Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Arunachala Aiyar v. T. Ramasami Aiyar

Madras High Court
Sep 9, 1914
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.

JUDGMENT

Sadasiva Ayyar and Napier, JJ.:— The learned District Judge has reversed the decision of the District Munsif who granted a decree for money against the first defendant personally. The District Judge held that the suit of the plaintiff (the vendee) so far as it prayed for recovery of compensation from the first defendant (the vendor) for the breach of the covenants for title and possession was barred by limitation, the period being three years under article 62 or 97 of the Limitation Act. The learned District Judge relied on Kovvuri Basivi Reddi v. Tallapragada Nagamma(1) in support of his decision.

It is contended before us that, as the sale-deed in this case was executed in 1904 long after the Transfer of Property Act came into force, the proper article to be applied in respect of a suit claiming compensation for breach of an express or implied covenant of title and quiet enjoyment is article 116 which allows a period of six years. We think that this contention must be upheld. It has been decided in a series of cases beginning in 1889 [see the two cases reported in Kasturi Naicken v. Venkatasubba Mudaly and Narayana Reddi v. Peda Rama Reddi(2)] that in all registered conveyances executed after the Transfer of Property Act came into force, a covenant; for title is implied by section 55, clause (2) of that Act, that the registered conveyance should be read as if it expressly embodied that covenant and that the breach of that convenant is the breach of a contract in writing registered within the meaning of article 116.

We need refer only to a few of the later cases, namely, those in Chidambaram Pillai v. Sivathasamy Thever(3). The Zamindar of Vizianagaram v. Behara Swyanarayana Patrulu(4), Nageswara Row v. Sambasiva Row(5), Krishnan Nambiar v. Kannan(6) and Unichaman v. Ahmed Kutti Kazi(7). It must, however, be admitted that the case in Kovvuri Basivi Reddi v. Tallapragada Nagamma(8) seems to throw some doubt on the decision in Krishnan Nambiar v. Kannan which follows the current of the earlier decisions. The reasoning in Kovvuri Basivi Reddi v. Tallapragada Nagamma is not quite clear and one of the two learned Judges who took part in it was also a party to the later decision which expressly followed the current of the earlier decisions [see the subsequent case Nageswara Row v. Sambasiva Row distinguishing Kovvuri Basivi Reddi v. Tallapragada Nagamma, as “not in point.”] In Kovvuri Basivi Reddi v. Tallapragada Nagamma, the correctness of the decision in Krishnan Nambiar v. Kannan was doubted on the strength of the Privy Council ruling in Hanuman Kamat v. Hanuman Mandur(9), wherein their Lordships held that in the case of a conveyance, executed in 1879 (before the Transfer of Proprerty Act came into force) a suit for compensation for failure of consideration (that is for the recovery of the purchase-money paid to the vendor) through the failure of the vendee to obtain possession of the land sold fell under article 97 (three years' rule) and that the date of the cause of action was the date of the obstructions by the vendor's co-parceners. Their Lordships had no occasion to consider the effect of section 55 clause (2) of the Tranefer of Property Act on a registered conveyance executed after the date of that Act. That case is therefore not an authority for the proposition that to a suit brought on the covenant added by the statute law to all registered conveyances executed after the Transfer of Property Act came into force, Article 116 did not apply but only article 62 or 97. In Unichaman v. Ahmed Kutti Kazi, a similar argument was addressed to a Bench of this Court, namely, that article 97 applied to such a suit because the Bombay High Court held that view is Sawaba Khandapa v. Abaji Jotirav. But as a Division Bench of this Court point out in Unichaman v. Ahmed Kutti Kazi, the Transfer of Property Act was not in force in Bombay when that decision in Sawaba Khandapa v. Abaji Jotirov was given. This distinction seems not to have been in the minds of the learned Judges who decided Kovvuri Basivi Reddi v. Tallapragada Nagamma. We might add that Benson, J., who took part in Kovvuri Basivi Reddi v. Tollapragada Nagamma was also a party to the prior case in Unichaman v. Ahmed Kutti Kazi. Next it was contended that Bakewell, J., doubted the correctness of Krishnan Nambiar v. Kannan in his judgment in Ramanatha Iyer v. Ozhahoor Pathinseri Raman Nambudripad. In the first place, the observation is obiter. In the second place (with the greatest respect) we find difficulty to following the observation of the learned Judge that the Transfer of Property Act “may be construed as having annexed the statutory agreement” (that is the contract embodying the covenant for title and other covenants) to the contract of sale and not to the deed of conveyance itself. As said in Dart's “Vendors and Purchasers”, Vol. I, page 567, these covenants are by the English Conveyancing Act, 1831, section 7 “implied in every conveyance” and we do not see why they should be held under the Transfer of Property Act to be attached only to the contrast of sale and not to the conveyance. The other learned Judge Miller, J. was prepared to follow Krishnan Nambiar v. Kannan. The respondent's vakil's argument that a covenant for title cannot be implied where the buyer knows the defect of title is opposed to the recent decision by Seshagiri Ayyar, J., Subbaraya Reddiar v. Rajagopala Reddiar with which decision we agree.

The learned District Judge has decided the case only on the preliminary ground of limitation raised in the ninth ground of the appeal memorandum presented to the District Court.

We are unable to agree with him in that finding and if article 116 applies, as we hold it to apply, it is not denied that the suit is not barred. The question whether plaintiff can he given a decree for recovery of the money due under the original hypothecation bond has also not been decided (see Order XLI, rule 33 of the Civil Procedure Code, and the wide powers of the Appellate Court).

We therefore reverse the District Judge's decision and remand the case for the disposal of the appeal preferred to the District Court on the other points arising in the case.

Costs will abide the result.

S.V