Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Nitai Lal Dutta v. Gobinda Bhushan Sen

Patna High Court
Dec 19, 1935
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary — Mohammad Noor, J.; Varma, J. concurred

Factual and Procedural Background

The suit concerned two plots (survey Nos. 2396 and 2397) in Jharia (Manbhum), described as part of the barmotta property of the Hazras. After familial divisions, Raghu, Sibu and Sambhu (sons of Ramkumar Hazra) had shares in the property. The plots in issue formed part of an occupancy holding of Lochan Dutt's descendants; defendants 2–4 (the raiyats) were admitted raiyats of plots 1269, 2396 and 2397 at an annual rent of Rs. 1-8-0, and Raghu and his brothers were their landlords.

The plaintiff claimed title by purchase from Sibu and Sambhu under a sale deed dated 17 February 1925 (Ex. 8) to two-thirds of plots 2396 and 2397. Earlier, Raghu Hazra had executed a sale deed dated 20 January 1917 (Ex. A-1) in favour of defendant 1 (the sister's son of defendants 2–4). During settlement operations defendant 1 was recorded as landlord of the two plots; the plaintiff was recorded in respect of plot 1269.

The plaintiff sued for a declaration of title to two-thirds of the two plots, partition by metes and bounds between him and defendant 1, and, against the raiyats (defendants 2–4), a permanent injunction and demolition of any house built on the land. The Subordinate Judge dismissed the suit holding plaintiff had no title and that the suit was barred by limitation. The plaintiff appealed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the sale-deed executed by Raghu dated 20 January 1917 (Ex. A-1) conveyed the whole proprietary right in plots 2396 and 2397 to defendant 1, or only Raghu's one-third share (with the remaining two-thirds belonging to Sibu and Sambhu and transferable to the plaintiff under Ex. 8 dated 17 February 1925).
  2. Whether the civil Court has jurisdiction to entertain the plaintiff's relief against occupancy raiyats (defendants 2–4), specifically an injunction and demolition order, given the provisions of the Chota Nagpur Tenancy Act (notably Section 21, Section 22 and Section 139(4)).
  3. Whether the plaintiff's combining of two independent causes of action (a declaration/partition claim against a co-sharer and an action against occupancy raiyats for injunction/demolition) rendered the suit improperly constituted and thus subject to procedural objection (i.e., whether the plaintiff ought to have been required to elect or to sue separately).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Plaintiff)

  • Claimed to have acquired two-thirds share in plots 2396 and 2397 by purchase from Sibu and Sambhu under deed dated 17 February 1925 (Ex. 8).
  • Sought partition and declaration of title to two-thirds, and sought injunction and demolition of house(s) erected by defendants 2–4 on the plots.

Respondents (Defendants)

  • Denied the plaintiff's title; asserted that defendant 1 acquired the entire proprietary right by purchase from Raghu under Ex. A-1 dated 20 January 1917.
  • Alleged there had been a partition among Raghu, Sibu and Sambhu and that the two plots fell exclusively to Raghu (i.e., Raghu had the right to dispose of the whole).
  • Raised (or the Court noted) that defendant 1 might be a benamidar for defendants 2–4 (the Subordinate Judge had considered this possibility, though it was not a pleaded case).

Table of Precedents Cited

The opinion does not cite judicial precedents (case law); it refers to statutory provisions instead.

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded along procedural and substantive lines.

Procedural observations:

  • The Court found the suit improperly combined two independent causes of action: (a) a declaration/partition claim against an alleged co-sharer (defendant 1) and (b) a claim against occupancy raiyats (defendants 2–4) for injunction and demolition. The judge expressed that the plaintiff should have been called upon to elect because the two claims were “absolutely independent and unconcerned with one another.”
  • The combination had led to unnecessary materials on the record and prolonged trial and appeal.

