Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Emperor Complainant v. Reed Accused.

Calcutta High Court
Jun 22, 1921
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.

Buckland, J.:β€” I know of no authority, nor has any been;advanced, for the proposition that it is the duty of the Public Prosecutor to call a witness who he has reason to believe would give false evidence.

2. In stating my opinion I cannot do better than adopt the language of a former Chief Justice of the High Court at Allahabad when he said in Queen-Empress v. Durga(1).

β€œIt cannot be the duty of a Public Prosecutor acting on behalf of the Government and the country to call or put into the witness-box for cross-examination a witness whom he believes to be a false or unnecessary witness.”

3. The learned Standing Counsel has refused to call Mr. Grant on the ground that he believes him to be a false witness.

4. In the former trial Mr. Grant was called by the Court and cross-examined by both sides. He was not examined as a witness for the Crown, in which case other considerations would have arisen, and in the circumstances I decline to interfere.

5. Interference refused.