- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Haradhan Chattoraj v. Kartik Chandra Chattopadhya
This appeal arises out of a suit for arrears of rent and the only questions raised before us on behalf of the Appellant who was Defendant No. 1 in the Court below are, first, whether the Court of Appeal below was right in holding that the portion of the rent that was payable in cash was rupees six and annas four; and, second, whether the lower Appellate Court was right in holding that the Defendant No. 1, who was the purchaser of the tenure or holding at a sale for arrears of rent, was liable for the rent of a certain period anterior to the date of his purchase.
Upon the first question it is argued for the Appellant that the Court of Appeal below is wrong in law in holding that the Appellant is bound to pay the money-rent at the rate claimed in the plaint, because that was the rate mentioned in the sale proclamation and he must be taken to have purchased the tenure or holding on the understanding that rent was payable at that rate; and in support of this argument the case of Alim v. Satis Chandra Chaturdhurin is relied upon. Perhaps the principle laid down by the learned Judge below in his judgment, that when a landlord brings an occupancy holding to sale for arrears of rent, alleging that rent is payable for the holding annually at a certain rate, the auction-purchaser is bound to pay rent at that rate, even though it may be in excess of the rate at which rent was payable by the defaulting tenant, may not be correct in its broad generality, but it is unnecessary that the western boundary of the premises sold might be rectified, or that such compensation should be allowed him in respect of the cook-room as to the Court might seem proper or “otherwise” that is failing redress in either of these forms, then that the sale might be rescinded. He asked for compensation as an alternative to a rectification of boundaries which latter it was not in the power of the Court to grant. It is difficult to see how he can now say that the case was not a fitting one for compensation.
Messrs Carruthers & Co., Attorneys for the Appellant.
Messrs B.B Bonnerjee, Butter & Co., and A.N Chunder, Attorneys for the Respondents.
A.N.C
Appeal allowed.
Alert