- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Dwarka Nath Das v. Monmohan Tafadar
This was a Rule calling upon the Opposite Party to show cause why the order of the Small Cause Court dismissing a suit for limitation should not be set aside.
The case is one which clearly falls under sec. 22 of the Limitation Act; and the question is whether it can be said that a pro formâ Defendant who was joined at the institution of the suit and who is made a Plaintiff after the period of limitation can be brought, within the meaning of sec. 22 of the Limitation Act as a new Plaintiff. On the authority of several cases, first of all the case of Nagendrabala Debya v. Tarapada Acharjee(1), then that of Hossainara Begum v. Rahimunessi Begum(2) and lastly that of Narsinh v. Vaman Venkatrao(3), we are of opinion that the rule, that a party transferred from the side of the Defendants to that of the Plaintiffs is not a new party to whom the provisions of sec. 22 of the Limitation Act apply, is an absolute rule and cannot be distinguished in the way in which the learned pleader for the Opposite Party has sought to distinguish it upon certain remarks in the case in Nagendrabala Debya v. Tarapada Acharjee. No such limitation was placed upon it by the Judges who presided over the Bench which issued the rule in delivering the judgment in the case in Hossainara Begum v. Rahimunessa Begum. On the contrary, he pointed out that the person who was transferred from the category of Defendant to the category of Plaintiff could not have maintained the action at the time the suit was instituted; and in the Bombay case the rule is stated without any qualification whatever. With regard to the case in Nagendrabala Debya v. Tarapada Acharjee, to which one of us was a party, we certainly did not intend to lay down that the circumstance mentioned, namely, that the original Plaintiff had a right to enforce his interest as co-sharer, should in any way affect the rule which we laid down in the same terms as it was laid down in the subsequent cases.
We are therefore of opinion that this Rule must be made absolute. The case will be remanded to the lower Court for a decision on the merits.
The Petitioners are entitled to the costs of this hearing which we assess at two gold mohurs.
Rule made absolute.
Alert