Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Doraiswami Reddiar v. Thangavelu Mudaliar

Madras High Court
Jan 29, 1929
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiffs filed a suit seeking a declaration that a release deed executed by their mother, who was their guardian, is not binding upon them. The release deed purportedly released the plaintiffs' rights in a partnership originally entered into by their father with the defendants. The plaintiffs allege that the release deed was obtained by fraud and undue influence and seek an injunction restraining the defendants from interfering with their participation in the partnership business. The lower Court held that the suit fell under Section 7 (iv) (c) of the Court-fees Act and valued the suit accordingly, allowing it to be filed in the Court of the District Munsif. This petition challenges the jurisdictional decision of the lower Court, asserting that the valuation and jurisdiction were incorrectly determined.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the plaintiffs are bound to get the release deed set aside before seeking relief.
  2. Whether the suit is properly valued and falls under Section 7 (iv) (c) or Section 7 (iv) (a) of the Court-fees Act.
  3. Whether the District Munsif Court has jurisdiction to try the suit based on its valuation.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kattiya Pillai v. Ramaswami Pillai, A.I.R. 1929 Mad. 396 Jurisdictional principle related to the valuation of relief and court-fee under the Court-fees Act. Used to support the interference in revision against the lower Court's jurisdictional decision.
Veeraraghavulu v. Sreeramulu, A.I.R. 1928 Mad. 816 Applicability of Section 7 (iv) (c) for suits involving alienations by managing members of a Hindu coparcenary. Distinguished by the court as not applicable since the alienation was by a guardian, not a managing coparcener.
Madugula Latchiah v. Mukkalinga, [1907] 39 Mad. 393 Requirement that alienations by guardians are voidable and must be regularly set aside. Applied to hold that the release deed executed by the plaintiffs' guardian mother is voidable and requires cancellation.
Muthukumara Chetty v. Anthony Udayan, [1915] 38 Mad. 867 Same principle regarding alienations by guardians requiring formal cancellation. Reinforced the court's view that the suit is effectively for cancellation of the release deed.
Kandasami v. Irusappa, [1918] 41 Mad. 102 Alienations by guardians are voidable and not absolute nullities. Supported the court’s interpretation that the relief sought is for cancellation of the document.
Arumugham Pillai v. Ambalam, A.I.R. 192 Mad. 425 Similar principle on voidability of guardian alienations. Used to justify reading the plaint as seeking cancellation of the release deed.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed whether the suit should be treated as one for cancellation of the release deed executed by the plaintiffs' mother as their guardian. It held that such a transaction is voidable, not void, and must be regularly set aside to affect the plaintiffs' rights. Consequently, the proper classification of the suit falls under Section 7 (iv) (a) of the Court-fees Act, which governs suits for cancellation of documents securing money or property having monetary value. The court reasoned that the release deed secured the defendants' interest in the partnership property, analogous to a sale deed, and thus the suit is for cancellation of a document securing property. Regarding valuation, the court observed that the consideration mentioned in the release deed was Rs. 3,461-8-0, but the plaintiffs' claim implies their interest is worth more, placing the suit beyond the pecuniary jurisdiction of the District Munsif Court. Therefore, the order of the lower Court was reversed, and the plaint was directed to be returned for presentation to the proper Court.

Holding and Implications

The court held that the suit is properly a suit for cancellation of the release deed under Section 7 (iv) (a) of the Court-fees Act and that the District Munsif Court lacks jurisdiction due to the valuation exceeding its pecuniary limits.

As a result, the plaint must be returned to the plaintiffs for presentation to the appropriate Court with jurisdiction. The respondents were ordered to pay the costs of the petition. No new legal precedent was established; the decision directly affects the parties by correcting the jurisdictional error and ensuring proper valuation and court assignment for the suit.

Show all summary ...

1. This petition raises a question relating to Court-fee as well as jurisdiction. The point in regard to Court-fee having been decided by the lower Court in favour of the plaintiffs, the reason for my interfering in revision is, that its decision is wrong on the question of jurisdiction: see the judgment in Kattiya Pillai v. Ramaswami Pillai A.I.R. 1929 Mad. 396.

