- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Barendra Nath Mitter v. Martin And Co. And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal arises from an order of Mr. Justice Buckland concerning the distribution of surplus sale proceeds in a mortgage suit. The material facts (not in dispute) are:
- On 14 May 1909 Mallik mortgaged immoveable property in favour of the Mitters; the property lay partly within and partly beyond the ordinary original civil jurisdiction of the Court.
- On 1 September 1910 the Mitters sued to enforce their security; preliminary decree 28 April 1911; final decree 12 July 1912; sale held 23 November 1918.
- Martin & Co. obtained a decree against Mallik on 2 June 1911 and attached the mortgaged properties in execution on 25 August 1911.
- On 21 April 1914 (after Martin & Co.'s attachment), Mallik executed another mortgage in favour of Barendra Nath Mitter; that mortgagee sued on 1 November 1915 with preliminary decree 4 February 1916 and final decree 4 July 1917; sale in the primary mortgage suit produced a surplus when amounts were ascertained on 27 August 1919.
- Other decree-holders with dates of decree and dates of application for execution/attachment were: Manmathanath Mallik (decree 21 Aug 1911; applied 14 Jul 1916), Srinath Pal (decree 1 May 1911; applied 14 Aug 1916), Duni Chand (decree 25 May 1917; applied 31 Aug 1917), Gorakhpur Bank (decree 10 Jul 1916; applied 18 Dec 1918).
- The purchaser paid the balance of purchase money into Court on 3 January 1919; the court treated that date as the receipt of assets by the Court for distribution purposes.
Mr. Justice Buckland had ordered that Martin & Co. be paid before Barendra Nath Mitter, and that Barendra Nath Mitter take priority before certain other creditors (with a particular ordering among creditors). Barendra Nath Mitter appealed against that order. The principal legal question for this Court was the construction and application of Sections 64 and 73 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC), 1908, to determine the relative rights to the surplus sale proceeds.
Legal Issues Presented
- How should Sections 64 and 73 of the CPC, 1908, be construed and applied to determine the relative rights of Martin & Co., Barendra Nath Mitter (the 1914 mortgagee), and other decree-holders to the surplus sale proceeds of mortgaged property?
- Whether a mortgage executed after an attachment (here, Barendra Nath Mitter's 1914 mortgage of the equity of redemption) is void as against the attaching creditor and others whose claims are enforceable under that attachment.
- Whether claims for rateable distribution (under Section 73) are "claims enforceable under the attachment" for the purpose of Section 64 when such claims arise after the private alienation/transfers or after the date of attachment but before receipt of assets by the Court.
- What is the relevant point of time for determining who is entitled to rateable distribution—date of sale, date of receipt of assets by the Court, or date(s) of attachment/application for execution?
Arguments of the Parties
Barendra Nath Mitter (appellant) — summarized from the opinion
- Claimed priority under Clause (c) of the proviso to sub-section (1) of Section 73 of the CPC, 1908 — i.e., that as a subsequent encumbrancer (mortgagee of 21 April 1914) he falls within the third category in Clause (c) and thus takes precedence over persons in the fourth category (holders of money decrees who applied for execution before the sale).
- Contended that Section 64 ceased to operate as soon as the sale was held under the decree obtained by the first mortgagee (i.e., his mortgage should not be treated as void as against claims enforceable under the attachment once a sale had occurred).
Other decree-holders (summarized from the opinion)
- Martin & Co. (attaching creditor of 25 August 1911) relied on their attachment as giving a priority claim enforceable under Section 64.
- The other four execution creditors (Manmathanath Mallik, Srinath Pal, Duni Chand and Gorakhpur Bank) argued that, because they had applied for execution before the Court received the assets (purchase money paid into Court on 3 January 1919), they are entitled to rateable distribution under Section 73 and that Barendra Nath Mitter's mortgage should be void as against their claims for rateable distribution (relying on the Explanation to Section 64 that includes claims for rateable distribution among "claims enforceable under an attachment").
