- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Gour Sundar Majumdar v. Krishna Kamini Chaudhurani .
Factual and Procedural Background
These two appeals challenge the concurrent decisions of the lower Courts in two suits seeking (a) assessment of fair and equitable rent and (b) recovery of damages for use and occupation of lands for the period described in the plaints (the opinion refers at one point to "the period from 1381 to 1333 B.S" and elsewhere to the years 1331–1333 B.S). The contesting defendant (defendant 1) defended on the grounds that there was no landlord–tenant relationship between him and the plaintiff and that he held the lands as "kaimi mukarari jama" under the pro forma defendant 2. Defendant 1 also pleaded that the suits were not maintainable because all cosharer landlords had not joined as plaintiffs.
The finally published Record of Rights indicated that the plaintiff was a landlord of defendant 1 (a tenure-holder) in respect of the lands in suit. The record showed payments by the defendant to pro forma defendant 2 but no rent shown as payable to the plaintiff, and contained a note that the tenancies were liable to be assessed with rent in respect of the shares of cosharer landlords of whom the plaintiff was one. The plaintiff’s claim was therefore grounded on the entries in the finally published Record of Rights, specifically that no rent had been settled as payable to the plaintiff in respect of her share.
The Courts below overruled defendant 1’s defence, assessed fair and equitable rent as claimed by the plaintiff, and entered decrees in favour of the plaintiff for damages for use and occupation for the years 1331, 1332 and 1333 B.S, using the assessed fair and equitable rent as the measure of damages. The present appeals attack various points in support of overturning those results.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a cosharer landlord may maintain a suit for assessment of fair and equitable rent without other cosharers joining as plaintiffs, where there is no dispute about the plaintiff’s share (i.e., maintainability of the suits).
- Whether the suits as framed were governed by the Bengal Tenancy Act (and specifically Section 188), or whether they arose under the general law.
- Whether the plaintiff’s claim for assessment of rent was barred by limitation, given that rent had not been realized for a prolonged period.
- Whether the lower Courts were correct in referring to principles in Section 7 of the Bengal Tenancy Act in working out assessment of fair and equitable rent, even if the suits did not fall within the Act.
- Whether decrees for damages for use and occupation should have been made against the cosharer landlord (pro forma defendant 2) instead of defendant 1, and whether a plaintiff in a suit for assessment can recover arrears/back rent for a past period.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant / Contesting Defendant (Defendant 1)
- Contended there was no landlord–tenant relationship between him and the plaintiff because he held the lands as "kaimi mukarari jama" under the pro forma defendant 2.
- Argued the suits were not maintainable because all cosharer landlords had not joined as plaintiffs.
- Contended (or advanced argument) that the plaints indicated the suits were under the Bengal Tenancy Act and thus Section 188 applied, requiring compliance with its provisions.
- Argued the decrees for damages should have been directed against the cosharer landlord defendant 2 rather than against defendant 1.
- Relied on authorities (e.g., Maharaja Birendra Kisore v. Anandapriya Baishanabi) to contend limitation or other procedural bars applied (as raised by the appellant's advocate).
Plaintiff / Respondent
- Relied on the finally published Record of Rights showing the plaintiff to be a landlord of defendant 1 and that rent had not been settled or paid to the plaintiff in respect of her share; thus the plaintiff sought assessment of fair and equitable rent under the general law.
