Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Partap Mahton v. Mussammat Wazirunnisa

Patna High Court
Feb 24, 1925
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiffs (respondents in this Second Appeal) are co-sharer landlords holding together a seven-annas odd share in two villages (Nathupur and Kazi Chak Sher Muhammad). The predecessor of the plaintiffs had khudkasht lands and, after purchasing further lands in execution of a decree in 1886, held a total of 44 bighas, 11 kathas, of which 9 bighas, 6 kathas were given to a co-sharer (Nasiruddin) in 1889. The khudkasht lands were let to tenants on terms that included payment to each co-sharer of his proportionate share of rent and an additional payment (one rupee per bigha initially, later commuted to nakdi, and one maund of polished rice per bigha to the plaintiffs from tenants' profits).

Defendants (and their predecessors) had holdings they claimed as raiyati kasht subject to kabuliyats of 1894 and 1898. In 1903 a fresh settlement of khudkasht lands occurred and plaintiffs allege that 22 bighas, 9 kathas of khudkasht were wrongly recorded in the record-of-rights as defendants' kaimi raiyati kasht (33 bighas, 8 kathas in all) with an annual jama of Rs. 63-10-7 (the amount attributable to the 10 bighas, 19 kathas only). Plaintiffs alleged deception and non-payment of the plaintiffs' proportionate rent and rice from 1915.

Plaintiffs did not seek a declaration of khudkasht title or recovery of possession; they sought their proportionate share of rent for the years 1323–1327 F.S. (for both the 10 bighas, 19 kathas and the 22 bighas, 9 kathas) at the rates claimed, and the value of one maund of polished rice per bigha for the years in suit. Alternatively, they asked the Court to assess a fair and equitable rent for the 22 bighas, 9 kathas if the agreed rate could not be proved.

The defendants pleaded limitation (suit instituted more than six years after final publication of the record-of-rights) and non-joinder of other co-sharers; they denied the khudkasht character and the rice claim (alleging it would be an illegal abwab) and asserted ancestral title and a single rent of Rs. 63-0-0 for the whole.

At trial the munsif found the kabuliyats genuine, held the 22 bighas, 9 kathas to be khudkasht and settled with defendants' predecessor in 1903, but held the plaintiffs' claim for additional rent barred by limitation and held that the plaintiffs' alternative claim for assessment was barred by section 188 of the Bengal Tenancy Act because other co-sharers had not joined. He awarded plaintiffs a money decree for Rs. 113 (for years 1323–1326 F.S.) and disallowed the rice claim as contrary to the Bengal Tenancy Act.

The Subordinate Judge overturned the munsif on limitation (treating the matter as a suit for assessment within 12 years) and held section 188 inapplicable (relying on Dhananjoy Manjhi v. Upendra Nath Deb). He assessed the rent for the 22 bighas at Rs. 5-13-0 per bigha and granted a decree for past years at that rate (but rejected the rice claim).

In this Court the appeal raised two principal points (non-joinder and maintainability; and the right to claim arrears at a newly assessed rate). The Court modified the lower appellate decree, limited the plaintiffs' recovery to Rs. 113-0-0 (years 1323–1326 F.S.), granted costs to the appellants, and dismissed the cross-appeal against the disallowance of the rice claim.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a suit for assessment of rent by co-sharer landlords is maintainable in the absence of other co-sharer landlords as parties (with particular reference to section 188 of the Bengal Tenancy Act).
  2. Whether, in a suit for assessment of a fair and equitable rent, a decree can be granted for arrears for past years at the rate newly assessed by the Court (i.e., can retrospective arrears be awarded where no previous rent for the lands in question had been fixed/paid).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' (Defendants') Arguments

  • The suit was barred by limitation because it was instituted more than six years after the final publication of the record-of-rights.
  • The suit was not maintainable because not all co-sharer landlords had been joined; section 188 of the Bengal Tenancy Act was relied upon to assert that the plaintiffs could not proceed without joining other co-sharers.
  • The lands in question were not khudkasht but ancestral raiyati kasht; the rent for the whole was Rs. 63-0-0.
  • The claim for one maund of polished rice is illegal (amounting to an abwab) and not recoverable.

