- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Satyapriya Banerjee Judgment-Debtor, v. Kundan Mull Babu Decree-Holder,
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal challenges an order made by the Subordinate Judge of Rajshahi on 25 September 1937 directing the Accountant-General of Bengal to remit Rs. 50 monthly out of the Appellant Satyapriya Banerjee's salary of Rs. 150 (as a member of the Bengal Legislative Assembly) in satisfaction of a decree. The decree was originally passed on 24 May 1933 in favour of the Respondent for Rs. 6,398 on a hand-note; on 17 September 1937 the decree-holder stated Rs. 4,441-4-3 remained due and sought attachment of half the Appellant's legislative salary. The Subordinate Judge ordered attachment under Order 21, rule 48 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The Appellant appealed, contending that as a member of the Legislative Assembly he is not a "public officer" within section 2(17) of the Code and therefore his salary is not attachable under Or. 21, r. 48.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a member of the Provincial Legislative Assembly (here, a member of the Bengal Legislative Assembly) is a "public officer" within the meaning of section 2, sub-section (17)(h) of the Code of Civil Procedure (i.e., "Every officer in the service or pay of the Government, or remunerated by fees or commission for the performance of any public duty").
- If not a public officer, whether attachment of the Appellant's salary could instead be supported under Order 21, rule 46 of the Code of Civil Procedure (attachment of a "debt").
- Practical jurisdictional and enforcement questions raised by the fact that the Accountant-General of Bengal (the paymaster) is located outside the Subordinate Judge's jurisdiction, and whether other remedies (including appointment of a receiver of salary) are appropriate.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The Appellant contended that he is not a "public officer" within section 2(17)(h) of the Code of Civil Procedure and therefore his salary as a Member of the Legislative Assembly cannot be attached under Or. 21, r. 48.
Respondent's Arguments
- The Respondent contended that the Appellant falls within section 2(17)(h) because he is remunerated (receives a salary for his membership), and thus is a "public officer" whose salary may be attached under Or. 21, r. 48.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Hollinshead v. Hazleton (House of Lords) | Consideration whether a Member of Parliament is the holder of an "office" (discussion in the House of Lords suggesting conflicting views: some passages treating membership as virtiute officii and others doubting that membership is an office of State). | The Court relied on Lord Atkinson's view in Hollinshead (that membership is not an office of State) rather than Lord Parker's incidental description, using this to support the conclusion that membership of legislative bodies is not an "office" within the meaning of the Code's definition of "public officer." |
| Devi Prosad v. Lewis | Held that the unearned salary of a private servant (salary for the month not yet earned) is not liable to attachment in advance; attachment under Or. 21, r. 46 requires an existing "debt". | The Court applied this ratio to conclude that the Appellant's monthly salary, payable at the end of the month, was not an attachable "debt" at the time the order was made and therefore could not be attached in advance under Or. 21, r. 46. |
| Dunlop & Co. v. Jagannath (Marwari) (referred to via Begg) | Principles concerning attachment where the payor or debt is outside the executing Court's jurisdiction; practical limits on orders binding officers located beyond the Court's jurisdiction. | Used to demonstrate that an order under Or. 21, r. 46 by the Subordinate Judge at Rajshahi could not bind the Accountant-General of Bengal (located in Calcutta) and to explain why Or. 21, r. 48 was designed to address such jurisdictional obstacles (but only applies to public officers, railway servants and local authority servants). |
| Syud Tuffuzzool Hossein Khan v. Rughoonath Pershad and Ladlee Pershaud (Judicial Committee) | Distinguished between an "existing debt" (attachable) and salary/wages which are only an accruing entitlement and not attachable before they become due; noted that if creditor wants security on salary as it accrues it must be by contract/arrangement, not court attachment. | The Court relied on these observations to reinforce that Or. 21, r. 46 contemplates attachment of an existing debt and does not permit attachment of an unearned salary of a person who is not a public officer; this reasoning further supported the view that the Appellant's salary could not be attached under Or. 21, r. 46. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court undertook a statutory and comparative analysis to determine whether a legislative member is a "public officer" for purposes of attachment under Order 21, rule 48.
- Definition focus: The Court began with section 2(17) of the Code of Civil Procedure, particularly sub-paragraph (h) ("Every officer in the service or pay of the Government, or remunerated by fees or commission for the performance of any public duty"), since the Respondent relied on that definition to treat the Appellant as a public officer.