Observations on parties' arguments (from the Court)
- The Court treated the central contest as over the construction of Sections 64 and 73 and the temporal point at which claims for rateable distribution are "in existence" for the purposes of Section 64.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For (as stated in the opinion) | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Ramamthan v. Subramania | Under the Code of 1882, where property is sold in execution in separate parcels, sale proceeds are not deemed realised until the entire purchase money for all parcels is paid into Court. | The Court applied this principle (and observed that the 1908 wording left the law unaltered) to treat the date of receipt of assets as the date the purchaser paid the balance into Court (3 Jan 1919), thereby placing all creditors who applied before that date in the same category for rateable distribution. |
| Payashram v. Govind | Equity of redemption is immoveable property within the meaning of the prohibitory provision (Order 21, Rule 54(1)) that prevents transfer after attachment. | Used to show that Martin & Co.'s attachment of the equity of redemption prohibited the mortgagor from validly creating a subsequent mortgage; Barendra Nath Mitter's mortgage thus contravened the prohibition applicable to immoveable property. |
| Faizar v. Pvag Nayain | Prior mortgagee is not bound or affected by an attachment or by a subsequent encumbrance; purchaser at sale is not prejudiced because sale conveys interests as at the date of first mortgage. | Cited to confirm that a sale under the first mortgage conveys interests as they stood at that date and wipes out subsequent encumbrances as between purchaser and mortgagor/mortgagee; but the Court emphasised that this does not negate Section 64's operation vis-à-vis claims enforceable under the attachment when conflict of claims for surplus proceeds arises. |
| Lokenath v. Achitananda | Similar to Faizar v. Pvag Nayain: prior mortgagee and purchaser at sale unaffected by subsequent encumbrance created pendente lite. | Referred to for the same point (sale conveys rights as at date of first mortgage) and to distinguish the consequences where the subsequent encumbrancer claims surplus proceeds against attaching creditor. |
| Soobuldas v. Joseph Iskender | Where a fund in Court has been attached by several creditors, none of the attaching creditors is entitled to preferential treatment by reason of priority of attachment. | Applied to hold that the four creditors who applied between 1916 and 1918, and Martin & Co. (1911), must be placed in the same class for rateable distribution and that successive dates of attachment do not give priority among those who applied before receipt of assets. |
| Suikeen v. Hajee Mahomed | Same principle as Soobuldas: multiple attachments of a fund do not confer preferential treatment on the earlier attacher. | Used alongside Soobuldas to support equality of rank among attaching creditors who had applied before receipt of assets by the Court. |
| Sorabji v. V. Govind | One of the authorities on whether a person who applies for rateable distribution is to be regarded as having a claim enforceable under an attachment (the opinion of Telang, J. was noted). | The Court observed that the legislature's insertion of the Explanation in Section 64 shows preference for some opinions expressed in Sorabji v. Govind; used to support the proposition that claims for rateable distribution must be in actual existence at the time of alienation to be "claims enforceable under the attachment". |
| Kushalchand v. Nandram | Listed among authorities addressing whether rateable-distribution claims are claims enforceable under attachment. | Cited as part of the body of cases relied on in argument; the Court did not adopt all propositions from these earlier decisions and observed that 1908 Code changes affected the law. |
| Jetha Bhima v. Lady Janbai | Listed among earlier cases on the same theme (rateable distribution and attachment). | Referred to as part of the previously decided cases; the Court preferred the approach indicated by Section 64's Explanation under the 1908 Code rather than relying on all pre-1908 decisions. |
| Durga Chum (Durgacharan) v. Monmohini | One of the decisions (earlier Code) taking a view contrary to Sorabji on whether rateable-distribution applicants were protected against private alienation. | Mentioned as part of the contrasting authorities; the Court noted that Code 1908 substantially altered the law and so did not undertake minute comparison, but indicated legislative preference for some views opposed to those in Durgacharan. |
| Manohar Das v. Ram Autar | Decision following the contrary view (to Sorabji) on protection of rateable-distribution claims. | Noted among conflicting pre-1908 authorities; the Court treated the 1908 provisions and the inserted Explanation as changing the law relevantly and therefore did not place decisive reliance on this line. |