Jurisdictional point under tenancy law:

  • The Court observed Section 21 of the Chota Nagpur Tenancy Act, which provides that an occupancy raiyat is not entitled to use his land so as to render it unfit for tenancy; Section 22 prescribes penalty and liability to ejectment; and Section 139(4) makes a suit for ejectment entertainable exclusively by the Deputy Commissioner. On this basis the Court expressed "grave doubts" whether a civil Court can entertain a suit for injunction and demolition against an occupancy raiyat where the statutory scheme contemplates remedy or ejectment via the Deputy Commissioner.
  • The Court also noted, by analogy to the Bengal Tenancy Act (Section 155), that the landlord's remedy there is compensation and remedial measures, with ejectment if compensation is not paid and the misuse is not remedied—implying that a landlord cannot circumvent statutory jurisdiction by suing in civil Court for injunction/demolition.
  • Although the jurisdictional objection was raised, it had not been pressed by the defendants; the Court nevertheless held that the plaintiff's claim against defendants 2–4 was in any event improperly combined with the partition/declaration suit and was therefore objectionable in form.

Substantive title analysis:

  • The Record of Rights name entry was treated as having presumptive evidentiary value; entries are presumed correct unless contrary is proved. Defendant 1 was recorded as landlord of the two plots after his purchase from Raghu during settlement operations, and no objections were raised by Sibu and Sambhu at that time. The plaintiff admitted in deposition that during the settlement operations he understood defendant 1 to be the sole landlord of the two plots.
  • The Court examined documentary evidence (notably Exs. C(2) and E(2) executed by Raghu alone, dated 1914–1915) and found clear indications that Raghu had separated from his brothers (i.e., there had been a partition), such that Raghu claimed exclusive rights in certain properties by that time. The judge accepted that documents showing joint execution by the brothers in respect of other properties did not necessarily negate a partition concerning these two plots.
  • The Court noted the conduct of witnesses (for example, one brother present in court who avoided testifying to a joint title) as corroborative of the separation evidence on record.
  • On this basis the Court concluded that Raghu was entitled to transfer the two plots exclusively in 1917 and that, having done so in favour of defendant 1, the two brothers (Sibu and Sambhu) had no right thereafter to transfer those plots to the plaintiff in 1925 once the Record of Rights had been settled in favour of defendant 1.
  • The Court characterized the plaintiff's later purchase as a speculative transaction and found that plaintiff was not entitled to succeed on the title claim. It also observed that the economic value (rent) of the property was minimal.

Taking the procedural objections, the statutory tenancy provisions, the Record of Rights' evidentiary value, the documentary evidence of separation/partition, and witnesses' conduct together, the Court concluded the plaintiff's suit failed on the merits and was not maintainable in the form presented.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Appeal dismissed. The Court found no merit in the appeal and ordered dismissal with costs to the contesting respondents. Varma, J. concurred.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The plaintiff's claim to two-thirds of plots 2396 and 2397 was rejected; the 1917 transfer by Raghu in favour of defendant 1 was treated as effective in respect of these plots, and the plaintiff's subsequent purchase from Sibu and Sambhu did not affect defendant 1's recorded proprietary position after the settlement operation.
  • The plaintiff's separate relief against occupancy raiyats (defendants 2–4) — an injunction and demolition order — was held to be improperly combined with the partition/declaration suit and, in any event, suspect because of the statutory remedy scheme under the Chota Nagpur Tenancy Act (Sections 21, 22 and 139(4)), which contemplates proceedings before the Deputy Commissioner for ejectment. The Court indicated that a civil Court suit for such relief may not be maintainable.
  • No new judicial precedent was announced; the decision resolves the dispute between the parties on the facts and applicable statutory framework as articulated in the opinion.

Sources relied upon in this summary: only the contents of the provided opinion text by Mohammad Noor, J. (with Varma, J. concurring) were used. No outside material, case-law or factual inference beyond the text was introduced.

Show all summary ...

