Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Binode Lal Chakraburtti v. Preo Nath Chakraburtti

Calcutta High Court
Mar 30, 1917
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.

1. In our opinion there can be no room for controversy that the view taken by Walmsley, J., is amply supported by the authorities. The plaintiff instituted this suit for recovery of money in the alternative from two sets of defendants. He claimed arrears of rent from the tenant-defendants and alleged, at the same time, that if the entire rent had already been realised from them by his co-sharers, he was entitled to a decree as against the latter. This form of action is well known [Sham Singh v. Kishun Sahai (1), Aiyathurai Ravuthan v. Santha Meera Ravuthan, (2), Yerukola v. Mudiya Kamudu (3)]. The Court of first instance found that the entire rent had been collected on 4th November 1907 by defendant 4 who was apparently the managing member of the family composed of the plaintiff and his co-sharers. The trial Court accordingly dismissed the suit against the tenant-defendants and made a decree against defendant 4. Thereupon defendant 4 appealed and argued that the claim, as against him, was barred by limitation, inasmuch as the rent had been collected by him on 4th November 1907 and the suit had not been instituted till 18th April 1911. The Sub-ordinate Judge gave effect to this contention and dismissed the suit. That decree has been affirmed by Walmsley, J., on second appeal to this Court.

2. It is plain that the case is governed by Article 62, Sch. 1, Lim. Act. That Article applies to a suit for money payable by the defendant to the plaintiff for money received by the defendant for the plaintiff's use.

3. It is now well settled that this article is applicable even though the defendant at the time when he received the money did not intend to pay it to the plaintiff, the operation of the article is attracted if it is established that the money received by the defendant is money which belongs to the plaintiff and is repayable to him in justice, equity and good conscience. In support of this proposition reference may be made to the case of Mahomed Wahib v. Mahomed Ameer (4). The same view has been subsequently adopted in a long series of decisions and the rule embodied in Article 62 has been applied in a variety of cases more or less analogous in their circumstances to those of the cases before us. We may mention the decision in Subbanna Bhatta v. Kunhanna Banta (5), Shanmuga Pillai v. Minor Govindasami (6), Sankunni Menon v. Govinda Menon (7), Baiznath Lala v. Ramadoss (8) and Niader Singh v. Ganga Dei (9). In our opinion, Article 62 is applicable to this case, and as the plaintiff has not sought the protection of Section 18 of the Lim. Act, on the allegation of fraud the suit has been rightly dismissed as barred by limitation. The appeal is consequently dismissed with costs.

V.B/R.K

4. Appeal dismissed.