- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Dhirendra Nath Roy v. Sailaj Kumar Bose Opposite Party
The Judgment of the Court was as follows:—
This was a Rule issued on the Opposite Parties to show cause why an order passed by the Subordinate Judge, 1st Court, Alipore, refusing to entertain an application for stay of sale under Or. 41, r. 6(2) should not be set aside. The material facts are as follows: The Opposite Party obtained a decree on the Original Side of this Court. He took out execution proceedings in the Court of the Subordinate Judge, 1st Court, Alipore. The Petitioner filed an objection under sec. 47 of the Code of Civil Procedure. This objection was heard by the learned Subordinate Judge and disallowed on the 29th July, 1939. Thereafter the Petitioners filed an appeal to this Court against the order disallowing his objection. When the appeal was admitted, a Rule was issued to the Opposite Party to show cause why further proceedings in the execution case and the sale of the immovable property should not be stayed, pending the decision of the appeal. When the Rule was heard, an order was passed staying further proceedings on terms. The terms were that Rs. 1,000 should be deposited on or before the 31st January, 1940, that a further sum of Rs. 1,500 should be deposited on or before the 20th March, 1940, and that security for the balance to the satisfaction of the lower Court should be furnished by the 20th March, 1940. The first two terms were fulfilled and security for the balance of the amount due was tendered to the lower Court before the 20th March, 1940. But the lower Court was dissatisfied with the security offered and directed the Petitioner to furnish further security. The Court then decided that it had no jurisdiction to extend the time within which security should be furnished. Thereafter, the present Petitioner applied to the learned Subordinate Judge under Or. 41, r. 6(2) for stay of the sale of the immovable property. The learned Subordinate Judge held that he had no jurisdiction to entertain that application, because there was no appeal pending from the decree in execution of which the sale was to be held. He, accordingly, rejected the application under Or. 41, r. 6.
This Rule has been obtained to show cause why that order should not be set aside.
It has been pointed out by the learned Advocate for the Petitioner that the Subordinate Judge has overlooked the provisions of Or. 41, r. 8 and it is not necessary in order to give the Court jurisdiction under Or. 41, r. 6 that there should be an appeal pending from the decree in execution of which the sale was to be held. It is sufficient. If there be pending an appeal from an order made in execution of that decree.
The Rule has been opposed not on the ground on which the order was passed by the Subordinate Judge, but on the ground that the learned Subordinate Judge had no jurisdiction to vary the order passed by this Court and had no jurisdiction to pass an order staying the sale which would in effect modify the stay order passed by, this Court. In our opinion, there is no substance in this objection. The order passed by this Court in Rule No. 1228(M) of 1939 was an order, passed under Or. 41, r. 5. Such an order is discretionary: it can be granted or refused at the discretion of the Appellate Court. We will assume for, the purposes of this case that the terms on which stay was granted under Or. 41, r. 5 were not fulfilled. It follows, therefore, that the Rule for stay under Or. 41, r. 5 must be taken to have been discharged. That order stands and cannot be set aside or modified by the lower Court and possibly not even by this Court. The result of this is that the position is the same as if an order for stay under Or. 41, r. 5 had been refused by this Court. But Or. 41, r. 6 does not leave it to the discretion of the Court whether stay should be granted or not. Under that Rule, the sale shall be stayed on such terms as to security or otherwise as the Court thinks fit. It follows, therefore, that if an order has been made for sale and an application under Or. 41, r. 6 has been made to the Court, the Court shall stay the sale on suitable terms and the Court must consider what terms are suitable. The fact that the stay has been refused under Or. 41, r. 5, does not justify the Court in refusing to exercise the jurisdiction vested in it under Or. 41, r. 6. This very question came up for consideration in this Court in the case of Jitendra Nath Choudhury v. Bholanath Choudhury , where it has been held that “although an application for stay of execution of a decree made under Or. 41, r. 5(1), C.P.C, may have been refused by the Appellate Court, still after an order for sale of immovable property in execution of the decree has been made, the Court making such order has jurisdiction to, and indeed must, stay the sale on terms as to security or otherwise.” When the terms on which the stay was granted under Or. 41, r. 5, were not fulfilled, the position was exactly the same as if stay under that order had been refused. In our opinion, it was incumbent upon the learned Subordinate Judge to entertain the application under Or. 41, r. 6 and to consider what were the appropriate terms on which the sale should be stayed.
This Rule is, therefore, made absolute, the order of the learned Subordinate Judge is set aside and the case is remanded for disposal of the application under Or. 41, r. 6(2) according to law. The Petitioner is entitled to his costs which we assess at one gold mohur.
P.C
Alert