- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Duraiswami Thevan v. K.N.K.L. Lakshmanan Chettiar
Factual and Procedural Background
The plaintiff, a landholder, filed an application under the Madras Estates Land Act concerning the appraisement and division of produce. Pursuant to Section 75 of the Act, an officer was deputed to carry out specified functions. During the inquiry, the defendant, a ryot under the plaintiff, made an oral statement alleging that the plaintiff had murdered his father-in-law, an allegation considered defamatory. The defendant denied making this statement, but two courts below concurrently found against him. The appeal raised the question of whether the alleged defamatory statement was absolutely privileged.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the alleged defamatory statement made by the defendant during the inquiry under Section 75 of the Madras Estates Land Act is absolutely privileged.
- Whether the proceedings before the officer deputed under Section 75 constitute a judicial or quasi-judicial proceeding conferring absolute privilege.
- Whether the defamatory statement was relevant or had reference to the matter in hand, thus attracting absolute privilege.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's (Plaintiff's) Arguments
- The proceeding before the officer deputed under Section 75 is not a judicial proceeding; therefore, the rule of absolute privilege does not apply.
- The officer's duty is merely to record objections and not to adjudicate judicially, making the tribunal non-judicial in nature.
- The alleged defamatory statement was irrelevant to the inquiry and hence not protected by absolute privilege.
- Relied on Royal Aquarium and Summer and Winter Garden Society v. Parkinson to argue that administrative or consultative bodies do not enjoy absolute privilege.
Respondent's (Defendant's) Arguments
- The statement was made in the course of quasi-judicial proceedings before an officer exercising judicial functions similar to a court.
- The doctrine of absolute privilege extends beyond strictly judicial tribunals to tribunals recognized by law that exercise judicial functions.
- The defamatory statement had reference to the subject matter of the inquiry and thus was protected under absolute privilege.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Royal Aquarium and Summer and Winter Garden Society v. Parkinson | Absolute privilege applies only to courts and tribunals exercising judicial functions, not to administrative or consultative bodies. | Rejected as inapplicable since the officer under Section 75 was held to exercise quasi-judicial functions unlike the administrative council in this case. |
| Seaman v. Netherclift (Judgment of Bramwell J.A.) | Statements enjoy absolute privilege if they have reference to the inquiry or matter in hand, not necessarily narrowly relevant. | Applied to hold that the defamatory statement was made with reference to the inquiry and thus absolutely privileged. |
| Adivaramma v. Ramachandra Reddy | Confirmed the broad application of absolute privilege to statements having reference to the inquiry. | Supported the conclusion that the statement was protected by absolute privilege. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined whether the officer deputed under Section 75 of the Madras Estates Land Act performed judicial or quasi-judicial functions. It noted that absolute privilege is not confined strictly to judicial tribunals but extends to tribunals recognized by law that exercise judicial functions similar to courts. The court found that while the officer's duty includes recording objections, he must also carry out appraisement or division, and in certain matters his decisions are final, indicating a quasi-judicial character rather than a purely ministerial role.
The court distinguished the plaintiff's cited precedent, Royal Aquarium and Summer and Winter Garden Society v. Parkinson, which involved an administrative body, and held it inapplicable. The court further analyzed the relevance of the defamatory statement, relying on the principle that absolute privilege protects statements having reference to the inquiry, not necessarily narrowly relevant. The court referred to the reasoning in Seaman v. Netherclift and Adivaramma v. Ramachandra Reddy to affirm that the defendant's statement was sufficiently connected to the matter in hand and thus protected.
Based on these principles, the court concluded that the defamatory statement made during the quasi-judicial inquiry was absolutely privileged.
Holding and Implications
The appeal is dismissed.
The court held that the judgment of the lower court reversing the District Munsif was incorrect. The defendant's defamatory statement made during the quasi-judicial inquiry was absolutely privileged. Although the defendant succeeded, no costs were awarded to either party, and each was directed to bear their own costs. The memorandum of objections was dismissed. This decision directly resolves the dispute between the parties without establishing new precedent beyond the application of existing principles of absolute privilege in quasi-judicial proceedings.
The point raised by the appeal is, whether the alleged defamatory statement made by the defendant is absolutely privileged. Under the sections of the Madras Estates Land Act relating to the appraisement and division of the produce, the landholder (the plaintiff in the case) presented an application, and under S. 75 an officer was deputed to carry out the functions specified in that section. In the inquiry that followed, the defendant (who was a ryot under the plaintiff gave a long oral statement, and in the course of it, made the allegation (said to amount to slander) that the plaintiff had murdered his (defendant's father-in-law). One of the pleas raised by the defendant in this connection is, that he did not make the allegation imputed to him; but this point is concluded by the concurrent finding against him of the two Courts below.