Respondents' (Plaintiffs') Arguments

  • The 22 bighas, 9 kathas were khudkasht and had been settled with the defendants' predecessor at specified terms (including per-bigha rent and one maund of polished rice to plaintiffs).
  • Plaintiffs sought their proportionate share of rent for the years in suit; alternatively, if the historic rate for the 22 bighas could not be proved, plaintiffs asked the Court to assess a fair and equitable rent for those lands and give a decree for arrears at the assessed rate.
  • The plaintiffs did not seek a declaration of title or recovery of possession, but a money decree for the share of rent and the value of rice (as per the pleaded terms).
  • They alleged the other co-sharers refused to join or take action, and that they (the plaintiffs) had acted in the settlement as agents of the co-sharers.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Dhananjoy Manjhi v. Upendra Nath Deb Cited by the Subordinate Judge for the proposition that section 188 of the Bengal Tenancy Act does not apply to suits for assessment of rent. The Court considered the case and related decisions; it acknowledged the Subordinate Judge's reliance but examined distinctions and analogous decisions to determine applicability of section 188 in the present facts.
Dwarka Dhakai v. Mathur Lal Majumdar Example where a co-sharer sued under section 52 (and section 188 applied) when additional area was found on measurement and other co-sharers were defendants. The Court distinguished that case from the present facts because here the claim related to lands settled under a separate agreement (khudkasht), not to lands found by measurement to be in excess of the kabuliyat area.
Gopal Chandar Das v. Umesh Narain Chowdhry Illustrates a case under sections 52 and 30 where section 188 applies (claims for excess area/assessment under those sections). Distinguished on facts: present case did not involve assessment under sections 52/30 for excess area forming part of the original holding.
Roy Jatindra Nath Chowdhry v. Prasanna Kumar Barterji (Privy Council) Held that where section 188 applies, other co-sharer landlords must join as plaintiffs (mere making them defendants is insufficient). The Court noted the decision but regarded it as addressing enhancement cases under section 188 and thus not directly controlling here (no enhancement question before the Court).
Khondkar Abdul Hamid v. Mohini Kant Saha Chaudhuri Holds that lands acquired by encroachment formed a new holding and a suit for assessment of that new holding was not an act authorized by section 188; section 52 did not apply. Used as persuasive support that assessment of a distinct/new holding is not covered by section 188; Court analogized present claim (assessment of khudkasht as separate holding) to this reasoning.
Gobind Chandra Pal v. Hamidulla Bhuian Where plaintiff sued on a kabuliyat (contractual basis) accepting the defendant's specific liability, section 188 did not apply because plaintiff did not sue under section 52/general right. The Court distinguished that case on its facts but cited it to show circumstances where section 188 will not apply because claim rests on a specific contractual acceptance of liability.
Dhananjoy Majhi v. Upendra Nath Deb Richardson, J., held the right to claim assessment arises from general law and land-revenue system and the right to sue for assessment is not limited by section 188. The Court relied on this reasoning to support the proposition that section 188 does not apply in cases where the right to assessment arises from general law (and not under section 52), though it balanced this against considerations of joinder and binding effect on all co-sharers.
Berhamdut v. Ramjee; Assanullah v. Mohini; Harihar Pande v. Keramat Hassan These cases were referred to in Richardson, J.'s reasoning (as part of the body of decisions considered in the question of assessment and s.188). The Court acknowledged their citation in Richardson, J.'s reasoning; they were used indirectly as part of the jurisprudential background supporting the assessment-right analysis.
Gobind Lal Sijaur v. Ramsaran Lal Authority for the proposition that a suit for determination of a fair and equitable rent proceeds on the assumption that no rent has been paid; such a suit is concerned with future rent rather than arrears already due. The Court applied this principle to hold that where no previous rent was settled or paid for the 22 bighas, an assessment can only relate to future years and cannot support a decree for arrears for past years.
Jagannath Manjhi v. Juman Ali Patwari Holds that in cases under section 52 arrears of rent can be claimed for additional area because the rent of the holding is known and proportionate addition is made for excess area. The Court contrasted these section-52 cases with assessment suits (where no previous rent was fixed) to show why arrears for past years are not claimable in an assessment proceeding like the present one.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in several analytically distinct steps:

