Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Aduram Haldar Judgment-Debtor v. Nakuleswar Rai Chowdhury And Others Decree-Holders

Calcutta High Court
Aug 21, 1918
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

These three appeals arose from an order of the District Judge of Khulna who reversed the decision of the Munsif of Bagerhat. The Munsif had refused the decree-holder auction-purchaser's application for delivery of possession of certain properties sold in execution of decrees, on the ground that the objectors were not the judgment-debtors despite bearing the same names, and that the properties belonged to the objectors and were not included in the certificate of sale. The District Judge treated the Munsif's order as one under Section 47 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC), assumed appellate jurisdiction, and directed delivery of possession to the decree-holder. The appeals challenge the District Judge's order on the question of jurisdiction and the entitlement to possession.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an appeal lies to the District Judge against an order of the Munsif refusing or allowing delivery of possession after an execution sale under Order 21, Rule 97 of the CPC.
  2. Whether the order of the District Judge assuming jurisdiction under Section 47 of the CPC was valid.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • An order allowing or refusing delivery of possession after an execution sale is not an order under Section 47 of the CPC, even if the decree-holder is the auction purchaser.
  • Consequently, no appeal lies to the District Judge against such an order of the Munsif.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sasibhusan Mookerjee v. Radhanath Bose Held that an order allowing or refusing delivery of possession after an execution sale is not an order under Section 47 of the CPC. Followed to conclude that no appeal lay to the District Judge from the Munsif's order in these cases.
Abdul Gani v. Raja Ram (Full Bench, Patna High Court) Supported the view that such orders are not appealable under Section 47 of the CPC. Relied upon to affirm that the District Judge lacked jurisdiction to entertain the appeal.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the nature of the Munsif's order refusing delivery of possession after an execution sale under Order 21, Rule 97 of the CPC. It noted that such an order is not an order under Section 47 of the CPC, which governs appeals from orders passed by subordinate courts. The District Judge had assumed appellate jurisdiction by treating the order as one under Section 47, but this was incorrect. The court reviewed prior case law, including the Sasibhusan Mookerjee case and the Abdul Gani case, which held that no appeal lies to the District Judge in such matters. The court concluded that the District Judge's order was without jurisdiction and restored the Munsif's order refusing possession. It further clarified that appeals against such orders lie to this Court (the High Court) and not to the District Judge.

Holding and Implications

APPEALS ALLOWED

The court set aside the District Judge's order and restored the Munsif's original order refusing delivery of possession in all three cases, with costs awarded to the appellants. The court assessed a hearing fee of one gold mohur in each case. The decision clarifies that orders under Order 21, Rule 97 of the CPC regarding delivery of possession after execution sale are not appealable to the District Judge under Section 47 CPC, thereby limiting intermediate appellate jurisdiction in such matters. No new precedent beyond reaffirming existing case law was established.

Show all summary ...

1. These three appeals are preferred against the order of the District Judge of Khulna reversing the decision of the Munsif of Bagerhat and directing delivery of possession of certain properties to the decree-holder auction-purchaser in three separate proceedings. The first question for consideration is whether an appeal lay to the District Judge against the order of the Munsif. It appears that in execution of certain decrees the decree-holder purchased certain properties and on the confirmation of the sale applied for delivery of possession. The appellants objected that they were not the judgment-debtors though bearing the same names, that those properties belonged to them and were not included in the certificate of sale. The learned Munsif refused the application of the decree-holder auction-purchaser on the ground that he was not satisfied that the objectors were the judgment-debtors. This order was in effect an order in a proceeding under O. 21, R. 97 of the CPC, from which no appeal lay to the District Judge. The learned Judge however treated the order as one under Section 47 of the CPC, and upon this view of the case assumed jurisdiction as a Court of appeal and going into the merits came to the conclusion that the decree-holder was entitled to an order for delivery of possession.

2. It is argued by the learned vakil for the appellant that an order allowing or refusing delivery of possesion after an execution sale is not an order under Section 47 of the CPC even where the decree holder is the auction purchaser, and that as such no appeal lay to the District Judge. The question whether an appeal lies against an order of this nature has been considered in several cases in this Court and the decisions are not uniform.

3. Our attention has been drawn to the case of Sasibhusan Mookerjee v. Radhanath Bose (1). In this case all the earlier decisions have been reviewed, and it has been held that such an order is not an order under Section 47 of the CPC. The same view appears to have been taken in a case decided by a Full Bench of the Patna High Court, Abdul Gani v. Raja Ram (2). Following these decisions we hold that no appeal lay to the District Judge and that the orders passed in appeal were without jurisdiction. Against the orders so passed it is now well settled that an appeal lies to this Court. We accordingly set aside the order of the District Judge and restore the order of the Munsif in all the three cases under appeal with costs of this Court and of the Court of appeal below. Hearing fee is assessed at one gold mohur in each case.

V.B/R.K

4. Appeals allowed.