- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Hiralal Banjara v. Bashiram Sharma And Ors.
Structured Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The applicant, Hiralal Banjara, obtained a patent dated 12 July 1928 for a machine for removing husks and shells from mahsoor. No other person was registered as proprietor until 9 October 1937, when Babu Ram Jainy was registered after acquiring purported rights by purchase on 20 September 1937 following an execution sale initiated by a judgment-creditor named Radhakissen.
Babu Ram Jainy assigned the patent to Bashiram Sharma (the "Respondent") by an assignment dated 24 November 1937; Bashiram Sharma obtained registration as proprietor on 15 January 1938. On the same day a person named Abdulla Miah was registered as a licensee under the Respondent pursuant to an agreement dated 22 November 1937.
The applicant challenged the sale to Babu Ram Jainy in the Court of Small Causes; that court declined to set aside the sale, but the High Court, exercising revisional jurisdiction under section 115 of the Civil Procedure Code, set the sale aside on 20 June 1938.
On 30 June 1938 the applicant wrote to the Controller of Patents requesting expungement from the register of the entries showing Babu Ram Jainy and the Respondent as proprietors and Abdulla Miah as licensee. The Controller referred the application to the High Court under section 64(3) of the Indian Patents and Designs Act, 1911. The present opinion is the High Court's decision on that reference.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Controller of Patents had the power under section 64(3) to refer the applicant's request for rectification (expungement of entries) to the High Court, given the limitations contained in section 64(5).
- Whether the applicant (Hiralal Banjara) was a "person aggrieved" within the meaning of section 64(1) and therefore entitled to apply for rectification of the register.
Arguments of the Parties
Applicant's Arguments
- The applicant claimed to be a person aggrieved by entries wrongly remaining on the register and so entitled to apply under section 64(1).
- Although the applicant had executed an assignment dated 14/15 May 1929 in favour of Ghanshyam Das Jaganani, it was argued (by Mr. P.C. Ghose) that certain rights remained with the applicant which would permit him to be regarded as a person aggrieved — however the Court noted that the assignee had not been registered and therefore that particular hypothetical need not be explored further.
- The applicant relied on the High Court's prior revisional order setting aside the execution sale (20 June 1938) as a basis for seeking expungement of subsequent registrations and entries resulting from that sale.
Respondent's Arguments
- The Respondent contended that the application was incompetent because the applicant was not a "person aggrieved" within the meaning of section 64(1).
Argument Challenging the Controller's Power to Refer
- It was argued (the source does not specify by which party) that because section 64(5) restricts the Controller from rectifying the register except to correct mistakes of fact apparent from the patent or from orders made under the Act, the Controller therefore had no power to refer to the High Court applications which the Controller himself was not empowered to decide. If accepted, this construction would confine the Controller's role to formal matters only and exclude from the Controller's power of reference substantial applications seeking relief based on orders made under other statutes (for example, the Civil Procedure Code).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| In re Hiralal Banjara (reported proceedings) | Record of prior proceedings in which the applicant successfully applied for the register to be rectified by expunging an entry that had recorded revocation; evidences that the High Court had ordered expungement of an entry recording invalidity. | The Court relied on that prior decision to conclude that it could not treat the patent as invalid when this Court had previously ordered the entry recording invalidity to be expunged; this supported the finding that the applicant was a person aggrieved and entitled to relief. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court first addressed the procedural/statutory question whether the Controller could refer the application under section 64(3). The Court analyzed the statutory scheme of section 64 as amended (noting changes made in 1930) and observed the following:
- Section 64(1) confers broad powers on the Controller to make, expunge or vary entries in the register "on the application of any person aggrieved."
- Section 64(3) (a new provision) permits appeals from Controller's orders to the High Court and authorizes the Controller to refer any application under section 64 to the High Court for decision.
- Section 64(5) restricts the Controller's powers by stating that nothing in the section empowers the Controller to rectify the register or decide any question relating to a patent except for correcting a mistake of fact apparent from the patent itself or from an order made under any provision of the Act; this provision thus limits the Controller to essentially formal corrections where the mistake is apparent from specified documents.