- Asserted entitlement to recover damages for use and occupation for the years specified, measured by the fair and equitable rent as assessed.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Chiranjib Sen v. Mohendra Nath Biswas, A.I.R. 1929 Cal. 90 | That a suit by a cosharer landlord for assessment of rent need not necessarily require other cosharers to join as plaintiffs where there is no dispute about the extent of the plaintiff's share. | The Court relied on this principle to support the conclusion that the plaintiff’s suit for assessment was maintainable and decided the question of maintainability against the appellant. |
| Dhananjoy Manjhi v. Upendra Nath, [1918] 46 I.C. 428 | Similar principle supporting a cosharer landlord’s right to seek assessment without other cosharers joining as plaintiffs. | Used alongside Chiranjib Sen to confirm that the plaintiff could maintain the suit and to support the finding that the plaintiff was entitled to have fair rent assessed. |
| Raj Chandra Bhowmick v. Habibulla, A.I.R. 1930 Cal. 693 | Referenced for Rankin, C.J.'s noting of prior observations (including the view that S.188 may not apply in certain cases and that other cosharers should at least be made parties defendant so the assessment binds all). | The Court adopted the reasoning that, while other cosharers may not need to join as plaintiffs, they should be made parties defendant so an assessment binds all equally; in the present suits all cosharers were joined as defendants, so maintainability objection failed. |
| Partap Mahton v. Mt. Wazirunnessa, A.I.R. 1925 Pat. 559 | Observation (by Adami, J., as noted) that it may be unnecessary to join other cosharers as plaintiffs because S.188 did not apply; and a reported holding (in Patna decision) that a plaintiff was not entitled to claim arrears at the assessed fair rent in the same suit. | The Court noted the observations but treated them as not preventing recovery of arrears where possession and limitation requirements are satisfied; thus Partap Mahton was discussed but not adopted as limiting the plaintiff’s claim in these cases. |
| Maharaja Birendra Kisore v. Anandapriya Baishanabi, [1912] 30 I.C. 946 | Decision where the defendant was treated as a trespasser, and the plaintiff was found not to be in possession within 12 years; used as an example where assessment was held to be barred by limitation. | The Court held this authority inapplicable on the present facts, because the Record of Rights here presumes a landlord–tenant relation in favour of the plaintiff which was not rebutted; thus the case did not assist the appellant. |
| Jagannath Majhi v. Jumman Ali Patwari, [1901] 29 Cal. 247 | Authority supporting the view that a landlord can recover arrears/back rent in a suit for assessment where possession is admitted or proved and the claim is within the period of limitation. | The Court relied on this line of authority to conclude that the plaintiff could recover damages for use and occupation for the years in suit, provided possession and limitation conditions were met. |
| Bhupendra Kumar Chakrabutty v. Surjahanta Rai Choudhury, A.I.R. 1924 Cal. 128 | Supporting principle that arrears can be recovered in an assessment suit when possession and limitation conditions are fulfilled. | Applied by the Court as part of the accepted Calcutta decisions permitting recovery of arrears in these circumstances; supported affirmance of decrees for damages measured by assessed rent. |
| Manmatha Nath Pal v. Surendra Nath Bose, A.I.R. 1925 Cal. 463 | Another Calcutta decision reinforcing that arrears/back rent may be recovered in an assessment suit where possession and limitation permit. | Used with the other Calcutta cases to justify the conclusion that the plaintiff could recover damages for use and occupation for the years claimed. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded through the contested points in a structured way:
- Maintainability: The Court examined the finally published Record of Rights, which showed that the plaintiff was a landlord of the contesting defendant and that rent had not been settled as payable to the plaintiff in respect of her share. Relying on the authorities cited (Chiranjib Sen; Dhananjoy Manjhi; and observations noted in Raj Chandra Bhowmick), the Court held that where there is no dispute about the extent of the plaintiff cosharer’s share a cosharer landlord can maintain a suit for assessment without other cosharers joining as plaintiffs; however, other cosharers should be made parties defendant so that an assessment binds all. Because all cosharers were joined as defendants in these suits, the maintainability objection raised by the appellant failed.
- Character of the Suits (Bengal Tenancy Act applicability): Although the cause title described the suits loosely as under the rent law, the plaints showed the main reliefs were claimed under the general law and not necessarily under the Bengal Tenancy Act. The Court therefore rejected the appellant’s contention that Section 188 of the Bengal Tenancy Act applied and that the suits should be treated as being under that Act.