| Anna Mali v. Pala Mali | Authority for the proposition that where a decree-holder attached land and others later applied for rateable distribution without attaching, and the judgment-debtor alienated and paid the attaching decree-holder, the other decree-holders could not impugn the alienation under Section 64. | Observed as supporting the view that rateable-distribution claims must be in existence at the time of alienation; the Court considered this case consistent with its narrower holding that such claims must have actually arisen by fulfilment of Section 73 conditions before alienation. |
| Delhi and London Bank v. Ramnarain | Earlier authority (pre-1908) cited among cases taking views contrary to Sorabji regarding protection for rateable-distribution applicants. | Referred to as part of the contrary line of authorities; the Court noted the 1908 Code's changes and therefore did not adopt all earlier propositions from this line. |
| Meena Kumari (Mina Kumari Bibi) v. Bijay (Bijoy) Singh | Judicial Committee decision: an alienation not made during the continuance of the attachment relied on for subsequent execution cannot be avoided by that subsequent attachment; demonstrates that the attachment relied on must be the same attachment in question. | Cited and relied upon to support the Court's conclusion that an alienation/private transfer contrary to an attachment is void only as against claims enforceable under that attachment and that such claims must be in existence at the time of alienation; used to illustrate the temporal requirement. |
| Annund Lal v. Julladhur | Private transfer contrary to an attachment is void only as against claims enforceable under the attachment (i.e., not absolutely void). | Used to support the point that Section 64 renders private transfers void only against existing claims enforceable under the attachment, and thus the persons entitled to rateable distribution are fixed at the moment of alienation. |
| Umesh v. Raj Bullubh | Same proposition: private transfer contrary to attachment is void only as against claims enforceable under the attachment. | Cited with Annund Lal and Adbul v. Gappo to support the Court's interpretation of Section 64's limited (relative) voidness. |
| Adbul v. Gappo | Same principle that private transfers contrary to attachment are void only as against claims enforceable under the attachment. | Again cited to reinforce the Court's conclusion on the relative, not absolute, invalidity of private transfers made contrary to an attachment, and that only claims in existence at alienation date are protected. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court's reasoning proceeded in structured steps applying Sections 64 and 73 of the CPC, 1908, and relevant authorities mentioned in the opinion:
- The Court first identified the temporal question: for the purpose of Section 73 (rateable distribution), the relevant time for comparison is the date of receipt of assets by the Court (i.e., when the purchaser paid the balance into Court), not the date of sale. The Court relied on Ramamthan v. Subramania to treat the date of full payment into Court (3 January 1919) as the date assets were received.
- Because Martin & Co., Manmathanath Mallik, Srinath Pal, Duni Chand and the Gorakhpur Bank had all applied for execution before the Court received assets, the Court placed them in the same class entitled to rateable distribution; priority among them could not be derived from earlier attachment dates (citing Soobuldas v. Joseph Iskender and Suikeen v. Hajee Mahomed).
- The Court examined whether Barendra Nath Mitter (who accepted a mortgage on 21 April 1914) acquired priority by virtue of Clause (c) of the proviso to sub-section (1) of Section 73. The Court held that Clause (c)'s third category (subsequent encumbrances of a kind entitled to precedence) applies only to encumbrances that in law are entitled to precedence over holders of money decrees; it cannot be used to grant precedence to encumbrances created in contravention of an existing attachment.
- Section 64 was construed: any private transfer or delivery of attached property contrary to an attachment is void as against "claims enforceable under the attachment," and the Explanation clarifies that such claims include claims for rateable distribution of assets. The Court emphasised that both the primary claim and claims for rateable distribution must be in actual existence at the time of the alienation/private transfer.
- Applying Order 21, Rule 54(1) and Payashram v. Govind, the Court held that Martin & Co.'s attachment barred the mortgagor from validly creating the later mortgage (Barendra's mortgage), because the equity of redemption is immoveable property and the attachment operated to prohibit such transfers; consequently, Barendra's mortgage was void under Section 64 as against all claims enforceable under Martin & Co.'s attachment.
- The Court rejected Barendra's contention that Section 64's operation ceased after the sale under the first mortgage; it held that, in a dispute over surplus proceeds between an attaching creditor and a subsequent encumbrancer, Section 64 must be given effect and the subsequent encumbrancer cannot claim priority unless he can show legal entitlement to precedence.
