Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Samayan Servai And Another v. P.K Kadir Moideen Rowthan And Others

Madras High Court
Oct 17, 1918
Smart Summary (Beta)

Concise Analytical Summary of the Opinion (Napier, J.; Phillips, J. concurring)

Factual and Procedural Background

This representative suit was brought by plaintiffs owning lands under the Sallivedan tank (the "plaint lands", Survey No. 807) for relief against: (a) the original owner of the tank-bed, and (b) certain assignees of land in the tank-bed. The plaintiffs alleged acts by the assignees in the tank-bed that had deprived them of customary water facilities.

The defendants pleaded multiple defences, including that the tank was not the source of irrigation for the plaint lands and that the tank-bed proper was only 3 acres and had not been encroached upon. The lower courts found those specific pleas to be false. Material findings by the Subordinate Judge and District Judge (not contested before the appellate Court) included:

  • The tank-bed area is 25 3/4 acres.
  • The tank was the historical/source means of irrigation for the plaint lands.
  • Up to 1902 the lands were regarded as irrigable by the tank; prior to 1903 the tank-bed had babul trees and was not cultivated; after 1902 cultivation began by a defendant (defendant 4).
  • The channel (Athan Odai) constituting the main historic source of supply to the tank had been obliterated and converted to nanja lands since about 1902.
  • Defendants 2 and 3 (assignees of land in the tank-bed) had cut the channel within the tank-bed, erected a bund preventing water from spreading over the tank-bed, and otherwise prevented the tank being used as a storage tank.
  • The plaintiffs, however, had not suffered damage under the present condition because an abundant Periyar channel supply now reaches the raiyats directly; the plaintiffs were cultivating a second crop.

The question presented to the appellate Court was whether, on these findings, the plaintiffs were entitled to have the tank-bed restored to its original storage condition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the raiyats have a right that the old customary source of irrigation by a storage tank should be maintained.
  2. Whether defendants 2 and 3 have done anything which infringes that right.
  3. Whether, given that no damage has accrued to the plaintiffs under the current supply regime, the plaintiffs nevertheless have a cause of action against defendants 2 and 3.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiffs' Arguments (counsel: Mr. Narasimha Ayyangar)

  • The plaintiffs (raiayats) are entitled to have the storage tank (the tank-bed and bund forming a storage tank) preserved and restored so that the accustomed quantity of water may flow through their lands.
  • The acts of defendants 2 and 3 in cultivating the tank-bed and building bunds infringed that right to the storage tank.
  • It is not necessary that the plaintiffs have suffered present damage for them to have a cause of action; reliance was placed on the doctrine in McCartney v. Londonderry and Lough Swilly Railway Co. Ltd. that a person having rights in the water of a natural stream need not prove damage to seek relief against diversion.
  • Even though the Athan Odai (old source) had been cut off, plaintiffs argued that if Periyar supply later ceased they might be able to restore the Athan Odai and would need the tank-bed available for storage.

Defendants' Arguments (including counsel: Mr. K. Srinivasa Ayyangar)

  • Defendants contended that the plaintiffs were receiving a never-failing and sufficient supply of Periyar water and therefore could not insist on restoring the tank to its original storage function.
  • It was argued that because the Athan Odai (the old main source) had already disappeared prior to the defendants' acts, the defendants' actions did not cause the original source to fail; accordingly, no present damage caused by defendants existed.
  • Mr. K. Srinivasa Ayyangar submitted that in the absence of damage the plaintiffs should not be entitled to relief.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
McCartney v. Londonderry and Lough Swilly Railway Co. Ltd. That the owner of a tenement adjoining a natural stream has no right to divert the water to a place outside the tenement and that a person claiming rights in the water of a natural stream need not always prove damage to seek relief. The Court acknowledged the proposition as valid in certain circumstances but observed it presupposes that the plaintiffs possess a right which may be affected; the crucial inquiry is whether the plaintiffs here actually possess such a right to the tank-storage that can be enforced without proof of present damage.
The Madras Railway Company v. The Zemindar of Carvetinagaram Statement (as treated by the Privy Council) that tanks are ancient, essential to welfare, and zamindars are charged under Indian law with the duty of preserving and repairing tanks; zamindars have no power to do away with such tanks in which many are interested. The Court relied on this passage as establishing the foundational duty of zamindars to preserve tanks, but distinguished the present case on facts: where storage is no longer essential and modern supply suffices, the zamindar is not under obligation to preserve storage in the old manner.
Collector of Trichinopoly v. Lukkamani Recognition of the proprietary right of zamindars in their lands, including waste lands and tank porambokes. The Court treated this authority as establishing zamindari proprietary rights in tank-lands, and used it to reason that raiyats do not thereby acquire proprietary rights to tank-beds or bunds beyond customary privileges (grazing, fuel, fishing) unless shown by grant or custom.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by first identifying the undisputed factual findings: the historic main channel (Athan Odai) had been obliterated before the defendants' actions, and since about 1902 an abundant Periyar channel supply had been established that reached the raiyats directly. The plaintiffs were found to be cultivating a second crop under the Periyar supply and to have suffered no present damage from the defendants' acts.