  1. Characterisation of the dispute: The Court accepted that the core contest was whether rent should be assessed (or was payable) in respect of the 22 bighas, 9 kathas alleged to be khudkasht and whether the plaintiffs could recover arrears for past years. It noted that the plaintiffs did not seek a declaration of khudkasht title or recovery of possession.
  2. Distinction from section-52 cases: The Court examined precedents where section 52 and section 188 applied (cases of additional land found on measurement or claims under kabuliyats) and distinguished them from the present case because here the lands claimed by plaintiffs formed separate khudkasht holdings under separate agreements rather than being additions to an original holding. Thus, the special joinder rules applicable to section-52 cases are not necessarily apt here.
  3. Applicability of section 188: The Court analysed whether assessment suits (suits to fix fair and equitable rent for lands for which no rent had been settled) fall within the ambit of section 188 of the Bengal Tenancy Act. It reviewed conflicting authorities. It observed that Richardson, J.'s decision in Dhananjoy Majhi supports the proposition that the right to claim assessment arises from general law and is not limited by section 188. The Court concluded that section 188 does not apply in the present category of assessment suits which seek to fix a rent for a separate holding not previously subject to a recorded rent.
  4. Joinder and practical effect: Despite holding that section 188 does not strictly bar a co-sharer from suing for assessment, the Court emphasised practical and procedural concerns: other co-sharers are vitally interested; failing to make them parties risks multiplicity of suits, inconsistent assessments and hardship to tenants. The Court therefore held that where the assessment sought concerns lands belonging jointly to co-sharers, those co-sharers should have been made parties (at least as defendants) so that any assessment would bind all and avoid multiplicity and uncertainty.
  5. Effect of findings on arrears: The Court considered whether the Subordinate Judge was entitled to give a decree for past years at the rate he assessed. Relying on Gobind Lal Sijaur v. Ramsaran Lal and the principle that a determination of fair and equitable rent presupposes that no rent has hitherto been paid for the subject lands, the Court found there had been no finding that the tenant ever paid rent for the 22 bighas or that a rate of Rs. 5-13-0 had been agreed at settlement. Consequently, the assessment could only be prospective. Therefore the Subordinate Judge erred in awarding arrears for past years based on the newly assessed rate.
  6. Conclusion on maintainability and remedy: Because the plaintiffs failed to join the other co-sharers as parties in respect of lands owned jointly, the Court held the suit insofar as it sought assessment of rent for lands belonging jointly to co-sharers was not maintainable. However, the munsif's money decree for Rs. 113 (for the years 1323–1326 F.S.) representing plaintiffs' share of the rent recorded in the record-of-rights was upheld and the Subordinate Judge's broader decree for arrears at the assessed rate was modified accordingly.
  7. Rice claim and statutory bar: On cross-appeal, the Court agreed with the lower courts that the alleged stipulation for one maund of polished rice per bigha was an addition to the rent and thus an illegal imposition under the statutory provisions cited; the cross-appeal challenging that disallowance failed.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

  • Decree modified. The appellate decree insofar as it assessed a rent for the 22 bighas and awarded arrears for past years at the newly assessed rate is set aside. The plaintiffs are entitled only to the previously granted money decree of Rs. 113-0-0 in respect of the rent of the lands in suit for the years 1323 to 1326 F.S.
  • Cross-appeal dismissed. The cross-appeal against the finding that the stipulation for one maund of polished rice per bigha was an illegal addition to rent was dismissed; that claim is not allowable.
  • The appellants (defendants) are awarded their costs throughout.

Immediate consequences:

  • The plaintiffs' attempt to obtain arrears for past years at a court-assessed rate for the 22 bighas fails because there is no finding that any rent had been previously fixed or paid for those lands; any assessment in such circumstances only determines future rent.
  • Because the plaintiffs did not join their co-sharers as parties in respect of lands owned jointly, the claim for assessment of rents relating to jointly-owned lands is not maintainable; the Court emphasised that for assessments affecting jointly-owned lands all interested co-sharers ought to be made parties so that any determination binds all and prevents multiplicity and inconsistency.