- As to the contention of the four execution creditors that Barendra's mortgage should be void as against their claims for rateable distribution, the Court held that claims for rateable distribution are included among "claims enforceable under the attachment" only if they were actually in existence at the time of the alienation/private transfer — i.e., if the requisite application to the Court for execution had already been made before the alienation. In short, the persons entitled to rateable distribution (like the attaching creditor) are fixed at the moment of alienation.
- The Court cited and discussed a number of earlier authorities (including Meena Kumari v. Bijay Singh and several pre-1908 cases) to show that the 1908 Code and the inserted Explanation in Section 64 led to the conclusion adopted: claims for rateable distribution must have been in existence at the date of alienation to be protected by Section 64.
Holding and Implications
The Court gave the following definitive orders and immediate effects on the parties:
- Core ruling: Barendra Nath Mitter's appeal is dismissed.
- Distribution of the available surplus sale proceeds is determined as follows:
- Martin & Co. will be paid first from the available surplus assets.
- Barendra Nath Mitter will be paid from the balance remaining after the dues of Martin & Co. have been satisfied.
- Any further balance will be distributed rateably among Manmathanath Mallik, Srinath Pal, Duni Chand and the Gorakhpur Bank.
- Costs:
- The appeal of Barendra Nath Mitter is dismissed with costs payable to Martin & Co.
- The appeal is allowed with costs as against the other respondents except the Gorakhpur Bank (because this decision does not alter the Bank's position under Mr. Justice Buckland's order).
- The order for costs made by Mr. Justice Buckland stands as between Barendra Nath Mitter and Martin & Co., but is set aside as between Barendra Nath Mitter and Satyendra Nath Pal (who will pay Mitter's costs).
- Costs allowed will be taxed on a hearing.
The opinion's effect is to resolve the parties' immediate disputes over entitlement to the surplus proceeds according to the Court's construction of Sections 64 and 73; the decision fixes the order of payment among the listed parties and addresses costs as above.
Mookerjee, A.C.J:— This is an appeal from the judgment of Mr. Justice Buckland on an application for the distribution of the surplus sale proceeds in a mortgage suit. The facts material for the determination of the questions raised before us are not in dispute and may be briefly recited.
2. On the 14th May, 1909, Mallik executed in favour of the Mitters a mortgage of immoveable property situated partly within and partly beyond the local limits of the ordinary original civil jurisdiction of this Court.
3. On the 1st September, 1910, the Mitters instituted a suit to enforce their security. The preliminary decree was made on the 28th April, 1911, and was followed by the final decree on the 12th July, 1912. The sale was held in due course, on the 23rd November, 1918. When the amount due on the mortgage in suit had been ascertained on the 27th August, 1919, it was found that a considerable surplus would be left after satis-faction of the claim of the mortgagees. Meanwhile, after the preliminary decree but before the final decree in the mortgage suit had been made, Martin & Co. on the 2nd June, 1911, obtained a decree against Mallik for a sum of Rs. 80,289-5-9, and on the 25th August, 1911, attached the mortgaged properties in execution of their money-decree. Some time afterwards, during the pendency of the mortgage suit, after the final decree therein but before the sale in execution, Mallik, on the 21st April, 1914, executed another mortgage in favour of one of the Mitters. The mortgagee instituted a suit on the 1st November, 1915, to enforce this security. The preliminary decree was made on the 4th February, 1916, and was followed by the final decree on the 4th July, 1917.
4. There were other creditors of Mallik who held decrees for money against him and applied for execution, as set out in the following statement:
Name of Creditor. Date of Decree. Date of application for execution and attachment. Manmathanath Mallik 21st August 1911 14th July, 1916 Srinath Pal 1st May, 1911 14th August, 1916 Duni Chand 25th May, 1917 31st August, 1917 Gorakhpur Bank 10th July, 1916 18th December, 1918
5. The question in controversy relates to the relative rights in the surplus sale proceeds, of Martin, & Co. Barendra Nath Mitter (the mortgagee of 1914), Manmatha Nath Mallik, Srinath Pal, Duni Chand and the Gorakhpur Bank. Mr. Justice Buckland has held that Martin & Co. are entitled to be paid before Barendra Nath Mitter who, in his opinion, is entitled to payment before the creditors who attached subsequent to the sale in the, suit of the first mortgagee, that is, before the Gorakhpur Bank, but after Manmath a Nath Mallik, Srinath Pal and Duni Chand. We have been invited in the present appeal, which has been preferred by Barendra Nath Mitter, to examine the legality of this order. The relative rights of the claimants must depend primarily upon the true construction of Sections 64 and 73 of the CPC, 1908.