- Limitation: The appellant did not press a contention based on long non-recovery of rent in oral argument, but the Court addressed the point raised. Given the Record of Rights indicating a landlord–tenant relationship and that rent had not been assessed in respect of the plaintiff’s share, the Court held that the mere non-realization of rent for many years did not bar a suit for assessment. The right to have fair rent assessed endures while the landlord–tenant relationship continues. The Court found the limitation argument raised by defendant 1 to be without substance and distinguished Maharaja Birendra Kisore v. Anandapriya Baishanabi (where plaintiff was not in possession within 12 years and defendant treated as trespasser).
- Use of Section 7 principles: The Court noted that the lower Courts had referred to Section 7 of the Bengal Tenancy Act in the course of reasoning but made clear that the actual basis of assessment accepted by the Courts below was that stated in the plaints. The assessment took gross collections from tenants under defendant 1 into account and made allowances for collection charges and profits to arrive at the fair and equitable rent payable by defendant 1 to the plaintiff. The Court held there is nothing inherently wrong in referring to the principles of Section 7 in arriving at a correct assessment even in cases not governed by the Act; the Courts below were correct in their approach.
- Damages / Back Rent: Concerning decrees for damages for use and occupation for 1331–1333 B.S, the Court rejected the contention that decrees should have been made against the cosharer landlord defendant 2 because no case had been made out against that defendant. The Court addressed the authority (Partap Mahton) that had held a plaintiff was not entitled to claim arrears at the assessed rate and concluded that the accepted view in this Court (supported by Jagannath Majhi and the Calcutta cases cited) permits recovery of arrears/back rent in a suit for assessment if the land was in the tenant’s possession for the period claimed and the claim was within the period of limitation. Here, possession during 1331–1333 B.S was not disputed, the claim was within time, and thus the assessed fair rent was the proper measure of damages per year.
Holding and Implications
CORE RULING: THE DECISIONS OF THE LOWER COURTS ARE AFFIRMED AND THE APPEALS ARE DISMISSED.
Direct consequences and orders explicitly stated in the opinion:
- The decrees of the lower Courts assessing fair and equitable rent and awarding damages for use and occupation for the years (as decreed below) are affirmed.
- The appeals are dismissed with costs; one hearing fee only is allowed for the two appeals.
- Leave to prefer appeals under the Letters Patent is refused.
The opinion does not purport to lay down any new legal principle or landmark precedent; it applies existing authorities and established principles to the facts and records before the Court and therefore does not claim to create a new precedent. The direct effect is to sustain the plaintiff's assessed rent and the damages decreed against defendant 1 as described above.
1. These two appeals are directed against the concurrent decisions of the Courts below arrived at in two suits for assessment of fair and equitable rent and for recovery of damages for use and occupation of lands for the period from 1381 to 1333 B.S, as also for other reliefs. The defence of the contesting defendant, defendant 1 in the suit, was that there was no relationship of landlord and tenant, between him and the plaintiff in the suit: that the lands in respect of which assessment of fair rent was asked for, were held by him as kaimi mukarari jama under the pro forma defendant 2 in the suits. It was also pleaded in defence that the suits as laid were not maintainable inasmuch as all the cosharer landlords had not instituted the suits as plaintiffs. It would appear from the finally published Record of Rights that the plaintiff was landlord of the contesting defendant in the suits in respect of the lands mentioned in the plaint: the defendant being a tenure-holder. The entries in the record further show that the defendant was paying certain amounts to the pro forma defendant 2, as rent, but no rent was shown as payable to the plaintiff. The record however contained a note that the tenancies forming the subject matter of these suits were liable to be assessed with rent in respect of the shares of the cosharer landlords, of whom the plaintiff was one. The plaintiff's claim was therefore based upon the state of things appearing from the finally published Record of Rights, no rent having been settled as payable by the contesting defendant in the suits in respect of the plaintiff's share.
2. The Courts below have agreed in overruling the defence of defendant 1 in the suits, and in assessing fair and equitable rent as prayed by the plaintiff in the suits. The lower Courts have also passed decrees in favour of the plaintiff, for damages for use and occupation of the lands in suit for the years 1331, 1332 and 1333 B.S, the measure of damages being the fair and equitable rent assessed in the suits.