The opinion limits relief to the direct monetary recovery that was supported by the record-of-rights and the munsif's findings; it does not purport to establish a novel rule of law beyond the distinctions drawn from the precedents analysed.

Show all summary ...

Adami, J.:— The plaintiffs, respondents in this Second Appeal, have a seven-annas odd share in the two villages of Nathupur and Kazichak Sher Muhammad. Though the two villages have separate tauzi numbers and separate sadr jama, the co-sharer landlords have treated the lands of the two villages as of one village and have kept joint collection papers for both villages. The predecessor in interest of the plaintiffs had 7 bighas, 6 kathas khudkasht land in the villages and in 1886 she purchased 37 bighas, 5 kathas, in execution of her decree for arrears of rent against Netlal Mahto, Partap Mahto and Sarju Mahto, who had held that area as their raiyati kasht land. The 37 bighas, 5 kathas, thus became her khudkasht land, which, with the 7 bighas, 6 kathas, she had held before, now amounted to 44 bighas, 11 kathas. In 1889 she give 9 bighas, 6 kathas, of this khudkasht land to Nasiruddin, one of the co-sharer landlords. According to the plaint these khudkasht lands were settled with tenants on bhaoli terms, the tenants paying to each co-sharer his share, and in addition to this making a payment of one rupee per bigha to the plaintiffs' ancestor out of the tenants' profit in 1892 the bhaoli rent was commuted to nakdi but the payment rupee one per bigha out of profits was continued.

Some time before 1896 the plaintiff no. 1 came into possession of a 4-annas 9-dams odd share in the tyro villages and plaintiff no. 2 came into possession of a 2-annas 12-dams share, so that together they hold a 7-annas odd share. In 1896 plaintiff no. 1 let out her share, including khudkasht lands, in ijara to Mussammat Bechan Kuer, and did not get direct possession again until 1916. In 1897 plaintiff no. 2 gave his share, including khudkasht lands, in jarato Jhari Lal, and he was still in possession as ijaradar when, in 1903, a fresh settlement of khudkasht lands was made. Under the terms of this fresh settlement the tenants were to pay to each of the co-sharer landlords his proportionate share of the annual rental of the khudkasht lands at the rate of Rs. 5-13-0 per bigha, and were to pay, in addition, to the plaintiffs, one maund of polished rice per bigha out of their profits.

It was the plaintiffs' case that the father of defendant no. 1 and the defendants nos. 2 and 3 cultivated 10 bighas, 19 kathas, in the two villages as their raiyati kasht land, at a rent of Rs. 5-13-0 per bigha, the total rent amounting to Rs. 63-10-7, and that they, had executed two kabuliyats in respect of this raiyati holding, one in 1894 and another in 1898, the latter enhancing the rent payable under the former. The plaintiffs alleged that in the settlement of khudkaiht ands made in 1903, the father of defendant no. 1 obtained settlement of 17 bighas, 5 kathas, out of the 35 bighas, 5 kathas, left after the gift of 9 bighas, 6 kathas, to Nasiruddin, at the rate of Rs. 5-13-0 per bigha, together with one maund of polished rice per bigha to be paid to the plaintiffs. At the same time Nasiruddin settled 5 bighas, 4 kathas, out of the 9 bighas, 6 kathas, given to him, with the father of defendant no. 1 at the same rate of rent and the same terms as to delivery of one maund of polished rice per bigha. The 17 bighas, 5 kathas, were contiguous to the holding of 10 bighas, 19 kathas.

In 1903 the father of defendant no. 1 took a thika of the share of another co-sharer landlord, Mussammat Halimunnissa, in the name of his grandson for a term of seven years.

