- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
The Travancore Natio... v. Tranabank Union, A P...
Factual and Procedural Background
This is an appeal against the decree of the City Civil Judge passed in O.S. No. 900 of 1940. The plaintiff, Travancore National Bank Subsidiary Company, Limited (now under liquidation) represented by its Official Liquidator, filed a suit to recover the balance of subscription due in respect of two chits. The plaintiff-company carried on a chit fund business, and the first defendant, "Tranabank Union," consisting of employees of the Travancore National and Quilon Bank, Ltd. (also under liquidation) and the plaintiff-company, subscribed for two chits and was the successful bidder at an auction held on 4th January 1938. An agreement for future instalments was executed on 10th January 1938, signed by the second defendant as agent of the first defendant. The suit was filed against both defendants, but the appeal concerns only the second defendant, who was sought to be held liable personally on the ground that the principal (Tranabank Union), being an unregistered union, could not be sued under Section 230(3) of the Indian Contract Act. The lower Court dismissed the suit against the second defendant, leading to this appeal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the second defendant, who signed the agreement as agent of the Tranabank Union, can be held personally liable for the balance due under the contract.
- Whether the Tranabank Union, an unregistered union of employees, can be sued as a principal under Section 230(3) of the Indian Contract Act, or whether liability attaches to the members or signatories of the union.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Ratnaswami Madan v. The Prince of Arcot's Endowments (1938) 2 M.L.J. 148; I.L.R. (1938) Mad. 1094 | Established that an unincorporated body cannot be sued as such for recovery of a debt or contract; procedure under Order 1, Rule 8 CPC is inapplicable for such cases. | The Court relied on this precedent to reject the lower Court's suggestion that the plaintiff could use Order 1, Rule 8 CPC to sue the unregistered Tranabank Union, emphasizing that the union cannot be sued as a legal entity. |
| Walker v. Sur (1914) 2 K.B. 930 | Only persons who signed or adopted contracts on behalf of an unincorporated association can be sued; other members cannot be proceeded against. | The Court applied this principle to hold the second defendant liable personally as he signed the contract on behalf of the unregistered union, whereas other members could not be sued. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the nature of the Tranabank Union as an unregistered association of employees without a register of members or subscriptions and noted that it was not an illegal body but could not be sued as a legal entity under contract law. The second defendant signed the agreement expressly as an agent of the Tranabank Union, which was clearly indicated in the document. The Court agreed with the lower Court that the second defendant did not indicate personal liability by his signature since he signed as agent. However, relying on established legal principles and precedents, the Court held that since the Tranabank Union cannot be sued as a principal, the liability for the contract extends to those who signed or adopted the contract on its behalf, including the second defendant. Therefore, the plaintiff was entitled to recover the amount from the second defendant personally in his capacity as a member and signatory of the union.
Holding and Implications
The Court reversed the decree of the lower Court and granted a decree for Rs. 1,050 with interest at six percent per annum from the date of suit against the second defendant, along with costs in both Courts.
The direct effect of this decision is that the second defendant is held personally liable for the contract amount due because the principal, an unregistered union, cannot be sued. No broader precedent was established beyond confirming the application of existing principles relating to unincorporated bodies and agency.
1. This is an appeal against the decree of the City Civil Judge passed in O.S. No. 900 of 1940. The plaintiff is the Travancore National Bank Subsidiary Company, Limited (now under liquidation) represented by its Official Liquidator. The lower Court dismissed the suit which was one to recover the balance of subscription due in respect of two chits. The plaintiff-company was carrying on a chit fund business. Various chits were started from time to time. The first defendant is styled " Tranabank Union" which admittedly consists of the employees of the Travancore National and Quilon Bank, Ltd. (now in liquidation) and also of the plaintiff-company which is the Travancore National Bank Subsidiary Company. The first defendant subscribed for two chits and was the successful bidder of both the tickets at the auction held on the 4th January, 1938. A sum of Rs. 1,340 in cash was paid to the first defendant-company and an agreement was executed for the future instalments on the 10th January, 1938. This agreement was signed by the second defendant on behalf of the first defendant. Though the suit was filed against both the defendants, the present appeal is pressed only against the second defendant who is the second respondent in this appeal. We are not concerned with the claim against the first defendant. The second defendant was sought to be made liable on the ground that though he signed as an agent in Ex. A, the suit document, the case is one coming under Section 230 (3) of the Contract Act for the reason that the principal though disclosed cannot be sued, This ground of liability is based upon the fact that the Tranabank Union is an unregistered union of the employees of the two companies. In such a case it is said that all the persons who were members of the Tranabank Union are liable under the contract. At any rate it is said that the persons who signed the document on behalf of that unregistered union are liable. The lower Court rejected the plaintiff's case and dismissed the suit. Hence this appeal.