- Consideration of authorities: The Court reviewed Hollinshead v. Hazleton and noted conflicting passages from Law Lords — one passage (Lord Parker) describing MP payments as virtute officii, another (Lord Atkinson) doubting that membership is an office of State. The Chief Justice preferred Lord Atkinson's reasoning, treating membership of the House (and by analogy the Provincial Legislature) as not constituting an "office."
- Statutory context (Government of India Act, 1935): The Court examined sections 69(1)(a) and 72 of the Government of India Act, 1935. Section 69 disqualifies a person who "holds any office of profit under the Crown" from membership unless otherwise declared; section 72 entitles members to salaries and allowances fixed by provincial statute. The Court reasoned that if membership itself were an "office" in the service or pay of the Crown, the disqualification provision in section 69(1)(a) would operate to disqualify salaried members, which would be an untenable result. Reading sections 69 and 72 together supported the conclusion that membership is not an office of profit under the Crown.
- Application to Code provisions: Given that Order 21, rule 48 applies specifically to public officers, railway servants and servants of local authorities to permit attachment of salaries payable outside the Court's jurisdiction, the Court held that rule 48 could not apply to the Appellant because he was not a "public officer" within the Code's definition.
- Alternate reliance on Or. 21, r. 46 considered and rejected: The Court considered whether attachment might be supported under Or. 21, r. 46 (attachment of a "debt"). It concluded this was not permissible because the Appellant's salary was ordinarily payable at the end of the month, and before that time it represented an expectancy, not an existing debt. The Court relied on Devi Prosad v. Lewis and related authority to confirm that unearned salary of a private servant is not attachable in advance and that attachment under r. 46 requires an existing debt. Jurisdictional considerations (the Accountant-General's location outside the Subordinate Judge's jurisdiction) meant an order by that Judge under r. 46 could not bind the paymaster; this is a reason r. 48 exists for public officers, but r. 48 did not help the Respondent here because the Appellant is not a public officer.
- Receiver suggestion: The Court noted a suggestion that a Receiver of the Appellant's salary might be appointed, but declined to accede to that suggestion in the circumstances, expressing grave objections to appointing a Receiver of a member of a Legislative Assembly's salary while acknowledging it might be done in a proper case if no other remedies were available.
- Conclusion of analysis: On the combined statutory interpretation, precedent and jurisdictional reasoning, the Court concluded that the Subordinate Judge's order for attachment under Or. 21, r. 48 could not stand and that Or. 21, r. 46 likewise did not permit the attachment in the present facts.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The appeal was allowed and the order of the Subordinate Judge (directing attachment of part of the Appellant's salary under Or. 21, r. 48) was set aside.
Consequences for the parties:
- The Appellant (Satyapriya Banerjee) is not treated as a "public officer" within section 2(17)(h) of the Code of Civil Procedure for the purposes of attachment under Order 21, rule 48, and therefore his legislative salary cannot be attached under that provision in these circumstances.
- The Court held that the salary could not be attached under Order 21, rule 46 either, because at the time of the order the salary was not an existing "debt" but an expectancy payable at the end of the month.
- The Court refused the immediate proposal to appoint a Receiver of the Appellant's salary, observing serious objections to such an appointment for a member of a Legislative Assembly (though not finally foreclosing the possibility in an appropriate case).
- The decree-holder (Respondent) retains other remedies (the Court observed other remedies are open to him) but the Court did not specify or decide upon them in this opinion.
- Costs: The appeal was allowed with costs; the hearing-fee was assessed at four gold mohurs.
Note: The opinion sets out statutory interpretation and applies existing case law to the facts. The Court did not purport to lay down a new general rule beyond the conclusions applied to this case's facts.
The Judgment of the Court was as follows:—
Derbyshire, C.J:— This is an appeal from the decision of the Subordinate Judge of Rajshahi made on September 25th, 1937, whereby he held that the Appellant Satyapriya Banerjee, the judgment-debtor, who is a member of the Legislative Assembly, Bengal, is a public officer and as such liable to have his pay attached under Or. 21, r. 48 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The learned Judge made an order that the Accountant-General of Bengal, should, out of the monthly salary of Rs. 150 payable to the Appellant, remit a sum of Rs. 50 each month to the Court until the amount under the decree is satisfied.
The Appellant is a member of the Bengal Legislative Assembly. A decree was passed against him at the instance of the Respondent on May 24th, 1933, for the sum of Rs. 6,398 on a hand-note. On September 17th, 1937, the decree-holder stated that a sum of Rs. 4,441-4-3 was still payable under the decree and asked for the attachment of half of the Appellant's salary as a member of the Legislative Assembly. The learned Judge made the order stated above.