6. Section 73 provides as follows:—
“(1) Where assets are held by a Court and more persons than one have, before the receipt of such assets, made application to the Court for the execution of decrees for the payment of money passed against the same judgment-debtor and have not obtained satisfaction thereof, the assets, after deducting the costs of realization, shall be rateably distributed among all such persons:
Provided as follows:—
(a)………….
(b)……………
(c) Where any immoveable property is sold in execution of a decee ordering its sale for the discharge of an incumbrance thereon, the proceeds of sale shall be applied—
first, in defraying the expenses of the sale;
secondly, in discharging the amount due under the decree;
thirdly, in discharging the interest and principal monies due on subsequent incumbrances (if any): and,
fourthly, rateably among the holders of decrees, for the payment of money against the judgment-debtor, who have, prior to the sale of the property, applied to the Court which passed the decree ordering such sale for execution of such decrees, and have not obtained satisfaction thereof.”
7. It is plain that to entitle a creditor to rateable distribution, he must have made an application to the Court, which holds the assets, before the receipt of such asset, for the execution of an unsatisfied decree for the payment of money passed against the same judgment-debtor, In the case before us, it is plain that Martin & Co., Manmatha Nath Mallik, Srinath Pal, Duni Chand and the Gorakhpur Bank had all applied for execution, each in respect of his own decree, before the receipt of assets by the Court. Mati lal Ray, the purchaser of one of one of the properties paid the balance of the purchase money into Court, only on the 3rd January, 1919. It was held under the Code of 1882 in the case of Ramamthan v. Subramania (1), that where property is sold in execution of an decree in separate parcels, the sale proceeds are not deemed to be realised until the entire amount of purchase money in respect of all the parcels is paid into Court. The substitution of the words “before the receipt of such assets” for the words “prior to the realisation” has clearly left the law unaltered in this respect. Consequently, from the point of view of the date of application for execution in relation to the date of the receipt of assets it follows that all the creditors, Martin & Co., Manmatha Nath Mallik, Srinath Pal, Duni Chand and the Gorakhpur Bank must be placed in the same category and are entitled to rank together.
8. The question next arises, whether Barendra Nath Mitter, who took the mortgage of the 21st April, 1914, is entitled to priority over any, and, if any, which of the money decree-holders just mentioned. He claims priority over all of them, and relies upon Clause (c) of the proviso to sub-Section (1) of Section 73. The argument in substance is that he comes under the third category mentioned in Clause (c) and consequently takes precedence over all persons included in the fourth cate-gory, which according to him, comprises the five money decree-holders just mentioned. We are of opinion that this argument is fallacious. The categories included in Clause (c) are no doubt arranged in order of priority, but the third category is obviously intended to refer to such subsequent encumbrances alone as are entitled to take precedence over the money decree-holders mentioned in the fourth category. The legislature could never have intended to include amongst the encumbrances enumerated in the third category such encumbrances, for instance, as may have been created by the judgment-debtor during the pendency of an attachment by a money decree-holder. If the contrary intention were imputed to the legislature, the result would follow that a dishonest judgment-debtor might nullify the salutary provisions of Section 64 by the creation of encumbrances after an attachment had been effected by a money decree-holder, and might, byre-course to this device, take away, through the bands of such encumbrancers, fund which would otherwise be legitimately available for the satisfaction of the claim of the unsecured creditors decree-holders. The essence of the matter is that when a subsequent encumbrancer invokes the aid of the third category of Clause (c) and claims the benefit of the priority conferred thereby, the Court is bound to satisfy itself that he is in law entitled to precedence over the holders of decrees for the payment of money mentioned in the fourth category, There is thus no escape from the conclusion that Barendra Nath Mitter cannot gain an advantage by appeal to Clause (c) of sub-Section (1) of Section 73, unless be establishes that he is a subsequent encumbrancer entitled to priority over the holders of the decrees for money already mentioned. This leads us on to an examination of the provisions of Section 64.