3. Of the various points raised in support of the appeals to this Court, the one relating to the maintainability of the suits may be considered first. The position that in a suit by a cosharer landlord as plaintiff for assessment of rent payable to such cosharer landlord it is not necessary that the other cosharers should join as plaintiffs where there is no dispute ‘about the extent of the share of the cosharer plaintiff, based on the principle (that a suit to have fair and equitable rent ‘assessed was consistent with and arises’ cut of the general law, and was not one which the landlord was required or authorized to do under the Bengal Tenancy Act within the meaning of S. 188 of the Act as hasbeen accepted in this Court: see Chiranjib Sen v. Mohendra Nath Biswas . A.I.R 1929 Cal. 90, Dhananjoy Manjhi v. Upendra Nath . [1918] 46 I.C 428.. As has been noticed by Rankin, C.J in the case of Raj Chandra Bhowmick v. Habibulla . A.I.R 1930 Cal. 693 the observations of Adami, J., of the Patna High Court in Partap Mahton v. Mt. Wazirunnessa . A.I.R 1925 Pat. 559 that it may be unnecessary to join the other cosharers as plaintiffs as S. 188 did not apply, but surely they should have been made parties defendants, so that the assessment when made might bind all equally, were sound in principle. In view of the fact that all the cosharers were joined as defendants in the suits out of which these appeals have arisen, the question of the maintainability of the suits by the plaintiff for assessment of fair and equitable rent must be decided against the appellant.
4. It has in the next place been argued that the plaint in the two suits give sufficient indication that the suits were under the Bengal Tenancy Act, to which the provisions of S. 188 of the Act were applicable. There is no doubt that in the cause title, the suit has been loosely described as one under the rent law, but that did not necessarily bring into operation the provisions of the Bengal Tenancy Act, when it is apparent from the plaint that the main reliefs claimed by the plaintiff was under the general law. It is impossible therefore to give effect to the argument in support of the appellant's contention in these appeals, that the suits were under the provisions of the Bengal Tenancy Act; nor is it possible to accept the contention that the suits were virtually for enhancement of rent.
5. The learned advocate for the appellant has not contended that the plaintiff not having realized rent from defendant 1 for a period of 40 years or more, the claim for assessment as made in the suits was barred by limitation. It is somewhat difficult to appreciate the force of this contention in view of the entries in the finally published Record of Rights, which go to indicate that defendant 1 is a tenant under the plaintiff in regard to a share, and that rent was not being paid to the plaintiff in respect of her share, and further that so, far as the plaintiff was concerned, rent was liable to be assessed, but had not been assessed. The fact that rent has not in point of fact been paid for a length of time, well over 12 years before suit, could not possibly be a ground for dismissal of a suit for assessment of rent. The right to have fair rent assessed continues so long as relationship of landlord continues. The contesting defendant having failed to substantiate his defence that there was no relationship of landlord and tenant as between him and the plaintiff, the liability of the defendant for rent assessed, on the prayer of the plaintiff, remained. A cosharer landlord in the position of the plaintiff in the suit was entitled to realize rent from the tenant defendant as her title to the lands could not even be challenged, and may be taken to have been established: see Dhananjoy Majhi's case and Chiranjib Sen's case referred to above, in another connexion. The question of limitation as raised by defendant 1 in the suits has no substance in it, and must be overruled. It may be mentioned that the case of Maharaja Birendra Kisore v. Anandapriya Baishanabi . [1912] 30 I.C 946. cited by the learned advocate for the appellant in support of his con-tention, can have no possible application to the facts of the cases before me, regard being had to the presumption arising from the finally published Record of Rights, which has not been rebutted in any way. In that case, the defendant was treated as a trespasser, and the plaintiff did not elect to treat him as a tenant on receipt of rent from him. The plaintiff was himself found to be not in possession within 12 years: in those circumstances the claim for assessment was held to be barred by limitation.