Given those facts, the Court addressed whether plaintiffs had a legal right enforceable by injunction to have the tank-bed restored to its original storage condition. The Court considered relevant legal authorities and principles:

  • It noted the Privy Council's statements that zamindars bear a duty to preserve tanks and that preservation of tanks historically served a wide public interest. However, the Court emphasized that those statements reflect a foundation for zamindari duty rather than an absolute rule that forbids all change in mode of supplying water.
  • It observed established law that zamindars possess proprietary rights in their lands (including tank porambokes), and that tenants' (raiayats') rights in such tank-beds and bunds have generally been limited to customary privileges (grazing, cutting fuel, fishing) unless a higher right is shown by grant or custom.
  • Because the plaintiffs had not produced their Pattas or other direct evidence establishing a proprietary or equivalent enforceable right to the tank-bed or bunds, and because the factual finding was that the storage function of the tank was no longer necessary for the raiyats' welfare (the Periyar supply sufficed and even improved irrigation), the Court found it difficult to sustain a claim for mandatory restoration of the tank-bed.
  • The Court considered the contingency argument (that Periyar supply might cease in future): it concluded that plaintiffs' right to relief against defendants 2 and 3 would arise when and if water from the old source were again brought to the tank and the condition of defendants' lands then made storage impossible. In other words, the Court limited a present cause of action in the absence of present invasion or damage by defendants.
  • The Court also emphasized practical consequences: ordering restoration would remove land currently under valuable cultivation and confer no present benefit on the raiyats; thus the remedy would be inappropriate on the present facts.

Phillips, J., concurring, added that if the tank had been a Government tank the distribution choice made by defendants would have been permissible, and there was no authority shown restricting a zamindar's analogous power; modern improvements in irrigation should not be made nugatory so long as the exercise of rights is not detrimental to the raiyats. On the facts, since no detriment to plaintiffs was found, he agreed with dismissal.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSITION: The appeal was allowed and the suit was dismissed.

Implications and Immediate Consequences:

  • The Court held that, on the found facts, the plaintiffs were not entitled to have the tank-bed restored to its original storage condition because storage was no longer essential and restoration would confer no present benefit while removing land from cultivation.
  • The Court qualified that the plaintiffs' rights against defendants 2 and 3 would arise in future if water from the old source were brought to the tank and the defendants' land condition then made storage impossible; thus a future cause of action was preserved pending changed facts.
  • Costs: because the defendants had set up false defences in both lower Courts, the suit was dismissed without costs in those Courts; the appellate Court allowed the costs of the appeal against respondents 21 to 24 (as stated in the opinion).
  • The Court did not record a change in legal doctrine beyond application to the present factual context; it treated parts of the matter as one of first impression and decided the case on the factual matrix rather than establishing a broad new precedent that would require preservation of historic tank storage irrespective of modern supply conditions.

This summary is compiled strictly from the text of the provided opinion. No facts, parties, outcomes, or legal propositions beyond those expressly contained in the opinion have been added or inferred.

Show all summary ...