Mohammad Noor, J.:— The facts of the case out of which this appeal has arises are simple though a number of unnecessary facts and documents brought on the record have made them somewhat complicated and have clouded the real issue involved in it. The suit relates to two pieces of land, being survey plots Nos. 2396 and 2397 situated within the town of Jharia in the district of Manbhum They are within the area referred in the suit as Manbad which is the barmotta property of some Brahmins who for the sake of brevity may be called ‘the Hazras After division and sub-division among the Hazras these two plots came to the share of one Ramkumar Hazra, and on his death to the share of his three sons, Raghu, Sibu and Sambhu. It is an admitted fact that these plots along with some other plots of land formed the occupancy holding of one Lochan Dutt the ancestor of defendants 2, 3 and 4, the Hazras being their landlords. After division and sub-division among the descendants of Lochan Dutt, these two plots along with another plot No. 1269 came to be possessed by one Bileshwar Dutt, the father of defendants 2 to 4 as raiyat with an annual rent of Rs. 1-8-0. So far the position is admitted, i.e, defendants 2 to 4 are the raiyats of the three plots 1269, 2396 and 2397 on an annual rent of Rs. 1-8-0, and Raghu Hazra and his brother were their landlords. The plaintiff claims to have acquired from the Hazras mukarrari of plot 1269 along with some other lands under a deed dated 8th October, 1913 (Ex. 3). We are however not concerned with that plot as the suit is, as I have said, in respect of the other two plots only. It appears that Raghu Hazra executed a sale deed (Ex. A-1), on 20th January, 1917 in respect of all the three plots of land in favour of defendant 1 who is the sister's son of defendants 2 to 4. Thereafter there was the settlement proceeding in which defendant 1 alone was recorded as the landlord of these two plots and the plaintiff was recorded in respect of plot No. 1269. After the settlement operation the plaintiff got a sale-deed in respect of two-thirds of these two plots from Sibu and Sambhu, the two brothers of Raghu who claimed to have that much share in them presumably on the ground that Raghu had no more than one-third share in them. The simple question in this case is whether the defendant 1 acquired any title to the proprietary right in these two plots from Raghu by virtue of the sale-deed (Ex. A-1) dated 20th January, 1917, or whether that sale-deed did not operate beyond one-third share of the two plots, the other two-thirds being the property of Raghu's two brothers Sibu and Sambhu, who conveyed it to the plaintiff under Ex. 8 dated 17th February, 1925.

2. The present suit is for a declaration of the plaintiff's title to the two-thirds share of the two plots on the basis of his purchase from Sibu and Sambhu, and for partition by metes and bounds between him and defendant 1 so as to separate his two-thirds share from the one-third share of defendant 1 by virtue of the latter's purchase from Raghu alone. The plaintiff also impleaded in the suit the raiyats, defendants 2 to 4, and asked for a permanent injunction against them restraining them from erecting any house upon the land and for an order that any house which may have been built by them upon the land should be removed and in case of failure on their part to do so it should be demolished by the Court. The defence was a denial of the plaintiff's title to the two plots in question. It was claimed to be entirely owned by defendant 1 by virtue of his purchase from Raghu under Ex. A-1. It was alleged by the defendants that there was a partition among the three brothers Raghu, Sibil and Sambhu and the two plots in suit and-some other land fell to the share of Raghu alone. The learned Subordinate Judge has dismissed the suit holding that the plaintiff had no title and that the-suit was barred by limitation. The plaintiff has preferred this appeal. I must state at the outset that the suit seems to me of a very peculiar nature. Two causes of action against two sets of defendants have been combined in one suit. In one suit the plaintiff has sued for a declaration of his title as proprietor in respect of two-thirds of the land against defendant 1 and for partition of his share after a declaration of that title and has also sued the admitted raiyats of the land for an independent relief against them in respect of the house which they have built on it.

3. It is again curious that the plaintiff has not confined his relief for injunction and demolition of house on land which may eventually fall to his share after his title be established and his portion separated. He has asked for demolition of house standing on any portion of the two plots. In my opinion the learned Subordinate Judge ought to have called upon the plaintiff to elect. The two claims in the suit were absolutely independent and unconcerned with one another. A suit against an alleged co-sharer for declaration of title and partition has nothing whatsoever to do with a suit against occupancy raiyats calling upon to remove a building from his holding. The suit, in my opinion, ought not to have been tried in this form. The result has been that a number of unnecessary materials were brought on the record which must have prolonged the trial and has in fact unnecessarily prolonged the hearing of the appeal.

