Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mahanth Kesho Das v. Hari Kishun Das

Patna High Court
Dec 14, 1937
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of the Opinion (Agarwala, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiffs sued to recover Rs. 1,125 alleged to have been lent to Defendant 1 on 23 March 1930 and Rs. 200 as interest on the loan. Defendant 2 was impleaded as surety. The plaint alleged that on 23 March 1930 Defendant 1 executed a handnote acknowledging the sum and promising to pay “on demand with interest at one percent per mensem,” and that Defendant 2 by a letter dated the same day agreed to repay if Defendant 1 failed to do so. The plaintiffs prayed for a decree for Rs. 1,325 against both defendants on the basis of the handnote and the surety letter.

Defendant 1 did not deny that Rs. 1,125 was due from him, but contended that the money was due to Defendant 2 on a bahi khata account. The trial Court disbelieved that defence and decreed the plaintiffs' suit. On appeal by Defendant 1 the case was remanded so that the plaintiffs might amend their plaint because the handnote did not contain the name of the payee and therefore could not support recovery on the handnote; the plaintiffs were given an opportunity to amend and sue on the loan itself. The plaint was amended to aver that the loan entry had been made in the plaintiffs' rokar bahi (book kept in the regular course of business) and to state that the cause of action arose when the loan was taken. On remand the trial Court again decreed the plaintiffs' suit. On further appeal to the District Judge the decree was attacked on four grounds, but the District Judge upheld the decree. The present opinion is from the second appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, when a suit based on a handnote fails because the handnote is inadmissible or defective, the creditor may nonetheless recover on the original loan (i.e., maintain a suit on the loan independent of the handnote), particularly after amendment of the plaint.
  2. Whether the amendment of the plaint (to plead the loan in place of, or in addition to, the handnote) should have been permitted.
  3. Whether the claim on the loan as framed after amendment was barred by limitation (given the date of the loan, the date of institution of the suit, and the date of amendment).
  4. Whether the plaintiffs' evidence and story of the loan were improbable (a contention attacking factual credibility).
  5. Whether interest at the rate specified in the handnote should have been granted.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (Defendant 1) Arguments

  • The amendment of the plaint should not have been allowed.
  • The plaintiffs' claim to recover the original loan was barred by limitation as of the date the amendment was made.
  • The plaintiffs' story of the loan was improbable and therefore not credible.
  • Interest at the rate mentioned in the handnote should not have been granted.