The Appellant has appealed against that order contending that he is not a public officer and is not liable to have his salary as an M.L.A attached under Or. 21, r. 48 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
Sec. 2, sub-sec. (17) of the Code of Civil Procedure defines the words “public officer.” It has been contended by the Respondent that the Appellant comes within sub-paragraph (h), namely:—
“Every officer in the service or pay of the Government, or remunerated by fees or commission for the performance of any public duty.”
The Bengal Legislative Chambers (Members Emoluments) Act, 1937 provides in paragraph 3 as follows:—
“There shall be paid to each member a salary at the rate of one hundred and fifty rupees per mensem with effect from the date on which he takes his oath.”
Sec. 4 of the same Act provides for certain allowances to be paid to members.
It is true that the Appellant receives remuneration in respect of his membership in the Legislative Assembly. The question is whether he is an officer within the meaning of sec. 2, sub-sec. (17)(h) of the Code of Civil Procedure.
In the case of Hollinshead v. Hazleton the question arose whether in bankruptcy proceedings in Ireland a member of Parliament could be ordered to pay a sum of £200 a year out of his salary of £400 a year as an M.P to the Official Assignee in Bankruptcy. It was held by the House of Lords that a member of Parliament could be ordered to make such a payment. During the discussion there was some consideration, not very extensive it is true, of the position of a member of Parliament. At page 460, Lord Parker of Waddmgton said:—
“The payment is made to and received by every member virttite officii…”
That sentence clearly suggests that a member of Parliament is the holder of an office. However, on page 439, Lord Atkinson used these words:
“Palles C.B in his judgment laid it down that this sum of £400 per annum is expressly given to each member of Parliament virttite officii and is payable out of State funds to enable them to support the office with the degree of dignity due to it and for that reason is inalienable.
It is certainly given to the members because they are members, but, with infinite respect for that most distinguished judge, I doubt very much whether membership of the House of Commons is, within the meaning of the principle of law and public policy to which he refers, an office of State at all.”
We have here two passages from the speeches from distinguished Law Lords which appear to be in opposition. Having regard to the fact that Lord Atkinson was specifically considering the question whether membership of the House of Commons was an office and Lord Parker was but referring to the matter incidentally, I have come to the conclusion that I ought to be guided in this respect by the words of Lord Atkinson and to take the view that membership of the House of Commons and similar institutions is not an office.
I find support for taking that view in this case in the provisions of the Government of India Act 1935 under which the Bengal Provincial Legislature is set up.
Sec. 69, sub-sec. (1) provides:—
“A person shall be disqualified for being chosen as and for being a member of Provincial Legislative Assembly or Legislative Council—
(a) if he holds any office of profit under the Crown in India, other than an office declared by Act of the Provincial Legislature not to disqualify its holder;”
Sec. 72 provides:—
“Members of Provincial Legislative Assemblies and Legislative Councils shall be entitled to receive such salaries and allowances as may from time to time be determined by Act of the Provincial Legislature….”
If membership of the Legislative Assembly were an office under the Crown it appears to me that each member of it receiving a salary contemplated by sec. 72 would be disqualified from sitting in it by the provisions of sec. 69(1)(a). Such cannot be the position. I am therefore of opinion that a member of the Legislative Assembly is not an officer in the service or pay of the Crown or remunerated by fees or commission for the performance of any public duty. Consequently he is not a public officer within the meaning of the Code of Civil Procedure.
Therefore the order which has been made by the learned Judge for the attachment of a part of the Appellant's salary under Or. 21, r. 48 of the Code which provides for the case of the attachment of the salary of a public officer cannot stand.
It must be borne in mind that as the suit herein was instituted before June 1st, 1937, the law applicable in this case is that which existed before sec. 60 of the Code of Civil Procedure was altered by Act IX of 1937.
It has been suggested that the order appealed from might be supported under Or. 21, r. 46 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
I do not think so.
Or. 21, r. 46 provides for the attachment of a “debt.” In this case the Appellant's salary is ordinarily payable at the end of each month and until the end of each month there is no “debt” in respect of it, only an expectancy of payment. At the time this order was made (September 25th, 1937) there was no “debt.” This was the ratio decidendi of Devi Prosad v. Lewis where a decree-holder applied on November 18th, 1907, for the attachment of the salary for November of the judgment-debtor who was a lawyer's clerk. The Court held that the unearned salary of a private servant in whole or in part was not liable to attachment in advance.
