Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Tarinicharan Chakrabarti v. Debendralal De

Calcutta High Court
Jan 9, 1935
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from a suit filed by the plaintiff seeking a declaration of title to an 8 annas share of Cadastral Survey plots 395 and 596, and for recovery of khâs possession of the same following partition. The plaintiff claimed title based on a purchase from a Hindu widow, Satyabhama, in Pons, 1334 B.S. The disputed land formed part of the joint family property of two brothers: the father of defendants Nos. 1 and 2, and the husband of Satyabhama. The plaintiff alleged that after the death of the two brothers, the disputed plots were jointly possessed by defendants Nos. 1 and 2 and Satyabhama. Defendant No. 2, the sole contesting defendant, contended that an amicable partition had taken place in 1308 B.S., allotting the disputed plots to defendants Nos. 1 and 2, thus negating plaintiff’s title. The defendant also argued that the suit was not maintainable as the plaintiff was not entitled to seek partition of only a portion of the joint family property. The lower courts rejected the defendants’ claim of prior partition and decreed the plaintiff’s suit. The defendants appealed against this decree.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a purchaser of a portion of joint family property from one co-owner is entitled to maintain a suit for partition of only that portion.
  2. Whether a suit for partial partition of joint family property lies under Hindu law.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The plaintiff, as purchaser of only a small portion of joint family property, is not entitled to a suit for partition limited to that portion.
  • The principle applicable to transfer of portions of joint property should not apply to joint family property of Hindus.
  • Citing Mayne's Hindu Law (9th ed., Art. 494), a stranger acquiring title to a portion of family property cannot demand partition only as to that portion; rather, a complete and final partition must be sought involving all family members.

Respondent's Position

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments beyond the appellant’s submissions.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Rajendra Kumar Bose v. Brojendra Kumar Bose General rule that a partition suit should embrace all joint property to ensure equitable distribution, possession, and adjustment of accounts. The court acknowledged this rule but emphasized it is a rule of equity and convenience, not exclusive to Hindu law, and may be relaxed if no prejudice or inconvenience results.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court recognized a divergence of judicial opinion on whether an alienee from a co-sharer can sue for partition of only the property in which he has interest. It noted that while generally a partition suit should include all joint property to avoid prejudice and ensure equitable distribution, the converse rule is that a suit cannot include property in which the parties do not claim interest. The court observed that the principle cited from Mayne’s Hindu Law did not rely on any special Hindu law rule but reflected ordinary partition principles. The court emphasized that the rule requiring inclusion of all joint property in a partition suit primarily serves equity and convenience, a matter of procedural law rather than substantive Hindu law. Since no evidence showed that the defendants would be prejudiced or inconvenienced by allowing a partial partition, the court upheld the lower courts' decree allowing the plaintiff’s suit for partial partition.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED

The court dismissed the appeal, affirming the lower courts’ decision to decree the plaintiff’s suit for partial partition of the joint family property. The immediate consequence is that the plaintiff is entitled to partition and possession of the purchased share. The court did not establish a new precedent but applied existing principles flexibly in light of the facts, indicating that partial partition suits may be permitted where no prejudice or inconvenience to other parties is demonstrated.

Show all summary ...

Nasim Ali, J.:— This appeal arises out of a suit for a declaration of plaintiff's title to 8 annas share of Cadastral Survey plots 395 and 596 and for recovery of khâs possession of the same after partition. Plaintiff based his claim on a purchase from a Hindu widow, Satyabhama, in Pons, 1334 B.S The father of defendants Nos. 1 and 2 and the husband of Satyabhama were two brothers. The disputed land was a part of the joint family property of the said two brothers. Plaintiff's case is that the disputed plots were in the joint possession of defendants Nos. 1 and 2 and Satyabhama after the death of the father of defendants Nos. 1 and 2 and the husband of Satyabhama. The defence of the defendant No. 2, who alone contested the suit, was that, by an amicable partition in the year 1308 B.S between his father and Satyabhama, the disputed plots were allotted to the share of the defendants Nos. 1 and 2 and consequently plaintiff acquired no title on the basis of his purchase from the lady. The defendant further pleaded that the suit was not maintainable in the present form, as the plaintiff is not entitled, under the law, to have a partition of only a portion of the joint family property of the defendants Nos. 1 and 2 and Satyabhama. The courts below have disbelieved the story of previous partition set up by the defendants and have decreed the plaintiff's suit. Hence the present appeal by the defendants Nos. 1 and 2.

The only point urged in support of the appeal is that the plaintiff, being the purchaser of a small portion of the joint family property from one of the co-owners, is not entitled, under the law, to get a partition only of the land purchased by him. In other words, the contention is that a suit for a partial partition does not lie. There has been some divergence of judicial opinion on the question whether an alienee from a co-sharer is entitled to institute a suit for partition of the property, in which he alone is interested. On the one hand, it has been maintained that the purchaser is exactly in the same position as his vendor, on the other hand, it is said that the transfer effects a severance and the only joint property held in common by the purchaser and the co-sharers of his vendor is what forms the subject matter of the conveyance. To give effect to the former view would be to affirm the principle that a plaintiff can institute a suit for partition in respect of property, in which he has no interest at all. The learned advocate for the appellant, however, contends that the principle applicable to transfer of portions of joint property is not applicable to transfer of a part of joint family property of Hindus. In support of this contention the learned advocate for the appellant cited the following passage from Mayne's Hindu Law, 9th edition, Article 494 at page 716:—

Where a stranger to the family acquires a title to a portion of the family property by purchase or under an execution, his remedy is by a suit to compel his vendor to come to a partition and so give him an absolute title. But he cannot demand a partition merely as to the portion over which he has claim. The vendor must have a complete and final partition so that all the family accounts may be taken against him and all the other members of the family must be made parties to the suit.

Mr. Mayne does not appear to have relied on any special rule of Hindu law for the above observations. The ordinary rule is that a suit for partition must embrace all joint properties owned by the parties thereto. But there is also the complimentary rule that a suit for partition cannot include properties, in which each of the parties does not claim an interest. It is true that the general rule that a partition suit should embrace all joint property ensures a just partition; otherwise parties might be greatly prejudiced as regards equitable distribution, retention of possession, liability for improvements and adjustment of accounts. See Rajendra Kumar Bose v. Brojendra Kumar Bose . This rule does not belong exclusively to Hindu law. It is primarily based on considerations of equity and convenience. It seems to me that it belongs more to the province of adjective than substantive law. In the present case, it has not been proved that the defendants would be, in any way, prejudiced or inconvenienced, if the application of the general rule be relaxed and partial partition be allowed. The courts below were, therefore, right in decreeing the plaintiff's suit. The appeal, therefore, fails and is dismissed with costs.

Leave to appeal under section 15 of the Letters Patent has been asked for and is refused.

Appeal dismissed.
G.S