- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Jai Singh Gir v. Sita Ram Singh
Lindsay, J.:— Only one question is raised in this second appeal. It appears that the appellant who was the plaintiff had his suit dismissed in the court of first instance. He went to the court of the District Judge and filed an appeal. According to the valuation of the appeal, which was the same as the valuation of the suit, the proper court-fee payable was Rs. 55, i.c, Rs. 10 in respect of a declaration which was being claimed and Rs. 45 in respect of the claim for possession.
2. The memorandum of appeal was filed on a ten-rupee stamp, on the 4th November, 1921.
3. That was the date on which the courts opened after the long vacation. The Munsarim recorded a report on the memorandum of appeal stating that the appeal was within time but pointing out that the memorandum of appeal was insufficiently stamped. On the 7th November, 1921, the learned District Judge recorded the following order:—
“I am not prepared to allow further time as only Rs. 10 court-fee stamp has been paid and Rs. 55 were due. The appeal will be rejected as insufficiently stamped.”
4. We may point out, in the first place, that the learned District Judge had no right to reject the appeal on the ground that it was insufficiently stamped. The powers of rejection in respect of a memorandum of appeal are set out in Order 41, rule 23. Again it does not appear from the Judge's order, although he says that he is not prepared to allow “further time,” that any time had been allowed to the appellant to make good the deficiency. It is true that under section 149 a discretion is reserved to the court in the matter of granting time for the making up of deficiencies in court-fees, and, if we were satisfied in the present case that the learned Judge had exercised any discretion, we should not have interfered. It does not, however, appear that the learned Judge really did exercise any discretion in the matter. He does not give any reasons why he is not prepared to allow the deficiency to be made good. We think the proper course, therefore, is to allow this appeal, set aside the order of the court below and direct the appeal to be returned to the District Judge who will give the appellant an opportunity of showing cause why the court's discretion should be exercised in his favour under the provisions of section 149 of the Code of Civil Procedure. Costs to abide the result. We may note for the information of the learned Judge that the full deficiency which was payable in the lower appellate court has already been paid into this Court.
5. Appeal allowed.
Alert