Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Shantilal, In Re

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Jan 14, 1959
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a reference by the learned Sessions Judge, West Nimar, Mandleshwar, recommending that the order passed by the Magistrate, First Class, Kasrawad, in Criminal Case No. 136 of 1957 dated April 4, 1958 be set aside and the prosecution be allowed to furnish fresh documents in that trial.

Shantilal and seven others were being tried by the Magistrate, First Class, Kasrawad, on charges under Section 147 read with Section 34, Indian Penal Code. With the police report dated October 28, 1957, certain copies were filed under Section 173 of the Criminal Procedure Code and those copies were supplied to the accused. Charges were framed on December 6, 1957.

On March 20, 1958 the prosecution applied to the trial Magistrate for leave to file two additional documents: (i) an application dated April 9, 1957 from the complainant Chunnilal to the District Superintendent of Police, which had been forwarded to the Station House Officer after the prosecution had been initiated; and (ii) a copy of a judgment dated March 12, 1958 passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Mandleshwar, in Criminal Appeal No. 108 of 1957.

The prosecution's application was opposed by the defence. The trial Magistrate held that once copies are filed under Section 173 CrPC, supplementary or additional documents could not be permitted to be filed because the Code contained no such provision and, in his view, documents could only be filed before the commencement of the trial. On revision the Sessions Judge took a contrary view and referred the matter to the higher court for decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial Magistrate has the power to allow the prosecution to file/produce additional documents after copies have been filed under Section 173 CrPC and after the commencement of the trial.

Arguments of the Parties

Prosecution's Arguments (as presented by Shri S.L. Dube)

  • Relied on decisions (Chaturbhuj v. Naharkhan; K. Somasuadaram v. Gopal; Ali Jan v. Amir Khan) holding that the court has power to allow fresh witnesses to be examined even if they were not named in the original list.
  • Contended that although Section 173(4) requires that copies of all documents on which the prosecution relies be furnished before the commencement of the trial and is mandatory in nature, this provision does not contain any disabling clause that strips the court of power to permit filing of fresh documents.
  • Argued that the first document sought to be produced came to the investigating officer after the challan was submitted, and the second document (the judgment) could not have been filed with the challan because it was pronounced after institution of the police report; therefore the trial court should have discretion to admit them.
  • Maintained that magistrates must have discretion to regulate production of evidence by parties within legal limits and there is no express provision in the Code preventing prosecution from filing additional documents or statements of witnesses later in the proceedings.

Defence / Trial Magistrate's Position

  • The prosecution's March 20, 1958 application was opposed by the defence (specific defence arguments are not separately detailed in the opinion).
  • The trial Magistrate held that once copies are filed under Section 173 CrPC, supplementary or additional documents could not be permitted because the Code contains no provision allowing such filing after the stage when the documents are submitted; i.e., documents must be filed before commencement of trial.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Chaturbhuj v. Naharkhan, 1957 MPC 190 : AIR 1958 Madh Pra 28 Cited for the proposition that the court has power to allow fresh witnesses to be examined even if they were not named in the original list. Relied upon by the prosecution (and accepted by the court as persuasive) to support the view that courts possess discretion to admit additional evidence/documents.
K. Somasuadaram v. Gopal, AIR 1958 Mad 341 Cited for the same proposition regarding the court's power to allow fresh witnesses. Relied upon as supportive authority for judicial discretion to permit additional evidence.
Ali Jan v. Amir Khan, AIR 1957 Cal 332 Cited for the same proposition regarding allowing fresh witnesses not named earlier. Relied upon by the prosecution and treated as supportive of permitting additional evidence.
Public Prosecutor v. C.S. Pachiappa Mudaliar, AIR 1958 Mad 295 Noted by the court as a recent decision of the Madras High Court supportive of the view permitting late production/admission of evidence. The court expressly stated it was supported in its view by this decision and used it to reinforce the conclusion that the magistrate has power to admit the additional documents.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court acknowledged that Section 173(4) CrPC requires that copies of all documents on which the prosecution relies be furnished to the defence before commencement of the trial and that the provision is mandatory in nature. However, the court analyzed the text of the provision and found no disabling language that would make the magistrate powerless to allow the prosecution to produce fresh documents later in the proceedings.

The court observed that the first document the prosecution sought to produce came to the investigating officer after the challan had been submitted, and the second document (a judgment) could not have been filed with the challan because it was pronounced subsequent to the institution of the police report. The court emphasized that a trial magistrate must retain judicial discretion to regulate the production of evidence by the parties within the limits prescribed by law, and where there is no express provision debarring evidence at a certain stage, the procedure should not be construed so as to deprive the court of that discretion.

The court stated it found no provision in Section 173 or elsewhere in the Criminal Procedure Code which prevents the prosecution from filing additional documents or statements of witnesses on which it proposes to rely. It recognized that the value to be attached to such additional documents produced late will depend on the peculiar circumstances of each case.