Confronted with an apparent tension — that sub-section (5) would prevent the Controller from deciding the very kinds of substantive applications the legislature previously allowed him to entertain — the Court refused to adopt a reading that would entirely deprive persons of remedies. The Court held that section 64(1) must be read as giving persons the right to make applications to the Controller even though subsection (5) prevents the Controller from deciding some of those applications; consequently, such applications fall within the Controller's power of reference under subsection (3). In short, the Controller can receive and refer to the High Court applications which the Controller himself cannot finally decide because of the limits in subsection (5).
The Court then turned to the substantive question whether the applicant was a "person aggrieved" within section 64(1). The Respondent relied upon two circumstances said to disqualify the applicant:
- That the applicant had executed an assignment on 14/15 May 1929 to Ghanshyam Das Jaganani, which (it was argued) might deprive him of a proprietary interest qualifying him as a person aggrieved. The Court examined the statutory definition of "patentee" (section 2(12)) and provisions governing the register (sections 20, 29 and 63). The Court concluded that until an assignee has been entered on the register he cannot sue for infringement or otherwise exercise the statutory powers of a registered proprietor; those statutory powers remain with the assignor while he remains on the register. Because the assignee under the 1929 assignment had not been registered, the applicant remained someone who could be aggrieved by subsequent registrations.
- That the patent had been held invalid in earlier proceedings before the Patna High Court (in the course of related infringement proceedings) and that an appeal to the Privy Council had not argued revocation. The Patna High Court's order (which purported to revoke) was sent to the Controller under section 33 and an entry was made in the register; subsequently the applicant successfully applied to have that entry expunged (reported as In re Hiralal Banjara). The Court considered that, in light of the High Court's order expunging the revocation-entry, it could not treat the patent as invalid for present purposes and noted that both parties were asserting rights to what each claimed to be a valid patent.
On these bases the Court concluded that the applicant was a person aggrieved under section 64(1) and that the Controller had power to refer the application to the High Court under section 64(3).
Holding and Implications
Core Holding: The Court directed that the register be rectified by expunging the entries specified in sub-paragraphs 1, 2 and 3 of the applicant's application dated 30 June 1938. The applicant (Hiralal Banjara) was held to be a "person aggrieved" within section 64(1), and the Controller was held to have power to refer the application under section 64(3).
Direct consequences and orders:
- The register was ordered to be rectified by expunging the entries relating to the execution sale and subsequent registrations (as specified in the applicant's application).
- The applicant was awarded costs of the application as against the Respondent.
- The Respondent was ordered to pay the Controller's costs up to the date of the earlier order. Costs were awarded as of a hearing and certified for one counsel.
The opinion does not elaborate on broader legal or policy implications beyond these direct effects on the parties. It does not purport to set a wider precedent beyond the statutory interpretation and application to the facts of this reference.
The Judgment of the Court was as follows:—
Panckridge, J.:— This is a reference made by the Controller of Patents under the provisions of sec. 64(3) of the Indian Patents and Designs Act, 1911.
The history of the events that have led to the reference is as follows. One Hiralal Banjara, to whom I will henceforward refer as the applicant, obtained a patent dated July 12th, 1928, in respect of a machine for removing the husks and shells from mahsoor. No other person was registered as a proprietor of this patent until October 9th 1937, when one Babu Ram Jainy was so registered.
The circumstances which enabled Babu Ram Jainy to obtain registration were as follows. A certain person named. Radhakissen obtained a money decree in the Court of Small Causes against the applicant. In execution of this decree he purported to attach and bring to sale the applicant's rights under his patent, which were sold to Babu Ram Jainy on September 20th, 1937.
On November 24th, 1937, Babu Ram Jainy assigned the patent to Bashiram Sharma, to whom I will refer as the “Respondent,” and who obtained registration on January 15th, 1938. On the same day, one Abdulla Miah got himself registered as a licensee under the Respondent in virtue of an agreement dated November 22nd, 1937.
