Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Samu Pattan v. Chidambara Odayan

Madras High Court
Aug 5, 1915
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff obtained an assignment of a mortgage debt from the defendant and sued the mortgagor for the mortgage amount. That suit was dismissed on the ground that the mortgagor had no title to the mortgaged properties. The reason why the plaintiff did not obtain a personal decree against the mortgagor was not explained. Subsequently, the plaintiff brought the present action in the Small Cause side of the Sub-Court, Mayavaram, seeking to recover damages for an alleged breach of a covenant for title. The first Court dismissed the suit, and the plaintiff filed the present application to revise that decree.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the transfer of a mortgage debt constitutes a sale of immovable property requiring compliance with the formalities under the Transfer of Property Act.
  2. Whether there is an implied covenant for title on a transfer of a mortgage debt.
  3. Whether the plaintiff has a cause of action against the defendant for breach of such a covenant.
  4. Whether the suit for damages for breach of covenant for title is barred by limitation.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ramasami Pattar v. Chinnan Asari, 24 M.k 449 Supports the view that a charge on land is an interest in immovable property and that formalities for sale of immovable property should be complied with for transfer of such charge. Used to assume that transfer of a mortgage charge requires compliance with formalities for sale of immovable property.
Subramaniam v. Perumal Reddi, 18 M.k 454 Establishes that what is primarily sold in a mortgage transfer is the debt, not ownership of immovable property. Relied upon to hold that transfer of mortgage is akin to transfer of an actionable claim and does not carry an implied covenant for title.
Marnham v. Weaver, 80 L.T. 412 Assumes that there is no implied covenant for title on transfer of a mortgage debt. Supported the court’s conclusion that no such covenant exists.
Section 55, Transfer of Property Act Deems that in a sale of immovable property, the transferor contracts that the interest transferred subsists. Considered by plaintiff to argue that the mortgage transfer was a sale of immovable property, but court did not accept this application fully.
Section 8, Transfer of Property Act Defines the formalities required for transfer of immovable property. Referenced to support the assumption about formalities required for transfer of mortgage charge.
Section 65(a), Transfer of Property Act Provides for an implied covenant for title in a transfer by way of mortgage. Distinguished by the court to mean that the implied covenant applies to the mortgage itself but not to the transfer of a mortgage debt.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by acknowledging that a charge on land is an interest in immovable property and accepted, for argument’s sake, that formalities for transfer of immovable property should apply to such charges. However, the court distinguished the transfer of a mortgage debt from the transfer of ownership of immovable property, emphasizing that what is sold in a mortgage transfer is primarily the debt, not the property itself. The rights of a transferee of a mortgage debt are akin to those of a transferee of an actionable claim, although a mortgage debt is not strictly an actionable claim under the Transfer of Property Act. The court found no precedent, Indian or English, supporting the existence of an implied covenant for title on transfer of a mortgage debt, and noted that the case of Marnham v. Weaver assumes no such covenant exists. Consequently, the court agreed with the lower court’s conclusion that the plaintiff had no cause of action against the defendant for breach of covenant for title. Additionally, the court observed that the suit appeared barred by limitation since the cause of action would arise at the time of execution of the conveyance, but refrained from expressing a final opinion on the limitation issue as it was not argued before the court.

Holding and Implications

The petition is dismissed with costs.

The direct effect of this decision is that the plaintiff’s suit for damages for breach of covenant for title on transfer of a mortgage debt fails, affirming the lower court’s dismissal. The court did not establish any new precedent and refrained from deciding on the limitation question definitively.

Show all summary ...

JUDGMENT

V.V. Srinivasa Iyengar, J.

1. The plaintiff obtained an assignment of a mortgage debt from the defendant and sued the mortgagor for the mortgage amount. That suit was dismissed on the ground that the mortgagor had no title to the mortgaged properties. Why the plaintiff did not obtain a personal decree against the mortgagor is not explained. The plaintiff brought the present action in the Small Cause side of the Sub-Court, Mayavaram, to recover damages for an alleged breach of a covenant for title. The 1st Court dismissed the suit and this application is to revise the decree of the first Court. Plaintiff contends that the mortgage is an interest in Immovable property, that the transfer was a sale of Immovable property and by virtue of Section 55 of the Transfer of Property Act, the defendant should be deemed to have contracted that the interest which he professed to transfer subsisted.

2. A charge on land is undoubtedly an interest in Immovable property, and I will assume, though there is a difference of opinion on this point, that for the transfer of such a charge, the formalities required for the sale of Immovable property should be complied with. See Ramasami Pattar v. Chinnan Asari 24 M.k 449, Subramaniam v. Perumal Reddi 18 M.k 454, and Section 8, Transfer of Property Act, Ghose on Mortgage, page 72 (note). But I am not prepared to hold that there is an implied covenant for title on a transfer of a mortgage-debt. A transfer of a mortgage can hardly be regarded as a transfer of ownership of Immovable property. What is sold is primarily not the charge but the debt Subramaniam v. Perumal Reddi 18 M.k 454; and the rights of such a transferee are practically the same as those of a transferee of an actionable claim, though a mortgage-debt is not an actionable claim as defined in the Transfer of Property Act. In a transfer by way of mortgage there is implied a covenant for title and the transferee of a mortgage gets the benefit of this covenant. [See Section 65, Clause (a), of the Transfer of Property Act]. My attention has not been drawn to any case, Indian or English, in which such a covenant was implied; on the other hand the case of Marnham v. Weaver 80 L.T. 412 seems to assume that there is no such covenant. I agree with the lower Court that the plaintiff has no cause of action against the defendant. Further, the suit appears to be barred by limitation, as the cause of action for a suit for damages for breach of a covenant for title arises on the execution of the conveyance. As, however, the question was not argued before me, I do not desire to express any final opinion on the question.

3. I dismiss the petition with costs.