9. Section 64 is in the following terms:
“Where an attachment has been made, any private transfer or delivery of the property attached or of any interest therein and any payment to the judgment-debtor of any debt, dividend or other monies contrary to such attachment, shall be void as against all claims enforceable under the attachment….
Explanation—For the purposes of this section, claims enforceable under an attachment include claims for the rateable distribution of assets.”
10. In the case before us, as we have already stated, Martin & Co., attached the mortgaged property, that is, the equity of redemption, on the 25th August, 1911. Thereafter, on the 21st April, 1914, the mortgagor executed the mortgage in favour of Barendra Nath Mitter. This encumbrance was in essence a mortgage of the equity of redemption which had already been attached by Martin & Co. Under Order 21, Rule 54(1) the attachment was made by an order prohibiting the judgment-debtor from transferring or charging the property in any way and all persons from taking any benefit from such transfer or charge. It was immaterial; that the property was the equity of redemption, because as pointed out in Payashram v. Govind (2), the equity of redemption, of a mortgagor is immoveable property within the meaning of this prohibitory provision of the law. The mortgage executed in favour of Barendra Nath Mitter, in contravention of this provision of the law, forthwith attracted the operation of Section 64, namely, the mortgage became void as against all claims enforceable under the attachment. It has been argued, however, on behalf of the mortgagee that Section 64 ceased to operate as soon as the sale was held under the decree obtained by the first mortgagee. But neither authority nor principle supports this construction which attributes to Section 64 an operation restricted in point of time. Doubtless, the prior mortgagee was in no way bound or affected either by the attachment or the subsequent encumbrance created pendente lite; Faizar v. Pvag Nayain (3); Lokenath v. Achitananda (4); the purchaser who acquired the property at the sale was not prejudiced thereby, for such a sale conveyed the interests of the mortgagor and mortgagee as they were at the date of the first mortgage, and therefore necessarily swept away the subsequent encumbrance. But it cannot be overlooked that the subsequent mortgagee claims the surplus sale proceeds on the basis of his position as mortgagee, and the attaching creditor also founds his claim on the attachment effected by him. Consequently, when this conflict of claims arises, we are bound to, give effect to the provision of Section 64 and treat the encumbrance void as against all claims enforceable under the attachment. The provisions of Section 64 would, be completely superseded, if we were to give effect to the contention of the second mortgagee that not only has his mortgage ceased to be void as against all claims enforceable under the attachment, but that he has become actually entitled to priority over the attaching creditor. We hold accordingly that Barendra Nath Mitter is not entitled, as against Martin & Co., to be placed in the third category of Clause (c) of the proviso to sub-Section (1) of Section 73 of the CPC.
11. The question next arises, whether the other decree-holders, namely, Manmatha Nath Mallik, Srinath Pal, Duni Chand and the Gorakhpur Bank are entitled to rank with Martin & Co. for the purpose of precedence over Barendra Nath Mitter. We have already pointed out that the distinction made by Mr. Justice Buckland between creditors who had attached at the date of sale and creditors who attached subsequently, cannot be sustained. The material point of time is, not the date of sale (which in this case was the 23rd November, 1918), but the date of receipt of assets by the Court (which was, as we have seen, the 3rd January, 1919). Consequently the four attaching creditors just mentioned stand in the same class for this purpose, as each of them had applied for execution of his decree before the receipt of assets by the Court. It is plain that, amongst themselves, no question of priority arises on the basis of the successive attachments, for as laid down in Soobuldas v. Joseph Iskender (5), and Suikeen v. Hajee Mahomed (6), where a fund in Court has been attached by several creditors of the judgment-debtor, none of the attaching creditors is entitled to preferential treatment by reason of the priority of his attachment.