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

Napier, J.:— In this suit the plaintiffs as representatives owning lands under the Sallivedan tank claimed relief against the original owner of the tank-bed and certain assignees of land in the tank-bed, alleging various acts by the assignees in the tank-bed which had deprived them of their water facilities. The defendants set up a number of pleas and among them alleged that the tank was not the source of irrigation for the plaint lands; that the tank-bed proper was only 3 acres in ex tent and that they had not encroached on it. These specific pleas have all been found to be false. Some of the acts alleged against them have not been held established but the findings of the lower appellate Court are as follows: The District Judge has found that the tank-bed has an area of 25 ¾ acres; that it is the source of irrigation of Survey No. 807 in respect of which this representative suit is brought; that up to 1902 the suit lands were regarded as irrigible by the tank that prior to 1903 the tank-bed was full of babul trees, that there was then no cultivation and that after 1902 defendant 4 began the cultivation in the tank-bed. He agrees with the other findings of the Subordinate Judge which include the finding that the channel forming the main source of supply to the tank has since 1902 been obliterated and converted into nanja lands. Then as to the acts of the defendant he finds that defendants 2 and 3, the assignees of the tank-bed have out the channel within the tank-bed and put up a bund which prevents the water spreading all over the tank-bed and have otherwise prevented the tank being used for the storage of water. These findings are not contested before us and the sole question is whether on the above findings the plaintiffs are entitled to have the tank-bed restored to its original condition.

2. The commissioner's plan and the survey plan make it clear what was the position prior to 1896 and what is the present position. The tank lies just below two other tanks named Reddiar tank and Vadukar tank. Prior to 1896 the western tank of the two other tanks that is the Reddiar tank was fed by a stream called Virasamarthu Odai flowing from the north and the eastern tank by a channel which conveyed water from an odai called Athan Odai taking its source in the Sirumalai Hills. This odai ran from north to south-east of the two upper tanks and east of the plaint tank, but the water was taken off by the channel at a point north-east of the upper tanks. The plan also shows that the Athan Odai channel besides feeding the eastern tank ran down between the two tanks and discharged the surplus water into the plaint tank. It appears that come surplus water from the Vadukar tank passed into the plaint tank and a certain amount of rain-water which is practically negligible, flowed off the land south of the upper tank down to the bund of the plaint tank. These were the nominal sources of supply for the plaint tank. In about the year 1896 the Periyar channel was out across from east to west north of the upper tanks and the course of supply of all the three tanks was immediately altered. For the Reddiar tank the water was brought from the Periyar channel down the old Virasamarathu Odai direct to the tank, and for the Vadukar tank a new channel was also led from the Periyar channel. This latter channel joined the course of the old Athan Odai channel where it ran between the two tanks towards the plaint tank and defendants 2 and 3, the assignees of land in the bed of the tank have continued this channel down to the tank bund enclosed it by a bund and created an outfall from it for the supply of the raiyats. The result is that at present the raiyats receive water direct: from the Periyar channel together with possibly a little surplus from the Periyar water in the two upper tanks. The old channel the Athan Odai, has, as previously stated, been obliterated and cultivated since 1902 at least. The lower appellate Court has found that plaintiffs have not suffered any damage by the present condition of the Sallivedan tank, and indeed it appears that having this abundant Periyar supply they are now cultivating a second crop. These facts are to be found in the judgments of the Courts and are not disputed here.

3. The Subordinate Judge states the proposition arising from these findings in para. 9 of his judgment as follows:

“The case for the defendants is that since the plaintiffs and other raiyats are getting a never failing and sufficient supply of Periyar water, they can not insist on getting the tank restored to its original state, especially as the channel from the Athan Odai which is its main source of supply is no longer available owning to disuse and consequent cultivation in the channel bed.”

4. He continues:

“There is some force in this contention but the Periyar supply is only a supplementary source of irrigation. The raiyats have no control over it. Sallivedan tank is the ancient and customary source of irrigations. Why should they sacrifice the natural source of water to which they are entitled as a matter of right, even though they do not now suffer for want of water from the tank? Those two sources are still available and nobody has a right to alter the customary source of irrigation. I must hold that the plaintiffs have a right to have the tank so kept as to allow the accustomed quantity of water to flow through the lands.”

5. The District Judge states the proposition more tersely. He says:

“The acts of the defendants restrict the plaintiff's accustomed user of the water of the tank for irrigation and he is entitled to an injunction.”

