- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ram Kishon Ram Bhakat And Anr. Decree-Holders v. Satya Narain Bhakat And Ors. Judgment-Debtors, S
The Judgment of the Court was as follows:—
A preliminary objection has been put forward to the effect that no appeal lies in this case, having regard to the provisions of sec. 102 of the Code of Civil Procedure. In view of the fact that the suit with reference to which this appeal arises appears to have been valued at Rs. 408, the preliminary objection must prevail. An alternative application has, however, been filed to the effect that the appeal may be treated as an application for revision and this application has been granted.
It appears that the Plaintiffs obtained a decree in the Court of the Munsif at Rampurhat on the 25th of February, 1931. This decree was put into execution at Rampurhat and a sum of Rs. 80 was realised. On the 1st, of February, 1933, the decree-holders applied to the Munsif at Rampurhat for a certificate of non-satisfaction and for the transmission of the decree for execution to the Jangipur Court in accordance with the provisions of sec. 39 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The decree was duly transmitted for execution to the Jangipur Court, but it appears that no further steps were taken at the Jangipur Court towards the execution of the decree with the result that on the 2nd of March, 1936, the decree was returned to the Court of the Munsif at Rampurhat. In the meantime on the 31st of January, 1936, the decree-holders filed a further application for execution at Rampurhat. This application appears to have been registered at Rampurhat on the 18th of March, 1936 and it was subsequently transferred to the Munsif at Jangipur for execution. The application was ultimately dismissed on the 11th of July, 1936. Subsequently another application for execution was filed on the 30th of January, 1937 and it is with this last application that we are now dealing. The first Court held that the application dated the 30th of January, 1937, had been filed in time. The lower Appellate Court held, however, that the application in question was time-barred on account of the fact that the previous application for execution dated the 31st of January, 1936, had not been filed in the proper Court in accordance with law as required by the provisions of Art. 182(5) of the Indian Limitation Act.
It has been argued by the learned Advocate for the Petitioners in this case that the application for execution, dated the 31st of January, 1936, was properly received by the Munsif at Rampurhat, even although the decree had been transferred for execution to the Court of the Munsif at Jangipur. In my opinion, however, this case is governed by the principles which have been laid down by the Privy Council in the case of Maharajah of Bobbili v. Narasarajupedusimhulu (1). In that case their Lordships of the Judicial Committee pointed out that after a decree had been transferred to another Court for execution, the proper Court to which a subsequent application for execution should be made was the transferee Court, as that was the Court whose duty it then was to execute the decree so far as it could be executed by that Court.
It is quite clear from the facts of the case now before me that on the 31st of January, 1936, the decree was actually pending for execution in the Court of the Munsif at Jangipur and it was in that Court that any further application for execution should have been filed.
It was not until the 2nd of March, 1936, that the execution case was retransferred by the Jangipur Court to the Rampurhat Court. The learned Advocate for the Petitioners contends that this date, namely, the 2nd of March, 1936, should be taken as the date of a final order passed on an application for execution, within the meaning of Art. 182(5) of the Indian Limitation Act and that if this contention is accepted, he argues that the present application for execution would be in time. In my opinion, however, it cannot be said that any final order with reference to the application for execution was passed on the 2nd of March, 1936. All that happened on this date was that the Jangipur Court re-transferred the execution proceedings to the Rampurhat Court and these particular proceedings remained in the same condition as they were, when they were transferred to the Jangipur Court on the 1st of February, 1933. It certainly cannot be said, therefore, that any final order was passed on the 2nd of March, 1936, with reference to these proceedings. To my mind it is quite clear that the application for execution, which was filed on the 31st of January, 1936, was not made to a proper Court within the meaning of Art. 182(5) of the Indian Limitation Act. It follows, therefore, that this case has been rightly decided by the Court below. The appeal is therefore dismissed.
This application for revision is, therefore, rejected. I make no order with regard to costs.
C.C
Alert