Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sewaram Gokaldas v. Bajrangdat Hardwar Potdar

Bombay High Court
Sep 20, 1915
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiffs, carrying on business in Bombay, had dealings with the defendant, who carried on business at Bassum in Akola under the style of Chatandas‑Shankardas. The parties' account was said to have been settled in 1912. After paying a certain sum in cash, the defendant passed two hundis for Rs. 900 and Rs. 1,000, respectively, drawn on his own firm and payable 181 and 361 days after sight. Those hundis were not met when due and the plaintiffs sued for recovery. Paragraph 5 of the plaint stated that the defendant resided at Bassum and that, although the hundis were passed at Bassum, their consideration was the balance due for transactions effected in Bombay and that a material part of the cause of action arose in Bombay. Leave was obtained under Clause 12 of the Letters Patent to file the suit in Bombay. The court examined whether any part of the cause of action had arisen within the local limits of the Bombay court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether any part of the cause of action arose within the local limits of the Bombay court for the purposes of jurisdiction under Clause 12 of the Letters Patent.
  2. Whether the consideration alleged to arise out of transactions in Bombay (the balance of account) constituted a part of the cause of action enabling suit in Bombay despite the hundis being passed elsewhere.
  3. Whether leave granted under Clause 12 was properly given where the hundis were not, in fact, payable in Bombay.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined whether the facts necessary to be proved by the plaintiffs to obtain a decree (the "cause of action") included the underlying transactions in Bombay or were limited to the hundis themselves. The court noted that under the Negotiable Instruments Act the consideration for hundis is to be presumed, so a plaintiff may be entitled to a decree on production of the hundis unless the defendant proves absence of consideration. The judge explained his practice under Clause 12: he had granted leave when the money was payable in Bombay and refused leave when payable outside Bombay. He reasoned that if a Bombay merchant accepts a promissory-note or hundi up country in satisfaction of an account arising from Bombay transactions, the merchant must ensure the instrument is made payable in Bombay if he wishes to sue in Bombay. On inspecting the hundis, the court found the plaint's statement that the hundis were payable in Bombay to be incorrect. The judge concluded that he had relied on that misstatement in granting leave and, had he known the true facts, he would have refused leave. Consequently, the court held it lacked jurisdiction.

Holding and Implications

The Court has no jurisdiction; the plaint is to be returned for presentation in the proper Court.

Direct consequences: the plaint was returned and the plaintiffs were ordered to pay the defendant's costs. The opinion does not discuss broader legal implications; it sets no new precedent beyond the court's stated practice regarding leave under Clause 12.

Show all summary ...

1. The plaintiffs, carrying on business in Bombay, had dealings with the defendant, who is said to carry on business at Bassum in Akola under the style of Chatandas-Shankardas. The plaintiffs say that the account was settled in 1912 between the parties. The defendant, after paying a certain amount in cash, passed two hundis for Rs. 900 and Rs. 1,000, respectively, drawn on his own firm by the defendant payable in Bombay 181 and 361 days after sight, respectively. As those hundis were not met when they fell due, the plaintiffs brought this suit for the recovery of the amount. Para. 5 of the plaint states that the defendant resides at Bassum; that the hundis were passed at Bassum but the consideration of the hundis was the balance of the account due by the defendant to the plaintiffs in respect of transactions effected in Bombay and the moneys were payable to the plaintiffs in Bombay and a material part of the cause of action arose in Bombay. Leave was obtained under Cl. 12 of the Letters Patent to file the suit in Bombay. The question has now arisen whether any part of the cause of action has arisen within the local limits. It must be admitted, on an inspection of the hundis that the Statement in the plaint that the hundis were payable in Bombay is incorrect. But it is contended that the consideration for the hundis was the balance of account due by the defendant to the plaintiffs in respect of transactions effected in Bombay.

2. The question is whether that was a part of the cause of action. The point apparently does not seem to have arisen before; but if the whole cause of action consists of those facts which it is necessary for the plaintiffs to prove in order to succeed in getting a decree, then it was not necessary to prove the transactions out of which the present claim arose, as the claim on those transactions was satisfied by the passing of the hundis and under the Negotiable Instruments Act the consideration for the hundis must be presumed, so the plaintiffs are entitled to a decree merely on production of the hundis unless the defendant can show that there was no consideration.

3. In giving leave under Cl. 12 of the Letters Patent in suits on promissory-notes or hundis, I have always given leave when the money was payable in Bombay and refused leave when the money was payable out of Bombay; and, in my opinion, if there are transactions in Bombay, which result in a credit in favour of the Bombay merchant against an up country merchant, and if the Bombay merchant goes to settle his account up country and accepts a promissory-note or hundi in isfaction of his account, then if he wants to sue on that note in Bombay he must take the precaution to see that the note is made payable in Bombay.

4. Unfortunately, the plaintiffs when they applied for leave, made a misstatement in the plaint upon which I relied in granting the leave. If I had been aware that the facts stated in the plaint were incorrect, I should have refused the leave. Therefore, I must hold now that the Court has no jurisdiction. The plaint should be returned to the plaintiffs for presentation in the proper Court. The plaintiffs to pay the defendant's costs.

G.P/R.K

5. Plaint returned.