In 1908 the survey and settlement operations started in the villages, and khewat and khatian were prepared for each of them separately. It is alleged by the plaintiffs that in the course of the settlement operations, defendant no. 1 and his nephews, defendants nos. 2 and 3, took advantage of the fact that they held a thika of Mussammat Halimunnissa's share, and managed to get the 17 bighas, 5 kathas, of khudkasht, settled with them by the plaintiffs, as well as the 5 bighas, 4 kathas, settled with them by Nasiruddin, amalgamated with 10 bighas, 19 kathas, which they held as raiyati kasht under the kabuliyats, the whole 33 bighas, 8 kathas, being described in the record-of-rights as the kaimi raiyati kasht of the defendants, at a rental for the whole of Rs. 63-10-7 which was really the rental payable for the 10 bighas, 19 kathas, alone. In the record-of-rights 12.97 acres were recorded against khata no. 113 of Nathupur with an annual jama of Rs. 63-10-7, and 7-57 acres were recorded against khata no. 121 of Kazi Chak Sher Muhammad with a remark that the jama was included in that of khata no. 113 of Nathpur. The plaintiffs alleged that, in order to keep them in ignorance and to prevent them taking any steps to get the record corrected within the time allowed, the defendants continued to pay rent for the 10 bighas, and separate rent for the 22 bighas of khudkasht land till 1914, and then from 1915 ceased to pay rent either for the kasht land or for the khudkasht.

The plaintiffs in the plaint state that they do not ask for a declaration of their khudkasht right or of the want of title in the defendants; nor do they seek to recover possession of the khudkasht lands; but they do claim that the defendants are not entitled to hold the 22 bighas, 9 kathas, of the lands settled with them as khudkasht without payment of rent, and that the plaintiffs are entitled to get their proportionate share of rent for the 22 bighas, 9 kathas, at the rate of Rs. 5-13-0 alleged by them to have been agreed on at the time of settlement, and also to get one maund of polished rice per bigha from the tenant's profit.

Thus the claim in the suit from which this appeal arises is for the plaintiffs' proportionate share of the rents for 1323 F.S to 1327 F.S of the 10 bighas, 19 kathas, at the rate mentioned in the kabuliyat of 1898 and also of the 22 bighas, 9 kathas, at the rate which they allege was agreed on at the time the settlement of khudkasht lands was made. In case the Court is not satisfied as to their allegation of the rate fixed at the time of the settlement of these 22 bighas, 9 kathas, the plaintiffs ask the Court to settle a fair and equitable rent for those lands and to give them a decree for the arrear rent of those lands at the rate so settled. A claim is made for the value of polished rice at the rate of one maund per bigha for the years in suit.

None of the other co-sharers were made parties to the suit either as plaintiffs or defendants; the plaintiffs allege that those co-sharers refused to join, them or take any action.

The defendants resisted the suit on the ground that, being instituted more than six years after the final publication of the record-of-rights, it was barred by limitation, and that it was not maintainable since all the co-sharer landlords had not joined in the suit. They denied that the lands were khudkasht, or that they were settled with the father of defendant no. 1 on the terms and rates alleged by the plaintiffs. They denied also the right of the plaintiffs to claim the value of any polished rice, as such payment would amount to an abwab. They controverted the story put forward by the plaintiffs atnd claimed that all the lands were their ancestral kasht lands and the rental for all was Rs. 63-0-0.

The munsif found that the kabuliyats of 1894 and 1898 were genuine and executed by the father of defendant no. 1, that, though undue influence was apparent as to some of the terms of the kabuliyats, none was used so far as the agreement to pay Rs. 63-9-7 for the 10 bighas, 19 kathas, was concerned, and that jama was paid up to the survey. He was satisfied that the remaining 22 bighas, 9 kathas, were khudkasht as alleged by the plaintiffs, and not ancestral raiyati lands of the defendants, and that these khudkashi lands were settled with defendant no. 1's father in 1903. He decided, however, that the plaintiffs had knowledge of the survey proceedings, and as the suit was instituted more than six years from the date of the publication of the record-of-rights, the suit was time-barred so far as the claim to the additional rent was concerned. As to the alternative prayer of the plaintiffs for a settlement of fair, and equitable rates for the khudkasht lands, the learned munsif held that the plaintiffs not being sole landlords, and the other co-sharers not having joined, the claim for assessment and for additional rent was barred by the provisions of section 188 of the Bengal Tenancy Act. As a result of his findings the learned munsif granted the plaintiffs a money decree for Rs. 113 only as representing their share for the years 1323 to 1326 F.S of the rent recorded in the record-of-rights as being payable for all the lands in suit. He disallowed the claim for the value of polished rice, this payment in kind being an addition to the rent and contrary to the provisions of the Bengal Tenancy Act.