6. It had been contended also in these appeals, that in assessing fair and equitable rent the Courts below should not have invoked the provisions contained in Section 7 of the Ben. Ten. Act. The judgment of the Courts below indicate clearly that although reference was made to S. 7, the basis of assessment as made by the trial Court, and accepted by the Court of appeal below was the one to which reference was made in the plaints. The gross collection from tenants under defendant 1 has been taken into account, and fair and equitable rent payable by defendant 1 to the plaintiff has been determined, after making allowances that should be made on account of collection charges and profits. No other basis has been suggested and none could be suggested in the matter of working out the rent which was fair and equitable, so far as defendant 1, the tenant was concerned. It may be pointed out in this connexion that there is nothing inherently wrong in referring to the principles embodied in Section 7 of the Ben. Ten. Act, in trying to arrive at the correct conclusion, so far as the assessment of fair and equitable rent was concerned, in cases which do not come within the purview of the Act. The decision of the Courts below on this part of the case appears to me entirely correct and unassailable.
7. Coming next to the decrees as passed against defendant 1 for damages for use and occupation for the period 1331 to 1333 B.S, as claimed in the suits, there is absolutely no substance in the point that the decrees for damages should have been made against the cosharer landlord defendant 2 in the suit. As has been pointed out by the Court of appeal below, no case has been made out for decrees against the defendant, and he could not be held liable for such damages. It is contended next, in this part of the case, although no such contention in the form it has been raised before me, was advanced., or even suggested in either of the Courts below, that the decrees for damages for use and occupation passed against the appellant were not sustainable, for the period 1331 to 1333 B.S, which has been mentioned by the Subordinate Judge in the Court of appeal below as the years in suit. Reliance has been placed by the learned advocate for the appellant on the decision of the Patna High Court in the case of Partab Mahton v. Mt. Wazirunnessa in which it was held that in a suit for assessment of a fair and equitable rent, the plaintiff was not entitled to claim rent in arrears at the rate to be assessed as fair and equitable, in the suit. The accepted view however so far as this Court is concerned, seems to be that there was nothing to prevent the landlord from claiming back rents, in a suit for assessment of fair and equitable rent, if the area in suit was in use and occupation of the tenant, provided the period for which the claim was made was within that prescribed by the law of limitation that the plaintiff in such a suit could recover arrears, or back rent: see Jagannath Majhi v. Jumman Ali Patwari . [1901] 29 Cal. 247., Bhupendra Kumar Chakrabutty v. Surjahanta Rai Choudhury . A.I.R 1924 Cal. 128 and Manmatha, Nath Pal v. Surendra Nath Bose . A.I.R 1925 Cal. 463.
8. On the principle on which the above cases have been decided in this Court there cannot be any bar to a decree for rent or damages for use and occupation in a suit for assessment of rent, if the fact of possession of the lands in respect of which assessment is prayed, has been admitted or proved, and if the claim was not barred by limitation. In the cases before me, the position has not been disputed that the tenant has been possessing during the period from 1331 to 1333 B.S, for which claim for damages for use and occupation was made by the plaintiff in the suit, and has not paid any rent payable to the plaintiff in respect of her share. There is no doubt that the claim was within time, so far as the period of limitation was concerned. The only question that seems to have been raised in the trial Court, on this part of the case was that relating to the sum recoverable for use and occupation for the three years from 1331 to 1333 B.S, and I am in entire agreement with the Court of first instance in holding that the fair and equitable rents deter, mined by the Court should be the best measure of damages per year, which the plaintiff could recover from defendant 1, for use and occupation of the lands in suit in both the cases.
9. As indicated above, the contentions urged in support of the appeals cannot be accepted.
10. In the result the decision of the Courts below and decrees passed by them are affirmed, and the appeals are dismissed with costs. One hearing fee only will be allowed for the two appeals. Leave to prefer appeals under the Letters Patent is refused.
R.M/R.K
11. Appeal dismissed.
Alert