Respondents' (Plaintiffs') Arguments / Case as Pleaded

  • The plaintiffs alleged that Defendant 1 borrowed Rs. 1,125 on 23 March 1930 and executed a handnote acknowledging the sum and promising to pay on demand with interest at 1% per mensem.
  • The plaintiffs alleged that Defendant 2 agreed by letter dated 23 March 1930 to repay the amount if Defendant 1 failed to do so (suretyship).
  • After remand the plaintiffs amended the plaint to aver that the loan was entered in the plaintiffs' rokar bahi kept in the regular course of business and to state specifically that the cause of action arose when the loan was taken.
  • At a later stage the plaintiffs did not press for interest at the rate mentioned in the handnote and accepted interest at the rate discussed in the cited authorities.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
14 PLT 651 : 12 Pat 8621 (Full Bench of this Court) Considered whether, when a suit on a handnote fails because the handnote is inadmissible, the creditor may recover on the original debt; Full Bench addressed the point in a case referred to it. The Court observed that the Acting Chief Justice in that Full Bench case referred to the trial Court's finding that the plaintiff had proved an oral contract to repay; accordingly the Full Bench held the specific question whether earlier decisions (e.g., 7 Pat 845) were correctly decided did not arise and those earlier decisions were not reversed.
1 PLT 203 Holding that where plaintiffs alleged adjustment of accounts of loans evidenced by a handnote found to be forged, the plaintiffs could maintain suit on the basis of their account books. The Court relied on this decision as authority that recovery on the underlying loan can be maintained even if the handnote is forged or invalid, provided supporting pleadings/evidence exist.
7 Pat 845 : 9 PLT 471 Held that an implied contract to repay money borrowed arises independently of an instrument or promissory note and is enforceable apart from the instrument even where lending and execution are contemporaneous. The Court cited this decision as part of a consistent line of authority establishing that an independent cause of action (the loan) can exist apart from the handnote.
13 PLT 524 Reiterated and followed the holding in 7 Pat 845 regarding an implied, independent obligation to repay a loan. Used as supporting authority reinforcing the established line of decisions allowing recovery on the underlying loan.
AIR 1933 Pat 1595 Held that where the payee's name was not entered in the handnote, the suit could be tried and decided as a suit for recovery of the loan independent of the handnote; the writing was admissible in evidence of the loan irrespective of whether it was a promissory note under the Negotiable Instruments Act. The Court relied on this decision to support the proposition that a suit can proceed on the loan independent of defects in the handnote and that the writing may be admissible as evidence of a loan.
13 PLT 5066 Where a suit on a handnote fails for a technical defect and the plaintiff seeks a decree on the loan instead, no decree can be passed unless a specific case has been made in the plaint as originally filed or the plaint has been amended; the onus shifts to the plaintiff. The Court noted this decision and observed that its effect was to send the matter back to the lower Court to afford the plaintiff an opportunity to amend — a result consistent with allowing amendment where necessary and appropriate.
39 CWN 1235 (Division Bench, Calcutta High Court) In a case where a claim on a promissory note failed (note under-stamped) and the plaint was amended to introduce a claim on the loan after the suit on the loan was barred, the amendment was considered in relation to limitation and the dating-back doctrine. The Court cited this decision for the proposition that where an amendment is allowed judicially, the amendment may date back to the presentation of the plaint for limitation purposes.
53 All 1147 (Full Bench, Allahabad High Court) Full Bench decision on related questions (brought to the Court's notice). The Court noted this decision among others from different jurisdictions but did not treat it as displacing the line of decisions of this Court.
59 Mad 268 (Full Bench, Madras High Court) Full Bench decision on similar subject matter (brought to notice). The Court mentioned this authority as part of the broader jurisprudence considered but relied on its own Court's precedents.
7 Cal 256 (Sir Richard Garth, C.J.) Earlier formulation discussed in the opinion; some readings emphasize the timing-word “then” in relation to causes of action arising from bills or notes. The Court referred to that reasoning and to differing interpretations but found no reason to depart from the established line of local decisions.
12 Rang 500 (Full Bench, Rangoon High Court) An attempt to summarise the law on this contested question (brought to notice). The Court referenced this as part of the comparative jurisprudence but applied its own Court's prior decisions.
3 Cal 314; 23 Cal 851; 17 CLJ 399; 1 East 551; (1914) AC 618 (Privy Council) Decisions noted by Rowland, J. as aligning with the view that recovery on the original consideration/loan is permissible independently of the instrument in certain circumstances. Rowland, J. relied on these authorities to express agreement with the correctness of the Court's earlier summarized decisions and to demonstrate consistency with other jurisdictions and the Privy Council.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by recounting the factual and procedural history: the original suit on the handnote, remand for amendment because the handnote lacked the payee's name, the amended plaint alleging the loan entry in the plaintiffs' rokar bahi and the cause of action as the date of loan, and the decrees in the Courts below.

The central legal question was whether, when a suit on a handnote is defective or the handnote is inadmissible, the creditor may nonetheless maintain an action to recover the original loan. The Court reviewed the line of decisions of this Court and of other jurisdictions. It identified a consistent direction in this Court's prior decisions (including 1 PLT 203, 7 Pat 845, 13 PLT 524 and AIR 1933 Pat 1595) holding that an independent cause of action to repay a loan may exist apart from the instrument and that a creditor can recover on the loan provided that the plaint contains, or is amended to contain, the facts necessary to sustain that claim.

The Court distinguished the Full Bench decision of this Court (reported as 14 PLT 651 : 12 Pat 8621 / 12 Pat 863 in the opinion) by noting that the Acting Chief Justice in that Full Bench relied on a trial Court finding that an oral contract to repay had been proved, and therefore the Full Bench did not decide (and did not overturn) the earlier line of decisions which established the plaintiff's entitlement to sue on the loan where appropriate facts are pleaded or the plaint is amended.

