- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Mt. Bahal Kuar v. Narain Singh
1. The relief asked for in this case was a declaration that the plaintiff was the owner of certain property and an injunction restraining the defendant, who claims the property, from interfering with the plaintiff's possession. This is clearly a claim for declaration with consequential relief. The right be obtain an injunction against the defendant flows from the declaration which the plaintiff seeks of his right be the property. If the plaintiff has that right be is entitled be an injunction in consequence. If he has not that right, he is not entitled to an injunction.
2. The Taxing Officer in fact felt to doubt on this point. The only reason that he has made this reference is that he was doubtful of his power under section 12(ii) of the Court Fees Act to decide that the plaint had been under-stamped in the Court below be the detriment of the revenue. Having, regard be section 5 of the Act I have no doubt that this power is vested in him. By that section the power of the Court be, decide disputed questions of Court-fee is vested in the Taxing Officer subject to his power be refer the matter be the Taxing Judge when a question of general importance arises. This authority extends be all such questions arising in the High Court whether the deficiency alleged is on the memorandum of appeal in this Court or on a plaint or memorandum of appeal filed in the Court below. This is my answer to the reference. The appellant is allowed up to November 4th be make good the deficiency in Court-fee.
3. Reference answered in affirmative.
Alert