One appeal the learned Subordinate judge has held that the finding of the munsif to the effect that Rs. 63 is the jama for the 10 bighas, and not for the entire lands is conclusive because the defendants did not file a cross appeal. It is obvious that the Subordinate judge has expressed the position wrongly; the defendants had proved successful on the main question in the suit, namely, whether they were liable to pay more than the rent recorded in the record-of-rights for the lands in suit; there was no occasion for them to appeal. The whole case was before the Subordinate judge on appeal, and what he apparently meant to say was that the finding of the munsif on this question was not contested before him.

The Subordinate judge overruled the munsif on the question of limitation, holding that the suit was within time being a suit for assessment of fair and equitable rent, and having been instituted within 12 years from the date of the publication of the record-of-rights when the plaintiffs' right to additional rent was challenged.

With regard to the finding of the trial court that the suit for assessment was barred by the provisions of section 188 of the Bengal Tenancy Act, the learned Subordinate judge relied on the case of Dhananjoy Manjhi v. Upendra Nath Deb and held that section 188 of the Bengal Tenancy Act had no application, the bringing of a suit for the assessment of rent not being an act which a landlord is authorized or required to do by the provisions of the Bengal Tenancy Act. He found therefore that the suit was maintainable at the instance of the two co-sharer landlords without joining the rest as parties.

The learned Subordinate judge proceeded to assess the rent for the 22 bighas odd at the rate of Rs. 5-13-0 a bigha, and held that the defendants, having been in occupation of the lands, were in justice and equity bound to pay rent for the past years in suit, and the settlement with them having been proved, and, on assessment, the rate of rent claimed by the plaintiffs having been found to be the right rate, the plaintiffs were entitled to a decree for the past years at that rate. He rejected the claim of one maund of polished rice per bigha, in that this did not form part of the rent. As a result he decreed the appeal except as to this claim for the value of polished rice.

I have stated the facts of the case in some detail because it will be necessary to distinguish them from the facts of the various cases relied on by the parties.

Two points are taken by the learned counsel for the appellants; the first is that the plaintiffs' suit cannot succeed in the absence of the other co-sharers, and section 188 of the Bengal Tenancy Act is relied on; the second point is that the suit being a suit for assessment of rent no decree could be granted for arrears of past years at the rate newly assessed by the Court. The finding of the lower appellate Court with regard to limitation has not been assailed in this Court and the suit has been treated as a suit for assessment of a fair and equitable rent of lands for which the record-of-rights omitted to mention a rent. It is to be noticed that the learned Subordinate judge first assessed a rent and then proceeded to treat the suit as an ordinary suit for arrears of rent because the rate of rent assessed by him coincided with the rate claimed in one of the alternative prayers of the plaint. It is clear that there was a necessity to assess the rent as prayed for in the other alternative prayer, for the plaintiffs had no document or other reliable evidence to show what rate of rent was agreed upon at the time of the settlement of the khudkasht lands with the defendants.

With regard to the first point taken by the appellants, namely, the maintainability of a suit for assessment by a co-sharer landlord, in the case of Dwarka Dhakai v. Mathur Lal Majumdar a co-sharer landlord brought a suit for arrears of rent and also for additional rent on the basis of a kabuliyat in which there was an agreement to pay additional rent for additional area. On measurement of the holding it was found that there was an addition of 10 bighas. The other co-sharers were made parties defendants. It was held that the suit was a suit under section 52 to which section 188 applied, and that the agreement to pay additional rent in the kabuliyat did not take it out of that section? That case is to be distinguished from the present one. Here we have no agreement as to additional lands and it is not a case of lands being found on measurement to be in excess of the area stated in the kabuliyat. We have here a prayer for assessment of the rent of lands settled under a separate agreement and not forming part of the area settled by the kabuliyats of 1894 and 1898. In Gopal Chandar Das v. Umesh Narain Chowdhry the proprietors of an eight-annas share claimed from a tenant rent for excess area under section 52 and for enhanced rent under section 30 and made the other co-sharers parties defendants. It was found that the land in excess was held as part of the original holding. This was clearly a case coming under sections 52 and 30 of the Tenancy Act and there can be no question that the provisions of section 188 apply to a suit under either of those sections. In the present case, as I have said before, assessment of rent is asked for with regard to lands not found to be part of the original holding.