On the question of amendment and limitation, the Court acknowledged that permitting an amendment that may deprive the defendant of the benefit of a limitation plea is a matter to be approached with care. It reiterated the principle that where a Court judicially allows an amendment, the amendment ordinarily dates back to the presentation of the plaint; consequently, if the original plaint was filed within the period of limitation applicable to the relief sought by the amendment, the suit is to be treated as within time. Applying that principle to the present facts, the Court noted that the loan was advanced on 23 March 1930, the suit was instituted on 17 September 1931, and the amendment was made on 21 March 1934; the Court concluded that the allegations originally made in the plaint were sufficient to entitle the plaintiffs to succeed on a suit on the loan, and that the amendment (being allowed judicially) operated for limitation purposes to preserve the plaintiffs' claim.

On the subsidiary points, the Court observed that the respondents did not press for interest at the rate mentioned in the handnote in view of the authorities (notably 7 Pat 845), and therefore the respondents would recover interest at the rate of six percent from the date of the loan. The Court also assessed the challenge that the plaintiffs' story was improbable and found that the grounds advanced in the appeals below and before this Court did not persuade the Court to disturb the findings of the Courts below.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal was dismissed.

Direct implications for the parties:

  • The plaintiffs (respondents) succeed in recovering the loan as pleaded and amended.
  • The plaintiffs are awarded interest at the rate of six percent per annum from the date of the loan (23 March 1930).
  • The respondents are entitled to the costs of this appeal.

Broader implications noted by the Court:

  • The Court applied and followed the existing line of decisions of this Court that permit recovery on the original loan where the suit on the handnote fails, provided that a proper case is pleaded or the plaint is amended and the amendment is allowed judicially; the Full Bench decision referred to did not displace those earlier decisions in the circumstances described.
  • The opinion does not announce a new principle of law beyond applying the established authorities and the doctrine that an allowed amendment dates back to the filing of the plaint for limitation purposes.


End of summarized opinion (Agarwala, J.). The summary is based exclusively on the content of the provided opinion and does not add information beyond that text.

Show all summary ...

Agarwala, J.:— The respondents sued to recover Rs. 1125, alleged to have been lent to defendant 1 on 23rd March 1930, and Rs. 200 as interest on the loan. Defendant 2 was impleaded as surety for repayment of the advance. In the plaint the plaintiffs stated that on 23rd March 1930, defendant 1st party borrowed the sum of Rs. 1125 and in token of the acknowledgment of the sum executed a hand note dated 23rd March 1930, and promised to pay this sum “on demand with interest at one percent per mensem.” The plaint further alleged that on the same date the defendant 2nd party agreed by a letter dated 23rd March 1930, to repay the amount if defendant 1 failed to do so. The plaintiffs accordingly in their plaint prayed for a decree for Rs. 1325 against defendants' 1st party and 2nd party, “on the basis of the hand note end the letter” of suretyship. Defendant 1 did not deny that Rs. 1125 was due from him. His defence was that this money was due not to the plaintiffs but to defendant 2 on bahi khata account. The first Court disbelieved the defence and decreed the plaintiffs' suit. An appeal by defendant 1 resulted in the suit being remanded to enable the plaintiffs to amend their plaint. The reason for this was that the document described as a handnote did not contain the name of the payee and the Court therefore held that the plaintiffs were not entitled to succeed on the basis of the handnote, but that in the circumstances they were entitled to an opportunity to amend their plaint and to seek to recover from the defendants on the basis of the loan. The case accordingly went back to the trial Court and the plaint was amended. The amendment consisted of a statement in the plaint “that the fact of the loan being advanced to the defendant was entered in the rokar bahi of the plaintiffs' shop which was kept in the regular course of business” and in the paragraph in which the data of the cause of action is mentioned, is addition to the original statement “that the cause of action arose on the date of the execution of the handnote” there was an addition “that the cause of action arose when the loan was taken from the plaintiffs.” The Court on remand again decreed the plaintiffs' suit. In appeal by defendant 1 to the District Judge the decree was attacked on four grounds. First, that the amendment of the plaint should not have been allowed, secondly, that as the claim to recover the original loan was barred by limitation at the date of the amendment the suit should have been dis missed on that ground, thirdly, that the plaintiffs' story of the loan was improbable, and, lastly, that interest at the rate mentioned in the handnote should not have been granted. All these grounds failed to impress the learned District Judge who upheld the decision of the first Court.