Again the Accountant-General of Bengal is located in Calcutta outside the jurisdiction of the Subordinate Judge at Rajshahi and as pointed out by Mr. Justice Nasim Ali during the argument, an order under Or. 21, r. 46 made by that Judge could not bind the Accountant-General.
See Begg, Dunlop & Co. v. Jogannath Marwari .
Or. 21, r. 48 was designed to overcome the obstacles just mentioned to attaching future salary playable tout-side the Court's jurisdiction. But it only applies to the salaries of public officers, railway servants and the servants of local authorities.
The amendments to sec. 60 of the Code of Civil Procedure introduced by the Act of 1937 may alter the position somewhat in a case of this kind but as pointed out above they do not apply here, because the decree herein was made before June 1st, 1937.
It has been suggested that this Court might appoint a Receiver of the salary of the Appellant. I do not feel disposed to accede to that suggestion. Members of Legislative Assemblies must satisfy their debts like other people but I can see grave objections to the appointment of a Receiver of the salary of a member of the Legislative Assembly, although I do not say that it could not be done in a proper case if no other remedies were available.
In this case the decree-holder has other remedies open to him if he is prepared to make use of them.
In my opinion this appeal should be allowed and the order appealed from set aside.
The appeal is allowed with costs—hearing-fee being assessed at four gold mohurs.
Nasim Ali, J.:— I agree with my Lord, the Chief Justice, that this appeal should be allowed. The order of the Subordinate Judge for attachment of the Appellant's salary cannot be supported under Or. 21, r. 48 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The mere fact that an elected member of a Provincial Legislative Assembly is entitled to receive such salary and allowance as may from time to time be determined by the Act of Provincial Legislature under sec. 72 of the Government of India Act of 1935, does not make him an Officer in the service or in the pay of the Crown. Membership of the Provincial Legislative Assembly cannot be held to be an office of profit under the Crown in India although they are entitled to salaries and allowances. If the two sections, namely, secs. 69 and 72 of the Government of India Act are read together, there cannot be any doubt that the Membership of Provincial Legislative Assembly or Legislative Council is not an office of profit under the Crown. I am inclined to think that these salaries and allowances are given to a member not to enable him to make a profit but to enable him to maintain his position and dignity as a member of the Provincial Legislative Assembly or Provincial Council.
An elected member of the Provincial Legislative Assembly or Provincial Council cannot be said to have been appointed for a remuneration to discharge a public duty. My conclusion, therefore, is that the Appellant is not a public officer and, consequently, his salary cannot be attached under Or. 21, r. 48 of the Code.
The order of the Subordinate Judge cannot also be supported under Or. 21, r. 46 of the Code. That Rule contemplates the attachment of a debt not secured by a negotiable instrument. There are two objections to the attachment of the Appellant's salary under this Rule. In the first place, that Rule contemplates the attachment of a debt.
“An existing debt, though payable on a future day, may be attached whilst a salary, wages, or money claimed accruing due, may not…” [Syud Tuffuzzool Hossein Khan v. Rughoonath Pershad and Ladlee Pershaud ].
Before the salary becomes payable it Cannot be attached as a debt. In the case cited above their Lordships of the Judicial Committee also observed:
“if the creditor desires to have the security on the receipt of salary as it accrues, that can be effected only by contract with the debtor and arrangement with him and not by attachment by an act of the Court.”
An exception, however, has now been made in the Civil Procedure Code so far as the salaries of Public Officers are concerned. The amendments of the Civil Procedure Code, however, do not in any way affect the observations of the Judicial Committee in the above case so far as the question of the attachment of the salary of a person other than a Public Officer is concerned. Further, a debt payable to the judgment-debtor outside the jurisdiction of the Court by a person not resident within the jurisdiction of the executing Court cannot be attached. Begg, Dunlop & Co. v. Jagannath Marwari . Here the money is payable to the Appellant within the Original Jurisdiction of this Court. The officer who makes payment, namely, the Accountant-General of Bengal, also resides within the jurisdiction of this Court. As a debt, therefore, his salary also cannot he attached under Or. 21, r. 46 of the Code.
I however express no opinion on the question as to whether the Respondent has got any other remedy open to him in order to enable him to have his decree satisfied from the salary of the Appellant.
C.C
Alert