Mr. Jayaswal relied on the decision of their Lordships of the Privy Council in Roy Jatindra Nath Chowdhry v. Prasanna Kumar Barterji but that was a case of enhancement of rent and is not relevant, for there is no question of enhancement before us. Their Lordships ruled that in cases to which section 188 applies it is not sufficient to make the other co-sharer landlords parties defendants, they must join as plaintiffs to make the suit maintainable.

On the other hand in the case of Khondkar Abdul Hamid v. Mohini Kant Saha Chaudhuri the defendants, tenants of the original holding under the plaintiffs and their co-sharers, took possession of certain lands by gradual encroachment. The plaintiffs brought a suit for recovery of their share of the encroached lands or in the alternative for assessment of rent and made their co-sharers parties. It was held that the defendants must be treated as tenants of those lands apart from their tenancy in respect of the holding, and that those lands formed a new holding and the rent assessed, upon it would be a new rent in respect of the new holding, and that a suit for the assessment of rent is not an act that is authorized by section 188 of the Bengal Tenancy Act and section 52 does not apply. In the present case the co-sharer plaintiffs are asking for an assessment of the rent of the 22 bighas claimed to be khudkasht and not for an assessment of the rent of the 10 bighas. If they had claimed rent, not merely of the additional 22 bighas in possession of the defendants over and above the 10 bighas but in respect of the entire quantity of land in possession of the defendants including the 10 bighas, according to the decision in this last case I have mentioned sections 52 and 188 would have applied. That is to say sections 52 and 188 will apply where the plaintiffs contend that there has been an addition to the original holding. That is not the contention in the present case.

In Gobind Chandra Pal v. Hamidulla Bhuian the defendant executed a kabuliyat in favour of one of the co-sharer landlords with respect to a quantity of land proportionate to that co-sharer's share in the entire holding. The co-sharer landlord sued the defendant for rent of land in excess of the area for which rent had been previously paid. The other co-sharer was not made a party. In the kabuliyat the defendant had agreed to pay additional rent for lands found on measurement to be in excess. Prinsep, J., held that as the plaintiff did not sue under the general right, declared by section 52 to be with a landlord, to assess rent on excess lands but on the kabuliyat under which the right to assess such rent on the specific share was accepted by the defendant, section 188 did not apply. The Court was not called on to consider what was the rent payable on the entire holding. The facts in that case are distinguishable from chose in the present case inasmuch as we find from the plaint in this case that the agreement at the settlement of the khudkasht lands was that the defendants should pay to each of the co-sharer landlords his proportionate: share of the rent, paying in addition the one maund of polished rice to the plaintiffs, who in making the settlement seem to have acted as agents of all the co-sharers.

The learned Subordinate judge relied on the case of Dhananjoy Majhi v. Upendra Nath Deb and that case has also been cited by the respondents. There the tenants' lands had been recorded in the record-of-rights as liable to be assessed with rent. A co-sharer landlord brought a suit to have the rent assessed, and made his other co-sharers defendants. The defendants contended that the land was held rent-free it was urged that under section 188 the suit was not maintainable. Richardson, J., after referring to the cases of Khondkar v. Mohini Kanta, Berhamdut v. Ramjee, Assanullah v. Mohini and Harihar Pande v. Keramat Hassan, held that the right to claim assessment is consistent with and arises out of the general law and land-revenue system of the country, and that the right to sue for assessment is not limited by the provisions of section 188.

There cannot be any doubt that the right to sue for assessment is a right given by the general law and that section 188 will not apply in a case like the present one. It cannot be held that the assessment was made under section 52 or under section 158(i)(d) of the Bengal Tenancy Act; the former section applies, as shown by the decisions I have cited, to cases where the area or a tenure or holding has increased; here rent is claimed for lands as forming separate holdings under separate agreements; the clause of the latter section refers only to a determination of the existing rent, and in the present case there was no existing rent, so the Court was asked to fix one.