6. He says also that the capacity of the tank as tank has, of course, been materially altered for the worse and the plaintiffs are entitled to have the whole tank-bed area of 253/4 acres available as a tank. It seems to me that the questions which arise for determination by us is as follows:

(1) Whether the raiyata have a right that the old customary source of irrigation by a storage tank should be maintained; (2) whether defendants 2 and 3 have done anything which infringes that right; and (3) whether, no damage having accrued to the plaintiffs they have any cause of action against defendants 2 and 3. Mr. Narasimha Ayyangar has argued that the plaintiffs are entitled to have the storage tank and that defendants 2 and 3 by cultivation of the lands and by the building of the banks in the tank-bed have infringed that right. He contends that the fact that they have suffered no damage at present does not deprive them of their cause of action.

7. The first difficulty in his way however is this, that the old source of supply was the Athan Odai which has disappeared. This disappearance occurred before the defendants did any of the acts complained of and it necessarily follows that the acts of the defendants have not caused the failure of water from the Athan Odai. Mr. Narasimha Ayyangar has been compelled to concede this. But his argument is that if at any time the Periyar water supply ceased, the plaintiffs might be able to get the old Athan Odai channel restored and take the water from their old source of supply. Judging by the plan and from some evidence given in the case, I believe this to be a physical impossibility for it seems to me that the Periyar channel crosses the source of the Athan Odai. But assuming that this contingency might occur, the question is whether the plaintiffs have now a right of suit against defendants. Mr. K. Srinivasa Ayyangar argued that as there was no damage, the plaintiffs were not entitled to any relief. Mr. Narasimha relies on the doctrine laid down in McCartney v. Londonderry and Lough Swilly Railway Co. Ltd.(1) that the owner of a tenement adjoining a natural stream has no right to divert the water to a place outside the tenement and that it was not necessary for a person having rights in the water of the natural stream to prove damage. This proposition is in certain circumstances unassailable, but it starts with the proposition that the plaintiffs have a right which may be affected, whereas the important question in this case is what are the rights of the plaintiffs. Section 54 of the Specific Relief Act provides that a perpetual injunction may be granted to prevent a breach of an obligation existing in favour of the applicant whether expressly or by implication, when the defendant invades or threatens to invade the plaintiff's right to or enjoyment of the property and among others, where the invasion is such that pecuniary compensation would not afford adequate relief. The question therefore to be determined is whether the plaintiffs have a right to or to the enjoyment of the property namely the tank bed and secondly, whether the defendants' auction invades or threatens to invade that right. Mr. Srinivasa Ayyangar at the beginning of the argument wished to contend before on that the sole right of a zamindari raiyat was to have his accustomed supply of water made available for his fields and that he was not entitled to look to the tank at all. I am not certain that it is open to us at this stage of the case to consider a proposition which has not been put forward at any earlier stage. We have not before us any of the Pattas held by the plaintiffs, and the sole finding bearing on the question is the finding that the tank was the old source of supply. This important question may arise for decision and I would reserve my opinion on it till then. But assuming the right of the raiyats to be to have their water from the tank, the question still remains whether they have such a right in the whole of the tank bed as to entitle them to insist on its total area being preserved and the tank bund being kept up in such a manner as to form a storage tank. In the well-known instructions issued to Collectors under the Presidency of Port St. George, dated October 1799, on the introduction of the permanent settlement of zamindari land, the Government distinctly stated their wish to leave the construction and care of the tanks and water-courses entirely to the proprietors: vide p. 332, Vol. 2 of the Fifth Report, and this was held by the Privy Council to be the Common law of this Presidency in the leading case of the The Madras Railway Company…Plaintiffs; v. The Zemindar Of Carvetinagaram…Defendant.(2). The passage is as follows:

“The tanks are ancient, and formed part of what may be termed a national system of irrigation, recognized by Hindu and Mahomedan law, by regulations of the East India Company, and by experience older than history, as essential to the welfare and indeed, to the existence of a large portion of the population of India. The public duty of maintaining existing tanks, and of constructing new ones in many places, was originally undertaken by the Government of India, and upon the settlement of the country has in many instances devolved on zamindara of whom the defendant is one. The zamindars have no power to do away with the tanks in the maintenance of which large numbers of people are interested but are charged under Indian law, by reason of the tenure, with the duty of preserving and repairing them.”