2. The plaintiffs allege in their plaint that their father entered into a partnership with defendants 1 to 3 which was to remain in force till 1931, that, after their father's death in 1925, their mother agreed with the said defendants to release the plaintiffs' rights in the partnership and executed a release deed, dated 10th April 1926. After plaintiff 1 attained majority in 1927, this suit was filed for obtaining a declaration that the release deed is not binding upon the plaintiffs. They allege that the deed was brought about by fraud and undue influence and that their rights are 'not affected by the release deed. The plaintiffs pray for a declaration that it is invalid and. for an injunction restraining the defendants from interfering with their participation in the business of the partnership. The lower Court has held that the suit falls within Section 7 (iv) (c), Court-fees Act, which relates to a suit, to obtain a declaratory decree or order where consequential relief is prayed

3. If this section applied, the plaintiffs would be at liberty to value the relief at any amount fixed by them. In this case, they valued the relief at Us. 2,100 and filed the suit in the Court of the District Munsif.

4. The question to be decided is: are the plaintiffs bound to get the release deed set aside? If they are, the form of the plaint may be disregarded, for, in substance, the relief claimed is one for can collation. The transaction was entered into by the mother of the plaintiffs as their guardian. Can it be said that such a transaction is an absolute nullity?' In my opinion, Article ii. Dim. Act, clearly applies. I am not now concerned with cases which have held, that in the case of alienations by managing members of a Hindu coparcenary it is unnecessary to get the transaction set aside. The case relied upon by the lower Court: Veeraraghavulu v. Sreeramulu A.I.R. 1928 Mad. 816, is a case of this description. In the present case, I am not called upon to consider whether this decision is correct or not. The alienation in question was made by the mother of the plaintiffs, their guardian under the Hindu law. In such a case the transaction is voidable and not void. Then again, the question does not arise whether Article 44 does or does not apply to an alienation by an unauthorized person. In this case, the complaint in short is that an authorized guardian effected an unauthorized transfer. An alienation by a guardian mu3t be regularly set aside: see Madugula Latchiah v. Mukkalinga [1907] 39 Mad. 393; Muthukumara Chetty v. Anthony Udayan [1915] 38 Mad. 867; Kandasami v. Irusappa [1918] 41 Mad. 102' and Arumugham Pillai v. Ambalam A.I.R. 192. Mad. 425. I am therefore disposed to read the plaint as if contains a prayer for the cancellation of the release deed. In this view, the section of the Court fees Act applicable is Section 7 (iv) (a). It reads thus:

In a suit for cancellation of a decree for money or other property having a money value or other document securing money or other property having such value, according to the value of the subject-matter of the suit.

5. The words " securing money or other property " are not happy; but the question is: Is this or not a suit for cancellation of a document securing property having money value? I think it clearly is. I have no doubt that the release deed in question is a document securing property; in other words, by that document, the property covered by it is made secure to the defendants. Can there be any doubt that a sale-deed comes within the terms of this section? The present instrument does not materially differ from a sale-deed. By that, the rights of the plaintiffs in the partnership and its property have been transferred for consideration to the defendants. The word " secure " may mean according to the Oxford Dictionary, " to make the tenure of a property secure to a person." I am, therefore, of the opinion that the proper section applicable is section 7 (iv) (a).

6. If that applies, what is the proper valuation of the suit. The section says:

The value of the suit shall be deemed to be if the whole decree or other document is sought to be cancelled, the amount or the value of the property for which the decree was passed or the other document executed.

7. What then is the value of the property for which the release deed was executed? It recites that the consideration paid to the plaintiff's mother is Rs. 3,461-8-0. The plaintiffs do not suggest in their plaint that this amount was not in fact paid. Their complaint is that the deed is vitiated by fraud and undue influence and is even otherwise not binding upon thorn. I am disposed to read the plaint as meaning that their rights, which their mother gave up, are worth to them much more than Rs. 3,461-8-0. It is not to be understood that I decide that the plaintiffs are precluded from proving that consideration did not pass either wholly or partly. At present, I am concerned with the plaint as it stands and I cannot help thinking that, according to the plaintiffs, the property which their mother gave up, that is, their interest in the partnership, is worth to them more than the amount mentioned in the deed. If that be so, the suit is beyond the pecuniary jurisdiction of the District Munsif. The order of the lower Court is reversed, and the Civil Revision Petition is allow-ad. I direct the plaint to be forwarded to the District Munsif's Court for being returned by that Court to the plaintiffs for re-presentation to the proper Court. The respondents shall pay the costs of this petition.