The court noted it was supported in this view by a recent decision of the Madras High Court (Public Prosecutor v. C.S. Pachiappa Mudaliar, AIR 1958 Mad 295), and accordingly concluded that the trial magistrate had the power to admit the two documents sought to be produced, subject to supplying copies to the defence.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Reference accepted; the order dated April 4, 1958 passed by the Magistrate, First Class, Kasrawad is set aside, and the prosecution is granted leave to file both documents referred to in the application dated March 20, 1958, provided copies are supplied in advance to the defence.

Implications: The direct effect is that the trial magistrate's order refusing leave to file the two documents is vacated and the prosecution may produce them subject to supplying copies to the accused. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new, broad precedent beyond this case; it rests its decision on the interpretation that Section 173 does not contain an express disabling provision and on authorities cited that support judicial discretion to admit additional evidence. No further or expansive implications are articulated in the opinion.

Reference accepted.

Show all summary ...

1. This is a reference by the learned Sessions Judge, West Nimar, Mandleshwar, recommending that the order passed by the Magistrate. First Class, Kasrawad, in Criminal Case No. 136 of 1957 on April 4, 1958, be set aside and the prosecution be allowed to furnish fresh documents in the course of that trial.

2. The material facts are that Shantilal and seven others are being tried by the Magistrate, First Class. Kasrawad, who has framed a charge against each of them under Section 147 read with Section 34 I.P.C With the police report dated October 28, 1957, certain copies were filed under section 173 of the Cr PC.

3. These copies were supplied to the accused. On December 6, 1957, charges were framed against the accused. On March 20, 1958 the prosecution, made an application to the trial Magistrate seeking leave to file two more document viz., (i) application dated April 9, 1957, addressed by Chunnilal (complainant) to the District Superintendent of Police, in connection with this very matter, which was forwarded to the Station House Officer after the prosecution had been initiated, and (ii) copy of judgment dated March 12, 1958, passed by the additional Sessions Judge. Mandleshwar in Criminal appeal No. 108 of 1957.

4. The said application dated March 20, 1958, was opposed by the defence. The learned trial magistrate held that once copies are filed under section 173 of the Cr PC, supplementary or additional documents could not be permitted to be filed as there was no such provision in the Code. According to him, the only stage of filing the documents is before fee commencement of the trial.

5. On revision, the learned Sessions Judge has taken a contrary view and has referred this case here as stated above.

6. Shri S.L Dube, learned Deputy Government Advocate supporting the reference, has relied on the decisions in Chaturbhuj v. Naharkhan, 1957 MPC 190 : (AIR 1958 Madh Pra 28) K. Somasuadaram v. Gopal, AIR 1958 Mad 341; and Ali Jan v. Amir Khan Opposite Party., (S), AIR 1957 Cal 332. In these cases it has been held that the court has power to allow fresh witnesses to be examined although they may not have been named in the original list. I am aware of the conflict of judicial opinion on the interpretation of the expression ‘remaining witnesses’ used in section 256 of the Code. But that is not the point for consideration before me. From the wording of section 173(4), it is very clear that the law imperatively requires copies of all documents on which the prosecution relies to be furnished to the defence before the commencement of the trial. It is also true that the provision is mandatory in nature. But in this provision, we cannot read any disabling provision so that the court becomes powerless to allow the prosecution to the fresh documents. In the present case, the first document above-named came to the investigation officer after he had submitted the challan to the court and the second document is patently one which could not be filed with the challan because that judgment was pronounced subsequent to the institution if the police report in court. That apart, the magistrate in the discharge of his judicial functions must always be that free to exercise his discretion in the matter of production of evidence by the parties, within the limits prescribed by the law, and it there is no express provision debarring evidence to be produced at a certain stage, the procedure should be construed in such a manner as not to deprive the court of that discretion. In Section 173, nor in any other provision of the Code of Criminal Procedure, do I find any such disabling provision; I do not find in the Code any provision which prevents the prosecution from filing additional documents or statements of witnesses on whom they propose to rely. What value is to be attached to such additional documents which are produced at a late stage, will always depend upon the peculiar circumstances of each case. I therefore hold that the trial magistrate has power to admit in evidence both the documents which the prosecution seeks to produce. Of course, copies thereof must be supplied to the defence. I am supported in my view by a recent decision of the Madras High Court in Public Prosecutor v. C.S Pachiappa Mudaliar ., AIR 1958 Mad 295.

7. I, therefore, accept this reference and setting aside the order dated April 4, 1958 passed by the Magistrate, First Class, Kasrawad grant leave to the prosecution to file both the documents referred to in their application dated March 20, 1958. The prosecution must supply in advance copies thereof to the defence.

K.S.B

8. Reference accepted.