2. The first ground on which the decision of the Courts below is attacked in second appeal is that the suit, after the amendment, was not maintainable. This is a ground which was not taken in the Courts below and was not taken in the grounds of appeal to this Court. It is contended however that the question is really decided by a decision of the Full Bench of this Court in 14 PLT 651 : 12 Pat 8621 which was a case referred to the Full Bench by Macpherson, J. and myself, the question being whether when a suit on a handnote fails by reason of the handnote being inadmissible in evidence, the creditor is entitled to recover on the original debt. So far as this Court is concerned, the first reported case in which that question was dealt with was 1 PLT 203.2 In that case Mullick and Sultan Ahmad, JJ. held that when the plaintiffs alleged that there was an adjustment of accounts of loans taken by the defendants who in acknowledgment thereof executed the handnote in suit, which was found by the lower Courts to be a forged one, the plaintiffs could maintain the suit on the basis of their account books even though the handnote in suit was forged.

3. The next case in this Court was 7 Pat 845 : 9 PLT 4713 which was decided by Kulwant Sahay and Macpherson, JJ. (one of the Judges by whom the first mentioned case was referred to the Full Bench). It was there held that there was an implied contract to repay money borrowed from another even though no express promise to repay is made either in writing or verbally and that this implied promise to repay arises apart from the instrument or promissory note evidencing the loan and is enforceable independently of the instrument or promissory note, even where the lending of the money and the execution of the note are contemporaneous. This view of the law was reiterated by Jwala Prasad and Kulwant Sahay, JJ. in 13 PLT 524 in which the decision in 7 Pat 845 was followed. The last decision of this Court before the Full Bench case was AIR 1933 Pat 1595 decided by Mohammad Noor, J. There the plaintiff sued on the allegations that the defendent bad borrowed Rs. 218 from him and had given him a handnote. There also the payee's name was not entered in the handnote Mohammad Noor, J. held that the suit as framed could be tried and decided as a suit for recovery of the loan independent of the handnote and that the writing was admissible in evidence of the loan irrespective of whether it was or was not a promissory note within the meaning of the Negotiable Instruments Act.

4. In 13 PLT 5066 Dhavle, J. sitting singly held that where a suit on a hand, note fails for soma technical defect and the plaintiff asks for a decree on the loan itself, no decree can be passed unless a specific case has been made in the plain as originally filed, or the plaint has been amended, the reason given being that in such a case the onus shifts to the plaintiff. In that case the learned Judge sent the case back to the lower Court to afford the plaintiff an opportunity to amend the plaint if be so desired to do. Except for the decision of the Full Bench there, fore, the views expressed by this Court have been consistent that the plaintiff is entitled to recover his claim on the original loan when the suit on the handnote fails either because the payee is not mentioned or because the handnote is not admissible in evidence provided that a proper case has been made out in the plaint or the plaint has been amended to state the facts necessary in support of the claim and the only question therefore is whether the Full Bench has upset this line of decisions so that we should have to follow the decision of the Full Bench in preference to the other decisions on the point of this Court. The Acting Chief Justice, in the Full Bench case, referred to the finding of the trial Court that the plaintiff bad proved that there was an oral contract to repay the advance and his Lordship therefore held that the question of whether the decisions in 7 Pat 845 and 13 PLT 52 were correctly deeded did not arise for consideration. Those decisions therefore were not reversed by the Full Bench. A number of decisions in other Courts relating to this much debated question have been brought to our notice including the Full Bench decision in 53 All 1147 and the Full Bench decision of the Madras High Court in 59 Mad 268,8 the decision of Sir Richard Garth, C.J in 7 Cal 256,9 and other cases of similar nature to which I do not propose to refer in detail. An attempt to sum marise the law was made by the Full Bench of the Rangoon High Court in 12 Rang 500.10 The decisions of our own Court on this points are binding on us and I do not therefore propose to analyse those decisions. Furthermore, the plaintiffs did not raise the question of maintainability of the suit in the Courts below after the amendment had been allowed and did not raise it in the grounds of appeal in this Court and the question of law propounded by the appellant, even if it be accepted, turns on a question of fact, viz whether in this particular case there was an independent contract to pay or not. That was a question which was not raised in the pleadings of the defendant.