8. The proprietary right of zamindars in their lands was established by the decision of the Board in the pass reported as Collector of Trichinopoly v. Lukkamani(3), and this right of ownership has always been applied to waste lands and tank porambokes and I know of no case in which it has been held that the rights of a tenant in a zamindari tank-bed and bunds are anything higher that the rights of grazing, cutting fuel and fishing arising either by grant or custom. It cannot therefore I think, be seriously argued that the plaintiffs, raiyats, have any proprietary right to the bed of the tank or its bunds, and the sole question really is whether their right to be provided with water from the tank is such a right to the enjoyment of property as cannot be varied. If it was to be contended that the water was property, the plaintiffs would be met with the difficulty that the water which now comes to the tank is not water from the old source of supply and that old source of supply has been cut off, not by the action of defendants 2 to 4, but by persons over whom they have no control. Their rights in the tank-bed and bunds must; be correlative to the duty of zamindars, and the language of the Privy Council standing the duty of the zamindars is prima facie in their favour. I asked Mr. Narasimha Ayyangar for further authority on this proposition, but he was unable to give me any, and indeed for the purpose of his argument assumed the position which is now in dispute. The matter is therefore one of first impression and I find considerable difficulty in disposing of it. The Privy Council in the passage above quoted have stated that the preservation of the tanks is essential to the welfare and indeed to the existence of a large portion of the population of India. That is the foundation of the duty, and it goes without saying that where a storage tank is essential for the welfare of the raiyats under the aiyacut, that tank must be maintained. But here we have the finding that a storage tank is not essential. The finding is that since 1902 at least, if not a few years previous, the whole of the water given to the raiyats out of their tank become from the Periyar Channel. It may be and probably is the fact that for the first few years the water from the channel was allowed to accumulate in the tank bed, but it is obvious that accumulation conferred no benefit on the raiyats of which they have now been deprived. At the present moment they are is fact cultivating a second crop with the Periyar water, a condition of affairs which was unknown under the old source of supply. The result of the action of defendants has been to do away with this unnecessary storage and lead the water direct to the ??? from which it is supplied to the raiyats, and the construction of the bunds for that purpose has result in the re-claiming of a major portion of the tank-bed for purposes of cultivation. To restore the tank-bed would therefore confer no benefit on the raiyats and could remove land from valuable cultivation. It seems to me that it is impossible to ignore the modern conditions of irrigation and to insist on the strict application of the language of the Board used with reference to conditions 40 years ago. In the course of argument my learned brother put this proposition to Mr. Narasimha Ayyangar:

“If it had been found possible in modern days to bring water down the old Athan odai channel through the tank-bed direct to the sluice without filling the tank, could it be suggested that is an infringement of the plaintiffs' right?”

9. Mr. Narasimha Ayyangar contended that it would be, and this in fact is the fundamental-position that he takes up. It is perfectly conceivable that at some time in the future storage tanks with their waste of large areas by submersion may be found to be unnecessary and that by a perfect system of distribution of river water with the and of pumping schemes, lands may be irrigated by direct flow. I cannot think that the Privy Council intended by the judgment to require adherence by zamindars to a system that may eventually be found wasteful and unnecessary. I am therefore of opinion that the enjoyment of the tank-bed, to the extent of the utilization of water stored in it, is a right which only exists as long as it is the duty of the zamindar to preserve such a tank, and that where he is in a position to give all proper water facilities from the tank without such storage, he is under no obligation to maintain the old system. With reference to Mr. Narasimha Ayyangar's farther argument that the supply from the Periyar may some day be discontinued, it seems to me sufficient to hold that the right of the plaintiffs against defendants 2 and 3 will arise when water is brought from the old source to the tank and the condition of the defendants' land is then found to make the storage impossible. I would therefore dismiss the suit, but in view of the fact that the defendants set up false defences in both the lower Courts, I would dismiss it without costs in those Courts, only allowing the costs of this appeal against respondents 21 to 24.

Phillips, J.:— It seemed to me that if the plaint tank were a Government tank, in exercise of its powers of distributing water it would be entitled to follow the course adopted by defendants 2 and 3 and there seems to be no reason why a zamindar, who owns a tank, should not have similar powers. At any rate we have not been referred to any authority to show that his powers are restricted unless, of course, there is an express contract to that effect, and to hold in favour of such restriction would result in harm to the general public, because improved methods of irrigation rendered possible by the discoveries of modern science would thereby become nugatory. It must, of course, be understood that the exercise of his rights by the zamindar must not in any way be detrimental to the raiyats concerned and as in this case it has been found that the plaintiffs have suffered no damage, I agree in the order proposed by my learned brother.

S.N/R.K

10. Appeal allowed.