The question next arises whether, under the general law, a suit by a co-sharer landlord for an, assessment, of the rent of a tenant's holding is maintainable where the other co-sharers have not been made parties either as plaintiffs or defendants. It is to be noticed that in the various cases noted above, except in the case of Gobind Chandra Pal v. Hamidulla Bhutan, the other co-sharers were made parties defendants to the suit for assessment; in the present case the plaintiffs have not made their co-sharers parties to the suit at all and the plaint tells us that the co-sharers refused to take any action; they are apparently satisfied with the rent now paid to them in accordance with the record-of-rights. Two of the co-sharers come forward and ask for an assessment of the rent of the 22 bighas and for their proportionate share; the other co-sharers are vitally interested. It may be that it was unnecessary to join the other co-sharers as plaintiffs as section 188 does not apply, but surely they should have been made parties defendants, so that the assessment when made might bind all equally. As pointed out by the learned munsif, great hardship will be caused to the tenants defendants if each of the other co-sharer landlords is left free to bring a separate spit for assessment; not only may there ensue a multiplicity of suits but also the tenant, if different assessments are made in the separate suits, will be uncertain as to what is really the assessed rental. No really effective decree can be made in the absence of the interested co-sharers and there can be he finality as to what is really the fair and equitable rent. As in a partition suit so in a suit for assessment all the interested persons should be made parties.

I am of opinion that as the other co-sharers were not joined as parties in the suit, the suit so far as it sought for assessment of the lands belonging to the co-sharers jointly, is not maintainable.

With regard to the second point taken in the appeal, namely, that the plaintiff was not entitled to claim rent in arrears at the rate to be assessed as fair and equitable in the suit, as pointed out by my learned brother Das, J., in Gobind Lal Sijaur v. Ramsaran Lal, a suit for the determination of a fair and equitable rent proceeds on the assumption that no rent has hitherto been paid by the tenant, and when a landlord claims fair rent in respect of past years for which rent has already accrued due, a suit for determination of fair and equitable rent does not lie. No doubt it has been held [Jagannath Manjhi v. Juman Ali Patwari] that in cases under section 52 of the Bengal Tenancy Act arrears of rent can be claimed for the additional area, but in those cases the rent of the holding is known and proportionate addition is made for the excess area. In suits for assessment of a fair and equitable rent it is understood that the rent has not been settled or paid hitherto and the Court is asked to determine the rent to be paid in future. The learned Subordinate judge states:

“The appellants did allege that the lands were settled with them (the present appellants) at the rate of Rs. 5-18-0 per bigha. This contention has been found to be true and correct.”

As a matter of fact there has been no such finding. The munsif in fact found that the 22 bighas were settled without any jama. The Subordinate judge made an assessment of what a fair and equitable rent would be and found that a rate of Rs. 5-13-0 per bigha, the amount claimed by the co-sharer landlord, was fair and equitable. There is no finding that the tenants ever paid rent for the 22 bighas, and there is no real finding that at the time of settlement a rate of Rs. 5-13-0 a bigha was agreed upon. Under the circumstances it may be taken that it is not found that up to the date of suit any rent had been settled for the 22 bighas, or paid, and therefore the assessment now made can only have reference to future years.

The suit for assessment of rent having been found not to be maintainable the appeal must succeed, and the decree of the lower appellate court must be modified to this extent, that the plaintiffs will be declared entitled to a money decree for the sum of Rs. 113-0-0 only, in respect of the rent of the lands in suit for the years 1323 to 1326 F.S The appellants will get their costs throughout.

The cross-appeal against the decision of both the lower courts that the alleged stipulation for payment by the tenant of one maund of polished rice per bigha would amount to an illegal imposition under the provisions of section 74 of the Bengal Tenancy Act, must fail. It is clear from the findings of the Courts that this payment would be an addition to the actual rent and would not form an integral part of the same. The cross-appeal is dismissed with costs.

Das, J.:— I agree.

Decree modified.
Cross-appeal dismissed.