition states as follows:—
“Saradindu Babu said that he had made the benami transaction in her relation's name and that the Defendant No. 2 was his relation and mother-in-law…….. We learnt on enquiry that Nanda Rani has no means to purchase properties for Rs. 4,000 and Saradindu Babu himself maintains her.”
5. In cross-examination he stated further:
“Each year I meet Saradindu Balm who also goes to Rai Bahadur Gunendra Krishna Roy's house. In his presence Saradindu Babu said that he had made the benami transaction.”
6. It is impossible to believe that if Defendant No. 1 really intended to make a sham transfer for the purpose of avioding his liability for rent, he would himself go to his landlord and tell him about it. It is true that there is no denial on the part of Defendant No. 1 that Nanda Rani is related to him. The attesting witnesses to the deed of sale also are all employees of Defendant No. 1 and it is admitted by the Defendant No. 1's own witnesses that even after the purchase, the management of the property was left in the hands of one of the officers of Defendant No. 1. These are suspicious circumstances no doubt and throw considerable suspicion regarding the genuineness of the transfer. But we cannot rest our decision on mere surmises or suspicions. There is no evidence on the Plaintiff's side to prove that there was no payment of consideration by Nanda Rani. Certainly the Plaintiffs could have produced better evidence to prove that the transaction was in reality a benami affair. We therefore overrule the first contention of Mr. Das.
7. The second point put forward by Mr. Das raises a question of some importance. It is a well-settled rule of English law which has been adopted in the Transfer of Property Act [vide sec. 108 (j) of the Transfer of Property Act] that when the liability of a tenant to pay rent is founded on privity of estate, the liability ceases as soon as the interest is transferred to some other person. But so far as the original lessee is concerned, his liability does not cease with mere assignment. The lessor in such cases can enforce payment of rent from his original tenant by reason of a privity of contract and the liability of the original tenant can only cease after the assignee is accepted as tenant by the lessor, either expressly or impliedly. The question is how far this principle is applicable to the case of a transfer of a permanent tenure governed by the Bengal Tenancy Act. Under sec. 11 of the Bengal Tenancy Act a permanent tenure is capable of being transferred in the same manner and to the same extent as any other immovable property. Sec. 12 prescribes the mode in which the transfer is to be effected. As soon as the document by which the transfer is made is registered, and the registration is not to take place unless the landlord's fees are paid, the transfer is complete. It has been held by the Judicial Committee in the case of Surapati Roy v. Ram Narain Mukher-jee(3), following a long series of decisions of this Court, that as soon as the transfer is complete, the liability of the old tenant for rent ceases. It is true that the facts of this case do not show as to whether the transfer in that case was by the original tenant or a subsequent assignee. But their Lordships expressly approved of the decision in the case of Hemendra Nath Mukherjee v. Kumar Nath Roy(4), where the original leseee was held to be absolved from liability to pay rent after a deed of release was executed and registered by him. It appears indeed that there was an additional finding in Hemendra Nath Mukherjee's case that the Plaintiff landlord never asked for any rent from the old lessees; but that was not the basis of the decision of the learned Judges. The case of Hemendra Nath Mukherjee v. Kumar Nath Roy was followed by Walmsley and Mukherji, JJ., in the case of Kanai Lal Ghose v. Basanta Behari Sen(5) and it was held that on the transfer of a permanent tenure being complete under sec. 12 of the Bengal Tenancy Act, the liability of the transferor, who was an original tenant and not an assignee, would cease. It was held further that though the original tenant would be absolved from his liability to pay rent as soon as the transfer was complete, still he would remain liable for the performance of other personal obligations created by the lease. As has been said already, even under the English law, the liability of the original tenant to pay rent comes to an end as soon as there is recognition of the assignee as a tenant by the lessor. We think that the effect of a transfer being completed with all the formalities required by sec. 12 of the Bengal Tenancy Act is that there is a statutory obligation on the part of the lessor to recognise the transferee as a tenant. Of course if there is a contract between a landlord and a tenant that the transfer shall not be valid and binding unless security is given or some other condition is fulfilled, the original tenant might still remain liable for the rent. But when there is no such condition, the lessor has got no other option but to recognise the transferee.
8. It is to be noted that before 1885 the duty was fixed upon the transferee of a tenure to get his name recorded in the Sherista of the landlord and if he failed to do that, the landlord could ignore him altogether and proceed against the recorded tenant for recovery of arrears of rent. The Act of 1885 made a change in this respect and under it, as soon as the deed of transfer-is registered, the old tenant walks cut of the field, no matter whether the landlord has actual notice of it or not— Vide the observations of the Judicial Committee in the case of Jitendra Nath Ghose v. Monmohan Ghose(6). We therefore think that in the present case the liability of Defendant No. 1 for the rent ceased after January 27th, 1936. He would only be liable for the rent of the Pous kist of 1342 B.S and for the subsequent period the decree should be made against Defendant No. 2 alone.
9. The result is that we allow the appeal and modify the judgment of the learned Subordinate Judge.
10. The Plaintiffs will have a decree for Rs. 1,626-15-3 against Defendant No. 1 and for Rs. 16,400-9-6 against Defendant No. 2 with proportionate costs of the trial Court against each.
11. There will be no order for costs in this Court.
12. The cross-objection is dismissed. There will be no order for costs in the cross-objection.
P.C
Alert