There were various proceedings by the applicant in the Court of Small Causes for having the sale to Babu Ram Jainy of September 20th, 1937, set aside. The Small Cause Court declined to set aside the sale, but this Court in exercise of its revisional powers under sec. 115 of the Civil Procedure Code set it aside on June 20th, 1938.
On June 30th, 1938, the applicant wrote to the Controller of Patents calling upon him to exercise his powers under sec. 64 of the Act by expunging the entries which showed Babu Ram [Jainy] and the Respondent as proprietors, and Abdulla Miah as licensee. This application has been referred to the High Court under sec. 64(3).
It has been argued that the Controller has no power to refer this application for rectification. The scheme of sec. 64 is as follows. Under sub-sec. (1) the Controller may on the application of any person aggrieved make such order for making, expunging or varying an entry as he thinks fit, and rectify the register accordingly. By sub-sec. (3)
“An appeal shall lie to the High Court from any order of the Controller under this section; and the Controller may refer any application under this section to the High Court for decision, and the High Court shall dispose of any application so referred.”
So far it is plain sailing.
But a difficulty is certainly occasioned by sub-sec. (5), which says that
“Nothing in this section shall be deemed to empower the Controller (a) to rectify the register of patents or to decide any question relating to a patent, otherwise than for the purpose of correcting a mistake of fact apparent from a reference either to the patent itself, or to some order of a competent authority made under any other provision of this Act, or (b) to make any such order cancelling the registration of a design as is provided for in s. 51—A.”
Now, it is conceded that by reason of sub-sec. (5) the Controller himself would have no power to rectify the register in the manner which the applicant desires, since there is no question of correcting a mistake of fact apparent from a reference to the patent itself, nor is it a question of correcting a mistake of fact apparent from a reference to some order of a competent authority made under any other provision of the Act, because the order which is to be looked at is the order of the High Court setting aside the execution sale by the Small Cause Court, and that is an order made not under the provisions of the Patents and Designs Act, but under the Code of Civil Procedure. Accordingly, it is plausibly argued that the present application is not an application made under the section within the meaning of sub-sec. (3), and therefore not one which the Controller can refer to the High Court. To construe the section in this way is really to hold that the legislature intended to confine the jurisdiction of the Controller to formal applications, and at the same time gave him the power to refer only those applications to Court, though ex hypothesi, they were matters with which he was perfectly competent to deal, leaving the person concerned with correcting a substantial error in the register without any remedy whatever.
I have compared the language of the section as originally enacted in 1911 with the language of it as it now stands after the amendments of 1930, and I find that the trouble has arisen from this. Sec. 64, sub-sec. (1), on the face of it, transfers very wide powers, previously exerciseable by the High Court, to the Controller. Sub-sec. (3), which is new, provides for an appeal from the Controller to the High Court and for the reference of applications by the Controller to the High Court. Sub-sec. (5) indicates that the legislature had misgivings as to the wide powers which sec. 64(1) conferred on the Controller, and accordingly proceeded to cut down those powers and leave the Controller with diminished powers, which are scarcely more than formal. It was undoubtedly the intention of the legislature to limit the powers of the Controller, but I cannot presume that the legislature desired entirely to deprive the subject of the remedies which he had hitherto enjoyed, by excluding from the applications “made under this section” those applications which the section specifically removes from the decision of the Controller. I think sec. 64(1) must be read as giving the subject a right to make an application to the Controller with which sub-sec. (5) prevents him from dealing. If that is so, this application is certainly within the powers of reference given to the Controller under sub-sec. (3).
I now turn to the more important aspect of the case. The main contention of the Respondent is that this application is incompetent because the applicant is not a person aggrieved within the meaning of sec. 64(1). The applicant's contention is that he comes within the section as being a person aggrieved by an entry wrongly remaining on the register.