2. The second defendant when affixing his signature to Ex. A expressly added the word " agent" to his signature. The document itself begins by saying that it was executed by the Tranabank Union which is called the borrower. So the document is executed by the Tranabank Union and it was signed by the second defendant as agent. It therefore clearly means that he signed it as the agent of the first defendant Union. It cannot therefore be said that he (second defendant) did not indicate in that document that he was signing only as the agent. I therefore agree with the City Civil Judge in holding that the second defendant cannot be made personally liable on the ground that when he signed his name, he did not say that he signed for the Tranabank Union. That he did so for and on behalf of the Tranabank Union is fairly clear from the document read as a whole.
3. The chief ground which was pressed before the lower Court was that the Tranabank Union cannot be sued and that therefore the second defendant was liable. This claim is covered by Section 230, Clause (3) of the Indian Contract Act. The lower Court declined to accept the plaintiff's contention that the Tranabank Union cannot be sued. After setting out a quotation from the evidence of the second defendant, the lower Court stated that it was clear from his evidence that the Tranabank Union was an association of the employees of the bank and the plaintiff-company, that is, the main Travancore National and Quilon Bank and the plaintiff-company
" without a register of members, without subscriptions and that it had been disbanded. Then dealing with the contention that the Tranabank Union cannot be sued, the Judge said that it was not an illegal body and that it may be difficult, and indeed very difficult to hold that the Tranabank Union is a party which cannot be sued. He winds up the discussion by saying that it was lip to the plaintiff-company to find out who were the members of the Union and to take steps to have them properly summoned and indicated that possibly the procedure under Order 1, Rule 8, Civil Procedure Code, maybe adopted. The learned Judge here overlooked the fact that under the law an unincorporated body cannot be sued as such for recovery of a debt or on a contract. That the procedure under Order 1, Rule 8 indicated by the City Civil Judge is inapplicable to a case of this kind has been laid down by Venkatasubba Rap and Abdur Rahman, JJ., in Ratnaswami Madan v. The Prince of Arcot's Endowments ( 1938) 2 M.L.J. 148 : I.L.R. (1938) Mad. 1094". That an unincorporated body cannot be sued is clear. In Halsbury's Laws of England (Hailsham Edition], Volume IV, page 498, paragraph 921 runs thus:
It has already been stated that an unincorporated members' club is not a partnership nor an association which, as an association is legally recognised; and questions frequently arise as to who are the persons liable for goods supplied to such a club, or on contracts professedly made on its behalf. These questions depend on the ordinary principles of agency. The person supplying the goods must proceed against the persons who gave or authorised the giving of the order; he must prove that the defendants, either by themselves or by their agent, entered into the contract.
In Walker v. Sur(1914) 2 K.B. 930, it is laid down that only those persons who signed the contracts on behalf of the association and those who adopted them can be sued and that other persons who are members of an unincorporated body cannot be proceeded against. Here the second defendant is admittedly an employee of the Travancore National and Quilon Bank, Limited, and the first defendant-company is admittedly composed of all the employees of the Travancore National and Quilon Bank, Limited and of the Subsidiary Company as well. The second defendant thus being a member of the first defendant union is liable to be sued under the authorities just referred to. This being so, the plaintiff is entitled to a decree against the second defendant in his capacity as a member of the first defendant-company and as the person who admittedly signed the document in question on behalf of the first defendant.
4. I reverse the decree of the lower Court and grant a decree for Rs. 1,050 with interest from the date of suit at six per cent, per annum against the second defendant with costs here and in the lower Court.
Alert