4. Again, I am not quite sure whether the plaintiff's suit, so far as the tenant defendants are concerned, is maintainable at any rate in the civil Court. Under Section 21 of the Chota Nagpur Tenancy Act, an occupancy raiyat is not entitled to use his land in such a way as to render it unfit for the purpose of tenancy. The penalty for such use is provided in S. 22, and the raiyat is liable to be ejected. A suit for such ejectment is entertainable exclusively by the Deputy Commissioner under Section 139(4) of the Chota Nagpur Tenancy Act. I have grave doubts whether under the tenancy law of Chota Nagpur a suit lies against an occupancy raiyat for injunction to restrain him from using his land in a way detrimental to the tenancy. The landlord by suing for injunction and demolition of the house cannot circumvent the jurisdiction of the Deputy Commissioner. Even under the Bengal Tenancy Act the right of the landlord is to get compensation and to have the misuse remedied if it is remediable. In case compensation be not paid and the remediable misuse be not remedied, the landlord is entitled to ejectment: Section 155 of the Bengal Tenancy Act.

5. I find that the question about the jurisdiction of the civil Court to entertain a suit like this was raised but seems to have not been pressed by the defendants. At any rate, the plaintiff's suit so far as it relates to the relief against defendants 2 to 4 is bad as it is combined with a suit which is for declaration of title and partition against the plaintiff's alleged co-sharer, defendant 1. However, as the plaintiff's suit fails on the merits it is not necessary for me to pursue this point further. I now come to the main point in the case, viz., whether the plaintiff is entitled to two-thirds share of the two plots and, as I have said, the only question is whether Raghu the elder brother, was entitled to transfer the whole of it to defendant 1 on 20th January, 1917. The learned Subordinate Judge has said that perhaps defendant 1 is a benamidar for defendants 2 to 4. This was not the case of the plaintiff nor was it of any of the defendants, and so far as this case is concerned the question is immaterial. Now the Record of Rights is entirely against the plaintiff. It has a presumptive evidentiary value. Under the law the entries must be presumed to be correct unless the contrary is proved by evidence. Defendant 1 has been recorded as landlord of the two plots by virtue of his purchase from Raghu. It is of importance that while a purchaser from Raghu Hazra i.e, defendant 1, was getting his name recorded as the landlord of these two plots during the settlement operation, no objection whatsoever was raised on behalf of the two brothers. The plaintiff in his deposition has admitted that during the time of the settlement operations he understood that defendant 1 was the sole landlord of the two plots. It was later, on information received from Sibu and Sambhu, that he came to know that their share was not affected by the sale by Raghu. Defendants' case is, as I have said, that the three brothers had separated and that these two plots along with some other lands of Manbad came into exclusive share of Raghu. That there was partition between the three brothers seems to have been admitted by the plaintiff's witness No. 5, though he makes a reservation that so far as the land in suit is concerned there was no partition.

6. In my opinion, the learned Subordinate Judge has rightly held (the parties being governed by the Dayabhag school) that once there is a partition between brothers, it must be taken that all the properties had been separated. Prom the two documents which are of very great importance, viz. Exs. C(2) and E(2) executed by Raghu alone, it is clear that at the time of their execution (1914–1915) Raghu at least claimed to have separated from his two brothers. The learned Advocate for the appellant has referred to a number of documents showing that the three brothers executed them jointly. But their joining in a particular document in respect of other properties will not show that they had not separated. The utmost which these documents show is that the three brothers had shares in those properties. It appears that one of the brothers Sibu, was present in Court and as soon as the attention of the Court was drawn to his presence he walked away. Though present in Court he did not dare to come into the witness-box to prove that he was joint with Raghu and that in 1917 Raghu had no exclusive right to transfer these two plots. It is unnecessary for me to refer to the documents in detail. In my opinion, there are clear indications on the record to show that the brothers had separated and that Raghu was entitled to transfer the two plots exclusively, and he having done so in favour of defendant 1 the two brothers had no right to transfer it to the plaintiff after the Record of Rights in 1925. It seems that the plaintiff entered into what may be called a speculative transaction.

7. The value of the property is not at all considerable, the rent realizable by the plaintiff even if his case succeeded will be Re. 0-10-8. The real object of the plaintiff was to acquire a portion of the landlord's right in these two pieces of land and thereby use measures against defendants 2 to 4 to exact some money from them as they had put up buildings on these lands. Even if the plaintiff had any title, for the reasons given by the learned Subordinate Judge and for what I have stated in the earlier part of my judgment, the plaintiff was not entitled to any relief against defendants 2 to 4, at any rate, in the present suit. In my opinion, there is no merit in this appeal and I would dismiss it with costs to the contesting respondents.

8. Varma, J.:— I agree.

R.M/R.K

9. Appeal dismissed.