Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Pattumadammal And Others v. Guru Nanjappa And Others S

Madras High Court
Oct 12, 1938

The question in this Second Appeal is whether the mortgage executed by the 1st defendant in favour of the plaintiff on 5th November 1925 is binding on his sons the 5th and 6th defendants in the suit. Some months before it was executed, the 5th defendant represented by his mother filed an application for leave to sue in forma pauperis on 16th September 1925 praying for partition of the joint family properties against the 1st defendant in the Court of the District Munsif of Kollegal. Leave to sue in forma pauperis was granted by the Court and the application was converted into O.S No. 63 of 1926. Subsequent to the institution of the suit the 6th defendant appears to have been born and he was added as a party defendant to the said partition suit, in June 1926. The plaint was amended accordingly, the plaintiff also reducing his share from one half to one third. The validity of the suit mortgage was put in issue in the suit. There was a preliminary decree in the suit in and by which the plaintiff was declared entitled to one third share in all the properties specified in the plaint including the suit property and so far as the suit mortgage was concerned it was declared not binding on the plaintiff's share. The suit on the present mortgage was instituted on 29th October 1931. Both the 5th and the 6th defendants took the plea that the mortgage was not binding on their share of the family property. So far as the 5th defendant is concerned, it is clear that the mortgage cannot be held to be binding on his share in the joint family property. There can be no doubt that the suit mortgage was subject to the operation of lis pendens by reason of the suit O.S No. 63 of 1926 and the decree passed therein. The rule of lis pendens would operate from the date of the application for leave to sue in forma pauperis and from that date the plaintiff must be deemed to have become separated from his father. [Vide my decision in Rama Rao v. Venkata Subbayya(1)].

Mr. Sampath Ayyangar contends that this point was not taken in the lower appellate Court and ought not to be allowed to be raised here. True, the point was not taken in the exact form in which it was put before me, but it was raised indirectly because it was contended before both the Courts that the mortgage having been executed subsequent to the plaintiff filing his application for leave to sue in forma pauperis, the 5th defendant who claimed under the 1st defendant must be deemed to be bound by the rule of res judicata. I therefore think that this point is open to the appellant in Second Appeal. Therefore I accordingly allowed it to be raised and argued.

Mr. Sampath Ayyangar further contends that it is not known whether after the preliminary decree there was a final decree in the suit or the matter was dropped at the stage of the preliminary decree. He also urged that if there was a final decree it may be that in the final decree the suit property might have been allotted to the share of the 6th defendant in which case no question of lis pendens or res judicata would arise. From the preliminary decree it is evident that the plaintiff was given a share in all the items of property specified in the plaint including the suit property. Mr. Venkatachariar from the Bar represents to me that there was a final decree and the plaintiff was given a third share in the suit property. I accept his statement and I have also directed him to file a copy of the final decree. Therefore in the view I have taken on the question of lis pendens, the decree of the lower appellate Court against the 5th defendant's share in the suit property must be set aside. So far as the 6th defendant is concerned, it cannot be said that the rule of lis pendens will operate in his favour and the question will still remain whether the mortgage was executed for legal necessity. That question has not been gone into by both the Courts. It is therefore necessary that I should remand the suit so far as the 6th defendant is concerned for disposal on this issue and a decree being passed in accordance with the result of the finding on that issue. Mr. Venkatachariar contends that leave should also be reserved to the 6th defendant to raise the contention of res judicata based on the decision in O.S No. 63 of 1926. I give him leave to raise that question at the trial. So far as the question of costs is concerned, I must direct the respondent to pay only half the costs throughout. So far as the 6th defendant is concerned, the costs will abide the result and in case he succeeds he will get half the costs throughout.

Mr. Sampath Ayyangar contends that in case the mortgage is held to be not binding on the 6th defendant, leave may be reserved to him to contend that his client may be given a relief on the basis of an unsecured debt of the 1st defendant and I give him leave to do so.

N.R.RDecree accordingly.