There are two circumstances which, it is said, disqualify the applicant from being a person aggrieved within the meaning of the sub-section. The first of these circumstances is the fact that on May 14th, 1929, the applicant executed a deed in favour of one Ghanshyam Das Jaganani whereby for consideration he assigned his invention and letters patent and the full and exclusive benefit thereof, and all rights, privileges and advantages appertaining thereto. Mr. P.C Ghose has argued that under the deed of assignment the applicant still retained certain rights, which would entitle him to call himself a person aggrieved, even if he had ceased to be the patentee within the meaning of the Act by reason of the assignee having himself registered as proprietor. Inasmuch, however, as there has been no registration of the assignee as proprietor I need not consider what the position would then have been.
Sec. 2(12) defines “patentee” as the person for the time being entered in the register of patents kept under this Act as the grantee or proprietor of the patent. Sec. 20 provides for the maintenance of the register, and sec. 29 gives to the patentee the right to institute a suit for infringement of his patent. Sec. 63(1) provides,
“Where a person becomes entitled by assignment ….. to a patent …., he may make an application to the Controller to register his title, and the Controller shall, on receipt of such application and on proof of title to his satisfaction, register him as the proprietor of such patent or design, and shall cause an entry to be made in the prescribed manner, in the register of the assignment,…”
Sub-sec. (3) provides,
“The person registerd as the proprietor of a patent …. shall subject to the provisions of this Act and to any rights appearing from the register to be vested in any other person, have power absolutely to assign, grant licenses as to, or otherwise deal with, the patent or design, and to give effectual receipts for any consideration for any such assignment, license or dealing.”
It is plain from these provisions that until an assignee has had himself entered on the register he is incapable of protecting the patent assigned to him by legal proceedings for infringement, or of assigning it, or granting license to it. Until registration these powers, subject to equities, remain vested in the assignor as long as he remains on the register. The assignor, however, loses these powers as soon as the assignee has himself registered as the proprietor. It follows from this that since the assignee under the assignment of May 15th, 1929, has not had himself registered as proprietor, the applicant is a person who may be aggrieved by subsequent registration.
The other ground on which it is urged the applicant is not a person aggrieved within the meaning of sec. 64(1) concerns certain proceedings in which his patent has been held to be invalid. Apparently, the assignee under the deed of May 15th, 1929, instituted a suit for infringement in the Patna District Court, which was subsequently transferred to the High Court. The applicant was a party to those proceedings, but his name appears to have been removed from the cause title when the suit was transferred. As a result of these proceedings the assignee suit was dismissed, and in addition to dismissing it, the Patna High Court went on to revoke the patent granted to the applicant. An appeal was taken to the Privy Council, and it is said that the question of revocation was not argued before them, but only the question of infringement. As a result the appeal was dismissed. It is conceded by Counsel that the Patna High Court had at that time no jurisdiction to entertain a claim for revocation by way of counter-claim in a suit for infringement. It appears that the order of the Patna High Court was sent to the Controller under the provisions of sec. 33 of the Act, and the Controller made the appropriate entry in the register. Upon this the present applicant successfully applied for the register to be rectified by expunging the entry, to which I have referred. Those proceedings are reported in In re Hiralal Banjara (1). I do not see how I can treat a patent as invalid when this Court has ordered the entry of the declaration of invalidity to be expunged from the register, the more so as both the parties to this reference are in agreement in this, that each of them is asserting his rights to what he claims to be a valid patent.
In these circumstances, I hold that the applicant is a person aggrieved within the meaning of sec. 64(1). The Court having declared the execution sale to be a nullity, the entry relating to that sale and the subsequent entries regarding the rights derived from the purchaser at such a sale clearly should not have appeared on the register. It appears to me that the proceedings before the Controller were perfectly in order as far as service of notices and the notification in the “Gazette of India” are concerned. I accordingly direct that the register should be rectified by expunging therefrom the entries referred to in sub-paragraphs 1, 2 and 3 of the applicant's application of June 30th, 1938. The applicant is entitled to the costs of this application as against the Respondent. The Respondent must pay the Controller's costs up to the date of making the previous order. Costs as of a hearing. Certified for one Counsel.
Solicitors: B.K Bose for the Applicant; K.K Gupta for the Respondents.
C.C
Alert