12. The question then reduces to this, whether the four creditors who applied for execution between the 14th July, 1916, and the 18th December, 1918, take rank with Martin and Co., who applied for execution and effected an attachment on the 25th August, 1911, and thus squeeze out, as it were, Barendra Nath Mitter who took his mortgage in the interval, on the 21st April, 1914. The solution of this question depends upon the true construction of the explanation to Section 64 which provides that, for the purposes of the section, claims enforceable under an attachment include claims for the rateable distribution of assets. The four execution creditors contend that, if there had been no mortgage to Barendra Nath Mitter, they would be entitled now, under Section 73, to rateable distribution along with Martin and Co., the mortgage of Barendra Nath Mitter should be deemed void, not only as against the claim of Martin and Co., but also as against their own claims for rateable distribution of assets, which they maintain, are in essence enforceable under the attachment of Martin and Co. We are of opinion that this contention is fallacious. The private transfer or delivery of the attached property is, no doubt, rendered, by virtue of Section 64, void as against all claims enforceable under the attachment inclusive of claims for the rateable dirtribution of assets. But, plainly, the claims for rateable distribution of assets, like the primary claim enforceable under the attachment, must be in actual existence when the private transfer or delivery of the attached property is made, in other words, the claims for rateable distribution of assets must have actually arisen, by reason of the fulfilment of the fundamental requirement of Section 73, namely, an application to the Court for the execution of decree for the payment of money.
13. The expression “claims enforceable under the attachment” taken apart from the explanation, unquestionably refers to a claim in existence as such on the date of the alienation. The explanation, no doubt, enlarges the scope of the words by the inclusion of claims for the rateable distribution of assets, but clearly such claims must possess the same quality as the claim primarily enforceable under the attachment, that is, actual existence at the time of alienation. In our opinion it would be unreasonable to hold that claims of the latter description include claims that might by possibility arise in the future. If we do not adopt such a construction, the consequence will follow, for all practical purposes, that once a property is attached, it can never be alienated, even though the attaching creditor does not object, may gives his consent to the transfer. Assume that an alienation is made with the consent of the attaching creditor, and some time after, other money-decrees are obtained against the same judgment-debtor, possibly upon transactions subsequent in date. It is difficult to see on what principle these subsequent decree-holders should be allowed to contend that the alienation made long before their decree, possibly long before their transactions, were void as against them. If we look at the matter from a slightly different point of view, the transferee is bound by the condition of things as they exist at the time of the transfer and is not prejudiced by events subsequent. Reference has been made, in the course of argument, to the decisions in Sorabji v. V. Govind (7); Kushalchand v. Nandram (8); Jetha Bhima v. Lady Janbai (9); Durga Chum v. Monmohini (10); Manohar Das v. Ram Autar (11); and Anna Mali v. Pala Mali (12).
14. The majority of these cases were decided under the Code of 1882; and as the Code of 1908 has substantially altered the law on this point, it would not be safe to embark upon a meticulous examination, by way of comparison and contrast, of all the relevant sections of the Codes of 1882 and 1908 with a view to determine the true meaning and effect of the new provisions. But there is considerable force in the contention that the legislature have, by insertion of the explanation in Section 64, indicated their preference for some at any rate of the opinions expressed by Telang, J., in Sorabji v. Govind , as against the view taken by Piggot, J., in Durgacharan v. Monmohini , and by Edge, C.J, in Delhi and London Bank v. Ramnarain (13), which were followed in Manohar v. Ram Autar , as authority for the proposition that the claim of a person who applies for a rateable distribution of assets is not a claim enforceable under the attachment placed upon the property at the instance of another judgment-creditor. It is not necessary, however, to hold that the alteration in the law made by the legislature is a legislative affirmance of all the propositions enunciated in Sorabji v. Govind , as appears to have been held in some of the judgments in Anna Mali v. Pala Mali . The case last mentioned is an authority for the proposition that where a decree-holder attached land in execution of his decree and other decree-holders applied for rateable distribution without attaching the land in execution of their decrees, and subsequently the judgment-debtor alienated the land and paid off the attaching decree-holder, the other decree-holders were not entitled to question the alienation under Section 64 of the CPC, 1908. For the purposes of the case before us, it is not necessary to affirm this proposition with its necessary implications in their entirety. It is