The question of law is, as I have said, whether the statement is absolutely privileged. Mr. A. Srinivasa Ayyangar for the plaintiff (respondent) has strenuously urged that the proceeding before the officer deputed under S. 75, is not a judicial proceeding and that the rule of absolute privilege has no application. But the doctrine of absolute privilege is not confined to statements made before judicial tribunals strictly so called but has been carried further, and has been held to apply to statements made before a “tribunal (which word covers a commission or inquiry) recognised by law, which, though not a Court in the ordinary sense of the word, exercises judicial functions, that is to say, acts in a manner similar to that in which a Court of Justice acts in respect of an inquiry before it.” Gatley on Libel and Slander, Ch. XI page 182, 1924 Edn. “So long as the substantial elements of natural justice are observed, an absolute privilege attaches to the proceedings. The substantial elements of natural justice must be found to have been present at the inquiry:” (page 183) The learned author points out that it is often a difficult question to determine, whether a particular tribunal exercises judicial functions so as to confer an absolute privilege on statements made in the course of its proceedings. In every case, he observes, it is necessary to examine somewhat narrowly the constitution, the functions and procedure of the tribunal. According to Folkard, absolute immunity exists in respect of statements made “in the ordinary course of the administration of justice” or “in the usual and regular course of legal procedure,” provided the statements made are “relative to the matter in hand.” Folkard's Slander and Libel 7th Edn. page 100. Accordingly it has been held that a military Court of inquiry, though not coming within the ordinary definition of a Court of Justice, is nevertheless a tribunal exercising judicial functions, so as to confer an absolute privilege on statements made before it. The General Medical Council, the Committee of the Law Society, a commission appointed by the bishop of a diocese, have similarly been held to be judicial tribunals within the meaning of the rule: (Gatley: pages 183 and 184).
It is therefore unnecessary to decide whether the officer deputed under S. 75 performs strictly judicial functions or not for, there can be no doubt that the proceedings before him are at any rate quasi judicial proceedings, and the law casts upon him the duty of acting in a manner similar to that in which Courts of Justice generally act. For the plaintiff it is contended that the officer's duty, if objections of a certain kind are taken, is merely to record them, and therefore he is not a judicial tribunal. This clearly is not the true effect of the sections; for, while it is laid down that he shall record the objections, he is required nevertheless to carry out the appraisement or division as there may be Cases occur where objections are taken, such as, that rent is not payable in kind but in cash, and the officer deputed cannot deal judicially with such questions; but the intention of the Legislature is that the proceeding should not be delayed until the objections have been disposed of. In a certain event, in regard to matters which are within the province of the officer, finality attaches to his decision, S. 75 (7), and it is futile to contend that his duty is merely ministerial. The case relied on for the plaintiff, The Royal Aquarium and Summer and Winter Garden Society v. Parkinson only lays down that the doctrine of absolute immunity does not extend further than to Courts of Justice and tribunals having similar attributes. The question arose, whether a meeting of the London County Council for granting music and dancing licenses, was a Court within the meaning of the rule by which defamatory statements made in the course of proceedings before a Judicial tribunal are absolutely privileged. Lord Esher M.R observes that the duties performed by the Council are administrative, their action being consultative for the purpose of administration, and not judicial. This case has no analogy to the present, and I reject the plaintiff's contention founded on the nature and character of the proceeding in question.
It is next contended for the plaintiff that the absolute privilege, protecting the party from action, does not apply, as the statement in question was irrelevant to the inquiry then being held. The defendant's case in that inquiry was, that no melvaram was due to the plaintiff and that the latter filed the application under S. 74 needlessly and out of spite. While stating that the melwaram had been already paid, he recounts the history of the relations between himself and the plaintiff. The lands had originally belonged to his father-in-law, who presented a “harvest petition” against the plaintiff, and before the passing of the award, the latter murdered his father-in-law. Then the defendant goes on to say that on his father-in-law's death, his share devolved upon him and his wife, which the plaintiff was anxious to purchase but he would not accede to his request. Displeased with him on that account, the plaintiff unnecessarily filed the application in question. This is the gist of what the defendant stated before the Revenue Officer. The Law is not that the statement, on which the privilege is conferred, must be relevant in the narrow sense of that word; the statement must be made with reference to the subject of the inquiry or must be relative to the matter in hand—this is what the authorities lay down. In the judgment of Bramwell J.A in Seaman v. Netherclift this point has been dealt with very tersely and clearly. Says Bramwell J.A:
“As to the first proposition I am by no means sure that the word “relevant” is the best word that could be used; the phrases used by the Chief Baron and the Lord Chancellor in Dawkins v. Lord Rokeby(2) would seem to be preferable; “having reference” or “made with reference to the inquiry.”
Then he shows by giving an example what is meant by a statement which has no reference to the inquiry at all. Suppose while a witness is in the box, a man were to coma in at the door and the witness were to exclaim, “That man picked my pocket,” that is not the kind of statement in respect of which the witness would enjoy immunity. Bramwell J.A goes onto say that the words “having reference to the inquiry” ought to have a very wide and comprehensive application and ought to extend to a statement which a witness might naturally and reasonably make when giving evidence with reference to the matter in hand. Cockburn C.J makes similar observations and referring to statements de hors the matter in hand, gives the following instance:—
“If a man, when in the witness-box, were asked: Were you at York on a certain day? and he were to answer: ‘Yes, and A.B picked my pocket there’.”
Such a statement would be altogether de hors the character of witness and not within the privilege. I may also refer to Adivaramma v. Ramachandra Reddy where Wallis J., as he then was, took the same view. Judged by this test, absolute immunity attaches to the statement in question.
In the result, I hold that the judgment of the lower Court, which reversed that of the District Munsif, is wrong and the suit is accordingly dismissed. Although the defendant succeeds, he is not in the circumstances entitled to costs, and I therefore direct each party to bear his costs throughout. The memorandum of objections is dismissed. No costs.
N.R.R Ordered accordingly.
Alert