5. The second question raised by the learned advocate for appellant was that the suit as now framed is barred by limitation. The loan was on 23rd March 1930. The suit was institated on 17th September 1931, the amendment was made on 21st March 1934. The circumstance that an amendment of the plaint may have the effect of depriving the defendant of the benefit of the plea of limitation is one of the circumstance, and a most important one, which has to be considered by a Court before permitting an amendment of the plaint. It is only in exceptional cases that the Court will allow the plaintiff to amend his plaint in such a way as to deprive the defendant of the plea of limitation, but when once the Court has exercised its discretion judicially, and the amendment has been allowed, the amendment dates back to the presentation of the plaint, and if that date is within the period of limitation prescribed for the particular relief which the plaintiff seeks by his amendment, the suit must be held to be within time. This was also the view expressed by the Division Bench of the Calcutta High Court in 39 CWN 123511 which was a case in which the claim on a promissory note failed as the note was under-stamped and the plaint was amended so as to introduce a claim on the loan, the amendment being made after the suit on the loan was barred. In any case in my view, the allegations in the plaint in this case were sufficient to entitle the plaintiffs to succeed on a suit on the loan distinct from the claim on the handnote. The plaintiffs distinctly sat out in their plaint that the defendant had borrowed money from them on 23rd March 1930, and it was to recover that money that the suit was instituted. It is true that they did not alternatively make a claim that they were entitled to recover the money as well on the original loan as on the basis of the handnote, but that I think is not fatal to the suit as all the facts necessary to support a claim on the loan were alleged and proved. In view of the observations regarding interest in 7 Pat 845, the plaintiffs-respondents did not press for interest at the rate mentioned in the handnote. They will recover interest at the rate of six per cant from the date of the loan. The respondents will be entitled to the costs of this appeal.

Rowland, J.:— I agree. If I may say so, I feel no doubt as to the correctness of the decisions of this Court which have just been summarised. I think the law is correctly stated in those decisions and in 3 Cal 314,12 23 Cal 851,13 17 CLJ 39914 and 39 CWN 1235. These decisions, it seems to me, are in agreement with 1 East 5515 and the Privy Council decision in (1914) AC 618.16 The other view seems to be based on over emphasis on the word “then” in the pronouncement of Sir Richard Garth in 7 Cal 256 when a cause of action for money ??? once complete in itself…. and the debtor then gives a bill or note to the creditor…. the creditor may sue for the original consideration.

6. The view has been expressed in some places that “then” does not include “at that time” which is the dictionary meaning of the word but means “thereafter” or “subsequently” and the Full Bench decision of the Allahabad High Court in 53 All 114, goes so far as to introduce an analogy with the requirement of antecedency in debts to make them binding on the junior members of a Hindu family. I can find nothing in the reasoning of that and the other decisions referred to, to displace the line of authority leading up and contained in the decisions of this Court. In the Full Bench decision, 12 Pat 863, we have referred to the original record and so far as we could ascertain, the loan and the handnote appear to have been of the same date; and as I under, stand the matter, to say that there is a cause of action independently of the bill or note need not imply that there is an antecedent and a subsequent transaction; at is enough that there was a good cause of action if the handnote had not been executed. Had it not been so, the case before the Full Bench should have been decided differently.

B.D/R.K

7. Appeal dismissed.