sufficient to hold that the claim for rateable distribution cannot be recognised as a claim under Section 64 unless it is in actual existence at the time of the alienation; and it cannot ripen into such a claim, unless the necessary conditions formulated in Section 73 have been fulfilled. One of such conditions undoubtedly is the presentation of an application for execution of a decree for the payment of money before the receipt of assets; and we need not pause to consider, whether the claim could be deemed a claim in existence, before the receipt of assets, even after the presentation of the application for execution. The view we take is supported by the decision of the Judicial Committee in Meena Kumari v. Bijay Singh (14). In that case a decree-holder held two decrees against the same person and attached certain properties in execution of one of his decrees and would have been entitled to rateable distribution if the attachment had resulted in a sale. Pending attachment, the judgment-debtor sold the property. The attachment subsequently ceased to be operative and the decree-holder then attached the property and brought it to sale. The purchaser sought to recover the property from the alienees from the judgment-debtor. A decree was passed in his favour by the High Court, but it was reversed on appeal by the Judicial Committee on the ground that the sale in execution being under an attachment subsequent to the private alienation was not protected by Section 276. Dealing with the argument that Section 276 rendered the alienation void as against the subsequent attachment, Sir Lawrence Jenkins observed:
“That section provides that when an attachment has been made as there described any private alienation of the property attached daring the continuance of the attachment shall be void against all claims enforceable under the attachment. Ex-hypothesi, the alienation to the plaintiff was not during the continuance of the attachment in execution case No. 16 of 1907, or, in Other words, the attachment under which the execution sale to the decree-holder was made. Therefore it cannot be avoided by that attachment,”
15. It was also urged before the Judicial Committee that, having regard to the decision of the Bombay High Court in Sorabji Edulji Warden v. Govind Ramji, F.N Wadia , the decree-holder was a person who would have been entitled to rateable distribution and was consequently protected against the private alienation. The Judicial Committee disposed of the argument with the following observations: Mina Kumari Bibi v. Bijoy Singh .
“He relies on Section 293 of the CPC as entitling him to the benefit of Section 276, and for this purpose he calls in aid his application for attachment in execution case No. 8 of 1902. To bring Section 293 into play certain conditions are necessary, and one of them is that there should be assets, held by the Court. It has not been shown that there were such assets, and the indications in the record point the other way. But apart from this, Section 293 cannot help the decree-holder. Though the word 1 attachment occurs three times in Section 276, the reference is to one, and only one, attachment; that one in this case is the attachment in execution case No. 16 of 1907. All that can be done is to employ that attachment for the purpose of impugning the private alienation, for it is on that alone that the decree-holder's title to the property in suit at present rests. So that even if it be assumed, for the sake of argument, that the view which prevailed in Sorabji v. Govind , is correct, and that the conditions of Section 295 have been satisfied, it cannot advance the decree-holder's case.”
16. It may be added that as a private transfer, contrary to an attachment, is, under Section 64 not absolutely void, but void only as against claims enforceable under the attachment: Annund Lal v. Julladhur (15); Umesh v. Raj Bullubh (16); Adbul v. Gappo (17). The result of the view we take is that the question of the extent to which the validity of the alienation can be impeached must be answered with reference to such claims enforceable under the attachment inclusive of claims for the rateable distribution of assets, as are in existence on the date of alienation. The persons entitled to rateable distribution become, in other words, fixed, like the attaching creditor, at the moment the alienation takes place. The conclusions which follow from this interpretation of Sections 64 and 73 may now be summarised:
(1) Martin and Co. will be paid first, from the available surplus assets;
(2) Barendra Nath Mitter will be paid from the balance, after the dues of Martin and Co., have been satisfied;,
(3) the balance, if any, will be available for rateable distribution amongst Manmatha Nath Mallik, Srinath Pal, Duni Chand and the Gorakhpur Bank.
17. The result is that the appeal of Barendra Nath Mitter is dismissed with costs payable to Martin and, Co. The appeal is allowed with costs as against the other respondents except the Gorakhpur Bank, as the position assigned to the Bank by the order of Mr. Justice Bucklaud has not been altered in effect by our decision. The order for costs made by Mr. Justice Buokland will stand as between Barendra Nath Mitter and Martin and Co., but will be set aside as between Barendra Nath Mitter and Satyendra Nath Pal, who will pay the costs of the former.
18. The costs allowed will be taxed on a hearing.
Fletcher, J.:— I agree. Appeal dismissed.
Alert