- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sabjan Mandal v. Haripada Saha
The Judgment of the Court was as follows:—
The Plaintiff, who is the Appellant in this case, purchased a holding in execution of a decree for arrears of rent on the 18th September 1913 and obtained formal possession on the 5th February 1914. He was, however, resisted by the Defendant, who had purchased the interest of one of the tenants in execution of a mortgage decree on the 18th May 1912. The rent suit appears to have been instituted on the 15th April 1912, and the sale in execution of the rent decree took place, as stated above, on the 18th September 1913. The Defendants' purchase at the sale in execution of the mortgage decree therefore took place after the institution of the rent suit, but before the sale in execution of the rent decree.
The Plaintiff brought the present suit for recovery of possession on the basis of his right by purchase at the rent sale. The Court of first instance decreed the suit. On appeal the decree was reversed on the ground that the Plaintiff had not annulled the encumbrance of the Defendant, the service of notice under sec. 167, Bengal Tenancy Act, not having been proved. The Plaintiff has appealed to this Court.
The question for consideration is whether the Defendant had any subsisting encumbrance at the date of the purchase by the Plaintiff at the rent sale which it was necessary to annul under the provisions of sec. 167 of the Bengal Tenancy Act. The learned District Judge relying upon the decision in the case of Ban Behary Kapur v. Khetrapal Singh Roy held that “the right purchased by the Defendant was an encumbrance within the meaning of sec. 161 of the Bengal Tenancy Act, and that he was entitled to ‘fall back upon the original mortgage as a shield’ against the purchaser in execution of the landlord's decree for arrears of the rent of the holding in question.”
The learned Judge, in the case of Ban Behary Kapur , relied upon the decision in Bhawani Kuwar v. Mathura Prosad (2). The latter case was, however, set aside on appeal by the Judicial Committee [see Bhawani Kuwar v. Mathura Prosad ].
It was held by their Lordships that after the sale took place on the mortgage, the mortgagee who purchased at the sale Became the owner of the property and that he could not maintain as against himself or against third parties unconnected with the mortgage transactions upon the property, the position that his mortgage still remained an encumbrance thereon.
It is true that the Defendant's purchase in execution of the mortgage decree took place after the institution of the rent suit, but he purchased a portion of the holding long before the sale in execution of the rent decree took place, and although he was not liable for arrears of rent for the period before his purchase, the rent was a first charge upon the holding. He therefore purchased subject to that charge. He became the owner of a portion of the holding before the rent sale took place, and his interest in the holding (which was that of an unregistered transferee) passed at the rent sale. There was therefore no subsisting encumbrance at the date of the Plaintiff's purchase which the Plaintiff was bound to annul under the provisions of sec. 167 of the Bengal Tenancy Act.
The decree of the lower Appellate Court is accordingly set aside and that of the Court of first instance restored. We make no order as to costs.
J.N.R
Appeal decreed.
Alert