Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Khatoo Sahoo v. Ratan Mahanti And Others Opposite Parties.

Calcutta High Court
May 1, 1902
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.

Ratan Mahanti and others holders a decree in the Court of Small Causes at Balasore, obtained an order, dated the 27th September, 1901, directing that a rubohari be sent to the Raja of Killa Mourbhunj through the Assistant Superintendent of the Tributary Mehals, Balasore, with a copy of the decree or of any order which may have been passed for execution of the same and a certificate of non-satisfaction. This order purports to have been passed under secs. 223 and 224, Civil Procedure Code.

The judgment-debtor has obtained this rule calling upon the decree-holders to show cause why the order complained of should not be set aside. No cause has been shown. It appears that this Court has on more than one occasion decided that the Tributary Mehals of Orissa, of which Mourbhunj is one, do not form part of British India; and this ruling has been accepted by the Secretary of State for India in Council, as appears from p. 119 of Vol. I of Mr. Aitchison's work entitled “A Collection of Treaties, Engagements and Sanads”. Under secs. 229A and 229B of the Code no decree by a Court in British India can be sent for execution into a territory such as Mourbhunj without prior notification in the India Gazette, as specified in these sections; no such notification appears to have been issued. The Judge of the Small Cause Court at Balasore had, therefore, no jurisdiction to make the order which he did in this case. The view we take is in accordance with that expressed in the case of Kasturchand Gajur v. Parshe Mahar.

The rule is accordingly made absolute and the order complained of is set aside with costs, which we assess at one gold mohur.

S.R.D
Rule made absolute.